Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1403.2374 · Information

Quantum States as Ordinary Information

K. B. Wharton

Published Mar 7, 2014• 44 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Despite various parallels between quantum states and ordinary information, quantum no-go-theorems have convinced many that there is no realistic framework that might underly quantum theory, no reality that quantum states can represent knowledge about. This paper develops the case that there is a plausible underlying reality: one actual spacetime-based history, although with behavior that appears strange when analyzed dynamically (one time-slice at a time). By using a simple model with no dynamical laws, it becomes evident that this behavior is actually quite natural when analyzed “all-at-once” (as in classical action principles). From this perspective, traditional quantum states would represent incomplete information about possible spacetime histories, conditional on the future measurement geometry. Without dynamical laws imposing additional restrictions, those histories can have a classical probability distribution, where exactly one history can be said to represent an underlying reality.

DOI
10.3390/info5010190

Related papers

Quantum Measure Theory and its Interpretation

Rafael D. Sorkin

We propose a realistic, spacetime interpretation of quantum theory in which reality constitutes a *single* history obeying a "law of motion" that makes definite, but incomplete, predictions about its behavior. We associate a "quantum measure" |S| to the set S of histories, and point out that |S| fulfills a sum rule generalizing that of classical probability theory. We interpret |S| as a "propensity", making this precise by stating a criterion for |S|=0 to imply "preclusion" (meaning that the true history will not lie in S). The criterion involves triads of correlated events, and in application to electron-electron scattering, for example, it yields definite predictions about the electron trajectories themselves, independently of any measuring devices which might or might not be present. (So we can give an objective account of measurements.) Two unfinished aspects of the interpretation involve *conditonal* preclusion (which apparently requires a notion of coarse-graining for its formulation) and the need to "locate spacetime regions in advance" without the aid of a fixed background metric (which can be achieved in the context of conditional preclusion via a construction which makes sense both in continuum gravity and in the discrete setting of causal set theory).

arXiv:gr-qc/9507057•Jul 30, 1995•112 citations

On the Physics of History Space: The Ensemble of Histories and Quantum Reality as an Ontological Foundation

Jincheng Zhang

If Richard Feynman's path integral formulation had been proposed not merely as a computational tool for probability amplitudes, but as a fundamental physical ontology—namely, that "all histories collectively constitute reality"—the foundational paradigm of physics would have undergone a profound transformation. Traditional physics treats a single trajectory of a system in spacetime as the primary object and path integration as a summation technique over possible paths. This paper systematically develops an alternative framework: Physics of History Space, where the ensemble of all possible histories serves as the irreduceable primary object of physical description. Within this paradigm, physical reality is defined by the topology, measure, and algebraic structures over the space of histories, rather than being restricted to a single actualized trajectory. We establish the mathematical formulation of history space and re-examine the measurement problem in quantum mechanics, the problem of initial conditions in cosmology, and the philosophy of time. We demonstrate that classical single-trajectory spacetime emerges merely as a low-dimensional projection of history space under decoherence and stationary phase limits.

•Jul 25, 2026•0 citations

Spacetime information

James B. Hartle

In usual quantum theory, the information available about a quantum system is defined in terms of the density matrix describing it on a spacelike surface. This definition must be generalized for extensions of quantum theory which neither require, nor always permit, a notion of state on a spacelike surface. In particular, it must be generalized for the generalized quantum theories appropriate when spacetime geometry fluctuates quantum mechanically or when geometry is fixed but not foliable by spacelike surfaces. This paper introduces a four-dimensional notion of the information available about a quantum system's boundary conditions in the various sets of decohering, coarse-grained histories it may display. This spacetime notion of information coincides with the familiar one when quantum theory is formulable in terms of states on spacelike surfaces but generalizes this notion when it cannot be so formulated. The idea of spacetime information is applied in several contexts: When spacetime geometry is fixed the information available through alternatives restricted to a fixed spacetime region is defined. The information available through histories of alternatives of general operators is compared to that obtained from the more limited coarse grainings of sum-over-histories quantum mechanics that refer only to coordinates. The definition of information is considered in generalized quantum theories. We consider as specific examples time-neutral quantum mechanics with initial and final conditions, quantum theories with nonunitary evolution, and the generalized quantum frameworks appropriate for quantum spacetime. In such theories complete information about a quantum system is not necessarily available on any spacelike surface but must be searched for throughout spacetime. The information loss commonly associated with the ``evolution of pure states into mixed states'' in black hole evaporation is thus not in conflict with the principles of generalized quantum mechanics.

arXiv:gr-qc/9409005•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Feb 15, 1995•19 citations

Physical Reality and Information - Three Hypotheses

Gerd Niestegge

Since its emergence, quantum mechanics has been a challenge for an understanding of reality which is based on our intuition in a classical world. Nevertheless, it has often been tried to impose this understanding of reality on quantum theory - with limited success. Instead, it might be a better alternative to redefine the meaning of physical reality. This is the objective of the paper. A consideration of the quantum measurement process, conditional probabilities and some well-known typical quantum physical experiments provides the reasoning for the following three hypotheses: (1) Prior to a first measurement, a physical system is not in a quantum state. (2) Physical reality is all that and only that about which (classical) information is available in the universe. (3) Information creation is an independent process and is not covered by the Schroedinger equation. It is the first step of the quantum measurement process and does not have a classical counterpart. The first hypothesis makes sense only if the quantum measurement process can be described without presupposing an initial state for the system under consideration. This becomes possible by the objective conditional probabilities which represent the transition probabilities between the outcomes of successive quantum measurements and have been introduced by the author in some recent papers. The second hypothesis holds as well in the classical case, but a certain incompleteness of reality is typical of quantum mechanics and the origin of many quantum phenomena. Classically, the existence of a complete reality is presumed, and hypothesis 3 has no meaning then.

arXiv:1003.2379•Mar 11, 2010•1 citation

Entropy as Inference and Entropy as a Physical Field: A Comprehensive Comparison of Ariel Caticha’s Entropic Dynamics (ED) and Obidi’s Theory of Entropicity (ToE)

John Onimisi Obidi

Entropy as Inference and Entropy as a Physical Field: A Comprehensive Comparison of Ariel Caticha’s Entropic Dynamics and Obidi’s Theory of Entropicity (ToE) Introduction Putting Ariel Caticha’s work on entropic dynamics (ED) side by side with Obidi’s Theory of Entropicity (ToE) is like comparing two very different bets on what “entropy” is allowed to be in physics. Both take entropy seriously, both see it as more than a bookkeeping device, and both use information‑theoretic ideas. But they diverge at the deepest level: Caticha treats entropy as an epistemic principle guiding inference about an underlying reality, while Obidi treats entropy as the ontological field that constitutes reality itself. That difference—epistemic versus ontological—is not cosmetic. It changes what counts as a law of nature, what time is, what causality is, and what it even means for something to exist. Caticha: Entropy as a principle of inference and dynamics Ariel Caticha’s program, broadly called entropic dynamics, starts from the idea that physical laws can be derived from principles of inference, especially the method of maximum entropy. The core move is: given incomplete information about a system, the best we can do is update probability distributions in a way that is consistent with known constraints and maximizes entropy subject to those constraints. From this perspective, dynamics—how systems evolve in time—can be seen as a sequence of entropic updates. Caticha shows that, under suitable assumptions, one can recover forms of classical and quantum dynamics from entropic inference. Time, in this view, is an ordering parameter for updates; it is not fundamental but emerges as a way of indexing successive states of knowledge. The underlying ontology is relatively modest: there is some “stuff” (positions, configurations, etc.), and we have incomplete information about it. Entropy quantifies that ignorance, and the laws of motion are rules for updating probabilities. So in Caticha’s world, entropy is: a measure of uncertainty, a tool for inference, a generator of effective dynamics. It is powerful, but it is not the substance of reality. It is about how we reason about reality. Obidi: Entropy as the Fundamental Field of Reality Obidi’s Theory of Entropicity (ToE) takes a much more audacious step. It does not merely use entropy to derive dynamics; it declares entropy to be the primitive physical field from which everything else emerges. Entropy is not a measure of ignorance; it is the structure that makes knowledge, states, and even ignorance possible. In ToE, the universe does not begin with spacetime, particles, or even probability distributions. It begins with an entropic field whose configurations encode distinguishability, structure, and the capacity for events to occur. Space and time are emergent bookkeeping devices that track how this entropic field differentiates itself. Causality is not geometric but entropic: events become causally related when the entropic field has evolved enough to separate and stabilize them. Measurement is not a mysterious collapse but an entropic stabilization of previously indistinguishable alternatives. Matter is "frozen" entropy; mass is stabilized internal entropic content; [absolute/inherent] identity is what survives when entropy can no longer erase distinctions [in a given system or element]. Where Caticha uses entropy to derive dynamics on an underlying configuration space, Obidi uses entropy to generate the configuration space itself, along with its geometry, its dynamics, and its ontology. Comparison of Ariel Caticha’s Entropic Dynamics and Obidi’s Theory of Entropicity: Conceptual, Philosophical, and Structural Differences A comparison between Ariel Caticha’s entropic dynamics and Obidi’s Theory of Entropicity (ToE) reveals two fundamentally different visions of what entropy is and what role it plays in physics. Caticha’s work is rooted in the epistemic tradition: entropy is a measure of uncertainty, and physical laws emerge from principles of inference. Obidi’s work is rooted in an ontological re‑founding of physics: entropy is the fundamental physical field, and the universe emerges from its evolution. Caticha’s entropic dynamics begins with the assumption that we have incomplete information about the positions or configurations of a system. Using the method of maximum entropy, he derives rules for updating probability distributions in a way that is consistent with known constraints. Under certain assumptions, these updates reproduce forms of classical and quantum dynamics. Time, in this framework, is an ordering parameter for successive entropic inferences. The underlying ontology remains modest: there is a configuration space, there are unknown variables, and entropy quantifies our uncertainty about them. Caticha’s program is therefore a powerful epistemic reconstruction of dynamics, but it does not claim that entropy is a physical field or that it generates spacetime, causality, or matter. Obidi’s Theory of Entropicity takes a radically different approach. Entropy is not a measure of ignorance but the primitive ontological field. It is the substrate from which distinguishability, time, causality, measurement, matter, and geometry emerge. The entropic and coherent sectors are not epistemic constructs but structural phases of the entropic field. The entropic sector is the domain of irreversible becoming, where the entropic field differentiates itself and writes the arrow of time. The coherent sector is the domain of stabilized being, where structures persist and interact. This two‑sector architecture is not present in Caticha’s work and has no analogue in entropic dynamics. Furthermore, Caticha does not develop a philosophical interpretation of his framework. His papers are technical, focused on inference, probability updating, and the derivation of dynamical equations. He does not address the ontological status of entropy, the metaphysics of becoming, the nature of measurement, or the philosophical implications of entropic evolution. Obidi, by contrast, explicitly engages with the philosophical foundations of physics, drawing connections to ontology, metaphysics, epistemology, and the philosophy of time. His work situates the Theory of Entropicity (ToE) within a broader intellectual tradition, including comparisons with Paul Tillich, Schopenhauer, and the classical distinction between appearance and reality. The originality of Obidi’s contribution lies in the systematic way he reorders the explanatory hierarchy of physics. Instead of deriving dynamics from inference, he derives inference, dynamics, geometry, and matter from the entropic field alone. Instead of treating probability as epistemic, he derives it as a conserved physical quantity. Instead of treating measurement as a postulate, he explains it as entropic stabilization. Instead of treating spacetime as fundamental, he derives it from information geometry via the Obidi Action. Instead of treating coherence as a mathematical artifact, he interprets and grounds it as a structural phase of the entropic field. The broader implications of this difference are profound. Caticha’s program suggests that physics is ultimately about how rational agents should update their beliefs. Obidi’s program suggests that physics is about how the universe entropically becomes what it is [and that ultimately it is not about beliefs taken as isolated givens or provisos independent of the Entropic Field (EF)]. Caticha reconstructs known laws; Obidi reconstructs the foundations from which laws arise. Caticha’s entropy is epistemic; Obidi’s entropy is ontological. Caticha’s dynamics is inferential; Obidi’s dynamics is generative. Caticha’s framework is silent on metaphysics; Obidi’s framework is a metaphysics inseparable from physics. References (Caticha): Caticha, A. Entropic Dynamics, in Bayesian Inference and Maximum Entropy Methods in Science and Engineering, AIP Conference Proceedings, 2011. Caticha, A. Entropic Inference and the Foundations of Physics, 2012. Caticha, A. From Entropic Dynamics to Quantum Theory, 2014. References (Obidi): Obidi, J. O. Theory of Entropicity (ToE) Canonical Archives, 2024–2026. Obidi, J. O. Obidi’s Philosophical Analysis of Being and Becoming, 2026. Obidi, J. O. The Obidi Action, Entropic Geometry, and the Emergence of Spacetime, 2025. Obidi, J. O. The Obidi Probability Law and the Two‑Sector Hilbert Space Decomposition, 2025. Entropic and Coherent Sectors: Caticha versus Obidi The language of “entropic” and “coherent” sectors is especially revealing. In Caticha’s framework, the entropic sector is essentially the inferential machinery: probability distributions, entropy functionals, constraints, and the maximum entropy principle. Coherence, when it appears, is largely about consistency of inference and the emergence of quantum‑like structures (e.g., complex amplitudes, Hilbert space) from entropic updating. The “coherent” behavior is a feature of how probability amplitudes evolve under entropic rules, not a separate ontological sector of reality. In Obidi’s ToE, the entropic and coherent sectors are structurally deeper. The entropic sector is the domain where the entropic field is actively differentiating, where distinguishability is being created, where time’s arrow is being written. The coherent sector is the regime where structures—once formed by entropic evolution—exhibit stability, persistence, and internal consistency. Coherence here is not just a property of wavefunctions; it is a structural phase of the entropic field itself. You can think of it this way: in ToE, the entropic sector is the “becoming” of reality, while the coherent sector is the “being” that results from that becoming. The two are not separate theories but two regimes of the same entropic substrate. The entropic sector governs how new distinctions, structures, and events come into existence; the coherent secto

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Entangled histories

Jordan S. Cotler, Frank A. Wilczek

We introduce quantum history states and their mathematical framework, thereby reinterpreting and extending the consistent histories approach to quantum theory. Through thought experiments, we demonstrate that our formalism allows us to analyze a quantum version of history in which we reconstruct the past by observations. In particular, we can pass from measurements to inferences about ‘what happened’ in a way that is sensible and free of paradox. Our framework allows for a richer understanding of the temporal structure of quantum theory, and we construct history states that embody peculiar, non-classical correlations in time.

arXiv:1502.02480•Physica Scripta•May 12, 2016•39 citations
Despite various parallels between quantum states and ordinary information, quantum no-go-theorems have convinced many that there is no realistic framework that might underly quantum theory, no reality that quantum states can represent knowledge about. This paper develops the case that there is a plausible underlying reality: one actual spacetime-based history, although with behavior that appears strange when analyzed dynamically (one time-slice at a time). By using a simple model with no dynamical laws, it becomes evident that this behavior is actually quite natural when analyzed “all-at-once” (as in classical action principles). From this perspective, traditional quantum states would represent incomplete information about possible spacetime histories, conditional on the future measurement geometry. Without dynamical laws imposing additional restrictions, those histories can have a classical probability distribution, where exactly one history can be said to represent an underlying reality.
We propose a realistic, spacetime interpretation of quantum theory in which reality constitutes a *single* history obeying a "law of motion" that makes definite, but incomplete, predictions about its behavior. We associate a "quantum measure" |S| to the set S of histories, and point out that |S| fulfills a sum rule generalizing that of classical probability theory. We interpret |S| as a "propensity", making this precise by stating a criterion for |S|=0 to imply "preclusion" (meaning that the true history will not lie in S). The criterion involves triads of correlated events, and in application to electron-electron scattering, for example, it yields definite predictions about the electron trajectories themselves, independently of any measuring devices which might or might not be present. (So we can give an objective account of measurements.) Two unfinished aspects of the interpretation involve *conditonal* preclusion (which apparently requires a notion of coarse-graining for its formulation) and the need to "locate spacetime regions in advance" without the aid of a fixed background metric (which can be achieved in the context of conditional preclusion via a construction which makes sense both in continuum gravity and in the discrete setting of causal set theory).
If Richard Feynman's path integral formulation had been proposed not merely as a computational tool for probability amplitudes, but as a fundamental physical ontology—namely, that "all histories collectively constitute reality"—the foundational paradigm of physics would have undergone a profound transformation. Traditional physics treats a single trajectory of a system in spacetime as the primary object and path integration as a summation technique over possible paths. This paper systematically develops an alternative framework: Physics of History Space, where the ensemble of all possible histories serves as the irreduceable primary object of physical description. Within this paradigm, physical reality is defined by the topology, measure, and algebraic structures over the space of histories, rather than being restricted to a single actualized trajectory. We establish the mathematical formulation of history space and re-examine the measurement problem in quantum mechanics, the problem of initial conditions in cosmology, and the philosophy of time. We demonstrate that classical single-trajectory spacetime emerges merely as a low-dimensional projection of history space under decoherence and stationary phase limits.
In usual quantum theory, the information available about a quantum system is defined in terms of the density matrix describing it on a spacelike surface. This definition must be generalized for extensions of quantum theory which neither require, nor always permit, a notion of state on a spacelike surface. In particular, it must be generalized for the generalized quantum theories appropriate when spacetime geometry fluctuates quantum mechanically or when geometry is fixed but not foliable by spacelike surfaces. This paper introduces a four-dimensional notion of the information available about a quantum system's boundary conditions in the various sets of decohering, coarse-grained histories it may display. This spacetime notion of information coincides with the familiar one when quantum theory is formulable in terms of states on spacelike surfaces but generalizes this notion when it cannot be so formulated. The idea of spacetime information is applied in several contexts: When spacetime geometry is fixed the information available through alternatives restricted to a fixed spacetime region is defined. The information available through histories of alternatives of general operators is compared to that obtained from the more limited coarse grainings of sum-over-histories quantum mechanics that refer only to coordinates. The definition of information is considered in generalized quantum theories. We consider as specific examples time-neutral quantum mechanics with initial and final conditions, quantum theories with nonunitary evolution, and the generalized quantum frameworks appropriate for quantum spacetime. In such theories complete information about a quantum system is not necessarily available on any spacelike surface but must be searched for throughout spacetime. The information loss commonly associated with the ``evolution of pure states into mixed states'' in black hole evaporation is thus not in conflict with the principles of generalized quantum mechanics.
Since its emergence, quantum mechanics has been a challenge for an understanding of reality which is based on our intuition in a classical world. Nevertheless, it has often been tried to impose this understanding of reality on quantum theory - with limited success. Instead, it might be a better alternative to redefine the meaning of physical reality. This is the objective of the paper. A consideration of the quantum measurement process, conditional probabilities and some well-known typical quantum physical experiments provides the reasoning for the following three hypotheses: (1) Prior to a first measurement, a physical system is not in a quantum state. (2) Physical reality is all that and only that about which (classical) information is available in the universe. (3) Information creation is an independent process and is not covered by the Schroedinger equation. It is the first step of the quantum measurement process and does not have a classical counterpart. The first hypothesis makes sense only if the quantum measurement process can be described without presupposing an initial state for the system under consideration. This becomes possible by the objective conditional probabilities which represent the transition probabilities between the outcomes of successive quantum measurements and have been introduced by the author in some recent papers. The second hypothesis holds as well in the classical case, but a certain incompleteness of reality is typical of quantum mechanics and the origin of many quantum phenomena. Classically, the existence of a complete reality is presumed, and hypothesis 3 has no meaning then.
Entropy as Inference and Entropy as a Physical Field: A Comprehensive Comparison of Ariel Caticha’s Entropic Dynamics and Obidi’s Theory of Entropicity (ToE) Introduction Putting Ariel Caticha’s work on entropic dynamics (ED) side by side with Obidi’s Theory of Entropicity (ToE) is like comparing two very different bets on what “entropy” is allowed to be in physics. Both take entropy seriously, both see it as more than a bookkeeping device, and both use information‑theoretic ideas. But they diverge at the deepest level: Caticha treats entropy as an epistemic principle guiding inference about an underlying reality, while Obidi treats entropy as the ontological field that constitutes reality itself. That difference—epistemic versus ontological—is not cosmetic. It changes what counts as a law of nature, what time is, what causality is, and what it even means for something to exist. Caticha: Entropy as a principle of inference and dynamics Ariel Caticha’s program, broadly called entropic dynamics, starts from the idea that physical laws can be derived from principles of inference, especially the method of maximum entropy. The core move is: given incomplete information about a system, the best we can do is update probability distributions in a way that is consistent with known constraints and maximizes entropy subject to those constraints. From this perspective, dynamics—how systems evolve in time—can be seen as a sequence of entropic updates. Caticha shows that, under suitable assumptions, one can recover forms of classical and quantum dynamics from entropic inference. Time, in this view, is an ordering parameter for updates; it is not fundamental but emerges as a way of indexing successive states of knowledge. The underlying ontology is relatively modest: there is some “stuff” (positions, configurations, etc.), and we have incomplete information about it. Entropy quantifies that ignorance, and the laws of motion are rules for updating probabilities. So in Caticha’s world, entropy is: a measure of uncertainty, a tool for inference, a generator of effective dynamics. It is powerful, but it is not the substance of reality. It is about how we reason about reality. Obidi: Entropy as the Fundamental Field of Reality Obidi’s Theory of Entropicity (ToE) takes a much more audacious step. It does not merely use entropy to derive dynamics; it declares entropy to be the primitive physical field from which everything else emerges. Entropy is not a measure of ignorance; it is the structure that makes knowledge, states, and even ignorance possible. In ToE, the universe does not begin with spacetime, particles, or even probability distributions. It begins with an entropic field whose configurations encode distinguishability, structure, and the capacity for events to occur. Space and time are emergent bookkeeping devices that track how this entropic field differentiates itself. Causality is not geometric but entropic: events become causally related when the entropic field has evolved enough to separate and stabilize them. Measurement is not a mysterious collapse but an entropic stabilization of previously indistinguishable alternatives. Matter is "frozen" entropy; mass is stabilized internal entropic content; [absolute/inherent] identity is what survives when entropy can no longer erase distinctions [in a given system or element]. Where Caticha uses entropy to derive dynamics on an underlying configuration space, Obidi uses entropy to generate the configuration space itself, along with its geometry, its dynamics, and its ontology. Comparison of Ariel Caticha’s Entropic Dynamics and Obidi’s Theory of Entropicity: Conceptual, Philosophical, and Structural Differences A comparison between Ariel Caticha’s entropic dynamics and Obidi’s Theory of Entropicity (ToE) reveals two fundamentally different visions of what entropy is and what role it plays in physics. Caticha’s work is rooted in the epistemic tradition: entropy is a measure of uncertainty, and physical laws emerge from principles of inference. Obidi’s work is rooted in an ontological re‑founding of physics: entropy is the fundamental physical field, and the universe emerges from its evolution. Caticha’s entropic dynamics begins with the assumption that we have incomplete information about the positions or configurations of a system. Using the method of maximum entropy, he derives rules for updating probability distributions in a way that is consistent with known constraints. Under certain assumptions, these updates reproduce forms of classical and quantum dynamics. Time, in this framework, is an ordering parameter for successive entropic inferences. The underlying ontology remains modest: there is a configuration space, there are unknown variables, and entropy quantifies our uncertainty about them. Caticha’s program is therefore a powerful epistemic reconstruction of dynamics, but it does not claim that entropy is a physical field or that it generates spacetime, causality, or matter. Obidi’s Theory of Entropicity takes a radically different approach. Entropy is not a measure of ignorance but the primitive ontological field. It is the substrate from which distinguishability, time, causality, measurement, matter, and geometry emerge. The entropic and coherent sectors are not epistemic constructs but structural phases of the entropic field. The entropic sector is the domain of irreversible becoming, where the entropic field differentiates itself and writes the arrow of time. The coherent sector is the domain of stabilized being, where structures persist and interact. This two‑sector architecture is not present in Caticha’s work and has no analogue in entropic dynamics. Furthermore, Caticha does not develop a philosophical interpretation of his framework. His papers are technical, focused on inference, probability updating, and the derivation of dynamical equations. He does not address the ontological status of entropy, the metaphysics of becoming, the nature of measurement, or the philosophical implications of entropic evolution. Obidi, by contrast, explicitly engages with the philosophical foundations of physics, drawing connections to ontology, metaphysics, epistemology, and the philosophy of time. His work situates the Theory of Entropicity (ToE) within a broader intellectual tradition, including comparisons with Paul Tillich, Schopenhauer, and the classical distinction between appearance and reality. The originality of Obidi’s contribution lies in the systematic way he reorders the explanatory hierarchy of physics. Instead of deriving dynamics from inference, he derives inference, dynamics, geometry, and matter from the entropic field alone. Instead of treating probability as epistemic, he derives it as a conserved physical quantity. Instead of treating measurement as a postulate, he explains it as entropic stabilization. Instead of treating spacetime as fundamental, he derives it from information geometry via the Obidi Action. Instead of treating coherence as a mathematical artifact, he interprets and grounds it as a structural phase of the entropic field. The broader implications of this difference are profound. Caticha’s program suggests that physics is ultimately about how rational agents should update their beliefs. Obidi’s program suggests that physics is about how the universe entropically becomes what it is [and that ultimately it is not about beliefs taken as isolated givens or provisos independent of the Entropic Field (EF)]. Caticha reconstructs known laws; Obidi reconstructs the foundations from which laws arise. Caticha’s entropy is epistemic; Obidi’s entropy is ontological. Caticha’s dynamics is inferential; Obidi’s dynamics is generative. Caticha’s framework is silent on metaphysics; Obidi’s framework is a metaphysics inseparable from physics. References (Caticha): Caticha, A. Entropic Dynamics, in Bayesian Inference and Maximum Entropy Methods in Science and Engineering, AIP Conference Proceedings, 2011. Caticha, A. Entropic Inference and the Foundations of Physics, 2012. Caticha, A. From Entropic Dynamics to Quantum Theory, 2014. References (Obidi): Obidi, J. O. Theory of Entropicity (ToE) Canonical Archives, 2024–2026. Obidi, J. O. Obidi’s Philosophical Analysis of Being and Becoming, 2026. Obidi, J. O. The Obidi Action, Entropic Geometry, and the Emergence of Spacetime, 2025. Obidi, J. O. The Obidi Probability Law and the Two‑Sector Hilbert Space Decomposition, 2025. Entropic and Coherent Sectors: Caticha versus Obidi The language of “entropic” and “coherent” sectors is especially revealing. In Caticha’s framework, the entropic sector is essentially the inferential machinery: probability distributions, entropy functionals, constraints, and the maximum entropy principle. Coherence, when it appears, is largely about consistency of inference and the emergence of quantum‑like structures (e.g., complex amplitudes, Hilbert space) from entropic updating. The “coherent” behavior is a feature of how probability amplitudes evolve under entropic rules, not a separate ontological sector of reality. In Obidi’s ToE, the entropic and coherent sectors are structurally deeper. The entropic sector is the domain where the entropic field is actively differentiating, where distinguishability is being created, where time’s arrow is being written. The coherent sector is the regime where structures—once formed by entropic evolution—exhibit stability, persistence, and internal consistency. Coherence here is not just a property of wavefunctions; it is a structural phase of the entropic field itself. You can think of it this way: in ToE, the entropic sector is the “becoming” of reality, while the coherent sector is the “being” that results from that becoming. The two are not separate theories but two regimes of the same entropic substrate. The entropic sector governs how new distinctions, structures, and events come into existence; the coherent secto
We introduce quantum history states and their mathematical framework, thereby reinterpreting and extending the consistent histories approach to quantum theory. Through thought experiments, we demonstrate that our formalism allows us to analyze a quantum version of history in which we reconstruct the past by observations. In particular, we can pass from measurements to inferences about ‘what happened’ in a way that is sensible and free of paradox. Our framework allows for a richer understanding of the temporal structure of quantum theory, and we construct history states that embody peculiar, non-classical correlations in time.