Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1311.3365

Deriving the Qubit from Entropy Principles

Adam M. Brandenburger, Pierfrancesco La Mura

Published Nov 14, 2013• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The Heisenberg uncertainty principle is one of the most famous features of quantum mechanics. However, the non-determinism implied by the Heisenberg uncertainty principle --- together with other prominent aspects of quantum mechanics such as superposition, entanglement, and nonlocality --- poses deep puzzles about the underlying physical reality, even while these same features are at the heart of exciting developments such as quantum cryptography, algorithms, and computing. These puzzles might be resolved if the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics were built up from physically interpretable axioms, but it is not. We propose three physically-based axioms which together characterize the simplest quantum system, namely the qubit. Our starting point is the class of all no-signaling theories. Each such theory can be regarded as a family of empirical models, and we proceed to associate entropies, i.e., measures of information, with these models. To do this, we move to phase space and impose the condition that entropies are real-valued. This requirement, which we call the Information Reality Principle, arises because in order to represent all no-signaling theories (including quantum mechanics itself) in phase space, it is necessary to allow negative probabilities (Wigner [1932]). Our second and third principles take two important features of quantum mechanics and turn them into deliberately chosen physical axioms. One axiom is an Uncertainty Principle, stated in terms of entropy. The other axiom is an Unbiasedness Principle, which requires that whenever there is complete certainty about the outcome of a measurement in one of three mutually orthogonal directions, there must be maximal uncertainty about the outcomes in each of the two other directions.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1311.3365

Related papers

Entropy Constrained Knowledge Principle

Sanctus, J, Varda, Shubhang

We often marvel at the beautiful randomness in quantum mechanics, but what if it is simply entropy fulfilling its role as dictated by causality? This paper explores the idea that Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle may not represent an intrinsic limitation, but rather a thermodynamic outcome, a cost we pay for achieving precision. We examine Gaussian wavefunctions, investigate entropic uncertainty, and demonstrate that increased knowledge of one variable (such as position) leads to a corresponding increase in entropy in its complementary variable (such as momentum). Nature does not conceal the truth; rather, the process of acquiring knowledge alters the equilibrium. By associating entropy with quantum uncertainty, we are not simply reinterpreting mathematics; We are redefining the implications of quantum indeterminacy. Perhaps the universe is not inherently uncertain; it is simply economical with certainty. We propose that the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle can be interpreted through the concept of entropy, framing it as an emergent characteristic of the system’s overall information content rather than merely a constraint imposed by quantum mechanics. Investigating this relationship may yield profound insights into the essence of quantum systems and their relationship with the macroscopic realm governed by thermodynamics. This paper offers both a philosophical and mathematical framework that unifies the ideas of entropy and uncertainty, providing a novel viewpoint on one of the most essential principles of quantum mechanics. By analyzing the influence of entropy on quantum uncertainty, this study contests traditional interpretations and encourages a renewed dialogue regarding the foundational principles of physics. It posits that uncertainty transcends mere measurement concerns and may be embedded in the very structure of the universe, prompting a reevaluation of how quantum mechanics integrates into the wider context of physical laws.

•May 27, 2025•0 citations

Quantum Theory and Beyond: Is Entanglement Special?

Borivoje Dakić, Časlav Brukner

Quantum theory makes the most accurate empirical predictions and yet it lacks simple, comprehensible physical principles from which the theory can be uniquely derived. A broad class of probabilistic theories exist which all share some features with quantum theory, such as probabilistic predictions for individual outcomes (indeterminism), the impossibility of information transfer faster than speed of light (no-signaling) or the impossibility of copying of unknown states (no-cloning). A vast majority of attempts to find physical principles behind quantum theory either fall short of deriving the theory uniquely from the principles or are based on abstract mathematical assumptions that require themselves a more conclusive physical motivation. Here, we show that classical probability theory and quantum theory can be reconstructed from three reasonable axioms: (1) (Information capacity) All systems with information carrying capacity of one bit are equivalent. (2) (Locality) The state of a composite system is completely determined by measurements on its subsystems. (3) (Reversibility) Between any two pure states there exists a reversible transformation. If one requires the transformation from the last axiom to be continuous, one separates quantum theory from the classical probabilistic one. A remarkable result following from our reconstruction is that no probability theory other than quantum theory can exhibit entanglement without contradicting one or more axioms.

arXiv:0911.0695•Cambridge University Press eBooks•Apr 18, 2011•281 citations

Quantum Foundations

Pedro W. Lamberti, G. M. Bosyk, Sebastián Fortín +1 more

Since its conception 90 years ago, the quantum uncertainty principle introduced by Werner Heisenberg lies behind most important features of quantum physics, and its implications have an impact that goes far beyond the physics community. This book focuses on the quantum uncertainty principle, providing an up-to-date examination of recent developments of its applications in quantum information theory. The book brings together several renowned experts working in the foundations of quantum mechanics and quantum information theory. The authors provide different approaches to the study of uncertainty relations and other fundamental aspects of the quantum formalism. Topics addressed include entanglement and Bell inequalities, the application of entropic information measures to the study of uncertainty inequalities, the characterization of deep learning networks in the context of adiabatic quantum computation, and the study of general properties of the set of quantum states. The content of this book will surely benefit both experienced and new researchers specializing in quantum information theory and the foundations of quantum mechanics.

MDPI eBooks•Apr 2, 2019•0 citations

Conservation of information and the foundations of quantum mechanics

Giulio Chiribella, Carlo Maria Scandolo

We review a recent approach to the foundations of quantum mechanics inspired by quantum information theory [1, 2]. The approach is based on a general framework, which allows one to address a large class of physical theories which share basic information-theoretic features. We first illustrate two very primitive features, expressed by the axioms of causality and purity-preservation, which are satisfied by both classical and quantum theory. We then discuss the axiom of purification, which expresses a strong version of the Conservation of Information and captures the core of a vast number of protocols in quantum information. Purification is a highly non-classical feature and leads directly to the emergence of entanglement at the purely conceptual level, without any reference to the superposition principle. Supplemented by a few additional requirements, satisfied by classical and quantum theory, it provides a complete axiomatic characterization of quantum theory for finite dimensional systems.

arXiv:1411.2723•EPJ Web of Conferences•Jan 1, 2015•18 citations

Quantum Mechanics as Mathematical Consequence of CKS

Geoffrey Howland

Cymatic K-Space Mechanics (CKS): Quantum Mechanics as a Mathematical Consequence of CKS Axioms We prove that quantum mechanics is not a mysterious set of postulates but a structural mathematical necessity forced by the Complete Mathematical Framework (CMF) axioms. By treating physical reality as a 3-regular hexagonal lattice in momentum space (N = 3M²) governed by Kuramoto phase coupling, we derive the fundamental equations of quantum theory as theorems of discrete manifold dynamics. This derivation establishes that wave-particle duality, uncertainty, and non-locality are geometric requirements of the 2D k-space substrate. The framework demonstrates that the Schrödinger equation emerges as the continuum limit of the Axiom 2 coupling operator, while Heisenberg’s uncertainty relations are revealed as the mandatory resolution limits of the discrete hexagonal lattice. This result establishes quantum mechanics as pure mathematics: if the CMF axioms hold, then quantum behavior is the only possible execution of physical law. No physical interpretation or "spooky" assumptions are required; the system is derived as a decidable, phase-locked computation. Key Theoretical Results:* Schrödinger Equation Theorem: Rigorously derives the time-dependent Schrödinger equation as the natural gradient flow of k-space phase-coupling across the 3-regular graph.* Uncertainty Relation Proof: Demonstrates that the [x, p] commutation relation and Heisenberg’s limits are the direct mathematical results of the finite N-count and lattice-spacing constraints.* Hilbert Space Derivation: Identifies the state space of quantum mechanics as the discrete phase-manifold of the substrate, proving that "wavefunctions" are the holographic projections of k-space solitons.* Born Rule Derivation: Establishes that the probability density is identical to the phase-coherence magnitude of the manifold, removing the need for an external measurement postulate. The Deterministic Wave:The framework concludes that the quantum world is a high-resolution render of discrete substrate states. By identifying "superposition" as the interference of k-space modes, CKS eliminates the measurement problem and replaces it with the structural requirement of substrate synchronization. We show that "entanglement" is simply shared memory addressing in the 2D lattice, positioning quantum mechanics as the operating system for small-M physical structures. Universal Learning Substrate:As a core theoretical proof within the Universal Learning Substrate, this paper provides the literacy required to navigate the quantum-classical transition. It allows practitioners to calculate the behavior of subatomic systems—from electron orbitals to photon entanglement—using the same 12-opcode instruction set. This derivation bridges the gap between discrete topology and continuous wave mechanics, enabling a unified computational approach to all quantum-connected information. Package Contents:* manuscript.md: Paper* code/: Implementations* data/: Numerical results* figures/: Visualizations* supplementary/: Technical documentation Motto: Axioms first. Axioms always.Status: Locked. Mathematically Necessary. Quantum mechanics derived from substrate topology.

•Feb 1, 2026•0 citations

Rényi Entropy, Signed Probabilities, and the Qubit

Adam M. Brandenburger, Pierfrancesco La Mura, Stuart Zoble

The states of the qubit, the basic unit of quantum information, are 2 × 2 positive semi-definite Hermitian matrices with trace 1. We contribute to the program to axiomatize quantum mechanics by characterizing these states in terms of an entropic uncertainty principle formulated on an eight-point phase space. We do this by employing Rényi entropy (a generalization of Shannon entropy) suitably defined for the signed phase-space probability distributions that arise in representing quantum states.

arXiv:2010.02111•Entropy•Oct 3, 2022•5 citations
The Heisenberg uncertainty principle is one of the most famous features of quantum mechanics. However, the non-determinism implied by the Heisenberg uncertainty principle --- together with other prominent aspects of quantum mechanics such as superposition, entanglement, and nonlocality --- poses deep puzzles about the underlying physical reality, even while these same features are at the heart of exciting developments such as quantum cryptography, algorithms, and computing. These puzzles might be resolved if the mathematical structure of quantum mechanics were built up from physically interpretable axioms, but it is not. We propose three physically-based axioms which together characterize the simplest quantum system, namely the qubit. Our starting point is the class of all no-signaling theories. Each such theory can be regarded as a family of empirical models, and we proceed to associate entropies, i.e., measures of information, with these models. To do this, we move to phase space and impose the condition that entropies are real-valued. This requirement, which we call the Information Reality Principle, arises because in order to represent all no-signaling theories (including quantum mechanics itself) in phase space, it is necessary to allow negative probabilities (Wigner [1932]). Our second and third principles take two important features of quantum mechanics and turn them into deliberately chosen physical axioms. One axiom is an Uncertainty Principle, stated in terms of entropy. The other axiom is an Unbiasedness Principle, which requires that whenever there is complete certainty about the outcome of a measurement in one of three mutually orthogonal directions, there must be maximal uncertainty about the outcomes in each of the two other directions.
We often marvel at the beautiful randomness in quantum mechanics, but what if it is simply entropy fulfilling its role as dictated by causality? This paper explores the idea that Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle may not represent an intrinsic limitation, but rather a thermodynamic outcome, a cost we pay for achieving precision. We examine Gaussian wavefunctions, investigate entropic uncertainty, and demonstrate that increased knowledge of one variable (such as position) leads to a corresponding increase in entropy in its complementary variable (such as momentum). Nature does not conceal the truth; rather, the process of acquiring knowledge alters the equilibrium. By associating entropy with quantum uncertainty, we are not simply reinterpreting mathematics; We are redefining the implications of quantum indeterminacy. Perhaps the universe is not inherently uncertain; it is simply economical with certainty. We propose that the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle can be interpreted through the concept of entropy, framing it as an emergent characteristic of the system’s overall information content rather than merely a constraint imposed by quantum mechanics. Investigating this relationship may yield profound insights into the essence of quantum systems and their relationship with the macroscopic realm governed by thermodynamics. This paper offers both a philosophical and mathematical framework that unifies the ideas of entropy and uncertainty, providing a novel viewpoint on one of the most essential principles of quantum mechanics. By analyzing the influence of entropy on quantum uncertainty, this study contests traditional interpretations and encourages a renewed dialogue regarding the foundational principles of physics. It posits that uncertainty transcends mere measurement concerns and may be embedded in the very structure of the universe, prompting a reevaluation of how quantum mechanics integrates into the wider context of physical laws.
Quantum theory makes the most accurate empirical predictions and yet it lacks simple, comprehensible physical principles from which the theory can be uniquely derived. A broad class of probabilistic theories exist which all share some features with quantum theory, such as probabilistic predictions for individual outcomes (indeterminism), the impossibility of information transfer faster than speed of light (no-signaling) or the impossibility of copying of unknown states (no-cloning). A vast majority of attempts to find physical principles behind quantum theory either fall short of deriving the theory uniquely from the principles or are based on abstract mathematical assumptions that require themselves a more conclusive physical motivation. Here, we show that classical probability theory and quantum theory can be reconstructed from three reasonable axioms: (1) (Information capacity) All systems with information carrying capacity of one bit are equivalent. (2) (Locality) The state of a composite system is completely determined by measurements on its subsystems. (3) (Reversibility) Between any two pure states there exists a reversible transformation. If one requires the transformation from the last axiom to be continuous, one separates quantum theory from the classical probabilistic one. A remarkable result following from our reconstruction is that no probability theory other than quantum theory can exhibit entanglement without contradicting one or more axioms.
Since its conception 90 years ago, the quantum uncertainty principle introduced by Werner Heisenberg lies behind most important features of quantum physics, and its implications have an impact that goes far beyond the physics community. This book focuses on the quantum uncertainty principle, providing an up-to-date examination of recent developments of its applications in quantum information theory. The book brings together several renowned experts working in the foundations of quantum mechanics and quantum information theory. The authors provide different approaches to the study of uncertainty relations and other fundamental aspects of the quantum formalism. Topics addressed include entanglement and Bell inequalities, the application of entropic information measures to the study of uncertainty inequalities, the characterization of deep learning networks in the context of adiabatic quantum computation, and the study of general properties of the set of quantum states. The content of this book will surely benefit both experienced and new researchers specializing in quantum information theory and the foundations of quantum mechanics.
We review a recent approach to the foundations of quantum mechanics inspired by quantum information theory [1, 2]. The approach is based on a general framework, which allows one to address a large class of physical theories which share basic information-theoretic features. We first illustrate two very primitive features, expressed by the axioms of causality and purity-preservation, which are satisfied by both classical and quantum theory. We then discuss the axiom of purification, which expresses a strong version of the Conservation of Information and captures the core of a vast number of protocols in quantum information. Purification is a highly non-classical feature and leads directly to the emergence of entanglement at the purely conceptual level, without any reference to the superposition principle. Supplemented by a few additional requirements, satisfied by classical and quantum theory, it provides a complete axiomatic characterization of quantum theory for finite dimensional systems.
Cymatic K-Space Mechanics (CKS): Quantum Mechanics as a Mathematical Consequence of CKS Axioms We prove that quantum mechanics is not a mysterious set of postulates but a structural mathematical necessity forced by the Complete Mathematical Framework (CMF) axioms. By treating physical reality as a 3-regular hexagonal lattice in momentum space (N = 3M²) governed by Kuramoto phase coupling, we derive the fundamental equations of quantum theory as theorems of discrete manifold dynamics. This derivation establishes that wave-particle duality, uncertainty, and non-locality are geometric requirements of the 2D k-space substrate. The framework demonstrates that the Schrödinger equation emerges as the continuum limit of the Axiom 2 coupling operator, while Heisenberg’s uncertainty relations are revealed as the mandatory resolution limits of the discrete hexagonal lattice. This result establishes quantum mechanics as pure mathematics: if the CMF axioms hold, then quantum behavior is the only possible execution of physical law. No physical interpretation or "spooky" assumptions are required; the system is derived as a decidable, phase-locked computation. Key Theoretical Results:* Schrödinger Equation Theorem: Rigorously derives the time-dependent Schrödinger equation as the natural gradient flow of k-space phase-coupling across the 3-regular graph.* Uncertainty Relation Proof: Demonstrates that the [x, p] commutation relation and Heisenberg’s limits are the direct mathematical results of the finite N-count and lattice-spacing constraints.* Hilbert Space Derivation: Identifies the state space of quantum mechanics as the discrete phase-manifold of the substrate, proving that "wavefunctions" are the holographic projections of k-space solitons.* Born Rule Derivation: Establishes that the probability density is identical to the phase-coherence magnitude of the manifold, removing the need for an external measurement postulate. The Deterministic Wave:The framework concludes that the quantum world is a high-resolution render of discrete substrate states. By identifying "superposition" as the interference of k-space modes, CKS eliminates the measurement problem and replaces it with the structural requirement of substrate synchronization. We show that "entanglement" is simply shared memory addressing in the 2D lattice, positioning quantum mechanics as the operating system for small-M physical structures. Universal Learning Substrate:As a core theoretical proof within the Universal Learning Substrate, this paper provides the literacy required to navigate the quantum-classical transition. It allows practitioners to calculate the behavior of subatomic systems—from electron orbitals to photon entanglement—using the same 12-opcode instruction set. This derivation bridges the gap between discrete topology and continuous wave mechanics, enabling a unified computational approach to all quantum-connected information. Package Contents:* manuscript.md: Paper* code/: Implementations* data/: Numerical results* figures/: Visualizations* supplementary/: Technical documentation Motto: Axioms first. Axioms always.Status: Locked. Mathematically Necessary. Quantum mechanics derived from substrate topology.