Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1410.0916 · Physical Review A

Quantum theory of angle and relative-phase measurement

Scott Roger Shepard

Published Dec 12, 2014• 7 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The complementarity between time and energy, as well as between an angle and a component of angular momentum, is described at three different layers of understanding. The phenomena of super-resolution are readily apparent in the quantum phase representation which also reveals that entanglement is not required. We modify Schwinger's harmonic oscillator model of angular momentum to include the case of photons. Therein, the quantum angle measurement is shown to be equivalent to the measurement of the relative phase between the two oscillators. Two reasonable ways of dealing with degeneracy are shown to correspond to a conditional measurement which takes a snapshot in absolute time (corresponding to adding probability amplitudes) and a marginal measurement which takes an average in absolute time (corresponding to adding probabilities). The sense in which distinguishability is a ``matter of how long we look'' is discussed and the meaning of the general theory is illustrated by taking the two oscillators to be circularly polarized photons. It is shown that an odd number of $x$-polarized photons will never have an angle in correspondence with the $y$ axis, but an even number of $x$-polarized photons always can! The behavior of an $x$-polarized coherent state is examined and the snapshot angular distributions are seen to evolve into two counter-rotating peaks resulting in considerable correspondence with the $y$ axis at the time for which a classical linear polarization vector would shrink to zero length. We also demonstrate how the probability distribution of absolute time (herein a measurable quantity, rather than just a parameter) has an influence on how these snapshot angular distributions evolve into a quantum version of the polarization ellipse.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.90.062117

Related papers

Phase of the quantum harmonic oscillator with applications to optical polarization

Scott Roger Shepard

The phase of the quantum harmonic oscillator, the temporal distribution of a particle in a square-well potential, and a quantum theory of angles are derived from a general theory of complementarity. Schwinger's harmonic oscillator model of angular momenta is modified for the case of photons. Angular distributions for systems of identical and distinguishable particles are discussed. Unitary and antiunitary time reversal operators are then presented and applied to optical polarization states in birefringent media.

•Jan 1, 1993•0 citations

Phase-space measurements and decoherence for angular momentum systems

Dorje C. Brody, Eva-Maria Graefe, Rishindra Melanathuru

The monitoring of the three independent components of the angular momentum (or spin) of a quantum system by its environment that does not isolate any preferred orientation is modelled in two different ways. One describes the dynamics by the Lindblad equation generated by three independent angular momentum operators. The other uses iterated measurements of the ``phase-space'' point on the sphere in terms of the positive operator-valued measure generated by SU(2) coherent states. In contrast to the equivalent scenario on a flat phase space, these two models give rise to subtle differences. Specifically, it is shown that the two super-operators corresponding to the two decoherence models for angular momentum systems are commutative, but their eigenvalues are different. Hence although both models give rise to phase-space decoherence, their dynamical behaviours are not equivalent. In either model, we find that the characterisation of classicality as represented by the decay rates of the elements of the density matrix (i.e. decoherence) and that as represented by the positivity of the quasiprobability distribution are not equivalent for angular momentum systems.

quant-pharXiv:2605.02696•May 5, 2026•0 citations

Angular momentum coherent states

P. W. Atkins, J. C. Dobson

Abstract The work of Carruthers & Nieto on the harmonic oscillator coherent states is combined with Schwinger’s construction of angular momentum to produce the angular momentum coherent states. It is shown that these states become the vector representatives of angular momentum in the classical limit, and so are particularly useful for discussing the transition from quantum to classical angular momentum. The uncertainty relations for angle and angular momentum are described and are compatible with the classical limit. Under rotations the coherent states transform in a manner that in the classical limit is equivalent to the transformation of vectors, and in the same limit the root mean square variation of the expectation values of the components of angular momentum become negligible in comparison with the expectation values themselves. The coupling of two angular momenta in the classical limit is investigated: it is shown that although the product of two coherent states is not itself a coherent state, it does represent a packet similar to a true coherent state, and centred on the direction of the classical resultant of the two component vectors. The properties and implications of hyperbolic angular momentum space are discussed.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A Mathematical and Physical Sciences•Feb 23, 1971•104 citations

Angle and Phase Coordinates in Quantum Mechanics

J. Žák

A general approach to the description of an angle and phase is given on the basis of the $\mathrm{kq}$ representation. It is shown that an angular coordinate in quantum mechanics has to be treated as a quasicoordinate in order to avoid inconsistencies. The $\mathrm{kq}$ representation leads to a consistent definition of the angular-momentum-angle degree of freedom. Using the correspondence between classical and quantum mechanics for the phase of a harmonic oscillator, operators are defined that form a new quantum-mechanical representation. This representation clarifies the concept of the phase and sheds light on the general understanding of rotations in quantum mechanics.

Physical Review•Nov 25, 1969•30 citations

Phase and Angle Variables in Quantum Mechanics

Peter Carruthers, Michael Martin Nieto

The quantum-mechanical description of phase and angle variables is reviewed, with emphasis on the proper mathematical description of these coordinates. The relations among the operators and state vectors under consideration are clarified in the context of the Heisenberg uncertainty relations. The familiar case of the azimuthal angle variable $\ensuremath{\phi}$ and its "conjugate" angular momentum ${L}_{z}$ is discussed. Various pitfalls associated with the periodicity problem are avoided by employing periodic variables ($sin\ensuremath{\phi}$ and $cos\ensuremath{\phi}$ to describe the phase variable. Well-defined uncertainty relations are derived and discussed. A detailed analysis of the three-dimensional harmonic oscillator excited in coherent states is given. A detailed analysis of the simple harmonic oscillator is given. The usual assumption that a (Hermitian) phase operator $\ensuremath{\varphi}$ (conjugate to the number operator $N$) exists is shown to be erroneous. However, cosine and sine operators $C$ and $S$ exist and are the appr\'opriate phase variables. A Poisson bracket argument using action-angle (rather $J$, $cos\ensuremath{\varphi}$, $sin\ensuremath{\varphi}$) variables is used to deduce $C$ and $S$. The spectra and eigenfunctions of these operators are investigated, along with the important "phase-difference" periodic variables. The properties of the oscillator variables in the various types of states are analyzed with special attention to the uncertainty relations and the transition to the classical limit. The utility of coherent states as a basis for the description of the evolution of the density matrix is emphasized. In this basis it is easy to identify the classical Liouville equation in action-angle variables along with quantum-mechanical "corrections." Mention is made of possible physical applications to superfluid systems.

Reviews of Modern Physics•Apr 1, 1968•1,114 citations

A classical, elementary approach to the foundations of Quantum Mechanics

David Rodríguez

Elementary particles are found in two different situations: (i) bound to metastable states of matter, for which angular momentum is quantized, and (ii) free, for which, due to their high energy-momentum and leaving aside inner a.m. or spin, the $h$-quantization step is completely harmless. Perhaps Quantum Mechanics can be seen just as the simplest mathematical formalism where angular momentum (the magnitude of each of its three orthogonal projections) is by construction quantized: all possible values are taken from a discrete set. Indeed: (i) This idea finds support in very reasonable, completely classical physical arguments, if we place ourselves in the framework of Stochastic Electrodynamics (SED): there, all sustained periodic movement of a charge must satisfy a power balance that restricts the value of the average angular momentum, on each of its projections. (ii) It gives a natural explanation of the concept of "photon", as a constraint on the observable spectrum of energy-momentum exchanges between metastable physical states, in particular also for its discreteness. QM would be, in this picture, a semi-static theory, transparent to all the (micro)-dynamics taking place between apparently "discrete" events (transitions in the state of the system). For instance, (the magnitude of the projections of) quantum angular momentum would only reflect average values over a (classical) cyclic trajectory, a fact that we regard as almost obvious given the particularity of the corresponding addition rules in QM.

arXiv:1112.3369•Dec 13, 2011•1 citation
The complementarity between time and energy, as well as between an angle and a component of angular momentum, is described at three different layers of understanding. The phenomena of super-resolution are readily apparent in the quantum phase representation which also reveals that entanglement is not required. We modify Schwinger's harmonic oscillator model of angular momentum to include the case of photons. Therein, the quantum angle measurement is shown to be equivalent to the measurement of the relative phase between the two oscillators. Two reasonable ways of dealing with degeneracy are shown to correspond to a conditional measurement which takes a snapshot in absolute time (corresponding to adding probability amplitudes) and a marginal measurement which takes an average in absolute time (corresponding to adding probabilities). The sense in which distinguishability is a ``matter of how long we look'' is discussed and the meaning of the general theory is illustrated by taking the two oscillators to be circularly polarized photons. It is shown that an odd number of xxx-polarized photons will never have an angle in correspondence with the yyy axis, but an even number of xxx-polarized photons always can! The behavior of an xxx-polarized coherent state is examined and the snapshot angular distributions are seen to evolve into two counter-rotating peaks resulting in considerable correspondence with the yyy axis at the time for which a classical linear polarization vector would shrink to zero length. We also demonstrate how the probability distribution of absolute time (herein a measurable quantity, rather than just a parameter) has an influence on how these snapshot angular distributions evolve into a quantum version of the polarization ellipse.
The phase of the quantum harmonic oscillator, the temporal distribution of a particle in a square-well potential, and a quantum theory of angles are derived from a general theory of complementarity. Schwinger's harmonic oscillator model of angular momenta is modified for the case of photons. Angular distributions for systems of identical and distinguishable particles are discussed. Unitary and antiunitary time reversal operators are then presented and applied to optical polarization states in birefringent media.
The monitoring of the three independent components of the angular momentum (or spin) of a quantum system by its environment that does not isolate any preferred orientation is modelled in two different ways. One describes the dynamics by the Lindblad equation generated by three independent angular momentum operators. The other uses iterated measurements of the ``phase-space'' point on the sphere in terms of the positive operator-valued measure generated by SU(2) coherent states. In contrast to the equivalent scenario on a flat phase space, these two models give rise to subtle differences. Specifically, it is shown that the two super-operators corresponding to the two decoherence models for angular momentum systems are commutative, but their eigenvalues are different. Hence although both models give rise to phase-space decoherence, their dynamical behaviours are not equivalent. In either model, we find that the characterisation of classicality as represented by the decay rates of the elements of the density matrix (i.e. decoherence) and that as represented by the positivity of the quasiprobability distribution are not equivalent for angular momentum systems.
Abstract The work of Carruthers & Nieto on the harmonic oscillator coherent states is combined with Schwinger’s construction of angular momentum to produce the angular momentum coherent states. It is shown that these states become the vector representatives of angular momentum in the classical limit, and so are particularly useful for discussing the transition from quantum to classical angular momentum. The uncertainty relations for angle and angular momentum are described and are compatible with the classical limit. Under rotations the coherent states transform in a manner that in the classical limit is equivalent to the transformation of vectors, and in the same limit the root mean square variation of the expectation values of the components of angular momentum become negligible in comparison with the expectation values themselves. The coupling of two angular momenta in the classical limit is investigated: it is shown that although the product of two coherent states is not itself a coherent state, it does represent a packet similar to a true coherent state, and centred on the direction of the classical resultant of the two component vectors. The properties and implications of hyperbolic angular momentum space are discussed.
A general approach to the description of an angle and phase is given on the basis of the kq\mathrm{kq}kq representation. It is shown that an angular coordinate in quantum mechanics has to be treated as a quasicoordinate in order to avoid inconsistencies. The kq\mathrm{kq}kq representation leads to a consistent definition of the angular-momentum-angle degree of freedom. Using the correspondence between classical and quantum mechanics for the phase of a harmonic oscillator, operators are defined that form a new quantum-mechanical representation. This representation clarifies the concept of the phase and sheds light on the general understanding of rotations in quantum mechanics.
The quantum-mechanical description of phase and angle variables is reviewed, with emphasis on the proper mathematical description of these coordinates. The relations among the operators and state vectors under consideration are clarified in the context of the Heisenberg uncertainty relations. The familiar case of the azimuthal angle variable $\ensuremath{\phi}$ and its "conjugate" angular momentum Lz{L}_{z}Lz​ is discussed. Various pitfalls associated with the periodicity problem are avoided by employing periodic variables ($sin\ensuremath{\phi}$ and $cos\ensuremath{\phi}$ to describe the phase variable. Well-defined uncertainty relations are derived and discussed. A detailed analysis of the three-dimensional harmonic oscillator excited in coherent states is given. A detailed analysis of the simple harmonic oscillator is given. The usual assumption that a (Hermitian) phase operator $\ensuremath{\varphi}$ (conjugate to the number operator NNN) exists is shown to be erroneous. However, cosine and sine operators CCC and SSS exist and are the appr\'opriate phase variables. A Poisson bracket argument using action-angle (rather JJJ, $cos\ensuremath{\varphi}$, $sin\ensuremath{\varphi}$) variables is used to deduce CCC and SSS. The spectra and eigenfunctions of these operators are investigated, along with the important "phase-difference" periodic variables. The properties of the oscillator variables in the various types of states are analyzed with special attention to the uncertainty relations and the transition to the classical limit. The utility of coherent states as a basis for the description of the evolution of the density matrix is emphasized. In this basis it is easy to identify the classical Liouville equation in action-angle variables along with quantum-mechanical "corrections." Mention is made of possible physical applications to superfluid systems.
Elementary particles are found in two different situations: (i) bound to metastable states of matter, for which angular momentum is quantized, and (ii) free, for which, due to their high energy-momentum and leaving aside inner a.m. or spin, the hhh-quantization step is completely harmless. Perhaps Quantum Mechanics can be seen just as the simplest mathematical formalism where angular momentum (the magnitude of each of its three orthogonal projections) is by construction quantized: all possible values are taken from a discrete set. Indeed: (i) This idea finds support in very reasonable, completely classical physical arguments, if we place ourselves in the framework of Stochastic Electrodynamics (SED): there, all sustained periodic movement of a charge must satisfy a power balance that restricts the value of the average angular momentum, on each of its projections. (ii) It gives a natural explanation of the concept of "photon", as a constraint on the observable spectrum of energy-momentum exchanges between metastable physical states, in particular also for its discreteness. QM would be, in this picture, a semi-static theory, transparent to all the (micro)-dynamics taking place between apparently "discrete" events (transitions in the state of the system). For instance, (the magnitude of the projections of) quantum angular momentum would only reflect average values over a (classical) cyclic trajectory, a fact that we regard as almost obvious given the particularity of the corresponding addition rules in QM.