Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1402.0227 · Physical Review Letters

Is the Molecular Berry Phase an Artifact of the Born-Oppenheimer Approximation?

Seung Kyu Min, Ali Abedi, Kwang S. Kim, Eberhard K. U. Gross

Published Dec 30, 2014• 126 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We demonstrate that the molecular Berry phase and the corresponding nonanalyticity in the electronic Born-Oppenheimer wave function is, in general, not a true topological feature of the exact solution of the full electron-nuclear Schrödinger equation. For a numerically exactly solvable model we show that a nonanalyticity, and the associated geometric phase, only appear in the limit of infinite nuclear mass, while a perfectly smooth behavior is found for any finite nuclear mass.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.113.263004

Related papers

Molecular geometric phase from the exact electron-nuclear factorization

Ryan Requist, Falk Tandetzky, Eberhard K. U. Gross

The Born-Oppenheimer electronic wave function ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}}_{R}^{\text{BO}}(r)$ picks up a topological phase factor $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1$, a special case of Berry phase, when it is transported around a conical intersection of two adiabatic potential energy surfaces in $R$ space. We show that this topological quantity reverts to a geometric quantity ${e}^{i\ensuremath{\gamma}}$ if the geometric phase $\ensuremath{\gamma}=\ensuremath{\oint}\mathrm{Im}\ensuremath{\langle}{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}}_{R}|{\mathbf{\ensuremath{\nabla}}}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}}_{R}\ensuremath{\rangle}\ifmmode\cdot\else\textperiodcentered\fi{}d{\mathbf{R}}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ is evaluated with the conditional electronic wave function ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}}_{R}(r)$ from the exact electron-nuclear factorization ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}}_{R}(r)\ensuremath{\chi}(R)$ instead of the adiabatic function ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}}_{R}^{\text{BO}}(r)$. A model of a pseudorotating triatomic molecule, also applicable to dynamical Jahn-Teller ions in bulk crystals, provides examples of nontrivial induced vector potentials and molecular geometric phase from the exact factorization. The induced vector potential gives a contribution to the circulating nuclear current that cannot be removed by a gauge transformation. The exact potential energy surface is calculated and found to contain a term depending on the Fubini-Study metric for the conditional electronic wave function.

arXiv:1506.09193•Physical Review A•Apr 13, 2016•86 citations

Born–Oppenheimer invariants along nuclear configuration paths

Roi Baer

Whenever a quantum chemist extracts the eigenstate of an electronic Hamiltonian, he makes, consciously or not, a decision concerning the phase of the wave function. This is done for each calculated state at each nuclear position. Thus he defines a Born–Oppenheimer (BO) frame of reference. There is no absolute phase just as there is no absolute position or time in mechanics. This leads naturally to the question: What are the quantities which do not depend on the arbitrary phases, i.e., what are the BO invariants? In this article we identify BO invariants with respect to an arbitrary path in nuclear configuration space. We identify invariant electronic states along these paths and their Aharonov–Anandan geometric phases. For closed loops not passing through electronic energy degeneracies these invariant states are the BO adiabatic wave functions and the phases are the Berry phases. The results establish rigorous relations between the full nonadiabatic couplings matrix and the geometric phases.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Oct 10, 2002•22 citations

The Berry phase revisited: application to Born–Oppenheimer molecular systems

Tamás Vértesi, Ágnes Vibók, Gábor J. Halász +1 more

In this paper, we study the implementation of the Berry approach as expressed in his seminal publication (1984 Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 392 45) within Born–Oppenheimer molecular systems (1927 Ann. Phys., Lpz. 84 457). This was done with the purpose of revealing the relation between the various time-dependent magnitudes in the adiabatic limit and their time-independent counterparts. The two main results are: (1) in the adiabatic limit, a single Born–Oppenheimer state becomes an eigenstate of the system during the excursion of a system along a given contour, and (2) at the end of a closed contour, the topological phases associated with the states that moved adiabatically along a closed contour are well presented by the diagonal D -matrix as obtained from the time-independent treatment. The theoretical study is supported by a detailed numerical study carried out for two ab initio molecular systems, namely the (Na, H 2 ) and the (H, H 2 ) systems.

Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Nov 23, 2004•13 citations

A general reduction scheme for the time-dependent Born–Oppenheimer approximation

André Martínez, Vania Sordoni

We construct a general reduction scheme for the study of the quantum propagator of molecular Schrödinger operators with smooth potentials. This reduction is made up to infinitely (resp. exponentially) small error terms with respect to the inverse square root of the mass of the nuclei, depending on the C ∞ (resp. analytic) smoothness of the interactions. Then we apply this result to the case when an electronic level is isolated from the rest of the spectrum of the electronic Hamiltonian.

Comptes Rendus Mathématique•Feb 1, 2002•45 citations

Non‐Adiabatic Effects in Chemical Reactions: Extended Born‐Oppenheimer Equations and its Applications

Satrajit Adhikari, Gert D. Billing

This Chapter gives a review of phase properties in molecular wave functions composed of a number of (and, at least, two) electronic states that become degenerate at some nearby values of the nuclear configuration. Apart from discussing phases and interference in classical (non-quantal) systems, including light waves, this chapter review looks at the constructability of complex wave functions from observable quantities (the phase problem), at the controversy regarding quantum mechanical phase operators, at the modes of observability of phase and at the role of phases in some nondemolition measurements. Advances in experimental and (especially) theoretical aspects of Aharonov–Bohm and topological (Berry) phases are described, including those involving two-electron and relativistic systems. Several works in the phase control and revivals of molecular wavepackets are cited as developments and applications of complex-function theory. Additional topics covered are coherent states, semiclassical approximations and the Maslov index. The interrelation between time and the complex state is noted in the contexts of time delays in scattering, of time-reversal invariance, and of the existence of a molecular time arrow. When the stationary Born–Oppenheimer description for a nearly degenerate state is regarded as “embedded” in a broader dynamic formulation, namely, through solution of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation, the wave function becomes necessarily complex. The analytic behavior of this function in the complex time plane can be exploited to gain information about the connection between phases and moduli of the component amplitudes. One form of this connection is a pair of reciprocal (Kramers–Kronig type) relations in the complex time domain. These show that certain phase changes in a component amplitude (e.g., lead to a non–zero Berry phase) require changes in the amplitude moduli, too, and imply degeneracies of the electronic state. The subject of conical degeneracy, or intersection, of adjacent potential surface is extended to nonlinear nuclear-electronic coupling, which can then result in multiple conical degeneracies on a nuclear coordinate plane. We treat cases of double and fourfold intersections, the latter under trigonal symmetry, and employ an analytic-graphical phase tracing method to obtain the resulting Berry phases as the system circles around some or all of the degeneracy points. These phases can take up values that are all integral multiples of π, with integers that vary with the physical situation (or with the model postulated for it). A further type of invariance, with respect to gauge transformation, is also tied to the complex form of the wave function. for a many-component state, this leads to a consideration of tensorial (Yang–Mills type) fields F for molecular systems. It is shown that it is the truncation of the Born–Oppenheimer electron-nuclear superposition that generates the molecular Yang–Mills fields. The equations of motion for the nuclear degrees of freedom are derived from a Lagrangean density ℒ, representing a non-Abelian situation. In ℒ, the non-adiabatic coupling terms (NACTs) that express the electronic background on the nuclear states enter as vector potentials (or gauge fields). We demonstrate a deep lying interrelation between two apparently distinct theoretical developments: that which led to the discovery of the Yang–Mills fields from considerations of local gauge invariance, and the use of an adiabatic–diabatic transformation matrix for the molecular case due to Baer. A generalized form of the NACTs is found, such that it makes the field F vanish for a complete electronic set. Finally, the use of phases and moduli as variables was found to be very convenient to obtain variationally the equation of continuity and the Hamilton–Jacobi equations from the Lagrangian of an electron following either the Schrüdinger or the Dirac equation. In the latter case, to a good approximation (in the nearly nonrelativistic limit) the phases in the different spinor components are not scrambled together and their Berry phases are unaffected.

Advances in chemical physics•Aug 7, 2002•36 citations

The Berry Phase as an Appropriate Correspondence Limit of the Aharonov-Anandan Phase in a Simple Model

Joy Christian, Abner Shimony

The relation between the Aharonov-Anandan phase and the Berry phase is studied in a simple model with a time-independent Hamiltonian, in which two spin-½ systems (I+II) are coupled to a plane rotator (III), so that the parameter ϕ in the part of the Hamiltonian governing I+II is a dynamical variable of 111. A family of solutions Ψ( t ) with period τ to the time-dependent Schrodinger equation for I+II+III is investigated, yielding the following information. ( i ) The Aharonov-Anandan phase is obtained for each Ψ( t ) over the period τ. ( ii ) By tracing out the variables of III a statistical operator W( t ) is obtained for I+II. ( iii ) In an appropriate correspondence limit, ϕ acquires a sharply defined value ϕ ( t ), and then W( t ) represents a pure state v( t ) of I+II. ( iv ) The Aharonov-Anandan phase is calculated for v(t) over the period τ and it is independent of the Aharonov-Anandan phase of ( i ). ( v ) In the adiabatic limit, when τ goes to infinity, the Aharonov-Anandan phase approaches the Berry phase for I+II. ( vi ) Finally, comparisons are made of the exact energy eigenvalues of the total system with the traditional Born-Oppenheimer approximation, and the improved Born-Oppenheimer approximation.

•Mar 1, 1991•3 citations
We demonstrate that the molecular Berry phase and the corresponding nonanalyticity in the electronic Born-Oppenheimer wave function is, in general, not a true topological feature of the exact solution of the full electron-nuclear Schrödinger equation. For a numerically exactly solvable model we show that a nonanalyticity, and the associated geometric phase, only appear in the limit of infinite nuclear mass, while a perfectly smooth behavior is found for any finite nuclear mass.
The Born-Oppenheimer electronic wave function ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}}_{R}^{\text{BO}}(r)$ picks up a topological phase factor $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}1$, a special case of Berry phase, when it is transported around a conical intersection of two adiabatic potential energy surfaces in RRR space. We show that this topological quantity reverts to a geometric quantity ${e}^{i\ensuremath{\gamma}}$ if the geometric phase $\ensuremath{\gamma}=\ensuremath{\oint}\mathrm{Im}\ensuremath{\langle}{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}}_{R}|{\mathbf{\ensuremath{\nabla}}}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}{\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}}_{R}\ensuremath{\rangle}\ifmmode\cdot\else\textperiodcentered\fi{}d{\mathbf{R}}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ is evaluated with the conditional electronic wave function ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}}_{R}(r)$ from the exact electron-nuclear factorization ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}}_{R}(r)\ensuremath{\chi}(R)$ instead of the adiabatic function ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}}_{R}^{\text{BO}}(r)$. A model of a pseudorotating triatomic molecule, also applicable to dynamical Jahn-Teller ions in bulk crystals, provides examples of nontrivial induced vector potentials and molecular geometric phase from the exact factorization. The induced vector potential gives a contribution to the circulating nuclear current that cannot be removed by a gauge transformation. The exact potential energy surface is calculated and found to contain a term depending on the Fubini-Study metric for the conditional electronic wave function.
Whenever a quantum chemist extracts the eigenstate of an electronic Hamiltonian, he makes, consciously or not, a decision concerning the phase of the wave function. This is done for each calculated state at each nuclear position. Thus he defines a Born–Oppenheimer (BO) frame of reference. There is no absolute phase just as there is no absolute position or time in mechanics. This leads naturally to the question: What are the quantities which do not depend on the arbitrary phases, i.e., what are the BO invariants? In this article we identify BO invariants with respect to an arbitrary path in nuclear configuration space. We identify invariant electronic states along these paths and their Aharonov–Anandan geometric phases. For closed loops not passing through electronic energy degeneracies these invariant states are the BO adiabatic wave functions and the phases are the Berry phases. The results establish rigorous relations between the full nonadiabatic couplings matrix and the geometric phases.
In this paper, we study the implementation of the Berry approach as expressed in his seminal publication (1984 Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 392 45) within Born–Oppenheimer molecular systems (1927 Ann. Phys., Lpz. 84 457). This was done with the purpose of revealing the relation between the various time-dependent magnitudes in the adiabatic limit and their time-independent counterparts. The two main results are: (1) in the adiabatic limit, a single Born–Oppenheimer state becomes an eigenstate of the system during the excursion of a system along a given contour, and (2) at the end of a closed contour, the topological phases associated with the states that moved adiabatically along a closed contour are well presented by the diagonal D -matrix as obtained from the time-independent treatment. The theoretical study is supported by a detailed numerical study carried out for two ab initio molecular systems, namely the (Na, H 2 ) and the (H, H 2 ) systems.
This Chapter gives a review of phase properties in molecular wave functions composed of a number of (and, at least, two) electronic states that become degenerate at some nearby values of the nuclear configuration. Apart from discussing phases and interference in classical (non-quantal) systems, including light waves, this chapter review looks at the constructability of complex wave functions from observable quantities (the phase problem), at the controversy regarding quantum mechanical phase operators, at the modes of observability of phase and at the role of phases in some nondemolition measurements. Advances in experimental and (especially) theoretical aspects of Aharonov–Bohm and topological (Berry) phases are described, including those involving two-electron and relativistic systems. Several works in the phase control and revivals of molecular wavepackets are cited as developments and applications of complex-function theory. Additional topics covered are coherent states, semiclassical approximations and the Maslov index. The interrelation between time and the complex state is noted in the contexts of time delays in scattering, of time-reversal invariance, and of the existence of a molecular time arrow. When the stationary Born–Oppenheimer description for a nearly degenerate state is regarded as “embedded” in a broader dynamic formulation, namely, through solution of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation, the wave function becomes necessarily complex. The analytic behavior of this function in the complex time plane can be exploited to gain information about the connection between phases and moduli of the component amplitudes. One form of this connection is a pair of reciprocal (Kramers–Kronig type) relations in the complex time domain. These show that certain phase changes in a component amplitude (e.g., lead to a non–zero Berry phase) require changes in the amplitude moduli, too, and imply degeneracies of the electronic state. The subject of conical degeneracy, or intersection, of adjacent potential surface is extended to nonlinear nuclear-electronic coupling, which can then result in multiple conical degeneracies on a nuclear coordinate plane. We treat cases of double and fourfold intersections, the latter under trigonal symmetry, and employ an analytic-graphical phase tracing method to obtain the resulting Berry phases as the system circles around some or all of the degeneracy points. These phases can take up values that are all integral multiples of π, with integers that vary with the physical situation (or with the model postulated for it). A further type of invariance, with respect to gauge transformation, is also tied to the complex form of the wave function. for a many-component state, this leads to a consideration of tensorial (Yang–Mills type) fields F for molecular systems. It is shown that it is the truncation of the Born–Oppenheimer electron-nuclear superposition that generates the molecular Yang–Mills fields. The equations of motion for the nuclear degrees of freedom are derived from a Lagrangean density ℒ, representing a non-Abelian situation. In ℒ, the non-adiabatic coupling terms (NACTs) that express the electronic background on the nuclear states enter as vector potentials (or gauge fields). We demonstrate a deep lying interrelation between two apparently distinct theoretical developments: that which led to the discovery of the Yang–Mills fields from considerations of local gauge invariance, and the use of an adiabatic–diabatic transformation matrix for the molecular case due to Baer. A generalized form of the NACTs is found, such that it makes the field F vanish for a complete electronic set. Finally, the use of phases and moduli as variables was found to be very convenient to obtain variationally the equation of continuity and the Hamilton–Jacobi equations from the Lagrangian of an electron following either the Schrüdinger or the Dirac equation. In the latter case, to a good approximation (in the nearly nonrelativistic limit) the phases in the different spinor components are not scrambled together and their Berry phases are unaffected.
The relation between the Aharonov-Anandan phase and the Berry phase is studied in a simple model with a time-independent Hamiltonian, in which two spin-½ systems (I+II) are coupled to a plane rotator (III), so that the parameter ϕ in the part of the Hamiltonian governing I+II is a dynamical variable of 111. A family of solutions Ψ( t ) with period τ to the time-dependent Schrodinger equation for I+II+III is investigated, yielding the following information. ( i ) The Aharonov-Anandan phase is obtained for each Ψ( t ) over the period τ. ( ii ) By tracing out the variables of III a statistical operator W( t ) is obtained for I+II. ( iii ) In an appropriate correspondence limit, ϕ acquires a sharply defined value ϕ ( t ), and then W( t ) represents a pure state v( t ) of I+II. ( iv ) The Aharonov-Anandan phase is calculated for v(t) over the period τ and it is independent of the Aharonov-Anandan phase of ( i ). ( v ) In the adiabatic limit, when τ goes to infinity, the Aharonov-Anandan phase approaches the Berry phase for I+II. ( vi ) Finally, comparisons are made of the exact energy eigenvalues of the total system with the traditional Born-Oppenheimer approximation, and the improved Born-Oppenheimer approximation.