Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1402.6621 · Physical Review A

Analysis of atom-interferometer clocks

Steven Peil, Christopher R. Ekstrom

Published Jan 21, 2014• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We analyze the nature and performance of clocks formed by stabilizing an oscillator to the phase difference between two paths of an atom interferometer. The phase evolution has been modeled as being driven by the proper-time difference between the two paths, although it has an ambiguous origin in the nonrelativistic limit and it requires a full quantum-field-theory treatment in the general case. We present conditions for identifying deviations from the nonrelativistic limit as a way of testing the proper-time-driven phase evolution model. We show that the system performance belies the premise that an atom-interferometer clock is referenced to a divided-down Compton oscillation, and we suggest that this implies there is no physical oscillation at the Compton frequency.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.89.014101

Related papers

Does an atom interferometer test the gravitational redshift at the Compton frequency?

Peter Wolf, Luc Blanchet A, Christian Bordé +3 more

Atom interferometers allow the measurement of the acceleration of freely falling atoms with respect to an experimental platform at rest on Earth's surface. Such experiments have been used to test the universality of free fall by comparing the acceleration of the atoms to that of a classical freely falling object. In a recent paper, Müller, Peters and Chu [Nature {\bf 463}, 926-929 (2010)] argued that atom interferometers also provide a very accurate test of the gravitational redshift when considering the atom as a clock operating at the Compton frequency associated with the rest mass. We analyze this claim in the frame of general relativity and of different alternative theories. We show that the difference of "Compton phases" between the two paths of the interferometer is actually zero in a large class of theories, including general relativity, all metric theories of gravity, most non-metric theories and most theoretical frameworks used to interpret the violations of the equivalence principle. Therefore, in most plausible theoretical frameworks, there is no redshift effect and atom interferometers only test the universality of free fall. We also show that frameworks in which atom interferometers would test the redshift pose serious problems, such as (i) violation of the Schiff conjecture, (ii) violation of the Feynman path integral formulation of quantum mechanics and of the principle of least action for matter waves, (iii) violation of energy conservation, and more generally (iv) violation of the particle-wave duality in quantum mechanics. Standard quantum mechanics is no longer valid in such frameworks, so that a consistent interpretation of the experiment would require an alternative formulation of quantum mechanics. As such an alternative has not been proposed to date, we conclude that the interpretation of atom interferometers as testing the gravitational redshift is unsound.

arXiv:1012.1194•Classical and Quantum Gravity•Jun 9, 2011•102 citations

Matter-wave clocks

Holger Müller, U C Berkeley

It is a key principle of quantum mechanics that plane matter waves are proportional to exp(-ipμxμ/ℏ)=exp(-iω0τ), where pμand xμare respectively 4-momentum and position, and τ is the proper time measured along the particle's tra-jectory. Thus, the quantum state of a free particle of mass m accumulates the same phase as a clock ticking at the particle's Compton frequency of ω0=mc2/ℏ travelling along the particle's trajectory. This equality, if it is not just an artifact of the theory, implies that a single particle can be a reference for a clock. In principle, such a clock could be built by annihilating particle-antiparticle pairs and counting the frequencies of the generated photons. This would provide a frequency reference with virtually infinite quality factor Q and unsurpassed stability against systematic influences. The frequency (ω0/2π=3×1025Hz for a Cesium atom), however, is far beyond modern counting techniques. A method to divide it into a technically accessible range is thus required.

Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics Europe & European Quantum Electronics Conference (CLEO/Europe-EQEC)•May 1, 2013•0 citations

Relational evolution with oscillating clocks

Martin Bojowald A, Luis Martínez, Garrett Wendel

A fundamental description of time can be consistent not only with the usual monotonic behavior but also with an oscillating physical clock variable, coupled to the degrees of freedom of a system evolving in time. Generically, one would in fact expect some kind of oscillating motion of a system that is dynamical and interacts with its surroundings, as required for a fundamental clock that can be noticed by any other system. Unitary evolution does not require a monotonic clock variable and can be achieved more generally by formally unwinding the oscillating clock movement, keeping track not only of the value of the clock variable but also of the number of cycles it has gone through at any moment. The specific treatment used here employs concatenations of evolution operators, alternating between forward and backward evolution of the oscillating clock. Because the clock and an evolving system have a common conserved energy, the clock is in different cycles for different energy eigenstates of the system state. As a result, the clock is generically in a quantum state with a superposition of different clock cycles, a key feature that distinguishes oscillating clocks from monotonic time. In addition, coherence could be lost faster than observed, for instance if a system that would be harmonic in isolation is made anharmonic by interactions with a fundamental clock, implying observational bounds on fundamental clocks. Numerical computations show that coherence is maintained over long timescales provided the clock period is much smaller than the system period. A small loss of coherence nevertheless remains and, measured in terms of the relative standard deviation of the system period, is proportional to the ratio of the system period and the clock period. Since the precision of atomic clocks could not be achieved if atomic frequencies would be subject to additional variations from coupling to a fundamental clock, an upper bound on the clock period can be obtained that turns out to be much smaller than currently available direct or indirect measurements of time.

arXiv:2110.07702•Physical review. D/Physical review. D.•May 24, 2022•9 citations

Phase locking an atom interferometer

Andréa D Bertoldi, Ralf Kohlhaas, Etienne Cantin +3 more

In atom interferometry the phase evolution of a quantum superposition state is measured with respect to a reference signal. The measurement has a limited unambiguous interval, since not the phase but its projection is measured as a population unbalance on two energetic levels. Resolving phase wrapping brings to a longer interrogation interval and hence instrument sensitivity. We extended the unambiguous probe interval using coherence preserving measurements and phase corrections, and demonstrated the phase lock of the clock oscillator to an atomic superposition state. On this basis we implemented a protocol to improve atomic clocks limited by local oscillator noise, which is the case of optical atomic clocks, nowadays the best frequency standard in terms of both accuracy and precision. The technique could be adopted to enhance the sensitivity of atomic gravimeters.

European Frequency and Time Forum•Apr 1, 2016•0 citations

Atom interferometry and the gravitational redshift

Supurna Sinha, Joseph Samuel

From the principle of equivalence, Einstein predicted that clocks slow down in a gravitational field. Since the general theory of relativity is based on the principle of equivalence, it is essential to test this prediction accurately. Muller, Peters and Chu claim that a reinterpretation of decade old experiments with atom interferometers leads to a sensitive test of this gravitational redshift effect at the Compton frequency. Wolf et al dispute this claim and adduce arguments against it. In this article, we distill these arguments to a single fundamental objection: an atom is NOT a clock ticking at the Compton frequency. We conclude that atom interferometry experiments conducted to date do not yield such sensitive tests of the gravitational redshift. Finally, we suggest a new interferometric experiment to measure the gravitational redshift, which realises a quantum version of the classical clock "paradox".

arXiv:1102.2587•Classical and Quantum Gravity•Jun 9, 2011•63 citations

Relativistic Beating of Compton Clocks, Action Discretization, and the Emergence of Planck's Constant

Jonatan P. camargo

We investigate the relationship between phase interference associated with action, the relativistic dynamics of proper time, and the structural origin of action quantization. We start from the general principle of interferential compatibility of action introduced in previous works, in which the dynamic phase of a system is given by $\phi=S/\hbar$ and phase coincidences between distinct evolutions occur only when $\Delta S = 2\pi n\hbar$. We show that when this formalism is specialized to the relativistic action of a free particle $S=-mc^{2}\tau$, the phase evolution naturally implies an internal frequency $\omega_C = mc^{2}/\hbar$, corresponding to the Compton clock. When two systems evolve with distinct proper times, their Compton phases diverge, producing a relativistic phase beating. We demonstrate that the interferential coherence condition $\Delta\phi = 2\pi n$ defines a discrete sequence of synchronization instants and directly implies the relation $mc^{2}\Delta\tau = nh$, showing that discrete action increments emerge as a geometric consequence of the relativistic periodicity of the phase. We also show that the used phase coincides exactly with the rest phase of the Dirac equation solutions, establishing the connection with the relativistic dynamics of fields. The beating between Compton clocks defines an operational discretization of the action that can be interpreted as a discrete sum, whose continuous form is recovered in the limit of almost perfect synchronization between reference frames. We also discuss the relationship of this formalism with the notion of the internal clock introduced by de Broglie and with the interferential structure of relativistic matter interferometry. In this framework, Planck's constant emerges as the geometric invariant associated with the first closure of the relativistic beating between Compton clocks. Quantization can then be interpreted as a coherence condition between relativistic phases, establishing a direct bridge between quantum interference, proper time relativistic dynamics, and the variational principle of stationary action.

•Mar 10, 2026•0 citations
We analyze the nature and performance of clocks formed by stabilizing an oscillator to the phase difference between two paths of an atom interferometer. The phase evolution has been modeled as being driven by the proper-time difference between the two paths, although it has an ambiguous origin in the nonrelativistic limit and it requires a full quantum-field-theory treatment in the general case. We present conditions for identifying deviations from the nonrelativistic limit as a way of testing the proper-time-driven phase evolution model. We show that the system performance belies the premise that an atom-interferometer clock is referenced to a divided-down Compton oscillation, and we suggest that this implies there is no physical oscillation at the Compton frequency.
Atom interferometers allow the measurement of the acceleration of freely falling atoms with respect to an experimental platform at rest on Earth's surface. Such experiments have been used to test the universality of free fall by comparing the acceleration of the atoms to that of a classical freely falling object. In a recent paper, Müller, Peters and Chu [Nature {\bf 463}, 926-929 (2010)] argued that atom interferometers also provide a very accurate test of the gravitational redshift when considering the atom as a clock operating at the Compton frequency associated with the rest mass. We analyze this claim in the frame of general relativity and of different alternative theories. We show that the difference of "Compton phases" between the two paths of the interferometer is actually zero in a large class of theories, including general relativity, all metric theories of gravity, most non-metric theories and most theoretical frameworks used to interpret the violations of the equivalence principle. Therefore, in most plausible theoretical frameworks, there is no redshift effect and atom interferometers only test the universality of free fall. We also show that frameworks in which atom interferometers would test the redshift pose serious problems, such as (i) violation of the Schiff conjecture, (ii) violation of the Feynman path integral formulation of quantum mechanics and of the principle of least action for matter waves, (iii) violation of energy conservation, and more generally (iv) violation of the particle-wave duality in quantum mechanics. Standard quantum mechanics is no longer valid in such frameworks, so that a consistent interpretation of the experiment would require an alternative formulation of quantum mechanics. As such an alternative has not been proposed to date, we conclude that the interpretation of atom interferometers as testing the gravitational redshift is unsound.
It is a key principle of quantum mechanics that plane matter waves are proportional to exp(-ipμxμ/ℏ)=exp(-iω0τ), where pμand xμare respectively 4-momentum and position, and τ is the proper time measured along the particle's tra-jectory. Thus, the quantum state of a free particle of mass m accumulates the same phase as a clock ticking at the particle's Compton frequency of ω0=mc2/ℏ travelling along the particle's trajectory. This equality, if it is not just an artifact of the theory, implies that a single particle can be a reference for a clock. In principle, such a clock could be built by annihilating particle-antiparticle pairs and counting the frequencies of the generated photons. This would provide a frequency reference with virtually infinite quality factor Q and unsurpassed stability against systematic influences. The frequency (ω0/2π=3×1025Hz for a Cesium atom), however, is far beyond modern counting techniques. A method to divide it into a technically accessible range is thus required.
A fundamental description of time can be consistent not only with the usual monotonic behavior but also with an oscillating physical clock variable, coupled to the degrees of freedom of a system evolving in time. Generically, one would in fact expect some kind of oscillating motion of a system that is dynamical and interacts with its surroundings, as required for a fundamental clock that can be noticed by any other system. Unitary evolution does not require a monotonic clock variable and can be achieved more generally by formally unwinding the oscillating clock movement, keeping track not only of the value of the clock variable but also of the number of cycles it has gone through at any moment. The specific treatment used here employs concatenations of evolution operators, alternating between forward and backward evolution of the oscillating clock. Because the clock and an evolving system have a common conserved energy, the clock is in different cycles for different energy eigenstates of the system state. As a result, the clock is generically in a quantum state with a superposition of different clock cycles, a key feature that distinguishes oscillating clocks from monotonic time. In addition, coherence could be lost faster than observed, for instance if a system that would be harmonic in isolation is made anharmonic by interactions with a fundamental clock, implying observational bounds on fundamental clocks. Numerical computations show that coherence is maintained over long timescales provided the clock period is much smaller than the system period. A small loss of coherence nevertheless remains and, measured in terms of the relative standard deviation of the system period, is proportional to the ratio of the system period and the clock period. Since the precision of atomic clocks could not be achieved if atomic frequencies would be subject to additional variations from coupling to a fundamental clock, an upper bound on the clock period can be obtained that turns out to be much smaller than currently available direct or indirect measurements of time.
In atom interferometry the phase evolution of a quantum superposition state is measured with respect to a reference signal. The measurement has a limited unambiguous interval, since not the phase but its projection is measured as a population unbalance on two energetic levels. Resolving phase wrapping brings to a longer interrogation interval and hence instrument sensitivity. We extended the unambiguous probe interval using coherence preserving measurements and phase corrections, and demonstrated the phase lock of the clock oscillator to an atomic superposition state. On this basis we implemented a protocol to improve atomic clocks limited by local oscillator noise, which is the case of optical atomic clocks, nowadays the best frequency standard in terms of both accuracy and precision. The technique could be adopted to enhance the sensitivity of atomic gravimeters.
From the principle of equivalence, Einstein predicted that clocks slow down in a gravitational field. Since the general theory of relativity is based on the principle of equivalence, it is essential to test this prediction accurately. Muller, Peters and Chu claim that a reinterpretation of decade old experiments with atom interferometers leads to a sensitive test of this gravitational redshift effect at the Compton frequency. Wolf et al dispute this claim and adduce arguments against it. In this article, we distill these arguments to a single fundamental objection: an atom is NOT a clock ticking at the Compton frequency. We conclude that atom interferometry experiments conducted to date do not yield such sensitive tests of the gravitational redshift. Finally, we suggest a new interferometric experiment to measure the gravitational redshift, which realises a quantum version of the classical clock "paradox".
We investigate the relationship between phase interference associated with action, the relativistic dynamics of proper time, and the structural origin of action quantization. We start from the general principle of interferential compatibility of action introduced in previous works, in which the dynamic phase of a system is given by ϕ=S/ℏ\phi=S/\hbarϕ=S/ℏ and phase coincidences between distinct evolutions occur only when ΔS=2πnℏ\Delta S = 2\pi n\hbarΔS=2πnℏ. We show that when this formalism is specialized to the relativistic action of a free particle S=−mc2τS=-mc^{2}\tauS=−mc2τ, the phase evolution naturally implies an internal frequency ωC=mc2/ℏ\omega_C = mc^{2}/\hbarωC​=mc2/ℏ, corresponding to the Compton clock. When two systems evolve with distinct proper times, their Compton phases diverge, producing a relativistic phase beating. We demonstrate that the interferential coherence condition Δϕ=2πn\Delta\phi = 2\pi nΔϕ=2πn defines a discrete sequence of synchronization instants and directly implies the relation mc2Δτ=nhmc^{2}\Delta\tau = nhmc2Δτ=nh, showing that discrete action increments emerge as a geometric consequence of the relativistic periodicity of the phase. We also show that the used phase coincides exactly with the rest phase of the Dirac equation solutions, establishing the connection with the relativistic dynamics of fields. The beating between Compton clocks defines an operational discretization of the action that can be interpreted as a discrete sum, whose continuous form is recovered in the limit of almost perfect synchronization between reference frames. We also discuss the relationship of this formalism with the notion of the internal clock introduced by de Broglie and with the interferential structure of relativistic matter interferometry. In this framework, Planck's constant emerges as the geometric invariant associated with the first closure of the relativistic beating between Compton clocks. Quantization can then be interpreted as a coherence condition between relativistic phases, establishing a direct bridge between quantum interference, proper time relativistic dynamics, and the variational principle of stationary action.