Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1311.3408

The phenomenon of state reduction

Petr Hájíček

Published Nov 14, 2013• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

A theory of quantum measurement was introduced some time ago that was based on the notion of the so-called separation status. This separation status had a spatial, local character, so that the theory worked only in special cases. Nevertheless, it enabled a description of state reduction process that was specific in where, when and under which objective conditions the process occurs and that preserved the unitary transformation symmetry of quantum mechanics. Now, in an accompanying paper (arxiv:1411.5524), a completely general mathematical definition of the status is given and analyzed. The present paper reformulates the theory of state reduction accordingly. A general mathematical form of the process is postulated and illustrated by examples of Stern-Gerlach experiment and of screening.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1311.3408

Related papers

On the theory of quantum measurement

Petr Hájíček

The notion of state reduction employed by the standard quantum theory of measurement is difficult to accept for two reasons: It leaves open where and when the reduction takes place and it does not give any objective conditions under which the reduction occurs. Some recently published ideas on this problem are developed an improved. The disturbance of measurement due to identical particles in the environment is shown to make any POV measure non-measurable. Truncated POV (TPOV) measures are introduced that can be measurable if object systems satisfy the additional requirement of having separation status. The separation status is generalised from domain of space to domain of phase space. Starting from the previously introduced distinction between ancillas and detectors, further study of experiments suggests that a thermodynamic mixing within a detector and the consequent loss of separation status is the objective condition for the occurrence of the state reduction. The conjecture is simple, specific and testable. The theory is illustrated by a model of a real measurement.

arXiv:1307.0694•Jul 2, 2013•0 citations

On the derivation of wave function reduction from Schrödinger's equation: A model

Roland L. Omnes

The possibility of consistency between the basic quantum principles and reduction (wave function reduction) is reexamined. The mathematical description of an organized macroscopic device is constructed explicitly as a convenient tool for this investigation. A derivation of reduction from quantum mechanics is proposed on a specific example, using standard methods of statistical physics. Although these methods are valid only "for all practical purposes", arguments are given to ascribe an emerging status to reduction (or the uniqueness of physical reality), similar to the status of classical physics. Examination of measurements of the particles in an EPR pair by two space-like separated apparatuses shows that the model is consistent with the non-separable character of quantum mechanics, although both measurements are local. Quantitative estimates are given.

arXiv:1006.3227•Jun 16, 2010•2 citations

Emergence of outcomes in quantum mechanics

Bradley A. Foreman

A persistent focus on the concept of emergence as a core element of the scientific method allows a clean separation, insofar as this is possible, of the physical and philosophical aspects of the problem of outcomes in quantum mechanics. The philosophical part of the problem is to explain why a closed system has definite experimental outcomes. The physical part is to show mathematically that there exists a limit in which the contradiction between unitary Schroedinger dynamics and a reduction process leading to distinct outcomes becomes negligible according to an explicitly stated criterion, and to make this criterion as objective as possible. The physical problem is solved here by redefining the notion of a quantum state and finding a suitable measure for the change of state upon reduction. The appropriate definition of the quantum state is not as a ray or density operator in Hilbert space, but rather as an equivalence class consisting of all density operators in a given subspace, the members of which all describe the same experimental outcome. For systems containing only subsystems that are integrated with their environments, these equivalence classes can be represented mathematically by projection operators, and the resulting formalism is closely related to that used by von Neumann to study the increase of entropy predicted by the second law of thermodynamics. However, nearly isolated subsystems are reduced only indirectly, as a consequence of their interaction with integrated subsystems. The reduced states of isolated subsystems are the same conditional states used in the definition of quantum discord. The key concepts of decoherence theory can all be adapted to fit this definition of a quantum state, resulting in a unified theory capable of resolving, in principle, all aspects of the quantum measurement problem. The theory thus obtained is weakly objective but not strongly objective.

arXiv:1907.03456•Jul 8, 2019•1 citation

Measurement in Quantum Mechanics. II: Reduction of a Wave Packet

Hitoshi Wakita

The theory of measurement is reasonably interpreted without any abrupt and noncausal change of a state, namely, with no “reduction of a wave packet”, in the framework of quantum mechanics. Though a process of measurement is causal in the usual quantum-mechanical sense, it is possible to utilize the concept of the “reduction of a wave packet” without any loss of compatibility. The Stern-Gerlach experiment is put to a careful study to show that the present interpretation is consistent with experiment.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Jan 1, 1962•7 citations

Do we really understand quantum mechanics? Strange correlations, paradoxes, and theorems

Franck Laloë

This article presents a general discussion of several aspects of our present understanding of quantum mechanics. The emphasis is put on the very special correlations that this theory makes possible: They are forbidden by very general arguments based on realism and local causality. In fact, these correlations are completely impossible in any circumstance, except for very special situations designed by physicists especially to observe these purely quantum effects. Another general point that is emphasized is the necessity for the theory to predict the emergence of a single result in a single realization of an experiment. For this purpose, orthodox quantum mechanics introduces a special postulate: the reduction of the state vector, which comes in addition to the Schrödinger evolution postulate. Nevertheless, the presence in parallel of two evolution processes of the same object (the state vector) may be a potential source for conflicts; various attitudes that are possible to avoid this problem are discussed in this text. After a brief historical introduction, recalling how the very special status of the state vector has emerged in quantum mechanics, various conceptual difficulties are introduced and discussed. The Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen (EPR) theorem is presented with the help of a botanical parable, in a way that emphasizes how deeply the EPR reasoning is rooted into what is often called “scientific method.” In another section the Greenberger–Horne–Zeilinger argument, the Hardy impossibilities, as well as the Bell–Kochen–Specker theorem are introduced in simple terms. The final two sections attempt to give a summary of the present situation: One section discusses nonlocality and entanglement as we see it presently, with brief mention of recent experiments; the last section contains a (nonexhaustive) list of various attitudes that are found among physicists, and that are helpful to alleviate the conceptual difficulties of quantum mechanics.

American Journal of Physics•Jun 1, 2001•202 citations

The Measurement Problem Dissolved: Why Definite Outcomes Require No Collapse Postulate

Marcus Schmieke

The quantum measurement problem—why and how the deterministic, unitary evolution of quantum states gives rise to definite, stochastic outcomes—has remained unresolved since the inception of quantum mechanics. This paper proposes that wave function reduction is not a separate physical process requiring its own postulate, but an instance of Level-0 projection within the Quantum Blueprint Formalism (QBF). The QBF Level-0 framework describes the constrained transition from a pre-coherent space M_s of distinction configurations to a coherence manifold M_Θ of macroscopic order parameters, governed by three admissibility conditions: local compatibility (A1), preserved Heisenberg structure (A2), and bounded compression (A3). We demonstrate that quantum state reduction exhibits the same formal structure: it is a constrained projection from Hilbert space (possibility space) to eigenstate space (actuality space), subject to conditions structurally isomorphic to (A1)–(A3).

•Feb 11, 2026•0 citations
A theory of quantum measurement was introduced some time ago that was based on the notion of the so-called separation status. This separation status had a spatial, local character, so that the theory worked only in special cases. Nevertheless, it enabled a description of state reduction process that was specific in where, when and under which objective conditions the process occurs and that preserved the unitary transformation symmetry of quantum mechanics. Now, in an accompanying paper (arxiv:1411.5524), a completely general mathematical definition of the status is given and analyzed. The present paper reformulates the theory of state reduction accordingly. A general mathematical form of the process is postulated and illustrated by examples of Stern-Gerlach experiment and of screening.
The notion of state reduction employed by the standard quantum theory of measurement is difficult to accept for two reasons: It leaves open where and when the reduction takes place and it does not give any objective conditions under which the reduction occurs. Some recently published ideas on this problem are developed an improved. The disturbance of measurement due to identical particles in the environment is shown to make any POV measure non-measurable. Truncated POV (TPOV) measures are introduced that can be measurable if object systems satisfy the additional requirement of having separation status. The separation status is generalised from domain of space to domain of phase space. Starting from the previously introduced distinction between ancillas and detectors, further study of experiments suggests that a thermodynamic mixing within a detector and the consequent loss of separation status is the objective condition for the occurrence of the state reduction. The conjecture is simple, specific and testable. The theory is illustrated by a model of a real measurement.
The possibility of consistency between the basic quantum principles and reduction (wave function reduction) is reexamined. The mathematical description of an organized macroscopic device is constructed explicitly as a convenient tool for this investigation. A derivation of reduction from quantum mechanics is proposed on a specific example, using standard methods of statistical physics. Although these methods are valid only "for all practical purposes", arguments are given to ascribe an emerging status to reduction (or the uniqueness of physical reality), similar to the status of classical physics. Examination of measurements of the particles in an EPR pair by two space-like separated apparatuses shows that the model is consistent with the non-separable character of quantum mechanics, although both measurements are local. Quantitative estimates are given.
A persistent focus on the concept of emergence as a core element of the scientific method allows a clean separation, insofar as this is possible, of the physical and philosophical aspects of the problem of outcomes in quantum mechanics. The philosophical part of the problem is to explain why a closed system has definite experimental outcomes. The physical part is to show mathematically that there exists a limit in which the contradiction between unitary Schroedinger dynamics and a reduction process leading to distinct outcomes becomes negligible according to an explicitly stated criterion, and to make this criterion as objective as possible. The physical problem is solved here by redefining the notion of a quantum state and finding a suitable measure for the change of state upon reduction. The appropriate definition of the quantum state is not as a ray or density operator in Hilbert space, but rather as an equivalence class consisting of all density operators in a given subspace, the members of which all describe the same experimental outcome. For systems containing only subsystems that are integrated with their environments, these equivalence classes can be represented mathematically by projection operators, and the resulting formalism is closely related to that used by von Neumann to study the increase of entropy predicted by the second law of thermodynamics. However, nearly isolated subsystems are reduced only indirectly, as a consequence of their interaction with integrated subsystems. The reduced states of isolated subsystems are the same conditional states used in the definition of quantum discord. The key concepts of decoherence theory can all be adapted to fit this definition of a quantum state, resulting in a unified theory capable of resolving, in principle, all aspects of the quantum measurement problem. The theory thus obtained is weakly objective but not strongly objective.
The theory of measurement is reasonably interpreted without any abrupt and noncausal change of a state, namely, with no “reduction of a wave packet”, in the framework of quantum mechanics. Though a process of measurement is causal in the usual quantum-mechanical sense, it is possible to utilize the concept of the “reduction of a wave packet” without any loss of compatibility. The Stern-Gerlach experiment is put to a careful study to show that the present interpretation is consistent with experiment.
This article presents a general discussion of several aspects of our present understanding of quantum mechanics. The emphasis is put on the very special correlations that this theory makes possible: They are forbidden by very general arguments based on realism and local causality. In fact, these correlations are completely impossible in any circumstance, except for very special situations designed by physicists especially to observe these purely quantum effects. Another general point that is emphasized is the necessity for the theory to predict the emergence of a single result in a single realization of an experiment. For this purpose, orthodox quantum mechanics introduces a special postulate: the reduction of the state vector, which comes in addition to the Schrödinger evolution postulate. Nevertheless, the presence in parallel of two evolution processes of the same object (the state vector) may be a potential source for conflicts; various attitudes that are possible to avoid this problem are discussed in this text. After a brief historical introduction, recalling how the very special status of the state vector has emerged in quantum mechanics, various conceptual difficulties are introduced and discussed. The Einstein–Podolsky–Rosen (EPR) theorem is presented with the help of a botanical parable, in a way that emphasizes how deeply the EPR reasoning is rooted into what is often called “scientific method.” In another section the Greenberger–Horne–Zeilinger argument, the Hardy impossibilities, as well as the Bell–Kochen–Specker theorem are introduced in simple terms. The final two sections attempt to give a summary of the present situation: One section discusses nonlocality and entanglement as we see it presently, with brief mention of recent experiments; the last section contains a (nonexhaustive) list of various attitudes that are found among physicists, and that are helpful to alleviate the conceptual difficulties of quantum mechanics.
The quantum measurement problem—why and how the deterministic, unitary evolution of quantum states gives rise to definite, stochastic outcomes—has remained unresolved since the inception of quantum mechanics. This paper proposes that wave function reduction is not a separate physical process requiring its own postulate, but an instance of Level-0 projection within the Quantum Blueprint Formalism (QBF). The QBF Level-0 framework describes the constrained transition from a pre-coherent space M_s of distinction configurations to a coherence manifold M_Θ of macroscopic order parameters, governed by three admissibility conditions: local compatibility (A1), preserved Heisenberg structure (A2), and bounded compression (A3). We demonstrate that quantum state reduction exhibits the same formal structure: it is a constrained projection from Hilbert space (possibility space) to eigenstate space (actuality space), subject to conditions structurally isomorphic to (A1)–(A3).