Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1310.6043 · Physical Review Letters

Heisenberg-Limited Atom Clocks Based on Entangled Qubits

E. M. Kessler, P. Kómár, Michael Bishof, Liang Jiang, Anders Søndberg Sørensen, J. Ye, Mikhail D. Lukin

Published May 15, 2014• 131 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We present a quantum-enhanced atomic clock protocol based on groups of sequentially larger Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) states that achieves the best clock stability allowed by quantum theory up to a logarithmic correction. Importantly the protocol is designed to work under realistic conditions where the drift of the phase of the laser interrogating the atoms is the main source of decoherence. The simultaneous interrogation of the laser phase with a cascade of GHZ states realizes an incoherent version of the phase estimation algorithm that enables Heisenberg-limited operation while extending the coherent interrogation time beyond the laser noise limit. We compare and merge the new protocol with existing state of the art interrogation schemes, and identify the precise conditions under which entanglement provides an advantage for clock stabilization: it allows a significant gain in the stability for short averaging time.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.112.190403

Related papers

Heisenberg-Limited Noisy Atomic Clock Using a Hybrid Coherent and Squeezed State Protocol

Luca Pezzè, Augusto Smerzi

We propose a hybrid quantum-classical atomic clock where the interrogation of atoms prepared in a spin-coherent (or weakly squeezed) state is used to feed back one or more highly spin-squeezed atomic states toward their optimal phase-sensitivity point. The hybrid clock overcomes the stability of a single Ramsey clock using coherent or optimal spin-squeezed states and reaches a Heisenberg-limited stability while avoiding nondestructive measurements. When optimized with respect to the total number of particles, the protocol surpasses the state-of-the-art proposals that use Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger or NOON states. We compare analytical predictions with numerical simulations of clock operations, including correlated 1/f local oscillator noise.

arXiv:2003.10943•Physical Review Letters•Nov 19, 2020•57 citations

Quantum-Enhanced Atomic Clocks for Military PNT and Secure Communications

Zuhair Ahmed

Abstract Precise timekeeping is a foundational, often overlooked dependency of both positioning/navigation/timing (PNT) systems and secure communications: satellite navigation requires nanosecond-level clock synchronization to compute position from signal time-of-flight, and time-synchronized cryptographic protocols (including key-exchange window validation and frequency-hopping schemes) depend on clock stability at the transmitting and receiving ends. Current-generation atomic clocks (cesium and rubidium standards) achieve their stability by averaging over many independent, unentangled atoms, a strategy fundamentally limited by the standard quantum limit (SQL), in which timing precision scales with the number of atoms N as N. Quantum-enhanced atomic clocks propose replacing independent-atom ensembles with entangled (GHZ-state) ensembles, whose Heisenberg-limited precision scales instead as N². This study validates the two components of that claim independently: (1) the entanglement-derived precision advantage, via GHZ Ramsey spectroscopy simulated on the PKTron quantum computing framework across probe sizes N = 1, 2, 4, and 6, and cross-checked on IBM Quantum's ibm_fez hardware at N = 4; and (2) accurate recovery of an atomic transition's phase signal, via PKTron's built-in Quantum Phase Estimation (QPE) algorithm, tested against three independent reference phases. Simulation reproduced exact Heisenberg scaling (measured Fisher information of 1.00, 4.00, 16.00, and 36.00 against theoretical N² values of 1, 4, 16, and 36) and exact QPE phase recovery (zero measured error across all three test phases). On real IBM Quantum hardware at N = 4, the zero-drift calibration point returned P(all-zero) = 0.972, and the maximum-sensitivity bias point returned P(all-zero) = 0.500, exactly matching the theoretical prediction. These results constitute a reproducible, multi-method, hardware-validated confirmation of the sensing and phase-extraction primitives that underlie quantum-enhanced atomic clock proposals. This work does not simulate or validate a physical atomic clock, an optical lattice clock, or any oscillator hardware; it validates the underlying discrete-variable sensing and estimation mechanisms only, and should be read accordingly.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Near-Heisenberg-Limited Atomic Clocks in the Presence of Decoherence

Johannes Borregaard, Anders Søndberg Sørensen

The ultimate stability of atomic clocks is limited by the quantum noise of the atoms. To reduce this noise it has been suggested to use entangled atomic ensembles with reduced atomic noise. Potentially this can push the stability all the way to the limit allowed by the Heisenberg uncertainty relation, which is denoted the Heisenberg limit. In practice, however, entangled states are often more prone to decoherence, which may prevent reaching this performance. Here we present an adaptive measurement protocol that in the presence of a realistic source of decoherence enables us to get near-Heisenberg-limited stability of atomic clocks using entangled atoms. The protocol may thus realize the full potential of entanglement for quantum metrology despite the detrimental influence of decoherence.

arXiv:1304.2288•Physical Review Letters•Aug 27, 2013•88 citations

Dynamical decoupling of laser phase noise in compound atomic clocks

Sören Dörscher, Ali Al-Masoudi, Marcin Bober +4 more

Abstract The frequency stability of many optical atomic clocks is limited by the coherence of their local oscillator. Here, we present a measurement protocol that overcomes the laser coherence limit. It relies on engineered dynamical decoupling of laser phase noise and near-synchronous interrogation of two clocks. One clock coarsely tracks the laser phase using dynamical decoupling; the other refines this estimate using a high-resolution phase measurement. While the former needs to have a high signal-to-noise ratio, the latter clock may operate with any number of particles. The protocol effectively enables minute-long Ramsey interrogation for coherence times of few seconds as provided by the current best ultrastable laser systems. We demonstrate implementation of the protocol in a realistic proof-of-principle experiment, where we interrogate for 0.5 s at a laser coherence time of 77 ms. Here, a single lattice clock is used to emulate synchronous interrogation of two separate clocks in the presence of artificial laser frequency noise. We discuss the frequency instability of a single-ion clock that would result from using the protocol for stabilisation, under these conditions and for minute-long interrogation, and find expected instabilities of σy(τ) = 8 × 10−16(τ/s)−1/2 and σy(τ) = 5 × 10−17(τ/s)−1/2, respectively.

arXiv:1911.13146•Communications Physics•Oct 20, 2020•28 citations

GHZ protocols enhance frequency metrology despite spontaneous decay

Timm Kielinski, Piet O. Schmidt, Klemens Hammerer

The use of correlated states and measurements promises improvements in the accuracy of frequency metrology and the stability of atomic clocks. However, developing strategies robust against dominant noise processes remains challenging. We address the issue of decoherence due to spontaneous decay and show that Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) states, in conjunction with a correlated measurement and nonlinear estimation strategy, achieve gains of up to 2.25 decibel, comparable to fundamental bounds for up to about 80 atoms in the presence of decoherence. This result is unexpected because GHZ states do not provide any enhancement under dephasing due to white frequency noise compared to the standard quantum limit of uncorrelated states. The gain arises from a veto signal, which allows for the detection and mitigation of errors caused by spontaneous emission events. Through comprehensive Monte Carlo simulations of atomic clocks, we demonstrate the robustness of the GHZ protocol.

arXiv:2406.11639•Science Advances•Oct 23, 2024•17 citations

Extending the fundamental limit of atomic clock stability

Ravid Shaniv, Ayush Agrawal, David B. Hume

Optical atomic clocks have been rapidly developing in recent decades, resulting in major improvements in both precision and accuracy. As a result, they have become instrumental in multiple areas of applied and fundamental research. Despite all atomic frequency references having more than two energy-levels, the commonly used model for evaluating their ultimate limits assumes a two-level atom. This leads to frequency interrogation protocols and theoretical stability bounds that are suboptimal for a true multi-level atom. The most fundamental stability bound assumes two noise sources - quantum projection noise and spontaneous decay from the excited state. In this work, we analyze a model that includes these noise types and is generalized beyond the two-level assumption, where spontaneous decay can branch to more than a single ground state. This model allows for detection and exclusion of atomic frequency interrogations in which the atom decayed, leading to a frequency stability improvement of up to $\approx 4.5 \text{ dB}$ compared with the two-level model. Furthermore, we identify an even greater stability enhancement of $\approx 5.4 \text{ dB}$ for frequency comparisons between atoms in an odd parity Bell state. These enhancements are particularly relevant for the numerous trapped-ion optical clock species that operate close to lifetime-limited stability. We calculate new stability limits for those cases and provide a detailed experimental protocol for frequency interrogation with an $^{27}\text{Al}^{+}$ optical ion clock.

physics.atom-phCross-listedarXiv:2604.01099•Apr 2, 2026•0 citations
We present a quantum-enhanced atomic clock protocol based on groups of sequentially larger Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) states that achieves the best clock stability allowed by quantum theory up to a logarithmic correction. Importantly the protocol is designed to work under realistic conditions where the drift of the phase of the laser interrogating the atoms is the main source of decoherence. The simultaneous interrogation of the laser phase with a cascade of GHZ states realizes an incoherent version of the phase estimation algorithm that enables Heisenberg-limited operation while extending the coherent interrogation time beyond the laser noise limit. We compare and merge the new protocol with existing state of the art interrogation schemes, and identify the precise conditions under which entanglement provides an advantage for clock stabilization: it allows a significant gain in the stability for short averaging time.
We propose a hybrid quantum-classical atomic clock where the interrogation of atoms prepared in a spin-coherent (or weakly squeezed) state is used to feed back one or more highly spin-squeezed atomic states toward their optimal phase-sensitivity point. The hybrid clock overcomes the stability of a single Ramsey clock using coherent or optimal spin-squeezed states and reaches a Heisenberg-limited stability while avoiding nondestructive measurements. When optimized with respect to the total number of particles, the protocol surpasses the state-of-the-art proposals that use Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger or NOON states. We compare analytical predictions with numerical simulations of clock operations, including correlated 1/f local oscillator noise.
Abstract Precise timekeeping is a foundational, often overlooked dependency of both positioning/navigation/timing (PNT) systems and secure communications: satellite navigation requires nanosecond-level clock synchronization to compute position from signal time-of-flight, and time-synchronized cryptographic protocols (including key-exchange window validation and frequency-hopping schemes) depend on clock stability at the transmitting and receiving ends. Current-generation atomic clocks (cesium and rubidium standards) achieve their stability by averaging over many independent, unentangled atoms, a strategy fundamentally limited by the standard quantum limit (SQL), in which timing precision scales with the number of atoms N as N. Quantum-enhanced atomic clocks propose replacing independent-atom ensembles with entangled (GHZ-state) ensembles, whose Heisenberg-limited precision scales instead as N². This study validates the two components of that claim independently: (1) the entanglement-derived precision advantage, via GHZ Ramsey spectroscopy simulated on the PKTron quantum computing framework across probe sizes N = 1, 2, 4, and 6, and cross-checked on IBM Quantum's ibm_fez hardware at N = 4; and (2) accurate recovery of an atomic transition's phase signal, via PKTron's built-in Quantum Phase Estimation (QPE) algorithm, tested against three independent reference phases. Simulation reproduced exact Heisenberg scaling (measured Fisher information of 1.00, 4.00, 16.00, and 36.00 against theoretical N² values of 1, 4, 16, and 36) and exact QPE phase recovery (zero measured error across all three test phases). On real IBM Quantum hardware at N = 4, the zero-drift calibration point returned P(all-zero) = 0.972, and the maximum-sensitivity bias point returned P(all-zero) = 0.500, exactly matching the theoretical prediction. These results constitute a reproducible, multi-method, hardware-validated confirmation of the sensing and phase-extraction primitives that underlie quantum-enhanced atomic clock proposals. This work does not simulate or validate a physical atomic clock, an optical lattice clock, or any oscillator hardware; it validates the underlying discrete-variable sensing and estimation mechanisms only, and should be read accordingly.
The ultimate stability of atomic clocks is limited by the quantum noise of the atoms. To reduce this noise it has been suggested to use entangled atomic ensembles with reduced atomic noise. Potentially this can push the stability all the way to the limit allowed by the Heisenberg uncertainty relation, which is denoted the Heisenberg limit. In practice, however, entangled states are often more prone to decoherence, which may prevent reaching this performance. Here we present an adaptive measurement protocol that in the presence of a realistic source of decoherence enables us to get near-Heisenberg-limited stability of atomic clocks using entangled atoms. The protocol may thus realize the full potential of entanglement for quantum metrology despite the detrimental influence of decoherence.
Abstract The frequency stability of many optical atomic clocks is limited by the coherence of their local oscillator. Here, we present a measurement protocol that overcomes the laser coherence limit. It relies on engineered dynamical decoupling of laser phase noise and near-synchronous interrogation of two clocks. One clock coarsely tracks the laser phase using dynamical decoupling; the other refines this estimate using a high-resolution phase measurement. While the former needs to have a high signal-to-noise ratio, the latter clock may operate with any number of particles. The protocol effectively enables minute-long Ramsey interrogation for coherence times of few seconds as provided by the current best ultrastable laser systems. We demonstrate implementation of the protocol in a realistic proof-of-principle experiment, where we interrogate for 0.5 s at a laser coherence time of 77 ms. Here, a single lattice clock is used to emulate synchronous interrogation of two separate clocks in the presence of artificial laser frequency noise. We discuss the frequency instability of a single-ion clock that would result from using the protocol for stabilisation, under these conditions and for minute-long interrogation, and find expected instabilities of σy(τ) = 8 × 10−16(τ/s)−1/2 and σy(τ) = 5 × 10−17(τ/s)−1/2, respectively.
The use of correlated states and measurements promises improvements in the accuracy of frequency metrology and the stability of atomic clocks. However, developing strategies robust against dominant noise processes remains challenging. We address the issue of decoherence due to spontaneous decay and show that Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) states, in conjunction with a correlated measurement and nonlinear estimation strategy, achieve gains of up to 2.25 decibel, comparable to fundamental bounds for up to about 80 atoms in the presence of decoherence. This result is unexpected because GHZ states do not provide any enhancement under dephasing due to white frequency noise compared to the standard quantum limit of uncorrelated states. The gain arises from a veto signal, which allows for the detection and mitigation of errors caused by spontaneous emission events. Through comprehensive Monte Carlo simulations of atomic clocks, we demonstrate the robustness of the GHZ protocol.
Optical atomic clocks have been rapidly developing in recent decades, resulting in major improvements in both precision and accuracy. As a result, they have become instrumental in multiple areas of applied and fundamental research. Despite all atomic frequency references having more than two energy-levels, the commonly used model for evaluating their ultimate limits assumes a two-level atom. This leads to frequency interrogation protocols and theoretical stability bounds that are suboptimal for a true multi-level atom. The most fundamental stability bound assumes two noise sources - quantum projection noise and spontaneous decay from the excited state. In this work, we analyze a model that includes these noise types and is generalized beyond the two-level assumption, where spontaneous decay can branch to more than a single ground state. This model allows for detection and exclusion of atomic frequency interrogations in which the atom decayed, leading to a frequency stability improvement of up to ≈4.5 dB\approx 4.5 \text{ dB}≈4.5 dB compared with the two-level model. Furthermore, we identify an even greater stability enhancement of ≈5.4 dB\approx 5.4 \text{ dB}≈5.4 dB for frequency comparisons between atoms in an odd parity Bell state. These enhancements are particularly relevant for the numerous trapped-ion optical clock species that operate close to lifetime-limited stability. We calculate new stability limits for those cases and provide a detailed experimental protocol for frequency interrogation with an 27Al+^{27}\text{Al}^{+}27Al+ optical ion clock.