Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1402.2295 · Quantum Information and Computation

Monte Carlo simulation of stoquastic Hamiltonians

Sergey B. Bravyi

Published Oct 1, 2015• 86 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Stoquastic Hamiltonians are characterized by the property that their off-diagonal matrix elements in the standard product basis are real and non-positive. Many interesting quantum models fall into this class including the Transverse field Ising Model (TIM), the Heisenberg model on bipartite graphs, and the bosonic Hubbard model. Here we consider the problem of estimating the ground state energy of a local stoquastic Hamiltonian $H$ with a promise that the ground state of $H$ has a non-negligible correlation with some `guiding' state that admits a concise classical description. A formalized version of this problem called Guided Stoquastic Hamiltonian is shown to be complete for the complexity class $\MA$ (a probabilistic analogue of $\NP$). To prove this result we employ the Projection Monte Carlo algorithm with a variable number of walkers. Secondly, we show that the ground state and thermal equilibrium properties of the ferromagnetic TIM can be simulated in polynomial time on a classical probabilistic computer. This result is based on the approximation algorithm for the classical ferromagnetic Ising model due to Jerrum and Sinclair (1993).

DOI
10.26421/qic15.13-14-3

Related papers

Complexity of Stoquastic Frustration-Free Hamiltonians

Sergey B. Bravyi, Barbara M. Terhal

We study several problems related to properties of nonnegative matrices that arise at the boundary between quantum and classical probabilistic computation. Our results are twofold. First, we identify a large class of quantum Hamiltonians describing systems of qubits for which the adiabatic evolution can be efficiently simulated on a classical probabilistic computer. These are stoquastic local Hamiltonians with a “frustration-free” ground-state. A Hamiltonian belongs to this class iff it can be represented as $H=\sum_{a}H_{a}$ where (1) every term $H_{a}$ acts nontrivially on a constant number of qubits, (2) every term $H_{a}$ has real nonpositive off-diagonal matrix elements in the standard basis, and (3) the ground-state of H is a ground-state of every term $H_{a}$. Second, we generalize the Cook–Levin theorem proving NP-completeness of the satisfiability problem to the complexity class MA (Merlin–Arthur games)—a probabilistic analogue of NP. Specifically, we construct a quantum version of the k-SAT problem which we call “stoquastic k-SAT” such that stoquastic k-SAT is contained in MA for any constant k, and any promise problem in MA is Karp-reducible to stoquastic 6-SAT. This result provides the first nontrivial example of a MA-complete promise problem.

arXiv:0806.1746•SIAM Journal on Computing•Nov 20, 2009•142 citations

Physically motivated guiding states for local Hamiltonians

Gabriel Waite, Karl Lin, Samuel J. Elman +1 more

We study the computational complexity of the Guided Local Hamiltonian problem: given a local Hamiltonian $H$ together with a classical description of a guiding state that has non-negligible overlap with the ground state of $H$, estimate the ground-state energy within inverse-polynomial precision. This setting captures real-world scenarios in quantum chemistry and many-body physics, where trial states derived from classical heuristics can be used to guide quantum algorithms. We identify families of physically-motivated guiding states for which the computational hardness of ground-state energy estimation persists in the guided setting. Extending prior results for semi-classical subset states, we prove BQP-hardness for classes including fixed-weight states, matrix product states, Gaussian states, and Fendley states. Our hardness results are obtained via refined Feynman-Kitaev circuit-to-Hamiltonian constructions that explicitly expose the structural role of the guiding state in the reduction. Complementing these results, we give a constructive proof of BQP containment when the guiding state admits a polynomial-size classical description, establishing BQP-completeness for the canonical formulation of the problem. Our results show that quantum advantage persists for the newly introduced state classes, and classical methods also remain viable when said guiding states admit appropriate descriptions. Together, our results identify a Goldilocks zone of guiding states that are efficiently preparable, succinctly described, and sample-query accessible, within which quantum advantage for ground-state estimation can be meaningfully assessed. We additionally formalise the Guided Fermi-Hubbard Hamiltonian problem and prove BQP-completeness on 2D square and triangular lattices, both with and without magnetic fields, when provided with an appropriate fermionic guiding state.

arXiv:2509.25815•Physical Review A•Jun 8, 2026•6 citations

Rapidly mixing loop representation quantum Monte Carlo for Heisenberg models on star-like bipartite graphs

Jun Takahashi, Sam Slezak, Elizabeth Crosson

Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) methods have proven invaluable in condensed matter physics, particularly for studying ground states and thermal equilibrium properties of quantum Hamiltonians without a sign problem. Over the past decade, significant progress has also been made on their rigorous convergence analysis. Heisenberg antiferromagnets (AFM) with bipartite interaction graphs are a popular target of computational QMC studies due to their physical importance, but despite the apparent empirical efficiency of these simulations it remains an open question whether efficient classical approximation of the ground energy is possible in general. In this work we introduce a ground state variant of the stochastic series expansion QMC method, and for the special class of AFM on interaction graphs with an $O(1)$-bipartite component (star-like), we prove rapid mixing of the associated QMC Markov chain (polynomial time in the number of qubits) by using Jerrum and Sinclair's method of canonical paths. This is the first Markov chain analysis of a practical class of QMC algorithms with the loop representation of Heisenberg models. Our findings contribute to the broader effort to resolve the computational complexity of Heisenberg AFM on general bipartite interaction graphs.

arXiv:2411.01452•Nov 3, 2024•9 citations

The Complexity of Stoquastic Local Hamiltonian Problems

Sergey B. Bravyi, David Peter Divincenzo, Roberto I. Oliveira +1 more

We study the complexity of the Local Hamiltonian Problem (denoted as LH-MIN) in the special case when a Hamiltonian obeys conditions of the Perron-Frobenius theorem: all off-diagonal matrix elements in the standard basis are real and non-positive. We will call such Hamiltonians, which are common in the natural world, stoquastic. An equivalent characterization of stoquastic Hamiltonians is that they have an entry-wise non-negative Gibbs density matrix for any temperature. We prove that LH-MIN for stoquastic Hamiltonians belongs to the complexity class AM -- a probabilistic version of NP with two rounds of communication between the prover and the verifier. We also show that 2-local stoquastic LH-MIN is hard for the class MA. With the additional promise of having a polynomial spectral gap, we show that stoquastic LH-MIN belongs to the class POSTBPP=BPPpath -- a generalization of BPP in which a post-selective readout is allowed. This last result also shows that any problem solved by adiabatic quantum computation using stoquastic Hamiltonians lies in PostBPP.

arXiv:quant-ph/0606140•Jun 16, 2006•106 citations

Complexity of geometrically local stoquastic Hamiltonians

Asad Raza, Jens Eisert, Alex B. Grilo

The QMA-completeness of the local Hamiltonian problem is a landmark result of the field of Hamiltonian complexity that studies the computational complexity of problems in quantum many-body physics. Since its proposal, substantial effort has been invested in better understanding the problem for physically motivated important families of Hamiltonians. In particular, the QMA-completeness of approximating the ground state energy of local Hamiltonians has been extended to the case where the Hamiltonians are geometrically local in one and two spatial dimensions. Among those physically motivated Hamiltonians, stoquastic Hamiltonians play a particularly crucial role, as they constitute the manifestly sign-free Hamiltonians in Monte Carlo approaches. Interestingly, for such Hamiltonians, the problem at hand becomes more ''classical'', being hard for the class MA (the randomized version of NP) and its complexity has tight connections with derandomization. In this work, we prove that both the two- and one-dimensional geometrically local analogues remain MA-hard with high enough qudit dimension. Moreover, we show that related problems are StoqMA-complete.

arXiv:2407.15499•Quantum•Feb 11, 2026•5 citations

Exponential Enhancement of the Efficiency of Quantum Annealing by Non-Stoquastic Hamiltonians

Hidetoshi Nishimori, Kabuki Takada

Non-stoquastic Hamiltonians have both positive and negative signs in off-diagonal elements in their matrix representation in the standard computational basis and thus cannot be simulated efficiently by the standard quantum Monte Carlo method due to the sign problem. We describe our analytical studies of this type of Hamiltonians with infinite-range non-random as well as random interactions from the perspective of possible enhancement of the efficiency of quantum annealing or adiabatic quantum computing. It is shown that multi-body transverse interactions like XX and XXXXX with positive coefficients appended to a stoquastic transverse-field Ising model render the Hamiltonian non-stoquastic and reduce a first-order quantum phase transition in the simple transverse-field case to a second-order transition. This implies that the efficiency of quantum annealing is exponentially enhanced, because a first-order transition has an exponentially small energy gap (and therefore exponentially long computation time) whereas a second-order transition has a polynomially decaying gap (polynomial computation time). The examples presented here represent rare instances where strong quantum effects, in the sense that they cannot be efficiently simulated in the standard quantum Monte Carlo, have analytically been shown to exponentially enhance the efficiency of quantum annealing for combinatorial optimization problems.

arXiv:1609.03785•Frontiers in ICT•Feb 17, 2017•106 citations
Stoquastic Hamiltonians are characterized by the property that their off-diagonal matrix elements in the standard product basis are real and non-positive. Many interesting quantum models fall into this class including the Transverse field Ising Model (TIM), the Heisenberg model on bipartite graphs, and the bosonic Hubbard model. Here we consider the problem of estimating the ground state energy of a local stoquastic Hamiltonian HHH with a promise that the ground state of HHH has a non-negligible correlation with some `guiding' state that admits a concise classical description. A formalized version of this problem called Guided Stoquastic Hamiltonian is shown to be complete for the complexity class \MA\MA\MA (a probabilistic analogue of \NP\NP\NP). To prove this result we employ the Projection Monte Carlo algorithm with a variable number of walkers. Secondly, we show that the ground state and thermal equilibrium properties of the ferromagnetic TIM can be simulated in polynomial time on a classical probabilistic computer. This result is based on the approximation algorithm for the classical ferromagnetic Ising model due to Jerrum and Sinclair (1993).
We study several problems related to properties of nonnegative matrices that arise at the boundary between quantum and classical probabilistic computation. Our results are twofold. First, we identify a large class of quantum Hamiltonians describing systems of qubits for which the adiabatic evolution can be efficiently simulated on a classical probabilistic computer. These are stoquastic local Hamiltonians with a “frustration-free” ground-state. A Hamiltonian belongs to this class iff it can be represented as H=∑aHaH=\sum_{a}H_{a}H=∑a​Ha​ where (1) every term HaH_{a}Ha​ acts nontrivially on a constant number of qubits, (2) every term HaH_{a}Ha​ has real nonpositive off-diagonal matrix elements in the standard basis, and (3) the ground-state of H is a ground-state of every term HaH_{a}Ha​. Second, we generalize the Cook–Levin theorem proving NP-completeness of the satisfiability problem to the complexity class MA (Merlin–Arthur games)—a probabilistic analogue of NP. Specifically, we construct a quantum version of the k-SAT problem which we call “stoquastic k-SAT” such that stoquastic k-SAT is contained in MA for any constant k, and any promise problem in MA is Karp-reducible to stoquastic 6-SAT. This result provides the first nontrivial example of a MA-complete promise problem.
We study the computational complexity of the Guided Local Hamiltonian problem: given a local Hamiltonian HHH together with a classical description of a guiding state that has non-negligible overlap with the ground state of HHH, estimate the ground-state energy within inverse-polynomial precision. This setting captures real-world scenarios in quantum chemistry and many-body physics, where trial states derived from classical heuristics can be used to guide quantum algorithms. We identify families of physically-motivated guiding states for which the computational hardness of ground-state energy estimation persists in the guided setting. Extending prior results for semi-classical subset states, we prove BQP-hardness for classes including fixed-weight states, matrix product states, Gaussian states, and Fendley states. Our hardness results are obtained via refined Feynman-Kitaev circuit-to-Hamiltonian constructions that explicitly expose the structural role of the guiding state in the reduction. Complementing these results, we give a constructive proof of BQP containment when the guiding state admits a polynomial-size classical description, establishing BQP-completeness for the canonical formulation of the problem. Our results show that quantum advantage persists for the newly introduced state classes, and classical methods also remain viable when said guiding states admit appropriate descriptions. Together, our results identify a Goldilocks zone of guiding states that are efficiently preparable, succinctly described, and sample-query accessible, within which quantum advantage for ground-state estimation can be meaningfully assessed. We additionally formalise the Guided Fermi-Hubbard Hamiltonian problem and prove BQP-completeness on 2D square and triangular lattices, both with and without magnetic fields, when provided with an appropriate fermionic guiding state.
Quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) methods have proven invaluable in condensed matter physics, particularly for studying ground states and thermal equilibrium properties of quantum Hamiltonians without a sign problem. Over the past decade, significant progress has also been made on their rigorous convergence analysis. Heisenberg antiferromagnets (AFM) with bipartite interaction graphs are a popular target of computational QMC studies due to their physical importance, but despite the apparent empirical efficiency of these simulations it remains an open question whether efficient classical approximation of the ground energy is possible in general. In this work we introduce a ground state variant of the stochastic series expansion QMC method, and for the special class of AFM on interaction graphs with an O(1)O(1)O(1)-bipartite component (star-like), we prove rapid mixing of the associated QMC Markov chain (polynomial time in the number of qubits) by using Jerrum and Sinclair's method of canonical paths. This is the first Markov chain analysis of a practical class of QMC algorithms with the loop representation of Heisenberg models. Our findings contribute to the broader effort to resolve the computational complexity of Heisenberg AFM on general bipartite interaction graphs.
We study the complexity of the Local Hamiltonian Problem (denoted as LH-MIN) in the special case when a Hamiltonian obeys conditions of the Perron-Frobenius theorem: all off-diagonal matrix elements in the standard basis are real and non-positive. We will call such Hamiltonians, which are common in the natural world, stoquastic. An equivalent characterization of stoquastic Hamiltonians is that they have an entry-wise non-negative Gibbs density matrix for any temperature. We prove that LH-MIN for stoquastic Hamiltonians belongs to the complexity class AM -- a probabilistic version of NP with two rounds of communication between the prover and the verifier. We also show that 2-local stoquastic LH-MIN is hard for the class MA. With the additional promise of having a polynomial spectral gap, we show that stoquastic LH-MIN belongs to the class POSTBPP=BPPpath -- a generalization of BPP in which a post-selective readout is allowed. This last result also shows that any problem solved by adiabatic quantum computation using stoquastic Hamiltonians lies in PostBPP.
The QMA-completeness of the local Hamiltonian problem is a landmark result of the field of Hamiltonian complexity that studies the computational complexity of problems in quantum many-body physics. Since its proposal, substantial effort has been invested in better understanding the problem for physically motivated important families of Hamiltonians. In particular, the QMA-completeness of approximating the ground state energy of local Hamiltonians has been extended to the case where the Hamiltonians are geometrically local in one and two spatial dimensions. Among those physically motivated Hamiltonians, stoquastic Hamiltonians play a particularly crucial role, as they constitute the manifestly sign-free Hamiltonians in Monte Carlo approaches. Interestingly, for such Hamiltonians, the problem at hand becomes more ''classical'', being hard for the class MA (the randomized version of NP) and its complexity has tight connections with derandomization. In this work, we prove that both the two- and one-dimensional geometrically local analogues remain MA-hard with high enough qudit dimension. Moreover, we show that related problems are StoqMA-complete.
Non-stoquastic Hamiltonians have both positive and negative signs in off-diagonal elements in their matrix representation in the standard computational basis and thus cannot be simulated efficiently by the standard quantum Monte Carlo method due to the sign problem. We describe our analytical studies of this type of Hamiltonians with infinite-range non-random as well as random interactions from the perspective of possible enhancement of the efficiency of quantum annealing or adiabatic quantum computing. It is shown that multi-body transverse interactions like XX and XXXXX with positive coefficients appended to a stoquastic transverse-field Ising model render the Hamiltonian non-stoquastic and reduce a first-order quantum phase transition in the simple transverse-field case to a second-order transition. This implies that the efficiency of quantum annealing is exponentially enhanced, because a first-order transition has an exponentially small energy gap (and therefore exponentially long computation time) whereas a second-order transition has a polynomially decaying gap (polynomial computation time). The examples presented here represent rare instances where strong quantum effects, in the sense that they cannot be efficiently simulated in the standard quantum Monte Carlo, have analytically been shown to exponentially enhance the efficiency of quantum annealing for combinatorial optimization problems.