Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1310.4043 · Physical Review A

Analysis of the trade-off between spatial and temporal resources for measurement-based quantum computation

Jisho Miyazaki, Michal Hajdušek, Mio Murao

Published May 4, 2015• 20 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In measurement-based quantum computation (MBQC), elementary quantum operations can be more parallelized than the quantum circuit model by employing a larger Hilbert space of graph states used as the resource. Thus MBQC can be regarded as a method of quantum computation where the temporal resource described by the depth of quantum operations can be reduced compared to the quantum circuit model by using the extra spatial resource described by graph states. To analyze the trade-off relationship of the spatial and temporal resources, we consider a method to obtain quantum circuit decompositions of general unitary transformations represented by MBQC on graph states with a certain underlying geometry called generalized flow. We present a method to translate any MBQC with generalized flow into quantum circuits without extra spatial resource. We also show an explicit way to unravel acausal gates without postselection that appear in the quantum circuit decomposition derived by a translation method [V. Danos and E. Kashefi, Phys. Rev. A 74, 052310 (2006)] and that represents an effect of the reduction of the temporal resource in MBQC. Finally, by considering a way to deterministically simulate these acausal gates, we investigate a general framework to analyze the trade-off between the spatial and temporal resources for quantum computation.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.91.052302

Related papers

Mapping quantum circuits to shallow-depth measurement patterns based on graph states

Thierry N. Kaldenbach, Matthias Heller

Abstract The paradigm of measurement-based quantum computing (MBQC) starts from a highly entangled resource state on which unitary operations are executed through adaptive measurements and corrections ensuring determinism. This is set in contrast to the more common quantum circuit model, in which unitary operations are directly implemented through quantum gates prior to final measurements. In this work, we incorporate concepts from MBQC into the circuit model to create a hybrid simulation technique, permitting us to split any quantum circuit into a classically efficiently simulatable Clifford-part and a second part consisting of a stabilizer state and local (adaptive) measurement instructions—a so-called standard form—which is executed on a quantum computer. We further process the stabilizer state with the graph state formalism, thus, enabling a significant decrease in circuit depth for certain applications. We show that groups of mutually-commuting operators can be implemented using fully-parallel, i.e. non-adaptive, measurements within our protocol. In addition, we discuss how groups of mutually commuting observables can be simulatenously measured by adjusting the resource state, rather than performing a costly basis transformation prior to the measurement as it is done in the circuit model. Finally, we demonstrate the utility of our technique on two examples of high practical relevance—the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm and the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) for the ground-state energy estimation of the water molecule. For the VQE, we find a reduction of the depth by a factor of 4 to 5 using measurement patterns vs. the standard circuit model. At the same time, since we incorporate the simultaneous measurements, our patterns allow us to save shots by a factor of at least 3.5 compared to measuring Pauli strings individually in the circuit model.

Quantum Science and Technology•Sep 26, 2024•14 citations

Mapping quantum circuits to shallow-depth measurement patters based on graph states

Kaldenbach, Thierry Nicolas, Heller, Matthias

The paradigm of measurement-based quantum computing (MBQC) starts from a highly entangled resource state on which unitary operations are executed through adaptive measurements and corrections ensuring determinism. This is set in contrast to the more common quantum circuit model, in which unitary operations are directly implemented through quantum gates prior to final measurements. In this work, we incorporate concepts from MBQC into the circuit model to create a hybrid simulation technique, permitting us to split any quantum circuit into a classically efficiently simulatable Clifford-part and a second part consisting of a stabilizer state and local (adaptive) measurement instructions—a so-called standard for —which is executed on a quantum computer. We further process the stabilizer state with the graph state formalism, thus, enabling a significant decrease in circuit depth for certain applications. We show that groups of mutually-commuting operators can be implemented using fully-parallel, i.e. non-adaptive, measurements within our protocol. In addition, we discuss how groups of mutually commuting observables can be simulatenously measured by adjusting the resource state, rather than performing a costly basis transformation prior to the measurement as it is done in the circuit model. Finally, we demonstrate the utility of our technique on two examples of high practical relevance—the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm and the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) for the ground-state energy estimation of the water molecule. For the VQE, we find a reduction of the depth by a factor of 4 to 5 using measurement patterns vs. the standard circuit model. At the same time, since we incorporate the simultaneous measurements, our patterns allow us to save shots by a factor of at least 3.5 compared to measuring Pauli strings individually in the circuit model.

•Mar 1, 2024•0 citations

Mapping quantum circuits to shallow-depth measurement patterns based on graph states

Thierry N. Kaldenbach, Heller, Matthias

The paradigm of measurement-based quantum computing (MBQC) starts from a highly entangled resource state on which unitary operations are executed through adaptive measurements and corrections ensuring determinism. This is set in contrast to the more common quantum circuit model, in which unitary operations are directly implemented through quantum gates prior to final measurements. In this work, we incorporate concepts from MBQC into the circuit model to create a hybrid simulation technique, permitting us to split any quantum circuit into a classically efficiently simulatable Clifford-part and a second part consisting of a stabilizer state and local (adaptive) measurement instructions, a so-called standard form, which is executed on a quantum computer. We further process the stabilizer state with the graph state formalism, thus enabling a significant decrease in circuit depth for certain applications. We show that groups of fully commuting operators can be implemented using fully-parallel, i.e., non-adaptive, measurements within our protocol. In addition, we discuss how such circuits can be implemented in constant quantum depths by employing quantum teleportation. Finally, we demonstrate the utility of our technique on two examples of high practical relevance: the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) and the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE).

arXiv:2311.16223•Nov 27, 2023•4 citations

Resource states and temporal order of the measurement-based model of quantum computation

Poya Haghnegahdar

Measurement-based quantum computation (MBQC) performs quantum algorithms by local, adaptive measurements on an initially entangled many-body "resource" state. This thesis investigates MBQC through two tightly coupled lenses: (i) which physical states and phases of matter constitute universal resources, and (ii) how the temporal order induced by measurement adaptivity constrains and, in turn, is constrained by those resources. Resources from valence-bond constructions. We develop hybrid AKLT-type (valence-bond) resources on two-dimensional lattices and show how a generalized POVM reduces higher-spin degrees of freedom to effective qubits while preserving computational viability. We analyze worst-case and frustrated geometries (e.g., kagome and decorated lattices), identify planarity-restoring local operations, and use percolation-style diagnostics on the induced graph states to certify universality beyond idealized cluster-state settings. A two-parameter phase with noisy POVMs. Extending ground states across a phase connected to the AKLT point, we introduce a measurement-noise–aware framework with probabilistic restoration and closed-form weight formulae derived via a graphical (g-)calculus. Large-scale numerics that account for correlations map a two-parameter phase diagram and delineate regimes of universal vs. non-universal post-measurement graphs. These results exhibit a robust universal region that persists away from ideal measurements and clarify how noise and Hamiltonian deformation jointly control computational power. Temporal order and determinism. We develop a stabilizer-and-influence-matrix formalism that places temporal dependencies on the same footing as resource structure. Four theorems establish a two-way determination between (a) the classical processing relations (including the influence matrix that generates the partial order of measurements) and (b) the resource stabilizer in a normal form, up to local equivalence. This links gauge freedoms, byproduct handling, and flow/gflow–style constraints into a unified picture of when adaptive measurement schedules yield deterministic computation. Together, these contributions clarify when physically motivated ground states serve as universal MBQC resources under realistic measurement noise, and how temporal constraints fundamentally shape the space of admissible computations in MBQC.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Adiabatic graph-state quantum computation

B Antonio, Damian Markham, Janet Anders

Measurement-based quantum computation (MBQC) and holonomic quantum computation (HQC) are two very different computational methods. The computation in MBQC is driven by adaptive measurements executed in a particular order on a large entangled state. In contrast in HQC the system starts in the ground subspace of a Hamiltonian which is slowly changed such that a transformation occurs within the subspace. Following the approach of Bacon and Flammia, we show that any MBQC on a graph state with generalized flow (gflow) can be converted into an adiabatically driven holonomic computation, which we call adiabatic graph-state quantum computation (AGQC). We then investigate how properties of AGQC relate to the properties of MBQC, such as computational depth. We identify a trade-off that can be made between the number of adiabatic steps in AGQC and the norm of as well as the degree of H , in analogy to the trade-off between the number of measurements and classical post-processing seen in MBQC. Finally the effects of performing AGQC with orderings that differ from standard MBQC are investigated.

arXiv:1309.1443•New Journal of Physics•Nov 26, 2014•8 citations

Universal Measurement-Based Quantum Computation in a One-Dimensional Architecture Enabled by Dual-Unitary Circuits

David T. Stephen, Wen Wei Ho, Tzu-Chieh Wei +2 more

A powerful tool emerging from the study of many-body quantum dynamics is that of dual-unitary circuits, which are unitary even when read "sideways," i.e., along the spatial direction. Here, we show that this provides the ideal framework to understand and expand on the notion of measurement-based quantum computation (MBQC). In particular, applying a dual-unitary circuit to a many-body state followed by appropriate measurements effectively implements quantum computation in the spatial direction. We show how the dual-unitary dynamics generated by the dynamics of the paradigmatic one-dimensional kicked Ising chain with certain parameter choices generate resource states for universal deterministic MBQC. Specifically, after k time steps, equivalent to a depth-k quantum circuit, we obtain a resource state for universal MBQC on ∼3k/4 encoded qubits. Our protocol allows generic quantum circuits to be "rotated" in space-time and gives new ways to exchange between resources like qubit number and coherence time in quantum computers. Beyond the practical advantages, we also interpret the dual-unitary evolution as generating an infinite sequence of new symmetry-protected topological phases with spatially modulated symmetries, which gives a vast generalization of the well-studied one-dimensional cluster state and shows that our protocol is robust to symmetry-respecting deformations.

arXiv:2209.06191•Physical Review Letters•Jun 17, 2024•44 citations
In measurement-based quantum computation (MBQC), elementary quantum operations can be more parallelized than the quantum circuit model by employing a larger Hilbert space of graph states used as the resource. Thus MBQC can be regarded as a method of quantum computation where the temporal resource described by the depth of quantum operations can be reduced compared to the quantum circuit model by using the extra spatial resource described by graph states. To analyze the trade-off relationship of the spatial and temporal resources, we consider a method to obtain quantum circuit decompositions of general unitary transformations represented by MBQC on graph states with a certain underlying geometry called generalized flow. We present a method to translate any MBQC with generalized flow into quantum circuits without extra spatial resource. We also show an explicit way to unravel acausal gates without postselection that appear in the quantum circuit decomposition derived by a translation method [V. Danos and E. Kashefi, Phys. Rev. A 74, 052310 (2006)] and that represents an effect of the reduction of the temporal resource in MBQC. Finally, by considering a way to deterministically simulate these acausal gates, we investigate a general framework to analyze the trade-off between the spatial and temporal resources for quantum computation.
Abstract The paradigm of measurement-based quantum computing (MBQC) starts from a highly entangled resource state on which unitary operations are executed through adaptive measurements and corrections ensuring determinism. This is set in contrast to the more common quantum circuit model, in which unitary operations are directly implemented through quantum gates prior to final measurements. In this work, we incorporate concepts from MBQC into the circuit model to create a hybrid simulation technique, permitting us to split any quantum circuit into a classically efficiently simulatable Clifford-part and a second part consisting of a stabilizer state and local (adaptive) measurement instructions—a so-called standard form—which is executed on a quantum computer. We further process the stabilizer state with the graph state formalism, thus, enabling a significant decrease in circuit depth for certain applications. We show that groups of mutually-commuting operators can be implemented using fully-parallel, i.e. non-adaptive, measurements within our protocol. In addition, we discuss how groups of mutually commuting observables can be simulatenously measured by adjusting the resource state, rather than performing a costly basis transformation prior to the measurement as it is done in the circuit model. Finally, we demonstrate the utility of our technique on two examples of high practical relevance—the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm and the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) for the ground-state energy estimation of the water molecule. For the VQE, we find a reduction of the depth by a factor of 4 to 5 using measurement patterns vs. the standard circuit model. At the same time, since we incorporate the simultaneous measurements, our patterns allow us to save shots by a factor of at least 3.5 compared to measuring Pauli strings individually in the circuit model.
The paradigm of measurement-based quantum computing (MBQC) starts from a highly entangled resource state on which unitary operations are executed through adaptive measurements and corrections ensuring determinism. This is set in contrast to the more common quantum circuit model, in which unitary operations are directly implemented through quantum gates prior to final measurements. In this work, we incorporate concepts from MBQC into the circuit model to create a hybrid simulation technique, permitting us to split any quantum circuit into a classically efficiently simulatable Clifford-part and a second part consisting of a stabilizer state and local (adaptive) measurement instructions—a so-called standard for —which is executed on a quantum computer. We further process the stabilizer state with the graph state formalism, thus, enabling a significant decrease in circuit depth for certain applications. We show that groups of mutually-commuting operators can be implemented using fully-parallel, i.e. non-adaptive, measurements within our protocol. In addition, we discuss how groups of mutually commuting observables can be simulatenously measured by adjusting the resource state, rather than performing a costly basis transformation prior to the measurement as it is done in the circuit model. Finally, we demonstrate the utility of our technique on two examples of high practical relevance—the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm and the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) for the ground-state energy estimation of the water molecule. For the VQE, we find a reduction of the depth by a factor of 4 to 5 using measurement patterns vs. the standard circuit model. At the same time, since we incorporate the simultaneous measurements, our patterns allow us to save shots by a factor of at least 3.5 compared to measuring Pauli strings individually in the circuit model.
The paradigm of measurement-based quantum computing (MBQC) starts from a highly entangled resource state on which unitary operations are executed through adaptive measurements and corrections ensuring determinism. This is set in contrast to the more common quantum circuit model, in which unitary operations are directly implemented through quantum gates prior to final measurements. In this work, we incorporate concepts from MBQC into the circuit model to create a hybrid simulation technique, permitting us to split any quantum circuit into a classically efficiently simulatable Clifford-part and a second part consisting of a stabilizer state and local (adaptive) measurement instructions, a so-called standard form, which is executed on a quantum computer. We further process the stabilizer state with the graph state formalism, thus enabling a significant decrease in circuit depth for certain applications. We show that groups of fully commuting operators can be implemented using fully-parallel, i.e., non-adaptive, measurements within our protocol. In addition, we discuss how such circuits can be implemented in constant quantum depths by employing quantum teleportation. Finally, we demonstrate the utility of our technique on two examples of high practical relevance: the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA) and the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE).
Measurement-based quantum computation (MBQC) performs quantum algorithms by local, adaptive measurements on an initially entangled many-body "resource" state. This thesis investigates MBQC through two tightly coupled lenses: (i) which physical states and phases of matter constitute universal resources, and (ii) how the temporal order induced by measurement adaptivity constrains and, in turn, is constrained by those resources. Resources from valence-bond constructions. We develop hybrid AKLT-type (valence-bond) resources on two-dimensional lattices and show how a generalized POVM reduces higher-spin degrees of freedom to effective qubits while preserving computational viability. We analyze worst-case and frustrated geometries (e.g., kagome and decorated lattices), identify planarity-restoring local operations, and use percolation-style diagnostics on the induced graph states to certify universality beyond idealized cluster-state settings. A two-parameter phase with noisy POVMs. Extending ground states across a phase connected to the AKLT point, we introduce a measurement-noise–aware framework with probabilistic restoration and closed-form weight formulae derived via a graphical (g-)calculus. Large-scale numerics that account for correlations map a two-parameter phase diagram and delineate regimes of universal vs. non-universal post-measurement graphs. These results exhibit a robust universal region that persists away from ideal measurements and clarify how noise and Hamiltonian deformation jointly control computational power. Temporal order and determinism. We develop a stabilizer-and-influence-matrix formalism that places temporal dependencies on the same footing as resource structure. Four theorems establish a two-way determination between (a) the classical processing relations (including the influence matrix that generates the partial order of measurements) and (b) the resource stabilizer in a normal form, up to local equivalence. This links gauge freedoms, byproduct handling, and flow/gflow–style constraints into a unified picture of when adaptive measurement schedules yield deterministic computation. Together, these contributions clarify when physically motivated ground states serve as universal MBQC resources under realistic measurement noise, and how temporal constraints fundamentally shape the space of admissible computations in MBQC.
Measurement-based quantum computation (MBQC) and holonomic quantum computation (HQC) are two very different computational methods. The computation in MBQC is driven by adaptive measurements executed in a particular order on a large entangled state. In contrast in HQC the system starts in the ground subspace of a Hamiltonian which is slowly changed such that a transformation occurs within the subspace. Following the approach of Bacon and Flammia, we show that any MBQC on a graph state with generalized flow (gflow) can be converted into an adiabatically driven holonomic computation, which we call adiabatic graph-state quantum computation (AGQC). We then investigate how properties of AGQC relate to the properties of MBQC, such as computational depth. We identify a trade-off that can be made between the number of adiabatic steps in AGQC and the norm of as well as the degree of H , in analogy to the trade-off between the number of measurements and classical post-processing seen in MBQC. Finally the effects of performing AGQC with orderings that differ from standard MBQC are investigated.
A powerful tool emerging from the study of many-body quantum dynamics is that of dual-unitary circuits, which are unitary even when read "sideways," i.e., along the spatial direction. Here, we show that this provides the ideal framework to understand and expand on the notion of measurement-based quantum computation (MBQC). In particular, applying a dual-unitary circuit to a many-body state followed by appropriate measurements effectively implements quantum computation in the spatial direction. We show how the dual-unitary dynamics generated by the dynamics of the paradigmatic one-dimensional kicked Ising chain with certain parameter choices generate resource states for universal deterministic MBQC. Specifically, after k time steps, equivalent to a depth-k quantum circuit, we obtain a resource state for universal MBQC on ∼3k/4 encoded qubits. Our protocol allows generic quantum circuits to be "rotated" in space-time and gives new ways to exchange between resources like qubit number and coherence time in quantum computers. Beyond the practical advantages, we also interpret the dual-unitary evolution as generating an infinite sequence of new symmetry-protected topological phases with spatially modulated symmetries, which gives a vast generalization of the well-studied one-dimensional cluster state and shows that our protocol is robust to symmetry-respecting deformations.