Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1403.2834 · Reviews in Mathematical Physics

A rigorous proof of the Bohr–van Leeuwen theorem in the semiclassical limit

Baptiste Savoie

Published Sep 1, 2015• 11 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The original formulation of the Bohr–van Leeuwen (BvL) theorem states that, in a uniform magnetic field and in thermal equilibrium, the magnetization of an electron gas in the classical Drude–Lorentz model vanishes identically. This stems from classical statistics which assign the canonical momenta all values ranging from -∞ to ∞ that makes the free energy density magnetic-field-independent. When considering a classical (Maxwell–Boltzmann) interacting electron gas, it is usually admitted that the BvL theorem holds upon condition that the potentials modeling the interactions are particle-velocities-independent and do not cause the system to rotate after turning on the magnetic field. From a rigorous viewpoint, when treating large macroscopic systems, one expects the BvL theorem to hold provided the thermodynamic limit of the free energy density exists (and the equivalence of ensemble holds). This requires suitable assumptions on the many-body interactions potential and on the possible external potentials to prevent the system from collapsing or flying apart. Starting from quantum statistical mechanics, the purpose of this paper is to give, within the linear-response theory, a proof of the BvL theorem in the semiclassical limit when considering a dilute electron gas in the canonical conditions subjected to a class of translational invariant external potentials.

DOI
10.1142/s0129055x15500191

Related papers

A rigorous proof of the Bohr-van Leeuwen theorem in the semiclassical limit.

Baptiste Savoie

The original formulation of the Bohr-van Leeuwen (BvL) theorem states that, in a uniform magnetic field and in thermal equilibrium, the magnetization of an electron gas in the classical Drude-Lorentz model vanishes identically. This stems from classical statistics which assign the canonical momenta all values ranging from $-\infty$ to $\infty$ what makes the free energy density magnetic-field-independent. When considering a classical (Maxwell-Boltzmann) interacting electron gas, it is usually admitted that the BvL theorem holds upon condition that the potentials modeling the interactions are particle-velocities-independent and do not cause the system to rotate after turning on the magnetic field. From a rigorous viewpoint, when treating large macroscopic systems one expects the BvL theorem to hold provided the thermodynamiclimit of the free energy density exists (and the equivalence of ensemble holds). This requires suitable assumptions on the many-body interactions potential and on the possible external potentials to prevent the system from collapsing or flying apart. Starting from quantum statistical mechanics, the purpose of this article is to give, within the linear-response theory, a proof of the BvL theorem in the semiclassical limit when considering a dilute electron gas in the canonical conditions subjected to a class of translational invariant external potentials.

•Mar 11, 2014•8 citations

Thermodynamic extension of density-functional theory. II. Finite-temperature ensemble spin-density functional theory

Robert Balawender, A. Holas

The formalism developed in the first paper of the series [arXiv:0901.1060] is applied to two thermodynamic systems: (i) of three global observables (the energy, the total electron number and the spin number), (ii) of one global observable (the internal electron energy) and two local (position-dependent) observables (the total electron density and the spin density). The two-component potential of the many-electron system of interest is constructed of a scalar external potential and a collinear magnetic field (coupled only with the spin operator). Various equilibrium characteristics of two systems are defined and investigated. Conditions for the equivalence between two systems (the same equilibrium density matrix demanded) are derived and thoroughly discussed. The applicability of the Hohenberg-Kohn theorem is extended to the thermodynamic spin-density functional theory. Obtained results provide a rigorous mathematical foundation for future derivation of the zero-temperature limit of this theory and determination of its chemical reactivity indices.

arXiv:0904.3990•Apr 25, 2009•11 citations

Diamagnetism of a free particle in classical electron theory with classical electromagnetic zero-point radiation

Timothy H. Boyer

Landau's diamagnetism for a free point charge is shown to exist within classical electron theory with classical electromagnetic zero-point radiation. The system considered is a nonrelativistic classical point charge bound harmonically in three dimensions and situated in a magnetic field when random classical electromagnetic zero-point radiation or thermal radiation is present. The average energy, angular momentum, and magnetic moment are calculated at finite temperature, and then carried to the limit at which the harmonic binding vanishes so as to obtain the behavior for a free particle. In the presence of the Rayleigh-Jeans radiation spectrum one finds that all diamagnetic effects vanish, in agreement with the results of traditional classical statistical mechanics. In the Planck radiation spectrum one finds exactly the results of quantum theory involving a Langevin function for the temperature dependence. In particular, the average angular momentum and magnetic moment for a classical point charge in classical zero-point radiation are $〈{L}_{z}〉=\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\hbar}$ and $〈{M}_{z}〉=\ensuremath{-}|e|\frac{\ensuremath{\hbar}}{2\mathrm{mc}}$, where the orientation of the $z$ axis is given by the magnetic field direction. Thus the classical results in the presence of classical zero-point radiation are entirely different from those of traditional classical electron theory, and they suggest possible classical explanations of the space quantization appearing in quantum theory. The results also suggest a derivation of Planck's spectrum from traditional classical statistical mechanics by applying Boltzmann statistics to the orientation of the average magnetic moment caused by the zero-point radiation.

Physical Review A•Jan 1, 1980•33 citations

On Magnetic Models in Wavefunction Ensembles

Leonardo De Carlo, W. David Wick

In a wavefunction-only philosophy, thermodynamics must be recast in terms of an ensemble of wavefunctions. In this perspective we study how to construct Gibbs ensembles for magnetic quantum spin models. We show that with free boundary conditions and distinguishable “spins” there are no finite-temperature phase transitions because of high dimensionality of the phase space. Then we focus on the simplest case, namely the mean-field (Curie–Weiss) model, in order to discover whether phase transitions are even possible in this model class. This strategy at least diminishes the dimensionality of the problem. We found that, even assuming exchange symmetry in the wavefunctions, no finite-temperature phase transitions appear when the Hamiltonian is given by the usual energy expression of quantum mechanics (in this case the analytical argument is not totally satisfactory and we relied partly on a computer analysis). However, a variant model with additional “wavefunction energy” does have a phase transition to a magnetized state. (With respect to dynamics, which we do not consider here, wavefunction energy induces a non-linearity which nevertheless preserves norm and energy. This non-linearity becomes significant only at the macroscopic level.) The three results together suggest that magnetization in large wavefunction spin chains appears if and only if we consider indistinguishable particles and block macroscopic dispersion (i.e., macroscopic superpositions) by energy conservation. Our principle technique involves transforming the problem to one in probability theory, then applying results from large deviations, particularly the Gärtner–Ellis Theorem. Finally, we discuss Gibbs vs. Boltzmann/Einstein entropy in the choice of the quantum thermodynamic ensemble, as well as open problems.

arXiv:2208.07688•Entropy•Mar 25, 2023•5 citations

Théorèmes de de Finetti, limites de champ moyen et condensation de Bose-Einstein

Nicolas Rougerie

These lecture notes treat the mean-field approximation for equilibrium states of N body systems in classical and quantum statistical mechanics. A general strategy to justify effective models based on assumptions of statistical independence of the particles is in presented in detail. The main tools are a structure theorems of de Finetti that describe large N limits of states accessible to the systems in question, exploiting the indistinguishablity of particles. The focus is on quantum aspects, particularly the mean-field approximation for the ground state of a large system of bosons, in connection with Bose-Einstein condensation: structure of reduced density matrices of a large bosonic system, localization methods in Fock space, derivation of Hartree and non-linear Schrödinger effective energy functionals.

arXiv:1409.1182•Sep 3, 2014•13 citations

〈ノート〉多体問題とグリーン関数との関係の研究--グリーン関数と多体問題(18) 量子統計力学(10)

橋爪 邦夫

[Synopsis] 0The alignment of the electron spin with the external magnetic field give rise to paramagnetism. Whereas, the orbital motions of the electrons give rise to diamagnetism. In this paper we consider the idealized problem of a free spinless electron gas in an external magnetic field H=H^^z . A free electron moves in a circular orbital quantized normal to the uniform magnetic field with the cycrotron frequency ω=<—eμ_0H>/m. The energy eigenvalues in two-dimesional electron system E_j =hω_0(j+1/2)=βH(2j+1) (j=0,1,2,・・・) are the Landau energy levels. β is a Bohr magneton. g=<—eμ_0H>/hL^2 is the degeneracy of a Landau level . In the low-temperature limit of electron in Landau levels, the electrons have a tendency to occupy the lowest available levels. As the magnetic field is decrease, each Landau level can accommodate fewer electrons because the degeneracy g is decreased. Consequently, some electrons will be forced to jump up to a higher level. This cause the oscillation of the low-temperature magnetic susceptibility X_m as a inverse function of the magnetic field 1/H. The magnetization M also oscillates as a function of the magnetic field. We call these phenomena the de Haas-Van Alphen effect.

近畿大学工学部研究報告•Dec 1, 2011•0 citations
The original formulation of the Bohr–van Leeuwen (BvL) theorem states that, in a uniform magnetic field and in thermal equilibrium, the magnetization of an electron gas in the classical Drude–Lorentz model vanishes identically. This stems from classical statistics which assign the canonical momenta all values ranging from -∞ to ∞ that makes the free energy density magnetic-field-independent. When considering a classical (Maxwell–Boltzmann) interacting electron gas, it is usually admitted that the BvL theorem holds upon condition that the potentials modeling the interactions are particle-velocities-independent and do not cause the system to rotate after turning on the magnetic field. From a rigorous viewpoint, when treating large macroscopic systems, one expects the BvL theorem to hold provided the thermodynamic limit of the free energy density exists (and the equivalence of ensemble holds). This requires suitable assumptions on the many-body interactions potential and on the possible external potentials to prevent the system from collapsing or flying apart. Starting from quantum statistical mechanics, the purpose of this paper is to give, within the linear-response theory, a proof of the BvL theorem in the semiclassical limit when considering a dilute electron gas in the canonical conditions subjected to a class of translational invariant external potentials.
The original formulation of the Bohr-van Leeuwen (BvL) theorem states that, in a uniform magnetic field and in thermal equilibrium, the magnetization of an electron gas in the classical Drude-Lorentz model vanishes identically. This stems from classical statistics which assign the canonical momenta all values ranging from −∞-\infty−∞ to ∞\infty∞ what makes the free energy density magnetic-field-independent. When considering a classical (Maxwell-Boltzmann) interacting electron gas, it is usually admitted that the BvL theorem holds upon condition that the potentials modeling the interactions are particle-velocities-independent and do not cause the system to rotate after turning on the magnetic field. From a rigorous viewpoint, when treating large macroscopic systems one expects the BvL theorem to hold provided the thermodynamiclimit of the free energy density exists (and the equivalence of ensemble holds). This requires suitable assumptions on the many-body interactions potential and on the possible external potentials to prevent the system from collapsing or flying apart. Starting from quantum statistical mechanics, the purpose of this article is to give, within the linear-response theory, a proof of the BvL theorem in the semiclassical limit when considering a dilute electron gas in the canonical conditions subjected to a class of translational invariant external potentials.
The formalism developed in the first paper of the series [arXiv:0901.1060] is applied to two thermodynamic systems: (i) of three global observables (the energy, the total electron number and the spin number), (ii) of one global observable (the internal electron energy) and two local (position-dependent) observables (the total electron density and the spin density). The two-component potential of the many-electron system of interest is constructed of a scalar external potential and a collinear magnetic field (coupled only with the spin operator). Various equilibrium characteristics of two systems are defined and investigated. Conditions for the equivalence between two systems (the same equilibrium density matrix demanded) are derived and thoroughly discussed. The applicability of the Hohenberg-Kohn theorem is extended to the thermodynamic spin-density functional theory. Obtained results provide a rigorous mathematical foundation for future derivation of the zero-temperature limit of this theory and determination of its chemical reactivity indices.
Landau's diamagnetism for a free point charge is shown to exist within classical electron theory with classical electromagnetic zero-point radiation. The system considered is a nonrelativistic classical point charge bound harmonically in three dimensions and situated in a magnetic field when random classical electromagnetic zero-point radiation or thermal radiation is present. The average energy, angular momentum, and magnetic moment are calculated at finite temperature, and then carried to the limit at which the harmonic binding vanishes so as to obtain the behavior for a free particle. In the presence of the Rayleigh-Jeans radiation spectrum one finds that all diamagnetic effects vanish, in agreement with the results of traditional classical statistical mechanics. In the Planck radiation spectrum one finds exactly the results of quantum theory involving a Langevin function for the temperature dependence. In particular, the average angular momentum and magnetic moment for a classical point charge in classical zero-point radiation are $〈{L}_{z}〉=\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\hbar}$ and $〈{M}_{z}〉=\ensuremath{-}|e|\frac{\ensuremath{\hbar}}{2\mathrm{mc}}$, where the orientation of the zzz axis is given by the magnetic field direction. Thus the classical results in the presence of classical zero-point radiation are entirely different from those of traditional classical electron theory, and they suggest possible classical explanations of the space quantization appearing in quantum theory. The results also suggest a derivation of Planck's spectrum from traditional classical statistical mechanics by applying Boltzmann statistics to the orientation of the average magnetic moment caused by the zero-point radiation.
In a wavefunction-only philosophy, thermodynamics must be recast in terms of an ensemble of wavefunctions. In this perspective we study how to construct Gibbs ensembles for magnetic quantum spin models. We show that with free boundary conditions and distinguishable “spins” there are no finite-temperature phase transitions because of high dimensionality of the phase space. Then we focus on the simplest case, namely the mean-field (Curie–Weiss) model, in order to discover whether phase transitions are even possible in this model class. This strategy at least diminishes the dimensionality of the problem. We found that, even assuming exchange symmetry in the wavefunctions, no finite-temperature phase transitions appear when the Hamiltonian is given by the usual energy expression of quantum mechanics (in this case the analytical argument is not totally satisfactory and we relied partly on a computer analysis). However, a variant model with additional “wavefunction energy” does have a phase transition to a magnetized state. (With respect to dynamics, which we do not consider here, wavefunction energy induces a non-linearity which nevertheless preserves norm and energy. This non-linearity becomes significant only at the macroscopic level.) The three results together suggest that magnetization in large wavefunction spin chains appears if and only if we consider indistinguishable particles and block macroscopic dispersion (i.e., macroscopic superpositions) by energy conservation. Our principle technique involves transforming the problem to one in probability theory, then applying results from large deviations, particularly the Gärtner–Ellis Theorem. Finally, we discuss Gibbs vs. Boltzmann/Einstein entropy in the choice of the quantum thermodynamic ensemble, as well as open problems.
These lecture notes treat the mean-field approximation for equilibrium states of N body systems in classical and quantum statistical mechanics. A general strategy to justify effective models based on assumptions of statistical independence of the particles is in presented in detail. The main tools are a structure theorems of de Finetti that describe large N limits of states accessible to the systems in question, exploiting the indistinguishablity of particles. The focus is on quantum aspects, particularly the mean-field approximation for the ground state of a large system of bosons, in connection with Bose-Einstein condensation: structure of reduced density matrices of a large bosonic system, localization methods in Fock space, derivation of Hartree and non-linear Schrödinger effective energy functionals.
[Synopsis] 0The alignment of the electron spin with the external magnetic field give rise to paramagnetism. Whereas, the orbital motions of the electrons give rise to diamagnetism. In this paper we consider the idealized problem of a free spinless electron gas in an external magnetic field H=H^^z . A free electron moves in a circular orbital quantized normal to the uniform magnetic field with the cycrotron frequency ω=<—eμ_0H>/m. The energy eigenvalues in two-dimesional electron system E_j =hω_0(j+1/2)=βH(2j+1) (j=0,1,2,・・・) are the Landau energy levels. β is a Bohr magneton. g=<—eμ_0H>/hL^2 is the degeneracy of a Landau level . In the low-temperature limit of electron in Landau levels, the electrons have a tendency to occupy the lowest available levels. As the magnetic field is decrease, each Landau level can accommodate fewer electrons because the degeneracy g is decreased. Consequently, some electrons will be forced to jump up to a higher level. This cause the oscillation of the low-temperature magnetic susceptibility X_m as a inverse function of the magnetic field 1/H. The magnetization M also oscillates as a function of the magnetic field. We call these phenomena the de Haas-Van Alphen effect.