Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1408.6268 · Physical Review B

Energy density of variational states

Leon Balents

Published Dec 8, 2014• 12 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

For a given many-body Hamiltonian, can a wavefunction in the wrong phase yield an arbitrarily good variational approximation to the true ground state energy density? The author discusses systems for which the answer is positive and outlines other cases where the Hamiltonian is expected to be variationally robust.
DOI
10.1103/physrevb.90.245116

Related papers

Variational-Correlations Approach to Quantum Many-body Problems

Arbel Haim, Richard Kueng, Gil Refael

We investigate an approach for studying the ground state of a quantum many-body Hamiltonian that is based on treating the correlation functions as variational parameters. In this approach, the challenge set by the exponentially-large Hilbert space is circumvented by approximating the positivity of the density matrix, order-by-order, in a way that keeps track of a limited set of correlation functions. In particular, the density-matrix description is replaced by a correlation matrix whose dimension is kept linear in system size, to all orders of the approximation. Unlike the conventional variational principle which provides an upper bound on the ground-state energy, in this approach one obtains a lower bound instead. By treating several one-dimensional spin $1/2$ Hamiltonians, we demonstrate the ability of this approach to produce long-range correlations, and a ground-state energy that converges to the exact result. Possible extensions, including to higher-excited states are discussed.

arXiv:2001.06510•Jan 17, 2020•29 citations

Comments on variational ground states for lattice hamiltonians

Ramesh Anishetty, Anton Bovier

Physics Letters B•Feb 1, 1984•1 citation

Many-Body Point Transforms. II. An Exact Noncluster Approach to the Hard-Core Many-Body Problem

Norman M. Witriol

The method of many-body point transforms previously developed by the author is modified to eliminate the interacting particle cluster formalism. The cutoff terms in the transformation, and thus in the Hamiltonian, are therefore removed. For the hard-core many-body problem, as in the previous work, a Hamiltonian is obtained which is Fourier analyzable, Hermitian and amenable to ordinary perturbation and variational techniques while still being equivalent to the original Hamiltonian. No approximations are made. It is demonstrated that the use of the standard zeroth-order approximation of the ground state Bose system, i.e., a constant, for the transformed wavefunction gives a negative expectation value of the energy for the hard core system. This discrepancy arises from the extended range of the new potential generated by the transformation, which necessitates explicit consideration of boundary conditions not satisfied by the above wavefunction.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Dec 1, 1971•3 citations

A Simple Variational Formula in Quantum

David Park

If one assumes that the change in a ground-state wave function produced by a perturbing potential V is proportional to V, a general and very simple formula for the perturbation in energy results. The formula is illustrated with two examples.

American Journal of Physics•Sep 1, 1973•1 citation

Variational Method for the Ground State Energy of a Quantum Many-Particle System

Hiroshi Takizawa, Akihide Oguchi

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Jul 15, 2000•0 citations

The relation between the Gross–Pitaevskii and Bogoliubov descriptions of a dilute Bose gas

A. J. Leggett

I formulate a 'pseudo-paradox' in the theory of a dilute Bose gas with repulsive interactions: the standard expression for the ground state energy within the Gross–Pitaevskii (GP) approximation is lower than that in the Bogoliubov approximation, and hence, by the standard variational argument, the former should prima facie be a better approximation than the latter to the true ground state—a conclusion which is of course opposite to the established wisdom concerning this problem. It is shown that the pseudo-paradox is (unsurprisingly) resolved by a correct transcription of the two-body scattering theory to the many-body case; however, contrary to what appears to be a widespread belief, the resolution has nothing to do with any spurious ultraviolet divergences which result from the replacement of the true interatomic potential by a delta-function pseudopotential. Rather, it relates to an infrared divergence which has the consequence that (a) the most obvious form of the GP 'approximation' actually does not correspond to any well-defined ansatz for the many-body wavefunction, and (b) that the 'best shot' at such a wavefunction always produces an energy which exceeds, or at best equals, that calculated in the Bogoliubov approximation. In fact, the necessity of the latter may be seen as a consequence of the need to reduce the Fock term in the energy, which is absent in the two-particle problem but dominant in the many-body case; it does this by increasing the density correlations, at distances less than or approximately equal to the correlation length , above the value extrapolated from the two-body case. As a by-product I devise an alternative formulation of the Bogoliubov approximation which does not require the explicit replacement of the true interatomic potential by a delta-function pseudopotential.

New Journal of Physics•Jul 31, 2003•29 citations
We investigate an approach for studying the ground state of a quantum many-body Hamiltonian that is based on treating the correlation functions as variational parameters. In this approach, the challenge set by the exponentially-large Hilbert space is circumvented by approximating the positivity of the density matrix, order-by-order, in a way that keeps track of a limited set of correlation functions. In particular, the density-matrix description is replaced by a correlation matrix whose dimension is kept linear in system size, to all orders of the approximation. Unlike the conventional variational principle which provides an upper bound on the ground-state energy, in this approach one obtains a lower bound instead. By treating several one-dimensional spin 1/21/21/2 Hamiltonians, we demonstrate the ability of this approach to produce long-range correlations, and a ground-state energy that converges to the exact result. Possible extensions, including to higher-excited states are discussed.
The method of many-body point transforms previously developed by the author is modified to eliminate the interacting particle cluster formalism. The cutoff terms in the transformation, and thus in the Hamiltonian, are therefore removed. For the hard-core many-body problem, as in the previous work, a Hamiltonian is obtained which is Fourier analyzable, Hermitian and amenable to ordinary perturbation and variational techniques while still being equivalent to the original Hamiltonian. No approximations are made. It is demonstrated that the use of the standard zeroth-order approximation of the ground state Bose system, i.e., a constant, for the transformed wavefunction gives a negative expectation value of the energy for the hard core system. This discrepancy arises from the extended range of the new potential generated by the transformation, which necessitates explicit consideration of boundary conditions not satisfied by the above wavefunction.
I formulate a 'pseudo-paradox' in the theory of a dilute Bose gas with repulsive interactions: the standard expression for the ground state energy within the Gross–Pitaevskii (GP) approximation is lower than that in the Bogoliubov approximation, and hence, by the standard variational argument, the former should prima facie be a better approximation than the latter to the true ground state—a conclusion which is of course opposite to the established wisdom concerning this problem. It is shown that the pseudo-paradox is (unsurprisingly) resolved by a correct transcription of the two-body scattering theory to the many-body case; however, contrary to what appears to be a widespread belief, the resolution has nothing to do with any spurious ultraviolet divergences which result from the replacement of the true interatomic potential by a delta-function pseudopotential. Rather, it relates to an infrared divergence which has the consequence that (a) the most obvious form of the GP 'approximation' actually does not correspond to any well-defined ansatz for the many-body wavefunction, and (b) that the 'best shot' at such a wavefunction always produces an energy which exceeds, or at best equals, that calculated in the Bogoliubov approximation. In fact, the necessity of the latter may be seen as a consequence of the need to reduce the Fock term in the energy, which is absent in the two-particle problem but dominant in the many-body case; it does this by increasing the density correlations, at distances less than or approximately equal to the correlation length , above the value extrapolated from the two-body case. As a by-product I devise an alternative formulation of the Bogoliubov approximation which does not require the explicit replacement of the true interatomic potential by a delta-function pseudopotential.