Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1310.6918

Discontinuities of energy derivatives in spin-density functional theory

Ali Malek, Robert Balawender

Published Oct 25, 2013• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Standard approximations for the exchange-correlation functional are known to deviate from linear dependence of the energy on the electron and spin numbers (in -space). Violation of this flat-plane condition underlies the failure of all known approximate functionals to describe band gaps in strongly correlated systems. Then crucial for further development of functionals is recognition of the behavior of the energy as a function of, and its derivatives (derivatives discontinuity pattern at 0K limit). In this Letter, the energy derivatives are analyzed thoroughly. It is shown that apart from the well-known type of discontinuity pattern, three other patterns are possible in the vicinity of the singlet state point. The zero temperature limits of energy derivatives at this point are derived, found different for various directions. Existence of all discontinuity patterns is illustrated on the example of diatomic molecules set.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1310.6918

Related papers

Discontinuous Nature of the Exchange-Correlation Functional in Strongly Correlated Systems

Paula Mori‐Sánchez, Aron J. Cohen, Weitao Yang

Standard approximations for the exchange-correlation functional have been found to give big errors for the linearity condition of fractional charges, leading to delocalization error, and the constancy condition of fractional spins, leading to static correlation error. These two conditions are now unified and extended to states with both fractional charge and fractional spin to give a much more stringent condition: the exact energy functional is a plane, linear along the fractional charge coordinate and constant along the fractional spin coordinate with a line of discontinuity at the integer. Violation of this condition underlies the failure of all known approximate functionals to describe the gaps in strongly correlated systems. It is shown that explicitly discontinuous functionals of the density or orbitals that go beyond these currently used smooth approximations is the key for the application of density functional theory to strongly correlated systems.

arXiv:0809.5108•Physical Review Letters•Feb 13, 2009•251 citations

Spin gaps and spin-flip energies in density-functional theory

Klaus Capelle, Giovanni Vignale, Carsten A. Ullrich

Energy gaps are crucial aspects of the electronic structure of finite and extended systems. Whereas much is known about how to define and calculate charge gaps in density-functional theory (DFT), and about the relation between these gaps and derivative discontinuities of the exchange-correlation functional, much less is known about spin gaps. In this paper we give density-functional definitions of spin-conserving gaps, spin-flip gaps and the spin stiffness in terms of many-body energies and in terms of single-particle (Kohn-Sham) energies. Our definitions are as analogous as possible to those commonly made in the charge case, but important differences between spin and charge gaps emerge already on the single-particle level because unlike the fundamental charge gap spin gaps involve excited-state energies. Kohn-Sham and many-body spin gaps are predicted to differ, and the difference is related to derivative discontinuities that are similar to, but distinct from, those usually considered in the case of charge gaps. Both ensemble DFT and time-dependent DFT (TDDFT) can be used to calculate these spin discontinuities from a suitable functional. We illustrate our findings by evaluating our definitions for the Lithium atom, for which we calculate spin gaps and spin discontinuities by making use of near-exact Kohn-Sham eigenvalues and, independently, from the single-pole approximation to TDDFT. The many-body corrections to the Kohn-Sham spin gaps are found to be negative, i.e., single-particle calculations tend to overestimate spin gaps while they underestimate charge gaps.

arXiv:0911.1712•Physical Review B•Mar 16, 2010•46 citations

Derivative Discontinuity in the Strong-Interaction Limit of Density-Functional Theory

André Mirtschink, Michael Seidl, Paola Gori‐Giorgi

We generalize the exact strong-interaction limit of the exchange-correlation energy of Kohn-Sham density functional theory to open systems with fluctuating particle numbers. When used in the self-consistent Kohn-Sham procedure on strongly interacting systems, this functional yields exact features crucial for important applications such as quantum transport. In particular, the steplike structure of the highest-occupied Kohn-Sham eigenvalue is very well captured, with accurate quantitative agreement with exact many-body chemical potentials. While it can be shown that a sharp derivative discontinuity is present only in the infinitely strongly correlated limit, at finite correlation regimes we observe a slightly smoothened discontinuity, with qualitative and quantitative features that improve with increasing correlation. From the fundamental point of view, our results obtain the derivative discontinuity without making the assumptions used in its standard derivation, offering independent support for its existence.

arXiv:1305.3982•Physical Review Letters•Sep 18, 2013•40 citations

Thermodynamic extension of density-functional theory. III. Zero-temperature limit of the ensemble spin-density functional theory

Robert Balawender

In this work, the zero-temperature limit of the thermodynamic spin-density functional theory is investigated. The coarse-grained approach to the equilibrium density operator is used to describe the equilibrium state. The characteristic functions of a macrostate are introduced and their zero-temperature limits are investigated. A detailed discussion of the spin-grand-canonical ensemble in the entropy and energy representations is performed. The maps between the state function variables at 0K limit are rigorously studied for both representations. In the spin-canonical ensemble, the energy surface and the discontinuity pattern are investigated. Finally, based on the maps between the state function variables at 0K limit, the Hohenberg-Kohn theorem for the systems with non-integer electron and spin numbers at zero-temperature limit is formulated.

arXiv:1212.1367•Dec 6, 2012•9 citations

Density-functional derivative discontinuities at the maximum number of bound electrons

Daniel Whitenack, Yu Zhang, Adam Wasserman

For every electronic many-body Hamiltonian with a one-body potential that goes to zero at infinity, there is a maximum number of bound electrons (${J}_{\mathrm{max}}$) that can be sustained in the system with an infinite lifetime. At this integer ${J}_{\mathrm{max}}$, the derivative discontinuity in the exact energy of ensemble density functional theory (DFT) is ill defined. However, we investigate the derivative discontinuity of the energy within the framework of density functional resonance theory [D. L. Whitenack and A. Wasserman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 163002 (2011)], which reduces to ground-state DFT as a coordinate scaling parameter is taken to zero, and find that the exact exchange-correlation potential experiences discontinuous jumps at integer particle numbers, including ${J}_{\mathrm{max}}$. For integers below ${J}_{\mathrm{max}}$ the jump is purely real because of the real shift in the chemical potential. At ${J}_{\mathrm{max}}$, the jump has a nonzero imaginary component reflecting the metastability of the system upon addition of one more electron. In addition, the magnitude of the derivative discontinuity at ${J}_{\mathrm{max}}$ is larger than would have been expected by simply setting the affinity to zero.

arXiv:1111.1934•Physical Review A•Apr 5, 2012•4 citations

Functional derivative of the universal density functional in Fock space

Federico E. Zahariev, Yan Alexander Wang

Within the framework of zero-temperature Fock-space density-functional theory (DFT), we prove that the G\^ateaux functional derivative of the universal density functional, ${\ensuremath{\delta}{F}^{\ensuremath{\lambda}}[\ensuremath{\rho}]∕\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremath{\rho}(\mathbit{r})\ensuremath{\mid}}_{\ensuremath{\rho}={\ensuremath{\rho}}_{0}}$, at ground-state densities with arbitrary normalizations $(⟨{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{0}(\mathbit{r})⟩=n∊{\mathcal{R}}_{+})$ and an electron-electron interaction strength $\ensuremath{\lambda}$, is uniquely defined, but is discontinuous when the number of electrons $n$ becomes an integer, thus providing a mathematically rigorous confirmation for the ``derivative discontinuity'' initially discovered by Perdew et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 49, 1691 (1982)]. However, the functional derivative of the exchange-correlation functional is continuous with respect to the number of electrons in Fock space; i.e., there is no ``derivative discontinuity'' for the exchange-correlation functional at an integer electron number. For a ground-state density ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{0,n}^{v,\ensuremath{\lambda}}(\mathbit{r})$ of an external potential $v(\mathbit{r})$, we show that ${\ensuremath{\delta}{F}^{\ensuremath{\lambda}}[\ensuremath{\rho}]∕\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremath{\rho}(\mathbit{r})\ensuremath{\mid}}_{\ensuremath{\rho}={\ensuremath{\rho}}_{0,n}^{v,\ensuremath{\lambda}}}={\ensuremath{\mu}}_{\mathrm{SM}}^{n}\ensuremath{-}v(\mathbit{r})$, where the constant ${\ensuremath{\mu}}_{\mathrm{SM}}^{n}$ is given by the following chain of dependences: ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{0,n}^{v,\ensuremath{\lambda}}(\mathbit{r})\ensuremath{\mapsto}[v]\ensuremath{\mapsto}{E}_{0}^{v,\ensuremath{\lambda}}(n)\ensuremath{\mapsto}{\ensuremath{\mu}}_{\mathrm{SM}}^{n}={\ensuremath{\partial}{E}_{0}^{v,\ensuremath{\lambda}}(k)∕\ensuremath{\partial}k\ensuremath{\mid}}_{k=n}$. Here $[v]$ is the class of the external potential $v(\mathbit{r})$ up to a real constant, and ${\ensuremath{\mu}}_{\mathrm{SM}}^{n}$ is the chemical potential defined according to statistical mechanics. At an integer electron number $N$, we find that there is no freedom of adding an arbitrary constant to the value of the chemical potential ${\ensuremath{\mu}}_{\mathrm{SM}}^{N}$, whose exact value is generally not the popular preference of the negative of Mulliken's electronegativity, $\ensuremath{-}\frac{1}{2}(I+A)$, where $I$ and $A$ are the first ionization potential and the first electron affinity, respectively. In addition, for any external potential converging to the same constant at infinity in all directions, we resolve that ${\ensuremath{\mu}}_{\mathrm{SM}}^{N}=\ensuremath{-}I$. Finally, the equality ${\ensuremath{\mu}}_{\mathrm{DFT}}={\ensuremath{\mu}}_{\mathrm{SM}}^{n}$ is rigorously derived via an alternative route, where ${\ensuremath{\mu}}_{\mathrm{DFT}}$ is the Lagrangian multiplier used to constrain the normalization of the density in the traditional DFT approach.

Physical Review A•Oct 18, 2004•28 citations
Standard approximations for the exchange-correlation functional are known to deviate from linear dependence of the energy on the electron and spin numbers (in -space). Violation of this flat-plane condition underlies the failure of all known approximate functionals to describe band gaps in strongly correlated systems. Then crucial for further development of functionals is recognition of the behavior of the energy as a function of, and its derivatives (derivatives discontinuity pattern at 0K limit). In this Letter, the energy derivatives are analyzed thoroughly. It is shown that apart from the well-known type of discontinuity pattern, three other patterns are possible in the vicinity of the singlet state point. The zero temperature limits of energy derivatives at this point are derived, found different for various directions. Existence of all discontinuity patterns is illustrated on the example of diatomic molecules set.
Standard approximations for the exchange-correlation functional have been found to give big errors for the linearity condition of fractional charges, leading to delocalization error, and the constancy condition of fractional spins, leading to static correlation error. These two conditions are now unified and extended to states with both fractional charge and fractional spin to give a much more stringent condition: the exact energy functional is a plane, linear along the fractional charge coordinate and constant along the fractional spin coordinate with a line of discontinuity at the integer. Violation of this condition underlies the failure of all known approximate functionals to describe the gaps in strongly correlated systems. It is shown that explicitly discontinuous functionals of the density or orbitals that go beyond these currently used smooth approximations is the key for the application of density functional theory to strongly correlated systems.
Energy gaps are crucial aspects of the electronic structure of finite and extended systems. Whereas much is known about how to define and calculate charge gaps in density-functional theory (DFT), and about the relation between these gaps and derivative discontinuities of the exchange-correlation functional, much less is known about spin gaps. In this paper we give density-functional definitions of spin-conserving gaps, spin-flip gaps and the spin stiffness in terms of many-body energies and in terms of single-particle (Kohn-Sham) energies. Our definitions are as analogous as possible to those commonly made in the charge case, but important differences between spin and charge gaps emerge already on the single-particle level because unlike the fundamental charge gap spin gaps involve excited-state energies. Kohn-Sham and many-body spin gaps are predicted to differ, and the difference is related to derivative discontinuities that are similar to, but distinct from, those usually considered in the case of charge gaps. Both ensemble DFT and time-dependent DFT (TDDFT) can be used to calculate these spin discontinuities from a suitable functional. We illustrate our findings by evaluating our definitions for the Lithium atom, for which we calculate spin gaps and spin discontinuities by making use of near-exact Kohn-Sham eigenvalues and, independently, from the single-pole approximation to TDDFT. The many-body corrections to the Kohn-Sham spin gaps are found to be negative, i.e., single-particle calculations tend to overestimate spin gaps while they underestimate charge gaps.
We generalize the exact strong-interaction limit of the exchange-correlation energy of Kohn-Sham density functional theory to open systems with fluctuating particle numbers. When used in the self-consistent Kohn-Sham procedure on strongly interacting systems, this functional yields exact features crucial for important applications such as quantum transport. In particular, the steplike structure of the highest-occupied Kohn-Sham eigenvalue is very well captured, with accurate quantitative agreement with exact many-body chemical potentials. While it can be shown that a sharp derivative discontinuity is present only in the infinitely strongly correlated limit, at finite correlation regimes we observe a slightly smoothened discontinuity, with qualitative and quantitative features that improve with increasing correlation. From the fundamental point of view, our results obtain the derivative discontinuity without making the assumptions used in its standard derivation, offering independent support for its existence.
In this work, the zero-temperature limit of the thermodynamic spin-density functional theory is investigated. The coarse-grained approach to the equilibrium density operator is used to describe the equilibrium state. The characteristic functions of a macrostate are introduced and their zero-temperature limits are investigated. A detailed discussion of the spin-grand-canonical ensemble in the entropy and energy representations is performed. The maps between the state function variables at 0K limit are rigorously studied for both representations. In the spin-canonical ensemble, the energy surface and the discontinuity pattern are investigated. Finally, based on the maps between the state function variables at 0K limit, the Hohenberg-Kohn theorem for the systems with non-integer electron and spin numbers at zero-temperature limit is formulated.
For every electronic many-body Hamiltonian with a one-body potential that goes to zero at infinity, there is a maximum number of bound electrons (Jmax{J}_{\mathrm{max}}Jmax​) that can be sustained in the system with an infinite lifetime. At this integer Jmax{J}_{\mathrm{max}}Jmax​, the derivative discontinuity in the exact energy of ensemble density functional theory (DFT) is ill defined. However, we investigate the derivative discontinuity of the energy within the framework of density functional resonance theory [D. L. Whitenack and A. Wasserman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 163002 (2011)], which reduces to ground-state DFT as a coordinate scaling parameter is taken to zero, and find that the exact exchange-correlation potential experiences discontinuous jumps at integer particle numbers, including Jmax{J}_{\mathrm{max}}Jmax​. For integers below Jmax{J}_{\mathrm{max}}Jmax​ the jump is purely real because of the real shift in the chemical potential. At Jmax{J}_{\mathrm{max}}Jmax​, the jump has a nonzero imaginary component reflecting the metastability of the system upon addition of one more electron. In addition, the magnitude of the derivative discontinuity at Jmax{J}_{\mathrm{max}}Jmax​ is larger than would have been expected by simply setting the affinity to zero.
Within the framework of zero-temperature Fock-space density-functional theory (DFT), we prove that the G\^ateaux functional derivative of the universal density functional, ${\ensuremath{\delta}{F}^{\ensuremath{\lambda}}[\ensuremath{\rho}]∕\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremath{\rho}(\mathbit{r})\ensuremath{\mid}}_{\ensuremath{\rho}={\ensuremath{\rho}}_{0}}$, at ground-state densities with arbitrary normalizations $(⟨{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{0}(\mathbit{r})⟩=n∊{\mathcal{R}}_{+})$ and an electron-electron interaction strength $\ensuremath{\lambda}$, is uniquely defined, but is discontinuous when the number of electrons nnn becomes an integer, thus providing a mathematically rigorous confirmation for the ``derivative discontinuity'' initially discovered by Perdew et al. [Phys. Rev. Lett. 49, 1691 (1982)]. However, the functional derivative of the exchange-correlation functional is continuous with respect to the number of electrons in Fock space; i.e., there is no ``derivative discontinuity'' for the exchange-correlation functional at an integer electron number. For a ground-state density ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{0,n}^{v,\ensuremath{\lambda}}(\mathbit{r})$ of an external potential $v(\mathbit{r})$, we show that ${\ensuremath{\delta}{F}^{\ensuremath{\lambda}}[\ensuremath{\rho}]∕\ensuremath{\delta}\ensuremath{\rho}(\mathbit{r})\ensuremath{\mid}}_{\ensuremath{\rho}={\ensuremath{\rho}}_{0,n}^{v,\ensuremath{\lambda}}}={\ensuremath{\mu}}_{\mathrm{SM}}^{n}\ensuremath{-}v(\mathbit{r})$, where the constant ${\ensuremath{\mu}}_{\mathrm{SM}}^{n}$ is given by the following chain of dependences: ${\ensuremath{\rho}}_{0,n}^{v,\ensuremath{\lambda}}(\mathbit{r})\ensuremath{\mapsto}[v]\ensuremath{\mapsto}{E}_{0}^{v,\ensuremath{\lambda}}(n)\ensuremath{\mapsto}{\ensuremath{\mu}}_{\mathrm{SM}}^{n}={\ensuremath{\partial}{E}_{0}^{v,\ensuremath{\lambda}}(k)∕\ensuremath{\partial}k\ensuremath{\mid}}_{k=n}$. Here [v][v][v] is the class of the external potential $v(\mathbit{r})$ up to a real constant, and ${\ensuremath{\mu}}_{\mathrm{SM}}^{n}$ is the chemical potential defined according to statistical mechanics. At an integer electron number NNN, we find that there is no freedom of adding an arbitrary constant to the value of the chemical potential ${\ensuremath{\mu}}_{\mathrm{SM}}^{N}$, whose exact value is generally not the popular preference of the negative of Mulliken's electronegativity, $\ensuremath{-}\frac{1}{2}(I+A)$, where III and AAA are the first ionization potential and the first electron affinity, respectively. In addition, for any external potential converging to the same constant at infinity in all directions, we resolve that ${\ensuremath{\mu}}_{\mathrm{SM}}^{N}=\ensuremath{-}I$. Finally, the equality ${\ensuremath{\mu}}_{\mathrm{DFT}}={\ensuremath{\mu}}_{\mathrm{SM}}^{n}$ is rigorously derived via an alternative route, where ${\ensuremath{\mu}}_{\mathrm{DFT}}$ is the Lagrangian multiplier used to constrain the normalization of the density in the traditional DFT approach.