Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1404.2761

Implications of quantum automata for contextuality

Jibran Rashid, Abuzer Yakaryılmaz

Published Apr 10, 2014• 14 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We construct zero-error quantum finite automata (QFAs) for promise problems which cannot be solved by bounded-error probabilistic finite automata (PFAs). Here is a summary of our results: - There is a promise problem solvable by an exact two-way QFA in exponential expected time, but not by any bounded-error sublogarithmic space probabilistic Turing machine (PTM). - There is a promise problem solvable by an exact two-way QFA in quadratic expected time, but not by any bounded-error $ o(\log \log n) $-space PTMs in polynomial expected time. The same problem can be solvable by a one-way Las Vegas (or exact two-way) QFA with quantum head in linear (expected) time. - There is a promise problem solvable by a Las Vegas realtime QFA, but not by any bounded-error realtime PFA. The same problem can be solvable by an exact two-way QFA in linear expected time but not by any exact two-way PFA. - There is a family of promise problems such that each promise problem can be solvable by a two-state exact realtime QFAs, but, there is no such bound on the number of states of realtime bounded-error PFAs solving the members this family. Our results imply that there exist zero-error quantum computational devices with a \emph{single qubit} of memory that cannot be simulated by any finite memory classical computational model. This provides a computational perspective on results regarding ontological theories of quantum mechanics \cite{Hardy04}, \cite{Montina08}. As a consequence we find that classical automata based simulation models \cite{Kleinmann11}, \cite{Blasiak13} are not sufficiently powerful to simulate quantum contextuality. We conclude by highlighting the interplay between results from automata models and their application to developing a general framework for quantum contextuality.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1404.2761

Related papers

Superiority of one-way and realtime quantum machines

Abuzer Yakaryılmaz

In automata theory, quantum computation has been widely examined for finite state machines, known as quantum finite automata (QFAs), and less attention has been given to QFAs augmented with counters or stacks. In this paper, we focus on such generalizations of QFAs where the input head operates in one-way or realtime mode, and present some new results regarding their superiority over their classical counterparts. Our first result is about the nondeterministic acceptance mode: Each quantum model architecturally intermediate between realtime finite state automaton and one-way pushdown automaton (one-way finite automaton, realtime and one-way finite automata with one-counter, and realtime pushdown automaton) is superior to its classical counterpart. The second and third results are about bounded error language recognition: for any k > 0, QFAs with k blind counters outperform their deterministic counterparts; and, a one-way QFA with a single head recognizes an infinite family of languages, which can be recognized by one-way probabilistic finite automata with at least two heads. Lastly, we compare the nondeterminictic and deterministic acceptance modes for classical finite automata with k blind counter(s), and we show that for any k > 0, the nondeterministic models outperform the deterministic ones.

RAIRO - Theoretical Informatics and Applications•Oct 1, 2012•19 citations

STATE SUCCINCTNESS OF TWO-WAY FINITE AUTOMATA WITH QUANTUM AND CLASSICAL STATES

Shenggen Zheng, Daowen Qiu, Lvzhou Li

Two-way quantum automata with quantum and classical states (2QCFA) were introduced by Ambainis and Watrous in 2002. In this paper we study state succinctness of 2QCFA. For any fix m ∈ ℤ + , we show that (1) there is a promise problem A meq which can be solved by 2QCFA in polynomial expected running time with one-sided error with constant numbers of quantum and classical states, whereas the sizes of the corresponding deterministic finite automata (DFA), two-way nondeterministic finite automata (2NFA) and polynomial expected running time two-way probabilistic finite automata (2PFA) are at least 2m + 2, and ; (2) there exists a language L mtwin which can be recognized by 2QCFA in exponential expected running time with one-sided error with constant numbers of quantum and classical states, whereas the sizes of the corresponding DFA, 2NFA and polynomial expected running time 2PFA are at least 2 m , and ; where b is a constant number.

International Conference on Quantitative Logic and Soft Computing (QLSC)•Apr 1, 2012•5 citations

Classical and quantum computation with small space bounds (PhD thesis)

Abuzer Yakaryılmaz

In this thesis, we introduce a new quantum Turing machine (QTM) model that supports general quantum operators, together with its pushdown, counter, and finite automaton variants, and examine the computational power of classical and quantum machines using small space bounds in many different cases. The main contributions are summarized below. Firstly, we consider QTMs in the unbounded error setting: (i) in some cases of sublogarithmic space bounds, the class of languages recognized by QTMs is shown to be strictly larger than that of classical ones; (ii) in constant space bounds, the same result can still be obtained for restricted QTMs; (iii) the complete characterization of the class of languages recognized by realtime constant space nondeterministic QTMs is given. Secondly, we consider constant space-bounded QTMs in the bounded error setting: (i) we introduce a new type of quantum and probabilistic finite automata (QFAs and PFAs, respectively,) with a special two-way input head which is not allowed to be stationary or move to the left but has the capability to reset itself to its starting position; (ii) the computational power of this type of quantum machine is shown to be superior to that of the probabilistic machine; (iii) based on these models, two-way PFAs and two-way classical-head QFAs are shown to be more succinct than two-way nondeterministic finite automata and their one-way variants; (iv) we also introduce PFAs and QFAs with postselection with their bounded error language classes, and give many characterizations of them. Thirdly, the computational power of realtime QFAs augmented with a write-only memory is investigated by showing many simulation results for different kinds of counter automata. Finally, some lower bounds of realtime classical Turing machines in order to recognize a nonregular language are shown to be tight.

arXiv:1102.0378•Feb 2, 2011•8 citations

Lower Bounds on the Running Time of Two-Way Quantum Finite Automata and Sublogarithmic-Space Quantum Turing Machines

Zachary Remscrim

The two-way finite automaton with quantum and classical states (2QCFA), defined by Ambainis and Watrous, is a model of quantum computation whose quantum part is extremely limited; however, as they showed, 2QCFA are surprisingly powerful: a 2QCFA with only a single-qubit can recognize the language $L_{pal}=\{w \in \{a,b\}^*:w \text{ is a palindrome}\}$ with bounded error in expected time $2^{O(n)}$, on inputs of length $n$. We prove that their result essentially cannot be improved upon: a 2QCFA (of any size) cannot recognize $L_{pal}$ with bounded error in expected time $2^{o(n)}$. To our knowledge, this is the first example of a language that can be recognized with bounded error by a 2QCFA in exponential time but not in subexponential time. Moreover, we prove that a quantum Turing machine (QTM) running in space $o(\log n)$ and expected time $2^{n^{1-Ω(1)}}$ cannot recognize $L_{pal}$ with bounded error; again, this is the first lower bound of its kind. Far more generally, we establish a lower bound on the running time of any 2QCFA or $o(\log n)$-space QTM that recognizes any language $L$ in terms of a natural "hardness measure" of $L$. This allows us to exhibit a large family of languages for which we have asymptotically matching lower and upper bounds on the running time of any such 2QCFA or QTM recognizer.

arXiv:2003.09877•Leibniz international proceedings in informatics•Mar 22, 2020•7 citations

1-way quantum finite automata: strengths, weaknesses and generalizations

Andris Ambainis, Rūsiņš Freivalds

We study 1-way quantum finite automata (QFAs). First, we compare them with their classical counterparts. We show that, if an automaton is required to give the correct answer with a large probability (greater than 7/9), then any 1-way QFAs can be simulated by a 1-way reversible automaton. However, quantum automata giving the correct answer with smaller probabilities are more powerful than reversible automata. Second, we show that 1-way QFAs can be very space-efficient. We construct a 1-way QFA that is exponentially smaller than any equivalent classical (even randomized) finite automaton. We think that this construction may be useful for design of other space-efficient quantum algorithms. Third, we consider several generalizations of 1-way QFAs. Here, our goal is to find a model which is more powerful than 1-way QFAs keeping the quantum part as simple as possible.

arXiv:quant-ph/9802062•Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science•Nov 27, 2002•250 citations

New results on classical and quantum counter automata

Masaki Nakanishi, Abuzer Yakaryılmaz, Aida Gainutdinova

We show that one-way quantum one-counter automaton with zero-error is more powerful than its probabilistic counterpart on promise problems. Then, we obtain a similar separation result between Las Vegas one-way probabilistic one-counter automaton and one-way deterministic one-counter automaton. We also obtain new results on classical counter automata regarding language recognition. It was conjectured that one-way probabilistic one blind-counter automata cannot recognize Kleene closure of equality language [A. Yakaryilmaz: Superiority of one-way and realtime quantum machines. RAIRO - Theor. Inf. and Applic. 46(4): 615-641 (2012)]. We show that this conjecture is false, and also show several separation results for blind/non-blind counter automata. Comment: 21 pages

arXiv:1412.6761•Discrete Mathematics & Theoretical Computer Science•Sep 27, 2019•2 citations
We construct zero-error quantum finite automata (QFAs) for promise problems which cannot be solved by bounded-error probabilistic finite automata (PFAs). Here is a summary of our results: - There is a promise problem solvable by an exact two-way QFA in exponential expected time, but not by any bounded-error sublogarithmic space probabilistic Turing machine (PTM). - There is a promise problem solvable by an exact two-way QFA in quadratic expected time, but not by any bounded-error o(log⁡log⁡n)o(\log \log n)o(loglogn)-space PTMs in polynomial expected time. The same problem can be solvable by a one-way Las Vegas (or exact two-way) QFA with quantum head in linear (expected) time. - There is a promise problem solvable by a Las Vegas realtime QFA, but not by any bounded-error realtime PFA. The same problem can be solvable by an exact two-way QFA in linear expected time but not by any exact two-way PFA. - There is a family of promise problems such that each promise problem can be solvable by a two-state exact realtime QFAs, but, there is no such bound on the number of states of realtime bounded-error PFAs solving the members this family. Our results imply that there exist zero-error quantum computational devices with a \emph{single qubit} of memory that cannot be simulated by any finite memory classical computational model. This provides a computational perspective on results regarding ontological theories of quantum mechanics \cite{Hardy04}, \cite{Montina08}. As a consequence we find that classical automata based simulation models \cite{Kleinmann11}, \cite{Blasiak13} are not sufficiently powerful to simulate quantum contextuality. We conclude by highlighting the interplay between results from automata models and their application to developing a general framework for quantum contextuality.
In automata theory, quantum computation has been widely examined for finite state machines, known as quantum finite automata (QFAs), and less attention has been given to QFAs augmented with counters or stacks. In this paper, we focus on such generalizations of QFAs where the input head operates in one-way or realtime mode, and present some new results regarding their superiority over their classical counterparts. Our first result is about the nondeterministic acceptance mode: Each quantum model architecturally intermediate between realtime finite state automaton and one-way pushdown automaton (one-way finite automaton, realtime and one-way finite automata with one-counter, and realtime pushdown automaton) is superior to its classical counterpart. The second and third results are about bounded error language recognition: for any k > 0, QFAs with k blind counters outperform their deterministic counterparts; and, a one-way QFA with a single head recognizes an infinite family of languages, which can be recognized by one-way probabilistic finite automata with at least two heads. Lastly, we compare the nondeterminictic and deterministic acceptance modes for classical finite automata with k blind counter(s), and we show that for any k > 0, the nondeterministic models outperform the deterministic ones.
Two-way quantum automata with quantum and classical states (2QCFA) were introduced by Ambainis and Watrous in 2002. In this paper we study state succinctness of 2QCFA. For any fix m ∈ ℤ + , we show that (1) there is a promise problem A meq which can be solved by 2QCFA in polynomial expected running time with one-sided error with constant numbers of quantum and classical states, whereas the sizes of the corresponding deterministic finite automata (DFA), two-way nondeterministic finite automata (2NFA) and polynomial expected running time two-way probabilistic finite automata (2PFA) are at least 2m + 2, and ; (2) there exists a language L mtwin which can be recognized by 2QCFA in exponential expected running time with one-sided error with constant numbers of quantum and classical states, whereas the sizes of the corresponding DFA, 2NFA and polynomial expected running time 2PFA are at least 2 m , and ; where b is a constant number.
In this thesis, we introduce a new quantum Turing machine (QTM) model that supports general quantum operators, together with its pushdown, counter, and finite automaton variants, and examine the computational power of classical and quantum machines using small space bounds in many different cases. The main contributions are summarized below. Firstly, we consider QTMs in the unbounded error setting: (i) in some cases of sublogarithmic space bounds, the class of languages recognized by QTMs is shown to be strictly larger than that of classical ones; (ii) in constant space bounds, the same result can still be obtained for restricted QTMs; (iii) the complete characterization of the class of languages recognized by realtime constant space nondeterministic QTMs is given. Secondly, we consider constant space-bounded QTMs in the bounded error setting: (i) we introduce a new type of quantum and probabilistic finite automata (QFAs and PFAs, respectively,) with a special two-way input head which is not allowed to be stationary or move to the left but has the capability to reset itself to its starting position; (ii) the computational power of this type of quantum machine is shown to be superior to that of the probabilistic machine; (iii) based on these models, two-way PFAs and two-way classical-head QFAs are shown to be more succinct than two-way nondeterministic finite automata and their one-way variants; (iv) we also introduce PFAs and QFAs with postselection with their bounded error language classes, and give many characterizations of them. Thirdly, the computational power of realtime QFAs augmented with a write-only memory is investigated by showing many simulation results for different kinds of counter automata. Finally, some lower bounds of realtime classical Turing machines in order to recognize a nonregular language are shown to be tight.
The two-way finite automaton with quantum and classical states (2QCFA), defined by Ambainis and Watrous, is a model of quantum computation whose quantum part is extremely limited; however, as they showed, 2QCFA are surprisingly powerful: a 2QCFA with only a single-qubit can recognize the language Lpal={w∈{a,b}∗:w is a palindrome}L_{pal}=\{w \in \{a,b\}^*:w \text{ is a palindrome}\}Lpal​={w∈{a,b}∗:w is a palindrome} with bounded error in expected time 2O(n)2^{O(n)}2O(n), on inputs of length nnn. We prove that their result essentially cannot be improved upon: a 2QCFA (of any size) cannot recognize LpalL_{pal}Lpal​ with bounded error in expected time 2o(n)2^{o(n)}2o(n). To our knowledge, this is the first example of a language that can be recognized with bounded error by a 2QCFA in exponential time but not in subexponential time. Moreover, we prove that a quantum Turing machine (QTM) running in space o(log⁡n)o(\log n)o(logn) and expected time 2n1−Ω(1)2^{n^{1-Ω(1)}}2n1−Ω(1) cannot recognize LpalL_{pal}Lpal​ with bounded error; again, this is the first lower bound of its kind. Far more generally, we establish a lower bound on the running time of any 2QCFA or o(log⁡n)o(\log n)o(logn)-space QTM that recognizes any language LLL in terms of a natural "hardness measure" of LLL. This allows us to exhibit a large family of languages for which we have asymptotically matching lower and upper bounds on the running time of any such 2QCFA or QTM recognizer.
We study 1-way quantum finite automata (QFAs). First, we compare them with their classical counterparts. We show that, if an automaton is required to give the correct answer with a large probability (greater than 7/9), then any 1-way QFAs can be simulated by a 1-way reversible automaton. However, quantum automata giving the correct answer with smaller probabilities are more powerful than reversible automata. Second, we show that 1-way QFAs can be very space-efficient. We construct a 1-way QFA that is exponentially smaller than any equivalent classical (even randomized) finite automaton. We think that this construction may be useful for design of other space-efficient quantum algorithms. Third, we consider several generalizations of 1-way QFAs. Here, our goal is to find a model which is more powerful than 1-way QFAs keeping the quantum part as simple as possible.
We show that one-way quantum one-counter automaton with zero-error is more powerful than its probabilistic counterpart on promise problems. Then, we obtain a similar separation result between Las Vegas one-way probabilistic one-counter automaton and one-way deterministic one-counter automaton. We also obtain new results on classical counter automata regarding language recognition. It was conjectured that one-way probabilistic one blind-counter automata cannot recognize Kleene closure of equality language [A. Yakaryilmaz: Superiority of one-way and realtime quantum machines. RAIRO - Theor. Inf. and Applic. 46(4): 615-641 (2012)]. We show that this conjecture is false, and also show several separation results for blind/non-blind counter automata. Comment: 21 pages