Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1409.3841 · Physical Review B

Conformal field theories at nonzero temperature: Operator product expansions, Monte Carlo, and holography

Emanuel Katz, Subir Sachdev A, Erik Schwartz Sørensen, William Witczak‐Krempa

Published Dec 1, 2014• 113 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Strongly correlated quantum critical points with conformal symmetry in two spatial dimensions describe many phase transitions in condensed matter systems, as for example that from superfluid to insulator. Combining field theory methods, Monte Carlo simulations, and the holographic duality from string theory, the authors use an operator product expansion to derive non-perturbative results for these systems, including the leading terms in the frequency dependence of the nonzero temperature conductivity and sum rules obeyed by the conductivity. These methods and results are applicable to a wide class of conformal field theories for condensed matter systems.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.90.245109

Related papers

The dynamics of quantum criticality: Quantum Monte Carlo and holography

William Witczak‐Krempa, Erik Schwartz Sørensen, Subir Sachdev A

Understanding the real time dynamics of quantum systems without quasiparticles constitutes an important yet challenging problem. We study the superfluid-insulator quantum-critical point of bosons on a two-dimensional lattice, a system whose excitations cannot be described in a quasiparticle basis. We present detailed quantum Monte Carlo results for two separate lattice realizations: their low-frequency conductivities are found to have the same universal dependence on imaginary frequency and temperature. We then use the structure of the real time dynamics of conformal field theories described by the holographic gauge/gravity duality to make progress on the dicult problem of analytically continuing the Monte Carlo data to real time. Our method yields quantitative and experimentally testable results on the frequency-dependent conductivity near the quantum critical point, and on the spectrum of quasinormal modes in the vicinity of the superfluid-insulator quantum phase transition. Extensions to other observables and universality classes are discussed.

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Mar 4, 2014•1 citation

Multipoint correlators of conformal field theories: Implications for quantum critical transport

Debanjan Chowdhury, Suvrat Raju, Subir Sachdev A +2 more

We compute three-point correlators between the stress-energy tensor and the conserved currents of conformal field theories (CFTs) in 2+1 dimensions. We first compute the correlators in the large-flavor-number expansion of conformal gauge theories and then perform the computation using holography. In the holographic approach, the correlators are computed from an effective action on (3+1)-dimensional anti-de Sitter space (${\mathrm{AdS}}_{4}$) and depend upon the coefficient $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ of a four-derivative term in the action. We find a precise match between the CFT and the holographic results, thus, fixing the values of $\ensuremath{\gamma}$. The CFTs of free fermions and bosons take the values $\ensuremath{\gamma}=1/12,\ensuremath{-}1/12$, respectively, and so saturate the bound $|\ensuremath{\gamma}|\ensuremath{\le}1/12$ obtained earlier from the holographic theory; the correlator of the conserved gauge flux of $U(1)$ gauge theories takes intermediate values of $\ensuremath{\gamma}$. The value of $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ also controls the frequency dependence of the conductivity and other properties of quantum critical transport at nonzero temperatures. Our results for the values of $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ lead to an appealing physical interpretation of particlelike or vortexlike transport near quantum phase transitions of interest in condensed-matter physics. This paper includes Appendices reviewing key features of the AdS-CFT correspondence for condensed-matter physicists.

arXiv:1210.5247•Physical Review B•Feb 28, 2013•67 citations

Holography and strongly correlated systems

Nabil Iqbal

In this thesis we apply techniques arising from string theory - gauge-gravity/duality, or holography - to problems associated with strongly coupled quantum field theories under extreme conditions such as finite temperature or density. We first study a strongly coupled field theory at finite temperature. We demonstrate that its low frequency limit is determined by the horizon geometry of its gravity dual, i.e. by the "membrane paradigm" fluid of classical black hole mechanics. Thus generic boundary theory transport coefficients can be expressed in terms of geometric quantities evaluated at the horizon, providing a simple understanding of results such as the universality of the shear viscosity in theories with gravity duals. Away from the low frequency limit we find a nontrivial radial flow from the black hole horizon to the boundary of the spacetime; we derive equations governing this flow and demonstrate their use in the simple examples of charge and momentum diffusion. Next, we turn to the study of strongly coupled theories with a finite density of a U(1) charge. The near-horizon geometry of the gravity dual of such a state has an AdS 2 factor, indicating the existence of a nontrivial emergent conformal symmetry in the infrared with nontrivial scaling only in the time direction. We review earlier work indicating that fermionic perturbations of such a state reveal non-Fermi-liquid behavior, i.e. gapless fermionic excitations that are not those of Fermi liquid theory. We perform a one-loop calculation in the bulk to compute the contribution from these Fermi surfaces to the conductivity of the full system. Interestingly, within this class of non-Fermi liquids we find examples whose single-particle spectral function and transport behavior both resemble those of strange metals, i.e. the anomalous metallic state existing in the real-life high Tc cuprates above their superconducting transition temperature. In particular, for these examples the contribution to the conductivity is inversely proportional to temperature. In our treatment these properties can be understood as being controlled by the scaling dimension of the fermion operator in the emergent IR fixed point. We then turn to models of symmetry breaking in holographic models at finite density. We observe that the presence of the AdS₂ factor can result in the condensation of a neutral scalar operator. This can be used to model an "antiferromagnetic" phase in which a global SU(2) symmetry is broken down to U(1). We study the collective modes of the ordered phase and recover the expected spin waves from a gravitational treatment. We then note that the phase transition can be driven to zero temperature by tuning various bulk couplings, resulting in a quantum phase transition of the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless type. We study this transition in detail, revealing novel critical behavior, including locally quantum critical dynamics and the existence of an infinite tower of excited states related by a discrete subgroup of the original emergent conformal symmetry. Throughout this thesis we focus on how the novel viewpoint provided by holography can help us gain new insights into the physics of strongly correlated systems.

•Jan 1, 2011•1 citation

Quasinormal modes of quantum criticality

William Witczak‐Krempa, Subir Sachdev A

We study charge transport of quantum critical points described by conformal field theories in 2+1 space-time dimensions. The transport is described by an effective field theory on an asymptotically anti-de Sitter space-time, expanded to fourth order in spatial and temporal gradients. The presence of a horizon at nonzero temperatures implies that this theory has quasinormal modes with complex frequencies. The quasinormal modes determine the poles and zeros of the conductivity in the complex frequency plane, and so fully determine its behavior on the real frequency axis, at frequencies both smaller and larger than the absolute temperature. We describe the role of particle-vortex or S duality on the conductivity, specifically how it maps poles to zeros and vice versa. These analyses motivate two sum rules obeyed by the quantum critical conductivity: the holographic computations are the first to satisfy both sum rules, while earlier Boltzmann-theory computations satisfy only one of them. Finally, we compare our results with the analytic structure of the $O(N)$ model in the large-$N$ limit, and other CFTs.

arXiv:1210.4166•Physical Review B•Dec 12, 2012•69 citations

OPE convergence in non-relativistic conformal field theories

Walter D. Goldberger, Zuhair U. Khandker, Siddharth G. Prabhu

Motivated by applications to the study of ultracold atomic gases near the unitarity limit, we investigate the structure of the operator product expansion (OPE) in non-relativistic conformal field theories (NRCFTs). The main tool used in our analysis is the representation theory of charged (i.e. non-zero particle number) operators in the NR-CFT, in particular the mapping between operators and states in a non-relativistic “radial quantization” Hilbert space. Our results include: a determination of the OPE coefficients of descendant operators in terms of those of the underlying primary state, a demonstration of convergence of the (imaginary time) OPE in certain kinematic limits, and an estimate of the decay rate of the OPE tail inside matrix elements which, as in relativistic CFTs, depends exponentially on operator dimensions. To illustrate our results we consider several examples, including a strongly interacting field theory of bosons tuned to the unitarity limit, as well as a class of holographic models. Given the similarity with known statements about the OPE in SO(2, d) invariant field theories, our results suggest the existence of a bootstrap approach to constraining NRCFTs, with applications to bound state spectra and interactions. We briefly comment on a possible implementation of this non-relativistic conformal bootstrap program.

arXiv:1412.8507•Journal of High Energy Physics•Dec 1, 2015•57 citations

Conformal perturbation of off-critical correlators in the 3D Ising universality class

Michele Caselle, Gianluca Costagliola, Nicodemo Magnoli

Thanks to the impressive progress of conformal bootstrap methods we have now very precise estimates of both scaling dimensions and operator product expansion coefficients for several 3D universality classes. We show how to use this information to obtain similarly precise estimates for off-critical correlators using conformal perturbation. We discuss in particular the $⟨\ensuremath{\sigma}(r)\ensuremath{\sigma}(0)⟩$, $⟨\ensuremath{\epsilon}(r)\ensuremath{\epsilon}(0)⟩$ and $⟨\ensuremath{\sigma}(r)\ensuremath{\epsilon}(0)⟩$ two-point functions in the high and low temperature regimes of the 3D Ising model and evaluate the leading and next to leading terms in the $s={\mathrm{tr}}^{{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{t}}$ expansion, where $t$ is the reduced temperature. Our results for $⟨\ensuremath{\sigma}(r)\ensuremath{\sigma}(0)⟩$ agree both with Monte Carlo simulations and with a set of experimental estimates of the critical scattering function.

arXiv:1605.05133•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•Jul 11, 2016•17 citations
Strongly correlated quantum critical points with conformal symmetry in two spatial dimensions describe many phase transitions in condensed matter systems, as for example that from superfluid to insulator. Combining field theory methods, Monte Carlo simulations, and the holographic duality from string theory, the authors use an operator product expansion to derive non-perturbative results for these systems, including the leading terms in the frequency dependence of the nonzero temperature conductivity and sum rules obeyed by the conductivity. These methods and results are applicable to a wide class of conformal field theories for condensed matter systems.
Understanding the real time dynamics of quantum systems without quasiparticles constitutes an important yet challenging problem. We study the superfluid-insulator quantum-critical point of bosons on a two-dimensional lattice, a system whose excitations cannot be described in a quasiparticle basis. We present detailed quantum Monte Carlo results for two separate lattice realizations: their low-frequency conductivities are found to have the same universal dependence on imaginary frequency and temperature. We then use the structure of the real time dynamics of conformal field theories described by the holographic gauge/gravity duality to make progress on the dicult problem of analytically continuing the Monte Carlo data to real time. Our method yields quantitative and experimentally testable results on the frequency-dependent conductivity near the quantum critical point, and on the spectrum of quasinormal modes in the vicinity of the superfluid-insulator quantum phase transition. Extensions to other observables and universality classes are discussed.
We compute three-point correlators between the stress-energy tensor and the conserved currents of conformal field theories (CFTs) in 2+1 dimensions. We first compute the correlators in the large-flavor-number expansion of conformal gauge theories and then perform the computation using holography. In the holographic approach, the correlators are computed from an effective action on (3+1)-dimensional anti-de Sitter space (AdS4{\mathrm{AdS}}_{4}AdS4​) and depend upon the coefficient $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ of a four-derivative term in the action. We find a precise match between the CFT and the holographic results, thus, fixing the values of $\ensuremath{\gamma}$. The CFTs of free fermions and bosons take the values $\ensuremath{\gamma}=1/12,\ensuremath{-}1/12$, respectively, and so saturate the bound $|\ensuremath{\gamma}|\ensuremath{\le}1/12$ obtained earlier from the holographic theory; the correlator of the conserved gauge flux of U(1)U(1)U(1) gauge theories takes intermediate values of $\ensuremath{\gamma}$. The value of $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ also controls the frequency dependence of the conductivity and other properties of quantum critical transport at nonzero temperatures. Our results for the values of $\ensuremath{\gamma}$ lead to an appealing physical interpretation of particlelike or vortexlike transport near quantum phase transitions of interest in condensed-matter physics. This paper includes Appendices reviewing key features of the AdS-CFT correspondence for condensed-matter physicists.
In this thesis we apply techniques arising from string theory - gauge-gravity/duality, or holography - to problems associated with strongly coupled quantum field theories under extreme conditions such as finite temperature or density. We first study a strongly coupled field theory at finite temperature. We demonstrate that its low frequency limit is determined by the horizon geometry of its gravity dual, i.e. by the "membrane paradigm" fluid of classical black hole mechanics. Thus generic boundary theory transport coefficients can be expressed in terms of geometric quantities evaluated at the horizon, providing a simple understanding of results such as the universality of the shear viscosity in theories with gravity duals. Away from the low frequency limit we find a nontrivial radial flow from the black hole horizon to the boundary of the spacetime; we derive equations governing this flow and demonstrate their use in the simple examples of charge and momentum diffusion. Next, we turn to the study of strongly coupled theories with a finite density of a U(1) charge. The near-horizon geometry of the gravity dual of such a state has an AdS 2 factor, indicating the existence of a nontrivial emergent conformal symmetry in the infrared with nontrivial scaling only in the time direction. We review earlier work indicating that fermionic perturbations of such a state reveal non-Fermi-liquid behavior, i.e. gapless fermionic excitations that are not those of Fermi liquid theory. We perform a one-loop calculation in the bulk to compute the contribution from these Fermi surfaces to the conductivity of the full system. Interestingly, within this class of non-Fermi liquids we find examples whose single-particle spectral function and transport behavior both resemble those of strange metals, i.e. the anomalous metallic state existing in the real-life high Tc cuprates above their superconducting transition temperature. In particular, for these examples the contribution to the conductivity is inversely proportional to temperature. In our treatment these properties can be understood as being controlled by the scaling dimension of the fermion operator in the emergent IR fixed point. We then turn to models of symmetry breaking in holographic models at finite density. We observe that the presence of the AdS₂ factor can result in the condensation of a neutral scalar operator. This can be used to model an "antiferromagnetic" phase in which a global SU(2) symmetry is broken down to U(1). We study the collective modes of the ordered phase and recover the expected spin waves from a gravitational treatment. We then note that the phase transition can be driven to zero temperature by tuning various bulk couplings, resulting in a quantum phase transition of the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless type. We study this transition in detail, revealing novel critical behavior, including locally quantum critical dynamics and the existence of an infinite tower of excited states related by a discrete subgroup of the original emergent conformal symmetry. Throughout this thesis we focus on how the novel viewpoint provided by holography can help us gain new insights into the physics of strongly correlated systems.
We study charge transport of quantum critical points described by conformal field theories in 2+1 space-time dimensions. The transport is described by an effective field theory on an asymptotically anti-de Sitter space-time, expanded to fourth order in spatial and temporal gradients. The presence of a horizon at nonzero temperatures implies that this theory has quasinormal modes with complex frequencies. The quasinormal modes determine the poles and zeros of the conductivity in the complex frequency plane, and so fully determine its behavior on the real frequency axis, at frequencies both smaller and larger than the absolute temperature. We describe the role of particle-vortex or S duality on the conductivity, specifically how it maps poles to zeros and vice versa. These analyses motivate two sum rules obeyed by the quantum critical conductivity: the holographic computations are the first to satisfy both sum rules, while earlier Boltzmann-theory computations satisfy only one of them. Finally, we compare our results with the analytic structure of the O(N)O(N)O(N) model in the large-NNN limit, and other CFTs.
Motivated by applications to the study of ultracold atomic gases near the unitarity limit, we investigate the structure of the operator product expansion (OPE) in non-relativistic conformal field theories (NRCFTs). The main tool used in our analysis is the representation theory of charged (i.e. non-zero particle number) operators in the NR-CFT, in particular the mapping between operators and states in a non-relativistic “radial quantization” Hilbert space. Our results include: a determination of the OPE coefficients of descendant operators in terms of those of the underlying primary state, a demonstration of convergence of the (imaginary time) OPE in certain kinematic limits, and an estimate of the decay rate of the OPE tail inside matrix elements which, as in relativistic CFTs, depends exponentially on operator dimensions. To illustrate our results we consider several examples, including a strongly interacting field theory of bosons tuned to the unitarity limit, as well as a class of holographic models. Given the similarity with known statements about the OPE in SO(2, d) invariant field theories, our results suggest the existence of a bootstrap approach to constraining NRCFTs, with applications to bound state spectra and interactions. We briefly comment on a possible implementation of this non-relativistic conformal bootstrap program.
Thanks to the impressive progress of conformal bootstrap methods we have now very precise estimates of both scaling dimensions and operator product expansion coefficients for several 3D universality classes. We show how to use this information to obtain similarly precise estimates for off-critical correlators using conformal perturbation. We discuss in particular the $⟨\ensuremath{\sigma}(r)\ensuremath{\sigma}(0)⟩$, $⟨\ensuremath{\epsilon}(r)\ensuremath{\epsilon}(0)⟩$ and $⟨\ensuremath{\sigma}(r)\ensuremath{\epsilon}(0)⟩$ two-point functions in the high and low temperature regimes of the 3D Ising model and evaluate the leading and next to leading terms in the $s={\mathrm{tr}}^{{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}}_{t}}$ expansion, where ttt is the reduced temperature. Our results for $⟨\ensuremath{\sigma}(r)\ensuremath{\sigma}(0)⟩$ agree both with Monte Carlo simulations and with a set of experimental estimates of the critical scattering function.