Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1408.6514 · Physical Review Letters

Gapped Domain Walls, Gapped Boundaries, and Topological Degeneracy

Tian Lan, Juven Wang, Xiao-Gang Wen

Published Feb 18, 2015• 181 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Gapped domain walls, as topological line defects between (2+1)D topologically ordered states, are examined. We provide simple criteria to determine the existence of gapped domain walls, which apply to both Abelian and non-Abelian topological orders. Our criteria also determine which (2+1)D topological orders must have gapless edge modes, namely, which (1+1)D global gravitational anomalies ensure gaplessness. Furthermore, we introduce a new mathematical object, the tunneling matrix W, whose entries are the fusion-space dimensions W(ia), to label different types of gapped domain walls. By studying many examples, we find evidence that the tunneling matrices are powerful quantities to classify different types of gapped domain walls. Since a gapped boundary is a gapped domain wall between a bulk topological order and the vacuum, regarded as the trivial topological order, our theory of gapped domain walls inclusively contains the theory of gapped boundaries. In addition, we derive a topological ground state degeneracy formula, applied to arbitrary orientable spatial 2-manifolds with gapped domain walls, including closed 2-manifolds and open 2-manifolds with gapped boundaries.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.114.076402

Related papers

Boundary degeneracy of topological order

Juven Wang, Xiao-Gang Wen

We introduce the concept of boundary degeneracy, as the ground state degeneracy of topologically ordered states on a compact orientable spatial manifold with gapped boundaries. We emphasize that the boundary degeneracy provides richer information than the bulk degeneracy. Beyond the bulk-edge correspondence, we find the ground state degeneracy of the fully gapped edge modes depends on boundary gapping conditions. By associating different types of boundary gapping conditions as different ways of particle or quasiparticle condensations on the boundary, we develop an analytic theory of gapped boundaries. By Chern-Simons theory, this allows us to derive the ground state degeneracy formula in terms of boundary gapping conditions, which encodes more than the fusion algebra of fractionalized quasiparticles. We apply our theory to Kitaev's toric code and Levin-Wen string-net models. We predict that the ${Z}_{2}$ toric code and ${Z}_{2}$ double-semion model [more generally, the ${Z}_{k}$ gauge theory and the $U{(1)}_{k}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}U{(1)}_{\ensuremath{-}k}$ nonchiral fractional quantum Hall state at even integer $k$] can be numerically and experimentally distinguished, by measuring their boundary degeneracy on an annulus or a cylinder.

arXiv:1212.4863•Physical Review B•Mar 13, 2015•125 citations

A mathematical theory of gapless edges of 2d topological orders. Part II

Liang Kong, Hao Zheng

This is the second part of a two-part work on the unified mathematical theory of gapped and gapless edges of 2+1D topological orders. In Part I, we have developed the mathematical theory of chiral gapless edges. In Part II, we study boundary-bulk relation and non-chiral gapless edges. In particular, we explain how the notion of the center of an enriched monoidal category naturally emerges from the boundary-bulk relation. After the study of 0+1D gapless walls, we give the complete boundary-bulk relation for 2+1D topological orders with chiral gapless edges (including gapped edges) and 0d walls between edges. This relation is stated precisely and proved rigorously as a monoidal equivalence, which generalizes the functoriality of the usual Drinfeld center to an enriched setting. We also develop the mathematical theory of non-chiral gapless edges and 0+1D walls, and explain how to gap out certain non-chiral 1+1D gapless edges and 0+1D gapless walls categorically. In the end, we show that all anomaly-free 1+1D boundary-bulk rational CFT's can be recovered from 2d topological orders with chiral gapless edges via a dimensional reduction process. This provides physical meanings to some mysterious connections between mathematical results in fusion categories and those in rational CFT's.

arXiv:1912.01760•Nuclear Physics B•Mar 23, 2021•73 citations

Braided fusion categories, gravitational anomalies, and the mathematical framework for topological orders in any dimensions

Liang Kong, Xiao-Gang Wen

Gravitational anomalies can be realized on the boundary of topologically ordered states in one higher dimension and are described by topological orders in one higher dimension. In this paper, we try to develop a general theory for both topological order and gravitational anomaly in any dimensions. (1) We introduce the notion of BF category to describe the braiding and fusion properties of topological excitations that can be point-like, string-like, etc. A subset of BF categories -- closed BF categories -- classify topological orders in any dimensions, while generic BF categories classify (potentially) anomalous topological orders that can appear at a boundary of a gapped quantum liquid in one higher dimension. (2) We introduce topological path integral based on tensor network to realize those topological orders. (3) Bosonic topological orders have an important topological invariant: the vector bundles of the degenerate ground states over the moduli spaces of closed spaces with different metrics. They may fully characterize topological orders. (4) We conjecture that a topological order has a gappable boundary iff the above mentioned vector bundles are flat. (5) We find a holographic phenomenon that every topological order with a gappable boundary can be uniquely determined by the knowledge of the boundary. As a consequence, BF categories in different dimensions form a (monoid) cochain complex, that reveals the structure and relation of topological orders and gravitational anomalies in different dimensions. We also studied the simplest kind of bosonic topological orders that have no non-trivial topological excitations. We find that this kind of topological orders form a $\mathbb{Z}$ class in 2+1D (with gapless edge), a $\mathbb{Z}_2$ class in 4+1D (with gappable boundary), and a $\mathbb{Z}\oplus \mathbb{Z}$ class in 6+1D (with gapless boundary).

arXiv:1405.5858•May 22, 2014•263 citations

Lattice model constructions for gapless domain walls between topological phases

Chenfeng Bao, Shuo Yang, Chenjie Wang +1 more

Domain walls between different topological phases are one of the most interesting phenomena that reveal the nontrivial bulk properties of topological phases. Very recently, gapped domain walls between different topological phases have been intensively studied. In this paper, we systematically construct a large class of lattice models for gapless domain walls between twisted and untwisted gauge theories with arbitrary finite group $G$. As simple examples, we numerically study several finite groups (including both Abelian and non-Abelian finite group such as ${S}_{3}$) in $2\mathrm{D}$ using the state-of-the-art loop optimization of tensor network renormalization algorithm. We also propose a physical mechanism for understanding the gapless nature of these particular domain wall models. Finally, by taking advantage of the classification and construction of twisted gauge theories using group cohomology theory, we generalize such constructions into arbitrary dimensions, which might provide us a systematical way to understand gapless domain walls and topological quantum phase transitions.

arXiv:1801.00719•Physical Review Research•Apr 14, 2022•33 citations

Theory of defects in Abelian topological states

Maissam Barkeshli, Chao‐Ming Jian, Xiao-Liang Qi

The structure of extrinsic defects in topologically ordered states of matter is host to a rich set of universal physics. Extrinsic defects in $2+1$-dimensional topological states include linelike defects, such as boundaries between topologically distinct states, and pointlike defects, such as junctions between different line defects. Gapped boundaries in particular can themselves be topologically distinct, and the junctions between them can localize topologically protected zero modes, giving rise to topological ground-state degeneracies and projective non-Abelian statistics. In this paper, we develop a general theory of point defects and gapped line defects in $2+1$-dimensional Abelian topological states. We derive a classification of topologically distinct gapped boundaries in terms of certain maximal subgroups of quasiparticles with mutually bosonic statistics, called Lagrangian subgroups. The junctions between different gapped boundaries provide a general classification of point defects in topological states, including as a special case the twist defects considered in previous works. We derive a general formula for the quantum dimension of these point defects and a general understanding of their localized ``parafermion'' zero modes and we define a notion of projective non-Abelian statistics for them. The critical phenomena between topologically distinct gapped boundaries can be understood in terms of a general class of quantum spin chains or, equivalently, ``generalized parafermion'' chains. This provides a way of realizing exotic $1+1\mathrm{D}$ generalized parafermion conformal field theories in condensed-matter systems.

arXiv:1305.7203•Physical Review B•Dec 2, 2013•191 citations

Generating domain walls between topologically ordered phases using quantum double models

Pramod Padmanabhan, Miguel Jorge Bernabé Ferreira, Paulo Teotonio-Sobrinho

Transitions between different topologically ordered phases have been studied by artificially creating boundaries between these gapped phases and thus studying their effects relating to condensation and tunneling of particles from one phase to the other. In this work we introduce exactly solvable models which are similar to the quantum double models (QDM) of Kitaev where such domain walls are dynamically generated making them a part of the spectrum. These systems have a local symmetry and may or may not have a global symmetry leading to the possibility of a ground state degeneracy arising from both, global symmetry breaking and a topological degeneracy. The domain wall states now separate the different topologically ordered phases belonging to the different sectors controlled by the global symmetry, when present. They have interesting properties including fusion with the deconfined anyons of the topologically ordered phase, to either create new domain walls, or their annihilation. They can also act like a scatterer permuting anyons of the topologically ordered phases on either side of the domain wall. Thus these domain wall states can be thought of as a synthetic scatterer which can be created in any part of the lattice. We show these effects for the simplest case of the $\mathbb{Z}_2$ toric code phase decorated with a global $\mathbb{Z}_2$ symmetry and then make remarks about the case when we have the QDM based on two arbitrary groups $G_1$ and $G_2$ in which case we may no longer have a global symmetry.

arXiv:1510.06627•Oct 22, 2015•1 citation
Gapped domain walls, as topological line defects between (2+1)D topologically ordered states, are examined. We provide simple criteria to determine the existence of gapped domain walls, which apply to both Abelian and non-Abelian topological orders. Our criteria also determine which (2+1)D topological orders must have gapless edge modes, namely, which (1+1)D global gravitational anomalies ensure gaplessness. Furthermore, we introduce a new mathematical object, the tunneling matrix W, whose entries are the fusion-space dimensions W(ia), to label different types of gapped domain walls. By studying many examples, we find evidence that the tunneling matrices are powerful quantities to classify different types of gapped domain walls. Since a gapped boundary is a gapped domain wall between a bulk topological order and the vacuum, regarded as the trivial topological order, our theory of gapped domain walls inclusively contains the theory of gapped boundaries. In addition, we derive a topological ground state degeneracy formula, applied to arbitrary orientable spatial 2-manifolds with gapped domain walls, including closed 2-manifolds and open 2-manifolds with gapped boundaries.
We introduce the concept of boundary degeneracy, as the ground state degeneracy of topologically ordered states on a compact orientable spatial manifold with gapped boundaries. We emphasize that the boundary degeneracy provides richer information than the bulk degeneracy. Beyond the bulk-edge correspondence, we find the ground state degeneracy of the fully gapped edge modes depends on boundary gapping conditions. By associating different types of boundary gapping conditions as different ways of particle or quasiparticle condensations on the boundary, we develop an analytic theory of gapped boundaries. By Chern-Simons theory, this allows us to derive the ground state degeneracy formula in terms of boundary gapping conditions, which encodes more than the fusion algebra of fractionalized quasiparticles. We apply our theory to Kitaev's toric code and Levin-Wen string-net models. We predict that the Z2{Z}_{2}Z2​ toric code and Z2{Z}_{2}Z2​ double-semion model [more generally, the Zk{Z}_{k}Zk​ gauge theory and the $U{(1)}_{k}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}U{(1)}_{\ensuremath{-}k}$ nonchiral fractional quantum Hall state at even integer kkk] can be numerically and experimentally distinguished, by measuring their boundary degeneracy on an annulus or a cylinder.
This is the second part of a two-part work on the unified mathematical theory of gapped and gapless edges of 2+1D topological orders. In Part I, we have developed the mathematical theory of chiral gapless edges. In Part II, we study boundary-bulk relation and non-chiral gapless edges. In particular, we explain how the notion of the center of an enriched monoidal category naturally emerges from the boundary-bulk relation. After the study of 0+1D gapless walls, we give the complete boundary-bulk relation for 2+1D topological orders with chiral gapless edges (including gapped edges) and 0d walls between edges. This relation is stated precisely and proved rigorously as a monoidal equivalence, which generalizes the functoriality of the usual Drinfeld center to an enriched setting. We also develop the mathematical theory of non-chiral gapless edges and 0+1D walls, and explain how to gap out certain non-chiral 1+1D gapless edges and 0+1D gapless walls categorically. In the end, we show that all anomaly-free 1+1D boundary-bulk rational CFT's can be recovered from 2d topological orders with chiral gapless edges via a dimensional reduction process. This provides physical meanings to some mysterious connections between mathematical results in fusion categories and those in rational CFT's.
Gravitational anomalies can be realized on the boundary of topologically ordered states in one higher dimension and are described by topological orders in one higher dimension. In this paper, we try to develop a general theory for both topological order and gravitational anomaly in any dimensions. (1) We introduce the notion of BF category to describe the braiding and fusion properties of topological excitations that can be point-like, string-like, etc. A subset of BF categories -- closed BF categories -- classify topological orders in any dimensions, while generic BF categories classify (potentially) anomalous topological orders that can appear at a boundary of a gapped quantum liquid in one higher dimension. (2) We introduce topological path integral based on tensor network to realize those topological orders. (3) Bosonic topological orders have an important topological invariant: the vector bundles of the degenerate ground states over the moduli spaces of closed spaces with different metrics. They may fully characterize topological orders. (4) We conjecture that a topological order has a gappable boundary iff the above mentioned vector bundles are flat. (5) We find a holographic phenomenon that every topological order with a gappable boundary can be uniquely determined by the knowledge of the boundary. As a consequence, BF categories in different dimensions form a (monoid) cochain complex, that reveals the structure and relation of topological orders and gravitational anomalies in different dimensions. We also studied the simplest kind of bosonic topological orders that have no non-trivial topological excitations. We find that this kind of topological orders form a Z\mathbb{Z}Z class in 2+1D (with gapless edge), a Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​ class in 4+1D (with gappable boundary), and a Z⊕Z\mathbb{Z}\oplus \mathbb{Z}Z⊕Z class in 6+1D (with gapless boundary).
Domain walls between different topological phases are one of the most interesting phenomena that reveal the nontrivial bulk properties of topological phases. Very recently, gapped domain walls between different topological phases have been intensively studied. In this paper, we systematically construct a large class of lattice models for gapless domain walls between twisted and untwisted gauge theories with arbitrary finite group GGG. As simple examples, we numerically study several finite groups (including both Abelian and non-Abelian finite group such as S3{S}_{3}S3​) in 2D2\mathrm{D}2D using the state-of-the-art loop optimization of tensor network renormalization algorithm. We also propose a physical mechanism for understanding the gapless nature of these particular domain wall models. Finally, by taking advantage of the classification and construction of twisted gauge theories using group cohomology theory, we generalize such constructions into arbitrary dimensions, which might provide us a systematical way to understand gapless domain walls and topological quantum phase transitions.
The structure of extrinsic defects in topologically ordered states of matter is host to a rich set of universal physics. Extrinsic defects in 2+12+12+1-dimensional topological states include linelike defects, such as boundaries between topologically distinct states, and pointlike defects, such as junctions between different line defects. Gapped boundaries in particular can themselves be topologically distinct, and the junctions between them can localize topologically protected zero modes, giving rise to topological ground-state degeneracies and projective non-Abelian statistics. In this paper, we develop a general theory of point defects and gapped line defects in 2+12+12+1-dimensional Abelian topological states. We derive a classification of topologically distinct gapped boundaries in terms of certain maximal subgroups of quasiparticles with mutually bosonic statistics, called Lagrangian subgroups. The junctions between different gapped boundaries provide a general classification of point defects in topological states, including as a special case the twist defects considered in previous works. We derive a general formula for the quantum dimension of these point defects and a general understanding of their localized ``parafermion'' zero modes and we define a notion of projective non-Abelian statistics for them. The critical phenomena between topologically distinct gapped boundaries can be understood in terms of a general class of quantum spin chains or, equivalently, ``generalized parafermion'' chains. This provides a way of realizing exotic 1+1D1+1\mathrm{D}1+1D generalized parafermion conformal field theories in condensed-matter systems.
Transitions between different topologically ordered phases have been studied by artificially creating boundaries between these gapped phases and thus studying their effects relating to condensation and tunneling of particles from one phase to the other. In this work we introduce exactly solvable models which are similar to the quantum double models (QDM) of Kitaev where such domain walls are dynamically generated making them a part of the spectrum. These systems have a local symmetry and may or may not have a global symmetry leading to the possibility of a ground state degeneracy arising from both, global symmetry breaking and a topological degeneracy. The domain wall states now separate the different topologically ordered phases belonging to the different sectors controlled by the global symmetry, when present. They have interesting properties including fusion with the deconfined anyons of the topologically ordered phase, to either create new domain walls, or their annihilation. They can also act like a scatterer permuting anyons of the topologically ordered phases on either side of the domain wall. Thus these domain wall states can be thought of as a synthetic scatterer which can be created in any part of the lattice. We show these effects for the simplest case of the Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​ toric code phase decorated with a global Z2\mathbb{Z}_2Z2​ symmetry and then make remarks about the case when we have the QDM based on two arbitrary groups G1G_1G1​ and G2G_2G2​ in which case we may no longer have a global symmetry.