Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1407.5549 · Physical Review Letters

Comment on “Counterintuitive Dispersion Violating Kramers-Kronig Relations in Gain Slabs”

Denis G. Baranov, A. A. Zyablovsky, A. V. Dorofeenko, Alexey P. Vinogradov, Alexander A. Lisyansky

Published Feb 26, 2015• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this Comment, we refute conclusions made in Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 233601 (2014) by L.-G. Wang, L. Wang, M. Al-Amri, S.-Y. Zhu, and M. S. Zubairy. These conclusions stem from the use of the linear theory, which is not applicable to systems having poles of the reflection and transmission coefficients in the upper half of the complex frequency plane.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.114.089301

Related papers

Comment on "Counterintuitive Dispersion Violating Kramers-Kronig Relations in Gain Slabs" Reply

Shi-Yao Zhu, Lin Wang, Li‐Gang Wang +2 more

Physical Review Letters•Jan 1, 2015•3 citations

Comment on “Relative phase between quantum transmission and reflection amplitudes in one dimension” by Y. Fu

Massimiliano Sassoli de Bianchi

Physics Letters A•Aug 1, 1996•0 citations

Comments on “Study of the Complex Atomic Susceptibility of Erbium-Doped Fiber Amplifiers”

Jean-Fran�ois Bisson, Dmitrii Kouznetsov

This comment aims to report and correct a mistake in the paper by Desurvire (J. Lightw. Technol., vol. 8, no. 10, pp. 1517-1527, Oct. 1990) with regard to the expression of the complex susceptibility of quasi-three-level laser systems. The derived susceptibility formula contradicts the assumption of thermal equilibrium between sublevels within each manifold and leads to the wrong conclusion that the real and imaginary parts of the susceptibility of saturated materials do not verify the Kramers-Kronig relations (KKR). The corrected formula for the susceptibility is hereby proposed. The poles of the susceptibility obtained with the new formula are all located in the upper half plane of the complex plane, in accordance with the principle of causality. Hence, the KKR should be valid in the saturated regime.

Journal of Lightwave Technology•Jan 1, 2008•1 citation

Comment on “Photonic tunneling times"

Aephraim M. Steinberg

In [1], some misleading statements were made about [2] and “zero-time" tunneling. We criticize these claims.

Journal de Physique I•Dec 1, 1994•12 citations

Counterintuitive Dispersion Violating Kramers-Kronig Relations in Gain Slabs

Li‐Gang Wang, Lin Wang, M. Al-Amri +2 more

We demonstrate the counterintuitive dispersion effect that the peaks (dips) in the gain spectrum correspond to abnormal (normal) dispersion, contrary to the usual Kramers-Kronig point of view. This effect may also lead to two unique features: a broadband abnormal dispersion region and an observable Hartman effect. These results are explained in terms of interference and boundary effects. Finally, two experiments are proposed for the potential experimental verification.

Physical Review Letters•Jun 11, 2014•19 citations

Negative superluminal velocity and violation of Kramers-Kronig relations in causal optical systems

Mehmet Emre Taşgın

We investigate nonanalyticities (e.g., zeros and poles) of refractive index $n(\ensuremath{\omega})$ and group index ${n}_{g}(\ensuremath{\omega})$ in different optical media. We first demonstrate that while a Lorentzian dielectric has no nonanalyticity in the upper half of the complex frequency plane (CFP), its group index---which governs the pulse-center propagation---possesses zeros in the same region. Thus we classify the nonanalyticities as in the (a) first order (refractive index or reflection) and (b) second order (group index or group delay). The latter contains the derivative of the former. Then, we study a possible connection between the negative superluminal velocities and the presence of nonanalyticities in the upper half of the CFP. We show that the presence of nonanalyticities in the upper half of the CFP for (a) the first-order and (b) the second-order responses are accompanied by the appearance of negative (a) phase and (b) group velocities, respectively. We also distinguish between two kinds of superluminosity, $v>c$ and $v<0$, where we show that the second one ($v<0$) appears with the violation of KKRs.

arXiv:2009.13625•Physical Review A•Jan 5, 2021•0 citations
In this Comment, we refute conclusions made in Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 233601 (2014) by L.-G. Wang, L. Wang, M. Al-Amri, S.-Y. Zhu, and M. S. Zubairy. These conclusions stem from the use of the linear theory, which is not applicable to systems having poles of the reflection and transmission coefficients in the upper half of the complex frequency plane.
This comment aims to report and correct a mistake in the paper by Desurvire (J. Lightw. Technol., vol. 8, no. 10, pp. 1517-1527, Oct. 1990) with regard to the expression of the complex susceptibility of quasi-three-level laser systems. The derived susceptibility formula contradicts the assumption of thermal equilibrium between sublevels within each manifold and leads to the wrong conclusion that the real and imaginary parts of the susceptibility of saturated materials do not verify the Kramers-Kronig relations (KKR). The corrected formula for the susceptibility is hereby proposed. The poles of the susceptibility obtained with the new formula are all located in the upper half plane of the complex plane, in accordance with the principle of causality. Hence, the KKR should be valid in the saturated regime.
We investigate nonanalyticities (e.g., zeros and poles) of refractive index $n(\ensuremath{\omega})$ and group index ${n}_{g}(\ensuremath{\omega})$ in different optical media. We first demonstrate that while a Lorentzian dielectric has no nonanalyticity in the upper half of the complex frequency plane (CFP), its group index---which governs the pulse-center propagation---possesses zeros in the same region. Thus we classify the nonanalyticities as in the (a) first order (refractive index or reflection) and (b) second order (group index or group delay). The latter contains the derivative of the former. Then, we study a possible connection between the negative superluminal velocities and the presence of nonanalyticities in the upper half of the CFP. We show that the presence of nonanalyticities in the upper half of the CFP for (a) the first-order and (b) the second-order responses are accompanied by the appearance of negative (a) phase and (b) group velocities, respectively. We also distinguish between two kinds of superluminosity, v>cv>cv>c and v<0v<0v<0, where we show that the second one (v<0v<0v<0) appears with the violation of KKRs.