Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1312.6907 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

Measurement and ergodicity in quantum mechanics

M. Bauer, Pier A. Mello

Published Apr 14, 2015• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Abstract The experimental realization of successive non-demolition measurements on single microscopic systems brings up the question of ergodicity in quantum mechanics (QM). We investigate whether time averages over one realization of a single system are related to QM averages over an ensemble of similarly prepared systems. We adopt a generalization of the von Neumann model of measurement, coupling the system to N ‘probes’, with a strength that is at our disposal, and detecting the latter. The model parallels the procedure followed in experiments on quantum electrodynamic cavities. The modification of the probability of the observable eigenvalues due to the coupling to the probes can be computed analytically and the results compare qualitatively well with those obtained numerically by the experimental groups. We find that the problem is not ergodic, except in the case of an eigenstate of the observable being studied.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8113/48/18/185302

Related papers

Ergodic Theorem in Quantum Mechanics

P. Bocchieri, A. Loinger

Landsberg and Farquhar have shown that the von Neumann-Fierz approach to the quantum ergodic problem does not give any criterion of ergodicity.In this paper it is shown that von Neumann's procedure of averaging over the macro-observers is sufficient by itself to "justify" at every time the use of the quantum microcanonical ensemble. It is then proved that the time behavior of the system is completely irrelevant to the demonstration of the von Neumann and von Neumann-Fierz ergodic theorems. It is concluded that the quantum ergodic problem must be attacked on entirely new lines.

Physical Review•Aug 1, 1958•36 citations

Ergodic Theorem for Interacting Systems

H. Ekstein

von Neumann has proved a quantum-mechanical ergodic theorem which deals with a closed macroscopic system and macroscopic observables. Certain unsatisfactory features of this theorem are probably due to the overly-strong idealization of a completely closed system.Since the claims of statistical mechanics go beyond macroscopic systems, there is a need for a more general theorem. The present paper deals with a system of any number of degrees of freedom and with any observable, during interaction with a temperature bath. In order to avoid an assumption of randomness, the bath must be described explicitly and precisely by a time-independent Hamiltonian. The model of the bath is obtained by taking the Gibbs ensemble seriously, i.e., as a set of $N$ identical systems interacting through a potential $\ensuremath{\lambda}V$.The following theorem is proved. The time average of the quantum-mechanical expectation value of any observable with respect to any initial state is equal to its statistical average, in the double limit $N\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$, $\ensuremath{\lambda}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$, for the overwhelming majority of all interaction potentials $V$.

Physical Review•Jul 15, 1957•10 citations

The Uncertainty Principle Revisited

A. Mann, Pier A. Mello, M. Revzen

We study the quantum-mechanical uncertainty relation originating from the successive measurement of two observables $\hat{A}$ and $\hat{B}$, with eigenvalues $a_n$ and $b_m$, respectively, performed on the same system. We use an extension of the von Neumann model of measurement, in which two probes interact with the same system proper at two successive times, so we can exhibit how the disturbing effect of the first interaction affects the second measurement. Detecting the statistical properties of the second {\em probe} variable $Q_2$ conditioned on the first {\em probe} measurement yielding $Q_1$ we obtain information on the statistical distribution of the {\em system} variable $b_m$ conditioned on having found the system variable $a_n$ in the interval $δa$ around $a^{(n)}$. The width of this statistical distribution as function of $δa$ constitutes an {\em uncertainty relation}. We find a general connection of this uncertainty relation with the commutator of the two observables that have been measured successively. We illustrate this relation for the successive measurement of position and momentum in the discrete and in the continuous cases and, within a model, for the successive measurement of a more general class of observables.

arXiv:2006.00347•May 30, 2020•1 citation

Fundamental Issues and Measurement Problem in Quantum Mechanics

Tadashi Nakajima

Foundations of quantum mechanics are reconsidered in relation to the measurement problem. We define two kinds of quantities. The type A quantities are observables obtained experimentally from a single measurement. A dynamical variable is a type A quantity whose measurement selects a set of eigenvalues (EVs) as \(c\)-numbers. The type B quantities represent theoretical quantities related to probabilities. State vectors, wave function, and the probability distribution (PD) are type B quantities. They are derived from an eigenvalue equation such as Schrödinger equation. A quantum jump (QJ) is the measurement of a dynamical variable to select a set of EVs. The wave function is a theoretical quantity which persists throughout an experiment and therefore it does not collapse. After a QJ, a selected set of EVs persists until it becomes macroscopic. However, an eigenstate is a theoretical notion irrelevant to a single measurement and it does not exist in reality after a QJ. One experiment is complete when an ensemble of EVs has been obtained and compared with the theoretically predicted PD. To obtain an ensemble, repeated measurements are required in general, but there are some exceptions like a Bose-Einstein condensate system for which a single measurement yields a real ensemble. We discuss the relation between the reality of the wave function and the derivation of non-relativistic quantum mechanics from quantum field theory.

Qeios•Dec 28, 2025•0 citations

Fundamental Issues and Measurement Problem in Quantum Mechanics

Tadashi Nakajima

Foundations of quantum mechanics are reconsidered in relation to the measurement problem. We define two kinds of quantities. The type A quantities are observables obtained experimentally from a single measurement. A dynamical variable is a type A quantity whose measurement selects a set of eigenvalues (EVs) as \(c\)-numbers. The type B quantities represent theoretical quantities related to probabilities. State vectors, wave function, and the probability distribution (PD) are type B quantities. They are derived from an eigenvalue equation such as Schrödinger equation. A quantum jump (QJ) is the measurement of a dynamical variable to select a set of EVs. The wave function is a theoretical quantity which persists throughout an experiment and therefore it does not collapse. After a QJ, a selected set of EVs persists until it becomes macroscopic. However, an eigenstate is a theoretical notion irrelevant to a single measurement and it does not exist in reality after a QJ. One experiment is complete when an ensemble of EVs has been obtained and compared with the theoretically predicted PD. To obtain an ensemble, repeated measurements are required in general, but there are some exceptions like a Bose-Einstein condensate system for which a single measurement yields a real ensemble. We discuss the relation between the reality of the wave function and the derivation of non-relativistic quantum mechanics from quantum field theory.

Qeios•Feb 20, 2026•0 citations

The von Neumann model of measurement in quantum mechanics

Pier A. Mello

We describe how to obtain information on a quantum-mechanical system by coupling it to a probe and detecting some property of the latter, using a model introduced by von Neumann, which describes the interaction of the system proper with the probe in a dynamical way. We first discuss single measurements, where the system proper is coupled to one probe with arbitrary coupling strength. The goal is to obtain information on the system detecting the probe position. We find the reduced density operator of the system, and show how Lüders rule emerges as the limiting case of strong coupling. The von Neumann model is then generalized to two probes that interact successively with the system proper. Now we find information on the system by detecting the position-position and momentum-position correlations of the two probes. The so-called "Wigner's formula" emerges in the strong-coupling limit, while "Kirkwood's quasi-probability distribution" is found as the weak-coupling limit of the above formalism. We show that successive measurements can be used to develop a state-reconstruction scheme. Finally, we find a generalized transform of the state and the observables based on the notion of successive measurements.

arXiv:1311.7649•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2014•15 citations
Abstract The experimental realization of successive non-demolition measurements on single microscopic systems brings up the question of ergodicity in quantum mechanics (QM). We investigate whether time averages over one realization of a single system are related to QM averages over an ensemble of similarly prepared systems. We adopt a generalization of the von Neumann model of measurement, coupling the system to N ‘probes’, with a strength that is at our disposal, and detecting the latter. The model parallels the procedure followed in experiments on quantum electrodynamic cavities. The modification of the probability of the observable eigenvalues due to the coupling to the probes can be computed analytically and the results compare qualitatively well with those obtained numerically by the experimental groups. We find that the problem is not ergodic, except in the case of an eigenstate of the observable being studied.
Landsberg and Farquhar have shown that the von Neumann-Fierz approach to the quantum ergodic problem does not give any criterion of ergodicity.In this paper it is shown that von Neumann's procedure of averaging over the macro-observers is sufficient by itself to "justify" at every time the use of the quantum microcanonical ensemble. It is then proved that the time behavior of the system is completely irrelevant to the demonstration of the von Neumann and von Neumann-Fierz ergodic theorems. It is concluded that the quantum ergodic problem must be attacked on entirely new lines.
von Neumann has proved a quantum-mechanical ergodic theorem which deals with a closed macroscopic system and macroscopic observables. Certain unsatisfactory features of this theorem are probably due to the overly-strong idealization of a completely closed system.Since the claims of statistical mechanics go beyond macroscopic systems, there is a need for a more general theorem. The present paper deals with a system of any number of degrees of freedom and with any observable, during interaction with a temperature bath. In order to avoid an assumption of randomness, the bath must be described explicitly and precisely by a time-independent Hamiltonian. The model of the bath is obtained by taking the Gibbs ensemble seriously, i.e., as a set of NNN identical systems interacting through a potential $\ensuremath{\lambda}V$.The following theorem is proved. The time average of the quantum-mechanical expectation value of any observable with respect to any initial state is equal to its statistical average, in the double limit $N\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$, $\ensuremath{\lambda}\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$, for the overwhelming majority of all interaction potentials VVV.
We study the quantum-mechanical uncertainty relation originating from the successive measurement of two observables A^\hat{A}A^ and B^\hat{B}B^, with eigenvalues ana_nan​ and bmb_mbm​, respectively, performed on the same system. We use an extension of the von Neumann model of measurement, in which two probes interact with the same system proper at two successive times, so we can exhibit how the disturbing effect of the first interaction affects the second measurement. Detecting the statistical properties of the second {\em probe} variable Q2Q_2Q2​ conditioned on the first {\em probe} measurement yielding Q1Q_1Q1​ we obtain information on the statistical distribution of the {\em system} variable bmb_mbm​ conditioned on having found the system variable ana_nan​ in the interval δaδaδa around a(n)a^{(n)}a(n). The width of this statistical distribution as function of δaδaδa constitutes an {\em uncertainty relation}. We find a general connection of this uncertainty relation with the commutator of the two observables that have been measured successively. We illustrate this relation for the successive measurement of position and momentum in the discrete and in the continuous cases and, within a model, for the successive measurement of a more general class of observables.
Foundations of quantum mechanics are reconsidered in relation to the measurement problem. We define two kinds of quantities. The type A quantities are observables obtained experimentally from a single measurement. A dynamical variable is a type A quantity whose measurement selects a set of eigenvalues (EVs) as ccc-numbers. The type B quantities represent theoretical quantities related to probabilities. State vectors, wave function, and the probability distribution (PD) are type B quantities. They are derived from an eigenvalue equation such as Schrödinger equation. A quantum jump (QJ) is the measurement of a dynamical variable to select a set of EVs. The wave function is a theoretical quantity which persists throughout an experiment and therefore it does not collapse. After a QJ, a selected set of EVs persists until it becomes macroscopic. However, an eigenstate is a theoretical notion irrelevant to a single measurement and it does not exist in reality after a QJ. One experiment is complete when an ensemble of EVs has been obtained and compared with the theoretically predicted PD. To obtain an ensemble, repeated measurements are required in general, but there are some exceptions like a Bose-Einstein condensate system for which a single measurement yields a real ensemble. We discuss the relation between the reality of the wave function and the derivation of non-relativistic quantum mechanics from quantum field theory.
Foundations of quantum mechanics are reconsidered in relation to the measurement problem. We define two kinds of quantities. The type A quantities are observables obtained experimentally from a single measurement. A dynamical variable is a type A quantity whose measurement selects a set of eigenvalues (EVs) as ccc-numbers. The type B quantities represent theoretical quantities related to probabilities. State vectors, wave function, and the probability distribution (PD) are type B quantities. They are derived from an eigenvalue equation such as Schrödinger equation. A quantum jump (QJ) is the measurement of a dynamical variable to select a set of EVs. The wave function is a theoretical quantity which persists throughout an experiment and therefore it does not collapse. After a QJ, a selected set of EVs persists until it becomes macroscopic. However, an eigenstate is a theoretical notion irrelevant to a single measurement and it does not exist in reality after a QJ. One experiment is complete when an ensemble of EVs has been obtained and compared with the theoretically predicted PD. To obtain an ensemble, repeated measurements are required in general, but there are some exceptions like a Bose-Einstein condensate system for which a single measurement yields a real ensemble. We discuss the relation between the reality of the wave function and the derivation of non-relativistic quantum mechanics from quantum field theory.
We describe how to obtain information on a quantum-mechanical system by coupling it to a probe and detecting some property of the latter, using a model introduced by von Neumann, which describes the interaction of the system proper with the probe in a dynamical way. We first discuss single measurements, where the system proper is coupled to one probe with arbitrary coupling strength. The goal is to obtain information on the system detecting the probe position. We find the reduced density operator of the system, and show how Lüders rule emerges as the limiting case of strong coupling. The von Neumann model is then generalized to two probes that interact successively with the system proper. Now we find information on the system by detecting the position-position and momentum-position correlations of the two probes. The so-called "Wigner's formula" emerges in the strong-coupling limit, while "Kirkwood's quasi-probability distribution" is found as the weak-coupling limit of the above formalism. We show that successive measurements can be used to develop a state-reconstruction scheme. Finally, we find a generalized transform of the state and the observables based on the notion of successive measurements.