Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1311.4091 · Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical

Maximum likelihood versus likelihood-free quantum system identification in the atom maser

Catalin Catana, Theodore Kypraios, Mădălin Guţǎ

Published Sep 25, 2014• 9 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider the problem of estimating a dynamical parameter of a Markovian quantum open system (the atom maser), by performing continuous time measurements in the systemʼs output (outgoing atoms). Two estimation methods are investigated and compared. Firstly, the maximum likelihood estimator (MLE) takes into account the full measurement data and is asymptotically optimal in terms of its mean square error. Secondly, the 'likelihood-free' method of approximate Bayesian computation (ABC) produces an approximation of the posterior distribution for a given set of summary statistics, by sampling trajectories at different parameter values and comparing them with the measurement data via chosen statistics. Building on previous results which showed that atom counts are poor statistics for certain values of the Rabi angle, we apply MLE to the full measurement data and estimate its Fisher information. We then select several correlation statistics such as waiting times, distribution of successive identical detections, and use them as input of the ABC algorithm. The resulting posterior distribution follows closely the data likelihood, showing that the selected statistics capture 'most' statistical information about the Rabi angle.

DOI
10.1088/1751-8113/47/41/415302

Related papers

Asymptotic inference in system identification for the atom maser

Cătălin Cătană, Merlijn van Horssen, Mădălin Guţǎ

System identification is closely related to control theory and plays an increasing role in quantum engineering. In the quantum set-up, system identification is usually equated to process tomography, i.e. estimating a channel by probing it repeatedly with different input states. However, for quantum dynamical systems such as quantum Markov processes, it is more natural to consider the estimation based on continuous measurements of the output, with a given input that may be stationary. We address this problem using asymptotic statistics tools, for the specific example of estimating the Rabi frequency of an atom maser. We compute the Fisher information of different measurement processes as well as the quantum Fisher information of the atom maser, and establish the local asymptotic normality of these statistical models. The statistical notions can be expressed in terms of spectral properties of certain deformed Markov generators, and the connection to large deviations is briefly discussed.

arXiv:1112.2080•Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Oct 22, 2012•21 citations

Efficient inference of quantum system parameters by approximate Bayesian computation

Lewis A. Clark, Jan Kołodyński

The ability to efficiently infer system parameters is essential in any signal-processing task that requires fast operation. In quantum systems, a serious challenge arises due to substantial growth of the underlying Hilbert space with the system size. As the statistics of the measurement data observed—i.e., the —can no longer be easily computed, common approaches such as maximum-likelihood estimators or particle filters become impractical. To address this issue, we propose the use of the approximate Bayesian computation (ABC) algorithm, which evades likelihood computation by sampling from a library of measurement data— prepared for a given quantum device. We apply ABC to interpret photodetection click patterns arising from real-time probing of a two-level atom and an optomechanical system. For the latter, we consider both linear and nonlinear regimes to show how to tailor the ABC algorithm by understanding the quantum measurement statistics. Our work demonstrates that fast parameter inference may be possible regardless of the complexity of the quantum device and the measurement scheme involved.

arXiv:2407.00724•Physical Review Applied•Apr 18, 2025•3 citations

Fisher informations and local asymptotic normality for continuous-time quantum Markov processes

Catalin Catana, Luc Bouten, Mădălin Guţǎ

Abstract We consider the problem of estimating an arbitrary dynamical parameter of an open quantum system in the input–output formalism. For irreducible Markov processes, we show that in the limit of large times the system-output state can be approximated by a quantum Gaussian state whose mean is proportional to the unknown parameter. This approximation holds locally in a neighbourhood of size in the parameter space, and provides an explicit expression of the asymptotic quantum Fisher information in terms of the Markov generator. Furthermore we show that additive statistics of the counting and homodyne measurements also satisfy local asymptotic normality and we compute the corresponding classical Fisher informations. The general theory is illustrated with the examples of a two-level system and the atom maser. Our results contribute towards a better understanding of the statistical and probabilistic properties of the output process, with relevance for quantum control engineering, and the theory of non-equilibrium quantum open systems.

arXiv:1407.5131•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Aug 17, 2015•40 citations

Parameter Estimation Via Single-Photon Detection in A Quantum V-Type Three-Level System

Zhenghao Zhang

We investigate parameter estimation in a Vconfiguration three-level atomic system continuously monitored via photon counting. By unraveling the system's dynamics into individual quantum trajectories, we demonstrate how time-resolved fluorescence records can be processed using maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) to extract key system parameters such as spontaneous decay rates and Rabi frequencies. We analyze the role of waiting-time distributions, likelihood reconstruction, and finite detector efficiencies, showing that trajectory-based MLE achieves the Cramér–Rao bound in the asymptotic limit. Our results highlight the potential of quantum-jump–resolved statistics to enable precision parameter estimation in open quantum systems.

International Conference on Electron Devices and Applications (ICEDA)•Dec 19, 2025•0 citations

Optimal, reliable estimation of quantum states

Robin Blume-Kohout

Accurately inferring the state of a quantum device from the results of measurements is a crucial task in building quantum information processing hardware. The predominant state estimation procedure, maximum likelihood estimation (MLE), generally reports an estimate with zero eigenvalues. These cannot be justified. Furthermore, the MLE estimate is incompatible with error bars, so conclusions drawn from it are suspect. I propose an alternative procedure, Bayesian mean estimation (BME). BME never yields zero eigenvalues, its eigenvalues provide a bound on their own uncertainties, and under certain circumstances it is provably the most accurate procedure possible. I show how to implement BME numerically, and how to obtain natural error bars that are compatible with the estimate. Finally, I briefly discuss the differences between Bayesian and frequentist estimation techniques.

arXiv:quant-ph/0611080•New Journal of Physics•Apr 20, 2010•428 citations

Asymptotic Efficiency and Finite Sample Performance of Frequentist Quantum State Estimation

Raj Chakrabarti, Anisha Ghosh

We undertake a detailed study of the performance of maximum likelihood (ML) estimators of the density matrix of finite-dimensional quantum systems, in order to interrogate generic properties of frequentist quantum state estimation. Existing literature on frequentist quantum estimation has not rigorously examined the finite sample performance of the estimators and associated methods of hypothesis testing. While ML is usually preferred on the basis of its asymptotic properties - it achieves the Cramer-Rao (CR) lower bound - the finite sample properties are often less than optimal. We compare the asymptotic and finite-sample properties of the ML estimators and test statistics for two different choices of measurement bases: the average case optimal or mutually unbiased bases (MUB) and a representative set of suboptimal bases, for spin-1/2 and spin-1 systems. We show that, in both cases, the standard errors of the ML estimators sometimes do not contain the true value of the parameter, which can render inference based on the asymptotic properties of the ML unreliable for experimentally realistic sample sizes. The results indicate that in order to fully exploit the information geometry of quantum states and achieve smaller reconstruction errors, the use of Bayesian state reconstruction methods - which, unlike frequentist methods, do not rely on asymptotic properties - is desirable, since the estimation error is typically lower due to the incorporation of prior knowledge.

arXiv:0904.1628•Apr 10, 2009•3 citations
We consider the problem of estimating a dynamical parameter of a Markovian quantum open system (the atom maser), by performing continuous time measurements in the systemʼs output (outgoing atoms). Two estimation methods are investigated and compared. Firstly, the maximum likelihood estimator (MLE) takes into account the full measurement data and is asymptotically optimal in terms of its mean square error. Secondly, the 'likelihood-free' method of approximate Bayesian computation (ABC) produces an approximation of the posterior distribution for a given set of summary statistics, by sampling trajectories at different parameter values and comparing them with the measurement data via chosen statistics. Building on previous results which showed that atom counts are poor statistics for certain values of the Rabi angle, we apply MLE to the full measurement data and estimate its Fisher information. We then select several correlation statistics such as waiting times, distribution of successive identical detections, and use them as input of the ABC algorithm. The resulting posterior distribution follows closely the data likelihood, showing that the selected statistics capture 'most' statistical information about the Rabi angle.
System identification is closely related to control theory and plays an increasing role in quantum engineering. In the quantum set-up, system identification is usually equated to process tomography, i.e. estimating a channel by probing it repeatedly with different input states. However, for quantum dynamical systems such as quantum Markov processes, it is more natural to consider the estimation based on continuous measurements of the output, with a given input that may be stationary. We address this problem using asymptotic statistics tools, for the specific example of estimating the Rabi frequency of an atom maser. We compute the Fisher information of different measurement processes as well as the quantum Fisher information of the atom maser, and establish the local asymptotic normality of these statistical models. The statistical notions can be expressed in terms of spectral properties of certain deformed Markov generators, and the connection to large deviations is briefly discussed.
The ability to efficiently infer system parameters is essential in any signal-processing task that requires fast operation. In quantum systems, a serious challenge arises due to substantial growth of the underlying Hilbert space with the system size. As the statistics of the measurement data observed—i.e., the —can no longer be easily computed, common approaches such as maximum-likelihood estimators or particle filters become impractical. To address this issue, we propose the use of the approximate Bayesian computation (ABC) algorithm, which evades likelihood computation by sampling from a library of measurement data— prepared for a given quantum device. We apply ABC to interpret photodetection click patterns arising from real-time probing of a two-level atom and an optomechanical system. For the latter, we consider both linear and nonlinear regimes to show how to tailor the ABC algorithm by understanding the quantum measurement statistics. Our work demonstrates that fast parameter inference may be possible regardless of the complexity of the quantum device and the measurement scheme involved.
Abstract We consider the problem of estimating an arbitrary dynamical parameter of an open quantum system in the input–output formalism. For irreducible Markov processes, we show that in the limit of large times the system-output state can be approximated by a quantum Gaussian state whose mean is proportional to the unknown parameter. This approximation holds locally in a neighbourhood of size in the parameter space, and provides an explicit expression of the asymptotic quantum Fisher information in terms of the Markov generator. Furthermore we show that additive statistics of the counting and homodyne measurements also satisfy local asymptotic normality and we compute the corresponding classical Fisher informations. The general theory is illustrated with the examples of a two-level system and the atom maser. Our results contribute towards a better understanding of the statistical and probabilistic properties of the output process, with relevance for quantum control engineering, and the theory of non-equilibrium quantum open systems.
We investigate parameter estimation in a Vconfiguration three-level atomic system continuously monitored via photon counting. By unraveling the system's dynamics into individual quantum trajectories, we demonstrate how time-resolved fluorescence records can be processed using maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) to extract key system parameters such as spontaneous decay rates and Rabi frequencies. We analyze the role of waiting-time distributions, likelihood reconstruction, and finite detector efficiencies, showing that trajectory-based MLE achieves the Cramér–Rao bound in the asymptotic limit. Our results highlight the potential of quantum-jump–resolved statistics to enable precision parameter estimation in open quantum systems.
Accurately inferring the state of a quantum device from the results of measurements is a crucial task in building quantum information processing hardware. The predominant state estimation procedure, maximum likelihood estimation (MLE), generally reports an estimate with zero eigenvalues. These cannot be justified. Furthermore, the MLE estimate is incompatible with error bars, so conclusions drawn from it are suspect. I propose an alternative procedure, Bayesian mean estimation (BME). BME never yields zero eigenvalues, its eigenvalues provide a bound on their own uncertainties, and under certain circumstances it is provably the most accurate procedure possible. I show how to implement BME numerically, and how to obtain natural error bars that are compatible with the estimate. Finally, I briefly discuss the differences between Bayesian and frequentist estimation techniques.
We undertake a detailed study of the performance of maximum likelihood (ML) estimators of the density matrix of finite-dimensional quantum systems, in order to interrogate generic properties of frequentist quantum state estimation. Existing literature on frequentist quantum estimation has not rigorously examined the finite sample performance of the estimators and associated methods of hypothesis testing. While ML is usually preferred on the basis of its asymptotic properties - it achieves the Cramer-Rao (CR) lower bound - the finite sample properties are often less than optimal. We compare the asymptotic and finite-sample properties of the ML estimators and test statistics for two different choices of measurement bases: the average case optimal or mutually unbiased bases (MUB) and a representative set of suboptimal bases, for spin-1/2 and spin-1 systems. We show that, in both cases, the standard errors of the ML estimators sometimes do not contain the true value of the parameter, which can render inference based on the asymptotic properties of the ML unreliable for experimentally realistic sample sizes. The results indicate that in order to fully exploit the information geometry of quantum states and achieve smaller reconstruction errors, the use of Bayesian state reconstruction methods - which, unlike frequentist methods, do not rely on asymptotic properties - is desirable, since the estimation error is typically lower due to the incorporation of prior knowledge.