Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1408.4589 · Europhysics Letters (EPL)

Violations of the second law of thermodynamics by a non-completely positive dynamics

Giuseppe Argentieri, Fabio Benatti, Roberto Floreanini B, Marco Pezzutto

Published Sep 1, 2014• 34 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider a recently proposed model of driven open quantum micro-circuit ( Pellegrini F. , Phys. Rev. Lett. , 107 (2011) 060401) amenable to experimental investigations. We show that such an open quantum system provides a concrete physical instance where we can prove that modeling its time evolution with a dynamics lacking complete positivity conflicts with the second law of thermodynamics.

DOI
10.1209/0295-5075/107/50007

Related papers

Fluctuations and entanglement in open quantum systems

Giuseppe Argentieri

The subject of this thesis is the study of the class of the Open Quantum Systems, i.e. quantum systems which are in weak interaction with an external environment, often acting as a reservoir, and whose evolution is consequently influenced by this interaction. \nSince the coupling of the system with the reservoir is weak, it makes sense to try to disentangle the dynamics of the system of interest from the global time-evolution. However, a particular attention must be taken in the derivation of the reduced evolution law, which is expressed by a Master Equation. When the reduced dynamics of the system has to be extracted from the dynamics of the compound system, different Master Equations can be obtained by the application of different kinds of Markovian approximations, which in turn give different evolution laws. \nIn order to sort out the disparate often incompatible open quantum dynamics, a leading criterion is to ensure that they do not violate important physical properties that a proper reduced dynamics must fulfill. In primis the positivity requirement, that ensures that any physical initial state is mapped into another physical state at any later time. Secondly, the complete positivity condition, that guarantees that physical consistency is preserved also when dealing with open quantum systems which are entangled with other systems. Usually, complete positivity is justified in terms of the existence of entangled states of the open quantum system coupled to an arbitrary, inert ancilla. Complete positivity avoids the appearance of negative probabilities in the spectrum of the time-evolving states of system plus ancilla. The main bulk of this thesis work is to show that a non completely positive dynamics can lead to violations of the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

•Mar 14, 2014•0 citations

On the non-equilibrium thermodynamics of quantum systems

Stefano Marcantoni

A consistent theory of non-equilibrium thermodynamics for Markovian open quantum systems has been developed in the late seventies in analogy with Classical Irreversible Thermodynamics. The time-evolution of these open systems is usually described by means of effective master equations in Lindblad form, that turn out to be reliable when there is a separation of time-scales between system and environment, such that memory effects are negligible and the so-called Markovian approximation is justified. In this framework, the variations of energy and entropy in the system are consistently described, distinguishing between heat and work contributions and providing a statement of the second law of thermodynamics as positivity of the entropy production.\nHowever, there is empirical evidence that many physical systems like photosynthetic complexes,\nopto-mechanical resonators and superconducting qubits, just to mention a few, experience more general non-Markovian dynamics. The formulation of the laws of thermodynamics in a non-Markovian setting is matter of current research and represents the main topic of the present work. As a first step, we show that the entropy production defined as in the Markovian case can be negative for a class of non-Markovian dynamics. We argue that this outcome should not be interpreted as a violation of the second law of thermodynamics because the environment must be explicitly taken into account in the balance of entropy in the non-Markovian setting. In order to justify this claim we adopt a more general point of view, studying a closed bipartite quantum system, such that each of the two subsystems plays the role of a finite environment out of equilibrium for the other one. We concentrate on the balance of energy first and construct an effective Hamiltonian for each subsystem using physically reasonable requirements; then we define heat and work as in the standard Markovian treatment, with the effective Hamiltonian replacing the free Hamiltonian. It turns out that, in our framework, the work power is perfectly balanced between subsystems, while the correlations can store a part of energy locally inaccessible and exchange it with both subsystems in the form of heat.\nConcerning the balance of entropy, a quite general formulation of the second law of thermodynamics can be given as follows: under the assumption of a factorized initial state for the compound system, the sum of the total variations of the entropies in the two subsystems is always nonnegative. We show with an explicit example that this general formulation does not correspond to the statement presented in the framework of Markovian master equations, which should not be considered a priori the second law of thermodynamics.\nIn the last part of the thesis we concentrate of the so-called fluctuation relations, that are results extending the thermodynamic formalism beyond the behavior of average quantities. After reviewing the main theoretical outcomes, such as the Jarzynski equality and the Crooks fluctuation theorem, we describe a proposal to access experimentally the work performed on an ensemble of diatomic molecules by a time-dependent electric field coupled with their vibrational degree of freedom. This procedure could then be used to test the quantum Jarzynski equality. With respect to the results so far appeared in the literature, in which the left-hand side of the equality is inferred from an experiment and the right-hand side is computed according to a model, in our proposed setting we should be able to estimate from the experiment both the left-hand side and the right-hand side of the equality, independently.

•Feb 6, 2018•1 citation

OPEN QUANTUM SYSTEMS AND COMPLETE POSITIVITY

Roberto Floreanini B

The dynamics of an open quantum system is usually assumed to be generated by time-evolution equations of Lindblad form. It follows that the time evolutors are completely positive. Far from being just a useful technicality, complete positivity is one of the many aspects of quantum entanglement and is necessary to avoid physical inconsistencies. This issue is addressed by examining the open dynamics of two level systems in situations typical of chemical physics and quantum optics.

Cybernetics & Systems•Apr 1, 2001•6 citations

Complete positivity and dissipative factorized dynamics: some comments

Fabio Benatti, Roberto Floreanini B, Marco Piani +1 more

After reviewing the main properties of time-evolutions of open quantum systems, some considerations about the positivity of factorized Markovian dynamics for bipartite systems are made. In particular, it is shown that the positivity of the whole time-evolution in general does not ask for the complete positivity of the single system time-evolutions, if they are allowed to differ. However, they must be completely positive if one is a small perturbation of the other, which is the typical situation for open systems in a heat bath.

arXiv:quant-ph/0310151•Oct 24, 2003•4 citations

Restoring the second law to classical-quantum dynamics

Isaac Layton, Harry J. D. Miller

All physical theories should obey the second law of thermodynamics. However, existing proposals to describe the dynamics of hybrid classical-quantum systems either violate the second law or lack a proof of its existence. Here, we rectify this by studying classical-quantum dynamics that are (1) linear and completely positive and (2) preserve the thermal state of the classical-quantum system. We first prove that such dynamics necessarily satisfy the second law. We then show how these dynamics may be constructed, proposing dynamics that generalize the standard Langevin and Fokker-Planck equations for classical systems in thermal environments to include backreaction from a quantum degree of freedom. Deriving necessary and sufficient conditions for completely positive, linear, and continuous classical-quantum dynamics to satisfy detailed balance, we find this property satisfied by our dynamics. To illustrate the formalism and its applications, we introduce two models. The first is an analytically solvable model of an overdamped classical system coupled to a quantum two-level system, which we use to study the total entropy production in both quantum system and classical measurement apparatus during a quantum measurement. The second describes an underdamped classical-quantum oscillator system subject to friction, which we numerically demonstrate exhibits thermalization in the adiabatic basis, showing the relevance of our dynamics for the mixed classical-quantum simulation of molecules.

arXiv:2504.10587•Physical Review Research•Apr 7, 2026•6 citations

Entropy production in the quantum walk

Andrés Vallejo, A. Romanelli, R. Donangelo +1 more

We explore the notion of generated entropy in open quantum systems. We focus on the study of the discrete-time quantum walk on the line, from the entropy production perspective. We argue that the evolution of the coin can be modeled as an open two-level system that exchanges energy with the lattice at some effective temperature that depends on the initial state. The entropy balance shows that there is a positive-entropy production during the evolution, in accordance with the second law of thermodynamics.

arXiv:2004.04850•Physical Review A•Mar 14, 2019•3 citations
We consider a recently proposed model of driven open quantum micro-circuit ( Pellegrini F. , Phys. Rev. Lett. , 107 (2011) 060401) amenable to experimental investigations. We show that such an open quantum system provides a concrete physical instance where we can prove that modeling its time evolution with a dynamics lacking complete positivity conflicts with the second law of thermodynamics.
The subject of this thesis is the study of the class of the Open Quantum Systems, i.e. quantum systems which are in weak interaction with an external environment, often acting as a reservoir, and whose evolution is consequently influenced by this interaction. \nSince the coupling of the system with the reservoir is weak, it makes sense to try to disentangle the dynamics of the system of interest from the global time-evolution. However, a particular attention must be taken in the derivation of the reduced evolution law, which is expressed by a Master Equation. When the reduced dynamics of the system has to be extracted from the dynamics of the compound system, different Master Equations can be obtained by the application of different kinds of Markovian approximations, which in turn give different evolution laws. \nIn order to sort out the disparate often incompatible open quantum dynamics, a leading criterion is to ensure that they do not violate important physical properties that a proper reduced dynamics must fulfill. In primis the positivity requirement, that ensures that any physical initial state is mapped into another physical state at any later time. Secondly, the complete positivity condition, that guarantees that physical consistency is preserved also when dealing with open quantum systems which are entangled with other systems. Usually, complete positivity is justified in terms of the existence of entangled states of the open quantum system coupled to an arbitrary, inert ancilla. Complete positivity avoids the appearance of negative probabilities in the spectrum of the time-evolving states of system plus ancilla. The main bulk of this thesis work is to show that a non completely positive dynamics can lead to violations of the Second Law of Thermodynamics.
A consistent theory of non-equilibrium thermodynamics for Markovian open quantum systems has been developed in the late seventies in analogy with Classical Irreversible Thermodynamics. The time-evolution of these open systems is usually described by means of effective master equations in Lindblad form, that turn out to be reliable when there is a separation of time-scales between system and environment, such that memory effects are negligible and the so-called Markovian approximation is justified. In this framework, the variations of energy and entropy in the system are consistently described, distinguishing between heat and work contributions and providing a statement of the second law of thermodynamics as positivity of the entropy production.\nHowever, there is empirical evidence that many physical systems like photosynthetic complexes,\nopto-mechanical resonators and superconducting qubits, just to mention a few, experience more general non-Markovian dynamics. The formulation of the laws of thermodynamics in a non-Markovian setting is matter of current research and represents the main topic of the present work. As a first step, we show that the entropy production defined as in the Markovian case can be negative for a class of non-Markovian dynamics. We argue that this outcome should not be interpreted as a violation of the second law of thermodynamics because the environment must be explicitly taken into account in the balance of entropy in the non-Markovian setting. In order to justify this claim we adopt a more general point of view, studying a closed bipartite quantum system, such that each of the two subsystems plays the role of a finite environment out of equilibrium for the other one. We concentrate on the balance of energy first and construct an effective Hamiltonian for each subsystem using physically reasonable requirements; then we define heat and work as in the standard Markovian treatment, with the effective Hamiltonian replacing the free Hamiltonian. It turns out that, in our framework, the work power is perfectly balanced between subsystems, while the correlations can store a part of energy locally inaccessible and exchange it with both subsystems in the form of heat.\nConcerning the balance of entropy, a quite general formulation of the second law of thermodynamics can be given as follows: under the assumption of a factorized initial state for the compound system, the sum of the total variations of the entropies in the two subsystems is always nonnegative. We show with an explicit example that this general formulation does not correspond to the statement presented in the framework of Markovian master equations, which should not be considered a priori the second law of thermodynamics.\nIn the last part of the thesis we concentrate of the so-called fluctuation relations, that are results extending the thermodynamic formalism beyond the behavior of average quantities. After reviewing the main theoretical outcomes, such as the Jarzynski equality and the Crooks fluctuation theorem, we describe a proposal to access experimentally the work performed on an ensemble of diatomic molecules by a time-dependent electric field coupled with their vibrational degree of freedom. This procedure could then be used to test the quantum Jarzynski equality. With respect to the results so far appeared in the literature, in which the left-hand side of the equality is inferred from an experiment and the right-hand side is computed according to a model, in our proposed setting we should be able to estimate from the experiment both the left-hand side and the right-hand side of the equality, independently.
After reviewing the main properties of time-evolutions of open quantum systems, some considerations about the positivity of factorized Markovian dynamics for bipartite systems are made. In particular, it is shown that the positivity of the whole time-evolution in general does not ask for the complete positivity of the single system time-evolutions, if they are allowed to differ. However, they must be completely positive if one is a small perturbation of the other, which is the typical situation for open systems in a heat bath.
All physical theories should obey the second law of thermodynamics. However, existing proposals to describe the dynamics of hybrid classical-quantum systems either violate the second law or lack a proof of its existence. Here, we rectify this by studying classical-quantum dynamics that are (1) linear and completely positive and (2) preserve the thermal state of the classical-quantum system. We first prove that such dynamics necessarily satisfy the second law. We then show how these dynamics may be constructed, proposing dynamics that generalize the standard Langevin and Fokker-Planck equations for classical systems in thermal environments to include backreaction from a quantum degree of freedom. Deriving necessary and sufficient conditions for completely positive, linear, and continuous classical-quantum dynamics to satisfy detailed balance, we find this property satisfied by our dynamics. To illustrate the formalism and its applications, we introduce two models. The first is an analytically solvable model of an overdamped classical system coupled to a quantum two-level system, which we use to study the total entropy production in both quantum system and classical measurement apparatus during a quantum measurement. The second describes an underdamped classical-quantum oscillator system subject to friction, which we numerically demonstrate exhibits thermalization in the adiabatic basis, showing the relevance of our dynamics for the mixed classical-quantum simulation of molecules.
We explore the notion of generated entropy in open quantum systems. We focus on the study of the discrete-time quantum walk on the line, from the entropy production perspective. We argue that the evolution of the coin can be modeled as an open two-level system that exchanges energy with the lattice at some effective temperature that depends on the initial state. The entropy balance shows that there is a positive-entropy production during the evolution, in accordance with the second law of thermodynamics.