Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1407.6668

On Single Qubit Quantum State Tomography

Ramesh Bhandari

Published Jul 24, 2014• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this paper, we derive analytic expressions for the starting (initial) values of the parameters of the T-matrix that is frequently employed in the construction of a theoretical density matrix in a Maximum Likelihood Estimate (MLE) procedure; this optimization procedure is used to fit the experimental data pertaining to single qubit state tomography. Appropriate starting values are critical in achieving a global minimum in the fitting process. We also indicate an analytic way of making the experimentally determined density matrix physical without resorting to the MLE process, if optimality in quantum state tomography can be disregarded, since the ultimate goal is optimality in quantum process tomography.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1407.6668

Related papers

Alternate Forms of the T-Matrix in Quantum State Tomography

Ramesh Bhandari

In this paper, we focus on alternate forms of the T-matrix used in the Maximum Likelihood Estimate (MLE) procedure for fitting the experimental data collected in quantum state tomography experiments. In particular, we analyze the single quantum state tomography case, deriving in the process three new valid alternate forms for achieving optimality. These alternative forms then serve as a consistency check, thus enhancing the robustness of the MLE fitting process. One form, in particular, serves as a useful compliment to the standard form normally employed. We subsequently provide a generalization of these forms to the case of multiqubit state tomography.

arXiv:1407.7843•Jul 29, 2014•0 citations

Quantum state tomography of a single qubit: comparison of methods

Roman Schmied

The tomographic reconstruction of the state of a quantum-mechanical system is an essential component in the development of quantum technologies. We present an overview of different tomographic methods for determining the quantum-mechanical density matrix of a single qubit: (scaled) direct inversion, maximum likelihood estimation (MLE), minimum Fisher information distance and Bayesian mean estimation (BME). We discuss the different prior densities in the space of density matrices, on which both MLE and BME depend, as well as ways of including experimental errors and of estimating tomography errors. As a measure of the accuracy of these methods, we average the trace distance between a given density matrix and the tomographic density matrices it can give rise to through experimental measurements. We find that the BME provides the most accurate estimate of the density matrix, and suggest using either the pure-state prior, if the system is known to be in a rather pure state, or the Bures prior if any state is possible. The MLE is found to be slightly less accurate. We comment on the extrapolation of these results to larger systems.

arXiv:1407.4759•Journal of Modern Optics•Feb 7, 2016•66 citations

Local solutions of maximum likelihood estimation in quantum state tomography

Douglas Soares Gonçalves, Márcia A. Gomes-Ruggiero, Carlile Lavor +2 more

Maximum likelihood estimation is one of the most used methods in quantum state tomography, where the aim is to reconstruct the density matrix of a physical system from measurement results. One strategy to deal with positivity and unit trace constraints is to parameterize the matrix to be reconstructed in order to ensure that it is physical. In this case, the negative log-likelihood function in terms of the parameters, may have several local minima. In various papers in the field, a source of errors in this process has been associated to the possibility that most of these local minima are not global, so that optimization methods could be trapped in the wrong minimum, leading to a wrong density matrix. Here we show that, for convex negative log-likelihood functions, all local minima of the unconstrained parameterized problem are global, thus any minimizer leads to the maximum likelihood estimation for the density matrix. We also discuss some practical sources of errors.

arXiv:1103.3682•Quantum Information and Computation•Sep 1, 2012•14 citations

Optimal Experiment Design for Quantum State and Process Tomography and Hamiltonian Parameter Estimation

Robert L. Kosut, Ian A. Walmsley, HERSCHEL A. RABITZ

A number of problems in quantum state and system identification are addressed. Specifically, it is shown that the maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) approach, already known to apply to quantum state tomography, is also applicable to quantum process tomography (estimating the Kraus operator sum representation (OSR)), Hamiltonian parameter estimation, and the related problems of state and process (OSR) distribution estimation. Except for Hamiltonian parameter estimation, the other MLE problems are formally of the same type of convex optimization problem and therefore can be solved very efficiently to within any desired accuracy. Associated with each of these estimation problems, and the focus of the paper, is an optimal experiment design (OED) problem invoked by the Cramer-Rao Inequality: find the number of experiments to be performed in a particular system configuration to maximize estimation accuracy; a configuration being any number of combinations of sample times, hardware settings, prepared initial states, etc. We show that in all of the estimation problems, including Hamiltonian parameter estimation, the optimal experiment design can be obtained by solving a convex optimization problem. Software to solve the MLE and OED convex optimization problems is available upon request from the first author.

arXiv:quant-ph/0411093•Nov 12, 2004•59 citations

Behavior of the maximum likelihood in quantum state tomography

Travis L. Scholten, Robin Blume-Kohout

Quantum state tomography on a d-dimensional system demands resources that grow rapidly with d.They may be reduced by using model selection to tailor the number of parameters in the model (i.e., the size of the density matrix).Most model selection methods typically rely on a test statistic and a null theory that describes its behavior when two models are equally good.Here, we consider the loglikelihood ratio.Because of the positivity constraint ρ0, quantum state space does not generally satisfy local asymptotic normality (LAN), meaning the classical null theory for the loglikelihood ratio (the Wilks theorem) should not be used.Thus, understanding and quantifying how positivity affects the null behavior of this test statistic is necessary for its use in model selection for state tomography.We define a new generalization of LAN, metric-projected LAN, show that quantum state space satisfies it, and derive a replacement for the Wilks theorem.In addition to enabling reliable model selection, our results shed more light on the qualitative effects of the positivity constraint on state tomography.Determining the quantum state ρ 0 produced by a specific preparation procedure for a quantum system is a problem almost as old as quantum mechanics itself [1,2].This task, known as quantum state tomography [3], is not only useful in its own right (diagnosing and detecting errors in state preparation), but is also used in other characterization protocols including entanglement verification [4-6] and process tomography [7].A typical state tomography protocol proceeds as follows: many copies of ρ 0 are produced, they are measured in diverse ways, and finally the outcomes of those measurements (data) are collated and analyzed to produce an estimate r ˆ.This is a straightforward statistical inference process [8,9], where the data are used to fit the parameters of a statistical model.In state tomography, the parameter is ρ, and the model is the set of all possible density matrices on a Hilbert space  (equipped with the Born rule).However, we do not always know what model to use.It is not always a priori obvious what , or its dimension, is; examples include optical modes [10-14] and leakage levels in AMO and superconducting [15,16] qubits.In such situations, we seek to let the data itself determine which of many candidate Hilbert spaces is best suited for reconstructing ρ 0 .Choosing an appropriate Hilbert space on the fly is an instance of a general statistical problem called model selection.Although model selection has been thoroughly explored in classical statistics [17], its application to state tomography encounters some obstacles.They stem from the fact that quantum states-and therefore, estimates of them-must satisfy a positivity constraint ρ0.(See figure 1.) A similar constraint, complete positivity, applies to process tomography.The impact of positivity constraints on state and process tomography is an active area of research [18][19][20][21], and its implications for model selection have also been considered [22][23][24][25][26][27][28].In this paper, we address a specific question at the heart of this matter: How does the loglikelihood ratio statistic used in many model selection protocols, including (but not limited to) information criteria such as Akaike's AIC [29], behave in the presence of the positivity constraint ρ0?We begin in section 1 by introducing the loglikelihood ratio statistic λ, and outline how it can be used to choose a Hilbert space.In section 2, we show how and why the classical null theory for its behavior, the Wilks theorem, falls apart in the presence of the positivity constraint, because quantum state space does not generally satisfy local asymptotic normality (LAN).We define a new generalization of LAN, metric-projected local asymptotic normality (MP-LAN), in section 3; this generalization explicitly accounts for the positivity constraint, and is satisfied by quantum state space.Using this generalization, we derive a closed-form approximation for λʼs expected value in section 4, thereby providing a replacement for the Wilks theorem that is

arXiv:1609.04385•New Journal of Physics•Feb 23, 2018•23 citations

Reconstruction of quantum states by applying an analytical optimization model

Rohit Prasad, Pratyay Ghosh, Ronny Thomale +1 more

When working with quantum states, analysis of the final quantum state generated through probabilistic measurements is essential. This analysis is typically conducted by constructing the density matrix from either partial or full tomography measurements of the quantum state. While full tomography measurement offers the most accurate reconstruction of the density matrix, limited measurements pose challenges for reconstruction algorithms, often resulting in nonphysical density matrices with negative eigenvalues. This is often remedied using maximum likelihood estimators, which have a high computing time or by other estimation methods that decrease the reconstructed fidelity. In this paper, we show that when restricting the measurement sample size, improvement over existing algorithms can be achieved. Our findings underline the multiplicity of solutions in the reconstruction problem, depending upon the generated state and measurement model utilized, thus motivating further research towards identifying optimal algorithms tailored to specific experimental contexts.

arXiv:2501.07404•Physical Review A•Feb 3, 2025•2 citations
In this paper, we derive analytic expressions for the starting (initial) values of the parameters of the T-matrix that is frequently employed in the construction of a theoretical density matrix in a Maximum Likelihood Estimate (MLE) procedure; this optimization procedure is used to fit the experimental data pertaining to single qubit state tomography. Appropriate starting values are critical in achieving a global minimum in the fitting process. We also indicate an analytic way of making the experimentally determined density matrix physical without resorting to the MLE process, if optimality in quantum state tomography can be disregarded, since the ultimate goal is optimality in quantum process tomography.
In this paper, we focus on alternate forms of the T-matrix used in the Maximum Likelihood Estimate (MLE) procedure for fitting the experimental data collected in quantum state tomography experiments. In particular, we analyze the single quantum state tomography case, deriving in the process three new valid alternate forms for achieving optimality. These alternative forms then serve as a consistency check, thus enhancing the robustness of the MLE fitting process. One form, in particular, serves as a useful compliment to the standard form normally employed. We subsequently provide a generalization of these forms to the case of multiqubit state tomography.
The tomographic reconstruction of the state of a quantum-mechanical system is an essential component in the development of quantum technologies. We present an overview of different tomographic methods for determining the quantum-mechanical density matrix of a single qubit: (scaled) direct inversion, maximum likelihood estimation (MLE), minimum Fisher information distance and Bayesian mean estimation (BME). We discuss the different prior densities in the space of density matrices, on which both MLE and BME depend, as well as ways of including experimental errors and of estimating tomography errors. As a measure of the accuracy of these methods, we average the trace distance between a given density matrix and the tomographic density matrices it can give rise to through experimental measurements. We find that the BME provides the most accurate estimate of the density matrix, and suggest using either the pure-state prior, if the system is known to be in a rather pure state, or the Bures prior if any state is possible. The MLE is found to be slightly less accurate. We comment on the extrapolation of these results to larger systems.
Maximum likelihood estimation is one of the most used methods in quantum state tomography, where the aim is to reconstruct the density matrix of a physical system from measurement results. One strategy to deal with positivity and unit trace constraints is to parameterize the matrix to be reconstructed in order to ensure that it is physical. In this case, the negative log-likelihood function in terms of the parameters, may have several local minima. In various papers in the field, a source of errors in this process has been associated to the possibility that most of these local minima are not global, so that optimization methods could be trapped in the wrong minimum, leading to a wrong density matrix. Here we show that, for convex negative log-likelihood functions, all local minima of the unconstrained parameterized problem are global, thus any minimizer leads to the maximum likelihood estimation for the density matrix. We also discuss some practical sources of errors.
A number of problems in quantum state and system identification are addressed. Specifically, it is shown that the maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) approach, already known to apply to quantum state tomography, is also applicable to quantum process tomography (estimating the Kraus operator sum representation (OSR)), Hamiltonian parameter estimation, and the related problems of state and process (OSR) distribution estimation. Except for Hamiltonian parameter estimation, the other MLE problems are formally of the same type of convex optimization problem and therefore can be solved very efficiently to within any desired accuracy. Associated with each of these estimation problems, and the focus of the paper, is an optimal experiment design (OED) problem invoked by the Cramer-Rao Inequality: find the number of experiments to be performed in a particular system configuration to maximize estimation accuracy; a configuration being any number of combinations of sample times, hardware settings, prepared initial states, etc. We show that in all of the estimation problems, including Hamiltonian parameter estimation, the optimal experiment design can be obtained by solving a convex optimization problem. Software to solve the MLE and OED convex optimization problems is available upon request from the first author.
Quantum state tomography on a d-dimensional system demands resources that grow rapidly with d.They may be reduced by using model selection to tailor the number of parameters in the model (i.e., the size of the density matrix).Most model selection methods typically rely on a test statistic and a null theory that describes its behavior when two models are equally good.Here, we consider the loglikelihood ratio.Because of the positivity constraint ρ0, quantum state space does not generally satisfy local asymptotic normality (LAN), meaning the classical null theory for the loglikelihood ratio (the Wilks theorem) should not be used.Thus, understanding and quantifying how positivity affects the null behavior of this test statistic is necessary for its use in model selection for state tomography.We define a new generalization of LAN, metric-projected LAN, show that quantum state space satisfies it, and derive a replacement for the Wilks theorem.In addition to enabling reliable model selection, our results shed more light on the qualitative effects of the positivity constraint on state tomography.Determining the quantum state ρ 0 produced by a specific preparation procedure for a quantum system is a problem almost as old as quantum mechanics itself [1,2].This task, known as quantum state tomography [3], is not only useful in its own right (diagnosing and detecting errors in state preparation), but is also used in other characterization protocols including entanglement verification [4-6] and process tomography [7].A typical state tomography protocol proceeds as follows: many copies of ρ 0 are produced, they are measured in diverse ways, and finally the outcomes of those measurements (data) are collated and analyzed to produce an estimate r ˆ.This is a straightforward statistical inference process [8,9], where the data are used to fit the parameters of a statistical model.In state tomography, the parameter is ρ, and the model is the set of all possible density matrices on a Hilbert space  (equipped with the Born rule).However, we do not always know what model to use.It is not always a priori obvious what , or its dimension, is; examples include optical modes [10-14] and leakage levels in AMO and superconducting [15,16] qubits.In such situations, we seek to let the data itself determine which of many candidate Hilbert spaces is best suited for reconstructing ρ 0 .Choosing an appropriate Hilbert space on the fly is an instance of a general statistical problem called model selection.Although model selection has been thoroughly explored in classical statistics [17], its application to state tomography encounters some obstacles.They stem from the fact that quantum states-and therefore, estimates of them-must satisfy a positivity constraint ρ0.(See figure 1.) A similar constraint, complete positivity, applies to process tomography.The impact of positivity constraints on state and process tomography is an active area of research [18][19][20][21], and its implications for model selection have also been considered [22][23][24][25][26][27][28].In this paper, we address a specific question at the heart of this matter: How does the loglikelihood ratio statistic used in many model selection protocols, including (but not limited to) information criteria such as Akaike's AIC [29], behave in the presence of the positivity constraint ρ0?We begin in section 1 by introducing the loglikelihood ratio statistic λ, and outline how it can be used to choose a Hilbert space.In section 2, we show how and why the classical null theory for its behavior, the Wilks theorem, falls apart in the presence of the positivity constraint, because quantum state space does not generally satisfy local asymptotic normality (LAN).We define a new generalization of LAN, metric-projected local asymptotic normality (MP-LAN), in section 3; this generalization explicitly accounts for the positivity constraint, and is satisfied by quantum state space.Using this generalization, we derive a closed-form approximation for λʼs expected value in section 4, thereby providing a replacement for the Wilks theorem that is
When working with quantum states, analysis of the final quantum state generated through probabilistic measurements is essential. This analysis is typically conducted by constructing the density matrix from either partial or full tomography measurements of the quantum state. While full tomography measurement offers the most accurate reconstruction of the density matrix, limited measurements pose challenges for reconstruction algorithms, often resulting in nonphysical density matrices with negative eigenvalues. This is often remedied using maximum likelihood estimators, which have a high computing time or by other estimation methods that decrease the reconstructed fidelity. In this paper, we show that when restricting the measurement sample size, improvement over existing algorithms can be achieved. Our findings underline the multiplicity of solutions in the reconstruction problem, depending upon the generated state and measurement model utilized, thus motivating further research towards identifying optimal algorithms tailored to specific experimental contexts.