We give a detailed physical argument for the area law for entanglement entropy in gapped phases of matter arising from local Hamiltonians. Our approach is based on renormalization group (RG) ideas and takes a resource oriented perspective. We report four main results. First, we argue for the ``weak area law'': any gapped phase with a unique ground state on every closed manifold obeys the area law. Second, we introduce an RG based classification scheme and give a detailed argument that all phases within the classification scheme obey the area law. Third, we define a special subclass of gapped phases, topological quantum liquids, which captures all examples of current physical relevance, and we rigorously show that topological quantum liquids obey an area law. Fourth, we show that all topological quantum liquids have MERA representations which achieve unit overlap with the ground state in the thermodynamic limit and which have a bond dimension scaling with system size $L$ as ${e}^{c{log}^{d(1+\ensuremath{\delta})}(L)}$ for all $\ensuremath{\delta}>0$. For example, we show that chiral phases in $d=2$ dimensions have an approximate MERA with bond dimension ${e}^{c{log}^{2(1+\ensuremath{\delta})}(L)}$. We discuss extensively a number of subsidiary ideas and results necessary to make the main arguments, including field theory constructions. While our argument for the general area law rests on physically motivated assumptions (which we make explicit) and is therefore not rigorous, we may conclude that ``conventional'' gapped phases obey the area law and that any gapped phase which violates the area law must be a dragon.
We give a detailed physical argument for the area law for entanglement entropy in gapped phases of matter arising from local Hamiltonians. Our approach is based on renormalization group (RG) ideas and takes a resource oriented perspective. We report four main results. First, we argue for the weak area law'': any gapped phase with a unique ground state on every closed manifold obeys the area law. Second, we introduce an RG based classification scheme and give a detailed argument that all phases within the classification scheme obey the area law. Third, we define a special subclass of gapped phases, topological quantum liquids, which captures all examples of current physical relevance, and we rigorously show that topological quantum liquids obey an area law. Fourth, we show that all topological quantum liquids have MERA representations which achieve unit overlap with the ground state in the thermodynamic limit and which have a bond dimension scaling with system size $L$ as ${e}^{c{log}^{d(1+\ensuremath{\delta})}(L)}$ for all $\ensuremath{\delta}>0$. For example, we show that chiral phases in $d=2$ dimensions have an approximate MERA with bond dimension ${e}^{c{log}^{2(1+\ensuremath{\delta})}(L)}$. We discuss extensively a number of subsidiary ideas and results necessary to make the main arguments, including field theory constructions. While our argument for the general area law rests on physically motivated assumptions (which we make explicit) and is therefore not rigorous, we may conclude that conventional'' gapped phases obey the area law and that any gapped phase which violates the area law must be a dragon.
We demonstrate an area law bound on the ground state entanglement entropy of a wide class of gapless quantum states of matter using a strategy called local entanglement thermodynamics. The bound depends only on thermodynamic data, actually a single exponent, the hyperscaling violation exponent $\ensuremath{\theta}$. All systems in d spatial dimensions obeying our scaling assumptions and with $\ensuremath{\theta}<d\ensuremath{-}1$ obey the area law, while systems with $\ensuremath{\theta}=d\ensuremath{-}1$ can violate the area law at most logarithmically. We also discuss the case of frustration-free Hamiltonians and show that to violate the area law more than logarithmically these systems must have an unusually large number of low energy states. Finally, we make contact with the recently proposed s-source framework and argue that $\ensuremath{\theta}$ and s are related by $s={2}^{\ensuremath{\theta}}$.
The area law for entanglement entropy captures a fundamental constraint on the complexity of quantum many-body ground states and enables their efficient description. While the area law is rigorously established in one dimension, its status in higher-dimensional local systems remains unresolved, and it does not hold in general for geometrically non-local systems. Here, we establish a generalized area law for gapped ground states of fully connected Hamiltonians. We show that the bipartite entanglement entropy grows at most logarithmically with system size despite the absence of geometric locality. In the ground state, each site is only weakly entangled with the rest, while configurations with extensive local fluctuations are strongly suppressed, effectively restricting the accessible Hilbert space. As a consequence, the ground state admits a matrix product state approximation with polynomial bond dimension with respect to the system size at fixed accuracy. In the permutation-invariant setting, we further prove a constant entanglement bound and demonstrate that the gapped ground state can be computed in time polylogarithmic in the system size. These results show that low entanglement complexity need not rely on geometric locality, broadening the conceptual and computational scope of area laws.
In this thesis we will explore entanglement of various subsystems in quantum field theory, and its uses for describing underlying structure of states. We begin this journey by focusing on topological quantum field theory in chapters 1 and 2. These chapters are based heavily upon the papers [1] and [2, 3], respectively. In the introduction to chapter 1 we take the opportunity to recall the definition of bipartite entanglement entropy in quantum field theory and describe, briefly, how the entropy associated to connected spatial subregions provides a signature of topological order at the level of the wave-function. In particular, for a gapped phase with topological order, we recapitulate how the sub-leading correction to the “area-law” of the entanglement entropy contains coarse information about the topological phase while also being insensitive to the short-distance details of the underlying theory. We then present results that show that this sub-leading correction can also detect the class of interactions that glue a subregion to its complement. In principle, the subregion could be a different topological phase than its complement, and so we say that the entanglement entropy provides a signature of the interface between topological phases. In showing this, we discuss the classes of interactions between gapped topological phases and how they are represented as boundary conditions in the low-energy effective topological field theory, which in this case is an Abelian Chern-Simons theory. Using these boundary conditions, we perform path-integral calculations of the entanglement entropy using the replica trick and show that the universal contribution does indeed depend on the class of boundary conditions, and the gapped topological phases of the subsystem and its complement. To finish this chapter we reformulate this problem at the level of the Hilbert space and show how these universal contributions are related to resolving a generic ambiguity in defining subsystems of field theories with gauge invariance. We continue in the theme of topological field theories for chapter 2. Here we will shift focus from subregions of a connected spatial slice to disconnected spatial regions in an effort to explore, firstly, how long-range entanglement is encoded in topological field theory, and secondly, how that entanglement is encoded amongst multiple parties. We begin with a brief introduction of multi-party entanglement and recall the classification of three-party entanglement. Moving on to our specific setup, we describe the construction of states on multiple non-intersecting torus boundaries. Generically, these are states on link complements where the torus boundaries can be thought of as the edges of thickened closed strings entwined and knotted inside a compact manifold, which we will take to be the three-sphere. The wave-functions of these states are represented by various link invariants (such as the Gauss linking number for Abelian links, and Jones polynomial for SU(2)). We will exhibit several examples of multi-component links in both the Abelian and the SU(2) theories, and afterwards discuss generic features of the entanglement of link states in Chern-Simons theories with a compact group. In this discussion, we will conjecture a classification (albeit broad) of links via multi-partite entanglement of their corresponding states. We will end the chapter moving away from compact groups and discuss hyperbolic links in SL(2,C) Chern-Simons theory in the semi-classical limit. In particular, utilizing the generalized volume conjecture, we will show that the entanglement structure of hyperbolic links is greatly constrained in this semi-classical limit. Finally, in chapter 3 we switch gears and discuss renormalization of free bosonic field theory. The content of this chapter is drawn from the work of [4]. Motivated by work establishing duality between the singlet sector of O(N) vector models at large N and higher spin gauge theory on Anti de Sitter (AdS) space, we develop an exact renormalization group (ERG) framework for discussing the renormalization of a large class of O(N) singlet states. We will show that for the ground state and the excited states in this class the ERG is implemented by the action of unitary operators (that can be taken to be local). Consequently, the ERG framework can be regarded as a continuum tensor network. We contrast this tensor network with some well known tensor network renormalization schemes such as the muti-scale entanglement renormalization ansatz (MERA) and its proposed continuum version (cMERA). We also comment on the nature of this network with ordinary Wilsonian renormalization. One of the central features of the ERG network is how it acts on the momentum space entanglement of the field theory. In particular, we argue that for excited states, the ERG disentangles modes that lie just above and below the UV cutoff.
We present a class of exactly solvable 2D models whose ground states violate conventional beliefs about entanglement scaling in quantum matter. These beliefs are (i) that area law entanglement scaling originates from local correlations proximate to the boundary of the entanglement cut, and (ii) that ground state entanglement in 2D Hamiltonians cannot violate area law scaling by more than a multiplicative logarithmic factor. We explicitly present two classes of models defined by local, translation-invariant Hamiltonians, whose ground states can be exactly written as weighted superpositions of framed loop configurations. The first class of models exhibits area-law scaling, but of an intrinsically nonlocal origin so that the topological entanglement entropy scales with subsystem sizes. The second class of models has a rich ground state phase diagram that includes a phase exhibiting volume law entanglement.
The Rényi area law conjecture is false below α=1 in high dimensions
Area laws express the expectation that entanglement in gapped quantum ground states scales with a boundary rather than a volume. In one dimension this holds for every Rényi entropy, and the Rényi area-law conjecture asserts the same in higher dimensions for each fixed 0<α<1. Here we disprove this conjecture in every spatial dimension two and higher. We construct finite-range Hamiltonians with fixed local dimension, bounded interaction strength, unique ground states and a uniform spectral gap, whose ground states exhibit volume-law Rényi entanglement while obeying a von Neumann area law and remaining connected to product states through uniformly gapped local paths. The mechanism is error-space complexity: locally identifiable components of arbitrarily small weight can encode states with high entanglement complexity. We also establish the worst-case rank-error trade-off for approximate ground-state projectors, a key tool in one-dimensional area-law proofs. At fixed gap, the optimal Schmidt rank at projection error ε across a planar cut of cross-section A scales as exp[Θ~((Alogε−1)2/3)] when logε−1≳A. Thus α=1 is the sharp threshold for a universal Rényi area law within this adiabatically connected class.
Abstract An outstanding challenge involves understanding the many-particle entanglement of liquid states of quantum matter that arise in systems of interacting electrons. The Fermi liquid (FL) shows a violation of the area-law in real-space entanglement entropy of a subsystem, believed to be a signature of the ground state of a gapless quantum critical system of interacting fermions. Here, we apply a T = 0 renormalization group approach to the FL, unveiling the long-wavelength quantum fluctuations from which long-range entanglement arises. A similar analysis of non-Fermi liquids such as the 2D marginal Fermi liquid (MFL) and the 1D Tomonaga–Luttinger liquid reveals a universal logarithmic violation of the area-law in gapless electronic liquids, with a proportionality constant that depends on the nature of the underlying Fermi surface. We extend this analysis to classify the gapped quantum liquids emergent from the destabilisation of the Fermi surface by renormalisation group relevant quantum fluctuations arising from backscattering processes.