Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1401.7410 · Physical Review A

Measurement errors in entanglement-assisted electron microscopy

Hiroshi Okamoto

Published Jun 30, 2014• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The major resolution-limiting factor in cryoelectron microscopy of unstained biological specimens is radiation damage by the very electrons that are used to probe the specimen structure. To address this problem, an electron microscopy scheme that employs quantum entanglement to enable phase measurement precision beyond the standard quantum limit has recently been proposed [H. Okamoto, Phys. Rev. A 85, 043810 (2012)]. Here we identify and examine in detail measurement errors that will arise in the scheme. Emphasis is given to considerations concerning inelastic scattering events because, in general, schemes assisted with quantum entanglement are known to be highly vulnerable to lossy processes. We find that the amount of error due to both elastic and inelastic scattering processes is acceptable provided that the electron beam geometry is properly designed and the specimen is sufficiently thin.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.89.063828

Related papers

Resilient quantum electron microscopy

Hiroshi Okamoto

We investigate the fundamental limit of biological quantum electron microscopy, which is designed to go beyond the shot noise limit. Inelastic scattering is expected to be the main obstacle in this setting, especially for thick specimens of actual biological interest. Here we describe a measurement procedure that, in principle, significantly neutralizes the effect of inelastic scattering.

arXiv:2001.05603•Physical Review A•Aug 5, 2022•3 citations

Spin Squeezing in Electron Microscopy

Shiran Even-Haim, Ethan Nussinson, Roni Ben-Maimon +5 more

Quantum metrology experiments in atomic physics and quantum optics have demonstrated measurement accuracy beyond the shot-noise limit via multi-particle entanglement. At the same time, electron microscopy, an essential tool for high-resolution imaging of biological systems, is severely constrained in its signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) by shot noise, due to the dose limit imposed by electron beam-induced damage. Here, we show theoretically that spin squeezing, a form of quantum metrology based on entanglement, is a natural fit for improving the SNR in electron microscopy. We investigate the generation of the necessary entangled states through electron-electron Coulomb interactions and quantum non-demolition measurements. Our results connect the fields of quantum metrology and electron interferometry, paving the way toward electron microscopy with SNR beyond the shot-noise limit.

arXiv:2507.09243•Jul 12, 2025•4 citations

Designs for a quantum electron microscope

P. Kruit, Richard G. Hobbs, Chung-Soo Kim +11 more

One of the astounding consequences of quantum mechanics is that it allows the detection of a target using an incident probe, with only a low probability of interaction of the probe and the target. This 'quantum weirdness' could be applied in the field of electron microscopy to generate images of beam-sensitive specimens with substantially reduced damage to the specimen. A reduction of beam-induced damage to specimens is especially of great importance if it can enable imaging of biological specimens with atomic resolution. Following a recent suggestion that interaction-free measurements are possible with electrons, we now analyze the difficulties of actually building an atomic resolution interaction-free electron microscope, or "quantum electron microscope". A quantum electron microscope would require a number of unique components not found in conventional transmission electron microscopes. These components include a coherent electron beam-splitter or two-state-coupler, and a resonator structure to allow each electron to interrogate the specimen multiple times, thus supporting high success probabilities for interaction-free detection of the specimen. Different system designs are presented here, which are based on four different choices of two-state-couplers: a thin crystal, a grating mirror, a standing light wave and an electro-dynamical pseudopotential. Challenges for the detailed electron optical design are identified as future directions for development. While it is concluded that it should be possible to build an atomic resolution quantum electron microscope, we have also identified a number of hurdles to the development of such a microscope and further theoretical investigations that will be required to enable a complete interpretation of the images produced by such a microscope.

arXiv:1510.05946•Ultramicroscopy•Mar 9, 2016•160 citations

Entanglement and decoherence in electron microscopy

P. Schattschneider, Stefan Löffler

Interaction of the probe with the specimen in an electron microscope inevitably leads to entanglement between the probe and the scatterer. In spite of the importance of entanglement in many areas of modern physics, this subject has not been touched in the literature. Here, we develop some ideas about entanglement in electron microscopy for a number of scattering mechanisms. The relationship between entropy, density matrices, and coherence is discussed. In addition, we explore the questions “Why is Bragg scattering coherent and energy loss incoherent?” and “When does decoherence play a role?” It seems to be possible to measure decoherence on extremely short timescales of ∼10−8s. This is especially important in view of recent developments in ultrafast electron microscopy.

Ultramicroscopy•Apr 13, 2018•28 citations

Entanglement-assisted electron microscopy based on a flux qubit

Hiroshi Okamoto, Yukinori Nagatani

A notorious problem in high-resolution biological electron microscopy is radiation damage caused by probe electrons. Hence, acquisition of data with minimal number of electrons is of critical importance. Quantum approaches may represent the only way to improve the resolution in this context, but all proposed schemes to date demand delicate control of the electron beam in highly unconventional electron optics. Here we propose a scheme that involves a flux qubit based on a radio-frequency superconducting quantum interference device, inserted in a transmission electron microscope. The scheme significantly improves the prospect of realizing a quantum-enhanced electron microscope for radiation-sensitive specimens.

arXiv:1311.2377•Applied Physics Letters•Feb 10, 2014•26 citations

Possible use of a Cooper-pair box for low-dose electron microscopy

Hiroshi Okamoto

A transmission electron microscope that takes advantage of superconducting quantum circuitry is proposed. The microscope is designed to improve the image contrast of radiation-sensitive weak-phase objects, in particular, biological specimens. The objective in this setting is to measure the phase shift of the probe electron wave to a precision \ensuremath{\Delta}\ensuremath{\theta} within the number of electrons $N$ that does not destroy the specimen. In conventional electron microscopy \ensuremath{\Delta}\ensuremath{\theta} scales as \ensuremath{\sim}1/${N}^{1/2}$, which falls short of the Heisenberg limit \ensuremath{\sim}1/$N$. To approach the latter by using quantum entanglement, we propose a design that involves a Cooper-pair box placed on the surface of an electrostatic electron mirror in the microscope. Significant improvement could be attained if inelastic scattering processes are sufficiently delocalized.

arXiv:1102.4691•Physical Review A•Apr 9, 2012•24 citations
The major resolution-limiting factor in cryoelectron microscopy of unstained biological specimens is radiation damage by the very electrons that are used to probe the specimen structure. To address this problem, an electron microscopy scheme that employs quantum entanglement to enable phase measurement precision beyond the standard quantum limit has recently been proposed [H. Okamoto, Phys. Rev. A 85, 043810 (2012)]. Here we identify and examine in detail measurement errors that will arise in the scheme. Emphasis is given to considerations concerning inelastic scattering events because, in general, schemes assisted with quantum entanglement are known to be highly vulnerable to lossy processes. We find that the amount of error due to both elastic and inelastic scattering processes is acceptable provided that the electron beam geometry is properly designed and the specimen is sufficiently thin.
Quantum metrology experiments in atomic physics and quantum optics have demonstrated measurement accuracy beyond the shot-noise limit via multi-particle entanglement. At the same time, electron microscopy, an essential tool for high-resolution imaging of biological systems, is severely constrained in its signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) by shot noise, due to the dose limit imposed by electron beam-induced damage. Here, we show theoretically that spin squeezing, a form of quantum metrology based on entanglement, is a natural fit for improving the SNR in electron microscopy. We investigate the generation of the necessary entangled states through electron-electron Coulomb interactions and quantum non-demolition measurements. Our results connect the fields of quantum metrology and electron interferometry, paving the way toward electron microscopy with SNR beyond the shot-noise limit.
One of the astounding consequences of quantum mechanics is that it allows the detection of a target using an incident probe, with only a low probability of interaction of the probe and the target. This 'quantum weirdness' could be applied in the field of electron microscopy to generate images of beam-sensitive specimens with substantially reduced damage to the specimen. A reduction of beam-induced damage to specimens is especially of great importance if it can enable imaging of biological specimens with atomic resolution. Following a recent suggestion that interaction-free measurements are possible with electrons, we now analyze the difficulties of actually building an atomic resolution interaction-free electron microscope, or "quantum electron microscope". A quantum electron microscope would require a number of unique components not found in conventional transmission electron microscopes. These components include a coherent electron beam-splitter or two-state-coupler, and a resonator structure to allow each electron to interrogate the specimen multiple times, thus supporting high success probabilities for interaction-free detection of the specimen. Different system designs are presented here, which are based on four different choices of two-state-couplers: a thin crystal, a grating mirror, a standing light wave and an electro-dynamical pseudopotential. Challenges for the detailed electron optical design are identified as future directions for development. While it is concluded that it should be possible to build an atomic resolution quantum electron microscope, we have also identified a number of hurdles to the development of such a microscope and further theoretical investigations that will be required to enable a complete interpretation of the images produced by such a microscope.
Interaction of the probe with the specimen in an electron microscope inevitably leads to entanglement between the probe and the scatterer. In spite of the importance of entanglement in many areas of modern physics, this subject has not been touched in the literature. Here, we develop some ideas about entanglement in electron microscopy for a number of scattering mechanisms. The relationship between entropy, density matrices, and coherence is discussed. In addition, we explore the questions “Why is Bragg scattering coherent and energy loss incoherent?” and “When does decoherence play a role?” It seems to be possible to measure decoherence on extremely short timescales of ∼10−8s. This is especially important in view of recent developments in ultrafast electron microscopy.
A notorious problem in high-resolution biological electron microscopy is radiation damage caused by probe electrons. Hence, acquisition of data with minimal number of electrons is of critical importance. Quantum approaches may represent the only way to improve the resolution in this context, but all proposed schemes to date demand delicate control of the electron beam in highly unconventional electron optics. Here we propose a scheme that involves a flux qubit based on a radio-frequency superconducting quantum interference device, inserted in a transmission electron microscope. The scheme significantly improves the prospect of realizing a quantum-enhanced electron microscope for radiation-sensitive specimens.
A transmission electron microscope that takes advantage of superconducting quantum circuitry is proposed. The microscope is designed to improve the image contrast of radiation-sensitive weak-phase objects, in particular, biological specimens. The objective in this setting is to measure the phase shift of the probe electron wave to a precision \ensuremath{\Delta}\ensuremath{\theta} within the number of electrons NNN that does not destroy the specimen. In conventional electron microscopy \ensuremath{\Delta}\ensuremath{\theta} scales as \ensuremath{\sim}1/N1/2{N}^{1/2}N1/2, which falls short of the Heisenberg limit \ensuremath{\sim}1/NNN. To approach the latter by using quantum entanglement, we propose a design that involves a Cooper-pair box placed on the surface of an electrostatic electron mirror in the microscope. Significant improvement could be attained if inelastic scattering processes are sufficiently delocalized.