Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1401.7039 · Physical Review A

Low-energy scattering of molecules and ions in a magnetic field

F. Robicheaux

Published Jun 3, 2014• 4 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We describe calculations of elastic and inelastic scattering of neutral molecules and cold ions in a magnetic field. The molecule is assumed to have a magnetic and electric dipole moment. The external magnetic field splits the ground rovibrational energy levels of the molecule. The highest energy state within the ground rovibrational manifold increases in energy as the distance to the ion decreases leading to a repelling potential. At low energy, inelastic collisions are strongly suppressed due to the large distance of closest approach. Thus, a collision between a neutral molecule and a cold ion will lead to a decrease in the molecule's kinetic energy with no change in internal energy. We present results for the specific case of OH molecules cooled by ${\mathrm{Be}}^{+}$, ${\mathrm{Mg}}^{+}$, or ${\mathrm{Ca}}^{+}$ ions. Also, we perform molecular dynamics simulations of ions and molecules in a combined Paul trap and time-averaged orbiting potential trap. Our results suggest that sympathetic cooling of neutral molecules by ions would be possible if cold ions and molecules could be simultaneously trapped.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.89.062701

Related papers

Elastic and inelastic collisions of 2Σ molecules in a magnetic field

Jie Cui, Roman V. Krems

We calculate the cross sections for elastic scattering and Zeeman relaxation in binary collisions of molecules in the rovibrational ground state of a ${}^{2}\ensuremath{\Sigma}$ electronic state and the Zeeman state with the electron spin projection ${M}_{S}=\frac{1}{2}$ on the magnetic field axis. This is the lowest-energy state of ${}^{2}\ensuremath{\Sigma}$ molecules confined in a magnetic trap. The results are averaged over calculations with multiple molecule-molecule interaction potentials, which yield the expectation intervals for the cross sections and the elastic-to-inelastic cross-section ratios. We find that the elastic-to-inelastic cross-section ratios under conditions corresponding to trapped molecular ensembles at $T\ensuremath{\sim}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}3}$ K exceed 100 for the majority of ${}^{2}\ensuremath{\Sigma}$ molecules. The range of ${}^{2}\ensuremath{\Sigma}$ molecules expected to be collisionally unstable in magnetic traps at $T<{10}^{\ensuremath{-}3}$ K is limited to molecules with the spin-rotation interaction constant ${\ensuremath{\gamma}}_{\mathrm{SR}}>0.5$ cm${}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$ and the rotational constant ${B}_{e}<4$ cm${}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$.

arXiv:1308.0771•Physical Review A•Oct 11, 2013•6 citations

Collisions of trapped molecules with slow beams

Timur V. Tscherbul, Zoran Miroslav Pavlovic, H. R. Sadeghpour +2 more

We present a theoretical study of molecular-trap loss induced by collisions with slow atomic beams based on an explicit analysis of collision kinematics in the laboratory frame and a rigorous quantum description of atom-molecule scattering in external fields. The theory is applied to elucidate the effects of nonuniform magnetic and optical trapping fields on low-temperature collisions of OH ($J=3/2,{M}_{J}=3/2,f$) molecules with $^{4}\mathrm{He}$ atoms. Our calculations quantify the extent to which both elastic and inelastic cross sections are suppressed by external trapping fields, clarify the role of small-angle scattering in trap loss, and may benefit future experiments on collisional cooling of molecules in electromagnetic traps. The calculated cross sections for trap loss in $^{4}\mathrm{He}$ $+$ OH collisions are consistent with recent experimental observations at low beam energies [B. C. Sawyer et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 203203 (2008)], demonstrating the importance of including the effects of nonuniform trapping fields in theoretical simulations of cold collision experiments with trapped molecules and slow atomic beams.

Physical Review A•Aug 10, 2010•16 citations

Dipolar collisions in cooling and trapping of paramagnetic atoms

Zoran Miroslav Pavlovic

In this dissertation, I present ab initio theoretical results on cold and ultra-cold collision of atomic and molecular systems with magnetic and electric dipole moments. The collisions of different isotopes of maximally spin-polarized chromium atoms (52Cr and 53Cr), alkali-metal atom (Rb) - chromium atom, and magnetically trapped hydroxide (OH) with cold supersonic helium beam are considered in this thesis. Spin-changing cross sections and rate constants in Cr-Cr isotopic collision in the presence of a magnetic field are calculated by propagating a set of multichannel equations in the field. The coupling between dipole-dipole allowed and hyperfine channels are included. The short range electrostatic interactions between atoms and atom-molecule are represented with highly-accurate Born-Oppenheimer (BO) potential energy curves. Due to the large spin multiplicity in Cr-Cr and Rb-Cr interactions, more than the usual singlet and triplet channels are obtained. The long-range van der Waals (vdW) interactions between atoms are calculated, for Cr, by including accurate transition frequencies, discrete dipole matrix elements, and photoionization continuum oscillator strengths, and for Rb, using published dynamic polarizabilities. The vdW coefficients for Cr-Cr and Rb-Cr are obtained. In the cold collision regime, I investigate the influence of angular momentum shape resonances on the elastic and inelastic (loss channel) rate coefficients, and when the Zeeman relaxation, resulting in the loss of atoms from the trap, dominates elastic collision. Dipolar collisions are crucial to achieving quantum degeneracy. Magnetically tuned Fano-Feshbach closed-channel resonances are used to obtain zero-energy scattering lengths in comparison with observation of trap loss. In bosonic chromium collisions, resonances appear due only to dipolar interaction. The interplay between hyperfine and dipolar resonances in mixed-species Cr-Cr and Rb-Cr collisions is studied. In Rb-Cr, it is found that the molecule has broken symmetry and therefore contains a large permanent electric dipole moment in the ground state. A recent collisional experiment at JILA of a supersonic helium beam with a magnetically trapped OH radical found the onset of a quantum threshold in the total OH loss rate. Using ab initio BO energy surfaces, I calculated the spin-changing collisions which removed OH from the trap. Only after including the effect of the trapping potential on the collision dynamics, some agreement with observation was found. ^

•Jan 1, 2011•1 citation

Magnetic field control of ultracold atom-molecule collision

Musie Beyene

In this work we investigate the potential of controlling cold (O(K)−mK) and ultracold (mK-μK) atom-molecule collisions by tuning scattering states across Feshbach resonances using magnetic fields. We are interested in particular in the prospect of suppressing the often undesirable inelastic collisions. The He-O_2 system provides the vehicle for our study. We calculate bound and quasi-bound states of several isotopic combinations, including their Zeeman structure, to reveal the underlaying pattern for easier characterization of quasi-bound states in terms of rigorous and approximately good quantum numbers. These calculations also help us locate the fields at which zero-energy resonances will occur. Scattering calculations are then performed for collisions of 3^He and 4^He with {16}^O_2 at fixed (1 μK) energy but varying magnetic field. The field is varied to sweep the scattering state across resonance. At low and ultralow energies we enter the Wigner threshold regime where the S-partial wave dominates the wavefunction. The cross sections, and the real and imaginary parts of the scattering length, vary dramatically across resonance. Their profiles are used to analyze the resonances. In a highlight of our results we show that dramatic suppression of inelastic cross sections occur for 4^He-{16}^O_2 . The resonances are relatively wide (of order 100 Gauss), with suppression of inelastic scattering over a similarly wide range of fields and for temperatures ranging from 10 mK down to 1 μK. We conclude that under certain conditions it is possible to almost completely eliminate inelastic collisions. This is potentially very important for cooling techniques, such as evaporative and sympathetic cooling, that require efficient elastic cross sections. Suppression of inelastic collisions can not only increase thermalization efficiency but it can also result in longer trap-lifetimes by reducing transitions to untrapable states. \n

•Jan 1, 2011•0 citations

Cold collisions of an open-shell S-state atom with a 2Π molecule: N(4S) colliding with OH in a magnetic field

Wojciech Skomorowski, Maykel Leonardo González-Martínez, Robert Moszyński +1 more

We present quantum-theoretical studies of collisions between an open-shell S-state atom and a (2)Π-state molecule in the presence of a magnetic field. We analyze the collisional Hamiltonian and discuss possible mechanisms for inelastic collisions in such systems. The theory is applied to the collisions of the nitrogen atom ((4)S) with the OH molecule, with both collision partners initially in fully spin-stretched (magnetically trappable) states, assuming that the interaction takes place exclusively on the two high-spin (quintet) potential energy surfaces. The surfaces for the quintet states are obtained from spin-unrestricted coupled-cluster calculations with single, double, and noniterative triple excitations. We find substantial inelasticity, arising from strong couplings due to the anisotropy of the interaction potential and the anisotropic spin-spin dipolar interaction. The mechanism involving the dipolar interaction dominates for small magnetic field strengths and ultralow collision energies, while the mechanism involving the potential anisotropy prevails when the field strength is larger (above 100 G) or the collision energy is higher (above 1 mK). The numerical results suggest that sympathetic cooling of magnetically trapped OH by collisions with ultracold N atoms will not be successful at higher temperatures.

arXiv:1107.1443•Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics•Jan 1, 2011•6 citations

Cold collisions of N ( 4 S) atoms and NH ( 3 Σ) molecules in magnetic fields

Piotr Szymon Żuchowski, Jeremy M. Hutson

We calculate the interaction potential between N atoms and NH molecules and use it to investigate cold and ultracold collisions important for sympathetic cooling. The ratio of elastic to inelastic cross sections is large over a wide range of collision energy and magnetic field for most isotopic combinations, so that sympathetic cooling of NH molecules by N atoms is a good prospect. However, there are important effects due to a p-wave shape resonance that may inhibit cooling in some cases. We show that scaling the reduced mass used in the collision is approximately equivalent to scaling the interaction potential. We then explore the dependence of the scattering properties on the reduced mass and explain the resonant effects observed using angular-momentum-insensitive quantum defect theory.

arXiv:1009.1322•Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics•Dec 24, 2010•38 citations
We describe calculations of elastic and inelastic scattering of neutral molecules and cold ions in a magnetic field. The molecule is assumed to have a magnetic and electric dipole moment. The external magnetic field splits the ground rovibrational energy levels of the molecule. The highest energy state within the ground rovibrational manifold increases in energy as the distance to the ion decreases leading to a repelling potential. At low energy, inelastic collisions are strongly suppressed due to the large distance of closest approach. Thus, a collision between a neutral molecule and a cold ion will lead to a decrease in the molecule's kinetic energy with no change in internal energy. We present results for the specific case of OH molecules cooled by Be+{\mathrm{Be}}^{+}Be+, Mg+{\mathrm{Mg}}^{+}Mg+, or Ca+{\mathrm{Ca}}^{+}Ca+ ions. Also, we perform molecular dynamics simulations of ions and molecules in a combined Paul trap and time-averaged orbiting potential trap. Our results suggest that sympathetic cooling of neutral molecules by ions would be possible if cold ions and molecules could be simultaneously trapped.
We calculate the cross sections for elastic scattering and Zeeman relaxation in binary collisions of molecules in the rovibrational ground state of a ${}^{2}\ensuremath{\Sigma}$ electronic state and the Zeeman state with the electron spin projection MS=12{M}_{S}=\frac{1}{2}MS​=21​ on the magnetic field axis. This is the lowest-energy state of ${}^{2}\ensuremath{\Sigma}$ molecules confined in a magnetic trap. The results are averaged over calculations with multiple molecule-molecule interaction potentials, which yield the expectation intervals for the cross sections and the elastic-to-inelastic cross-section ratios. We find that the elastic-to-inelastic cross-section ratios under conditions corresponding to trapped molecular ensembles at $T\ensuremath{\sim}{10}^{\ensuremath{-}3}$ K exceed 100 for the majority of ${}^{2}\ensuremath{\Sigma}$ molecules. The range of ${}^{2}\ensuremath{\Sigma}$ molecules expected to be collisionally unstable in magnetic traps at $T<{10}^{\ensuremath{-}3}$ K is limited to molecules with the spin-rotation interaction constant ${\ensuremath{\gamma}}_{\mathrm{SR}}>0.5$ cm${}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$ and the rotational constant Be<4{B}_{e}<4Be​<4 cm${}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$.
We present a theoretical study of molecular-trap loss induced by collisions with slow atomic beams based on an explicit analysis of collision kinematics in the laboratory frame and a rigorous quantum description of atom-molecule scattering in external fields. The theory is applied to elucidate the effects of nonuniform magnetic and optical trapping fields on low-temperature collisions of OH (J=3/2,MJ=3/2,fJ=3/2,{M}_{J}=3/2,fJ=3/2,MJ​=3/2,f) molecules with 4He^{4}\mathrm{He}4He atoms. Our calculations quantify the extent to which both elastic and inelastic cross sections are suppressed by external trapping fields, clarify the role of small-angle scattering in trap loss, and may benefit future experiments on collisional cooling of molecules in electromagnetic traps. The calculated cross sections for trap loss in 4He^{4}\mathrm{He}4He +++ OH collisions are consistent with recent experimental observations at low beam energies [B. C. Sawyer et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 203203 (2008)], demonstrating the importance of including the effects of nonuniform trapping fields in theoretical simulations of cold collision experiments with trapped molecules and slow atomic beams.
In this dissertation, I present ab initio theoretical results on cold and ultra-cold collision of atomic and molecular systems with magnetic and electric dipole moments. The collisions of different isotopes of maximally spin-polarized chromium atoms (52Cr and 53Cr), alkali-metal atom (Rb) - chromium atom, and magnetically trapped hydroxide (OH) with cold supersonic helium beam are considered in this thesis. Spin-changing cross sections and rate constants in Cr-Cr isotopic collision in the presence of a magnetic field are calculated by propagating a set of multichannel equations in the field. The coupling between dipole-dipole allowed and hyperfine channels are included. The short range electrostatic interactions between atoms and atom-molecule are represented with highly-accurate Born-Oppenheimer (BO) potential energy curves. Due to the large spin multiplicity in Cr-Cr and Rb-Cr interactions, more than the usual singlet and triplet channels are obtained. The long-range van der Waals (vdW) interactions between atoms are calculated, for Cr, by including accurate transition frequencies, discrete dipole matrix elements, and photoionization continuum oscillator strengths, and for Rb, using published dynamic polarizabilities. The vdW coefficients for Cr-Cr and Rb-Cr are obtained. In the cold collision regime, I investigate the influence of angular momentum shape resonances on the elastic and inelastic (loss channel) rate coefficients, and when the Zeeman relaxation, resulting in the loss of atoms from the trap, dominates elastic collision. Dipolar collisions are crucial to achieving quantum degeneracy. Magnetically tuned Fano-Feshbach closed-channel resonances are used to obtain zero-energy scattering lengths in comparison with observation of trap loss. In bosonic chromium collisions, resonances appear due only to dipolar interaction. The interplay between hyperfine and dipolar resonances in mixed-species Cr-Cr and Rb-Cr collisions is studied. In Rb-Cr, it is found that the molecule has broken symmetry and therefore contains a large permanent electric dipole moment in the ground state. A recent collisional experiment at JILA of a supersonic helium beam with a magnetically trapped OH radical found the onset of a quantum threshold in the total OH loss rate. Using ab initio BO energy surfaces, I calculated the spin-changing collisions which removed OH from the trap. Only after including the effect of the trapping potential on the collision dynamics, some agreement with observation was found. ^
In this work we investigate the potential of controlling cold (O(K)−mK) and ultracold (mK-μK) atom-molecule collisions by tuning scattering states across Feshbach resonances using magnetic fields. We are interested in particular in the prospect of suppressing the often undesirable inelastic collisions. The He-O_2 system provides the vehicle for our study. We calculate bound and quasi-bound states of several isotopic combinations, including their Zeeman structure, to reveal the underlaying pattern for easier characterization of quasi-bound states in terms of rigorous and approximately good quantum numbers. These calculations also help us locate the fields at which zero-energy resonances will occur. Scattering calculations are then performed for collisions of 3^He and 4^He with {16}^O_2 at fixed (1 μK) energy but varying magnetic field. The field is varied to sweep the scattering state across resonance. At low and ultralow energies we enter the Wigner threshold regime where the S-partial wave dominates the wavefunction. The cross sections, and the real and imaginary parts of the scattering length, vary dramatically across resonance. Their profiles are used to analyze the resonances. In a highlight of our results we show that dramatic suppression of inelastic cross sections occur for 4^He-{16}^O_2 . The resonances are relatively wide (of order 100 Gauss), with suppression of inelastic scattering over a similarly wide range of fields and for temperatures ranging from 10 mK down to 1 μK. We conclude that under certain conditions it is possible to almost completely eliminate inelastic collisions. This is potentially very important for cooling techniques, such as evaporative and sympathetic cooling, that require efficient elastic cross sections. Suppression of inelastic collisions can not only increase thermalization efficiency but it can also result in longer trap-lifetimes by reducing transitions to untrapable states. \n
We present quantum-theoretical studies of collisions between an open-shell S-state atom and a (2)Π-state molecule in the presence of a magnetic field. We analyze the collisional Hamiltonian and discuss possible mechanisms for inelastic collisions in such systems. The theory is applied to the collisions of the nitrogen atom ((4)S) with the OH molecule, with both collision partners initially in fully spin-stretched (magnetically trappable) states, assuming that the interaction takes place exclusively on the two high-spin (quintet) potential energy surfaces. The surfaces for the quintet states are obtained from spin-unrestricted coupled-cluster calculations with single, double, and noniterative triple excitations. We find substantial inelasticity, arising from strong couplings due to the anisotropy of the interaction potential and the anisotropic spin-spin dipolar interaction. The mechanism involving the dipolar interaction dominates for small magnetic field strengths and ultralow collision energies, while the mechanism involving the potential anisotropy prevails when the field strength is larger (above 100 G) or the collision energy is higher (above 1 mK). The numerical results suggest that sympathetic cooling of magnetically trapped OH by collisions with ultracold N atoms will not be successful at higher temperatures.
We calculate the interaction potential between N atoms and NH molecules and use it to investigate cold and ultracold collisions important for sympathetic cooling. The ratio of elastic to inelastic cross sections is large over a wide range of collision energy and magnetic field for most isotopic combinations, so that sympathetic cooling of NH molecules by N atoms is a good prospect. However, there are important effects due to a p-wave shape resonance that may inhibit cooling in some cases. We show that scaling the reduced mass used in the collision is approximately equivalent to scaling the interaction potential. We then explore the dependence of the scattering properties on the reduced mass and explain the resonant effects observed using angular-momentum-insensitive quantum defect theory.