Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1309.4439 · Entropy

Fluctuations of Intensive Quantities in Statistical Thermodynamics

Artur E. Ruuge

Published Nov 11, 2013• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In phenomenological thermodynamics, the canonical coordinates of a physical system split in pairs, with each pair consisting of an extensive quantity and an intensive one. In the present paper, the quasithermodynamic fluctuation theory of a model system of a large number of oscillators is extended to statistical thermodynamics based on the idea of perceiving the fluctuations of intensive variables as the fluctuations of specific extensive ones in a “thermodynamically dual” system. The extension is motivated by the symmetry of the problem in the context of an analogy with quantum mechanics, which is stated in terms of a generalized Pauli problem for the thermodynamic fluctuations. The doubled Boltzmann constant divided by the number of particles plays a similar role as the Planck constant.

DOI
10.3390/e15114889

Related papers

Pauli problem in thermodynamics

Artur E. Ruuge

A thermodynamic analogue of the Pauli problem (reconstruction of a wavefunction from the position and momentum distributions) is formulated. The coordinates of a quantum system are replaced by the inverse absolute temperature and other intensive quantities, and the Planck constant is replaced by the Boltzmann constant multiplied by two. A new natural mathematical generalization of the quasithermodynamic fluctuation theory is suggested and sufficient conditions for the existence of asymptotic solutions of the thermodynamic Pauli problem are obtained.

arXiv:1208.2919•Aug 14, 2012•6 citations

Microlagrangian manifolds and quasithermodynamic fluctuations of nonequilibrium states

Artur E. Ruuge

The paper deals with "quantization" and "second quantization" of phenomenological thermodynamics with respect to the Boltzmann's constant. It is suggested to perceive the quasithermodynamic parameter (corresponding to the Boltzmann's constant) as a mathematical analogue of the semiclassical parameter (corresponding to the Planck's constant), and to introduce a new concept of a "thermocorpuscle" (a thermodynamic analogue of a particle where the coordinates are replaced by the nonequilibrium thermodynamic forces and the momenta are replaced by the corresponding flows). The semiclassical quantization of phenomenological thermodynamic Lagrangian manifolds yields a new system of equations for the quasithermodynamic fluctuations along a curve of evolution of a nonequilibrium physical system. This leads to a quasithermodynamic analogue of Bell's inequalities and their violation is a new effect that can be tested experimentally. The generating function of the quasithermodynamic fluctuations (the nonequilibrium analogue of a partition function) is interpreted as an expectation value of a second quantized operator expressed via the density of thermocorpuscles. An analogue of the BBGKY chain of equations defines a deformation of the fluctuations by an interaction between the thermocorpuscles. In place of an interaction parameter in mechanics (the "external" Planck's constant), one introduces the "external" Boltzmann's constant for an asymptotic expansion of the thermodynamic collision integral.

arXiv:1008.3297•Aug 19, 2010•1 citation

Fluctuations and the quantization of the entropy production rate

Mohammad Mehrafarin

Based on a commonly used model for the time evolution of extensive variables and on the basis of the analogies between the nonlinear stochastic theory and imaginary time quantum mechanics in curved space, we set up a canonical operator formulation of non-equilibrium thermodynamics which emphasizes the fundamental role played by the Boltzmann constant k in fluctuations. The k to 0 of this theory yields the classical description of non-equilibrium thermodynamics. The new formulation is technically useful and provides new insights which have important consequences, namely the thermodynamic uncertainty principle and the quantization of the entropy production rate for stationary states.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Sep 7, 1994•1 citation

An outline of a purely phenomenological theory of statistical thermodynamics--I: Canonical ensembles

Benoît B. Mandelbrot

"Boltzmann's problem" of statistical thermodynamics, is that of eliminating the paradoxical incompatibility of structure, existing between the irreversibility of the classical phenomenological thermodynamics, and the reversibility of any purely kinetic model, one could ever think of for these phenomena. One finds that, in order to construct kinetic "analogs" to the laws of phenomenological thermodynamics, the dynamics of large assemblies of molecules (Liouville theorem, etc,\cdots) must be completed by some hypotheses of randomness. Once established, this randomness can be followed up in its development, with no new conceptual paradox (although with great technical difficulty: there is a great amount of current work on this topic). But the introduction of randomness still raises entirely uncleared problems. Since, therefore, the kinetic foundations of thermodynamics are not sufficient in the absence of further hypotheses of randomness, are they still quite necessary in the presence of such hypotheses? Or else, could not one "short-circuit" the atoms, by centering upon any elements of randomness, for example those introduced by the process of observation? Our aim is to show (partly after Szilard) that a substantial part of the results, usually obtained through kinetic arguments, could be obtained by postulating from the outset a statistical distribution for the properties of a system, and following up with a purely phenomenological argument. The spirit of the theory is extremely close to that of the conventional (Copenhagen) approach to quantum theory, and the results are quite parallel, although the mathematics is quite different. Randomness is introduced by following the modern statistical theory of the estimation of non directly observable intensive variables of state, such as the temperature. The discussion of the methodological foundations of modern statistics can thus be translated into a full-fledged, and possibly significant , counterpart of the discussion of the kinetic foundations of thermodynamics. Statistics is thus provided with a particularly concrete example for some of its more involved methods; thermodynamics appears clarified in its classical aspects, and is further completed with an apparently new uncertainty relationship. It may also be of interest to the communication engineer to have a unified treatment of the foundations of fluctuation phenomena, and of methods of fighting noise : a discussion of entropy and information performed in this spirit, will be given in Part II of the paper.

IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Sep 1, 1956•47 citations

A New Approach for the Statistical Thermodynamic Theory of the Nonextensive Systems Confined in Different Finite Traps

Hui-yi Tang, Jian-Hui Wang, Yongli Ma

For a small system at a low temperature, thermal fluctuation and quantum effect play important roles in quantum thermodynamics. Starting from micro-canonical ensemble, we generalize the Boltzmann–Gibbs statistical factor from infinite to finite systems, no matter the interactions between particles are considered or not. This generalized factor, similar to Tsallis’s q-form as a power-law distribution, has the restriction of finite energy spectrum and includes the nonextensivities of the small systems. We derive the exact expression for distribution of average particle numbers in the interacting classical and quantum nonextensive systems within a generalized canonical ensemble. This expression in the almost independent or elementary excitation quantum finite systems is similar to the corresponding ones obtained from the conventional grand-canonical ensemble. In the reconstruction for the statistical theory of the small systems, we present the entropy of the equilibrium systems and equation of total thermal energy. When we investigate the thermodynamics for the interacting nonextensive systems, we obtain the system–bath heat exchange and “uncompensated heat” which are in the thermodynamical level and independent on the detail of the system–bath coupling. For ideal finite systems, with different traps and boundary conditions, we calculate some thermodynamic quantities, such as the specific heat, entropy, and equation of state, etc. Particularly at low temperatures for the small systems, we predict some novel behaviors in the quantum thermodynamics, including internal entropy production, heat exchanges between the system and its surroundings and finite-size effects on the free energy.

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•May 14, 2014•5 citations

Statistical Mechanics from a Quantum Perspective

Roland Kjellander

An energy level consists of all microscopic states of a system with the same energy. The energy levels of a system depend on the number of particles and the volume. At each instance in time, many different quantum states are represented in the various systems in the ensemble. A microcanonical ensemble describes an isolated system which has a fixed energy, volume and number of particles. The chapter describes certain relationships between fluctuations in thermodynamical variables and some other thermodynamical entities. One case of particular interest is when each subsystem is composed of one single particle, for instance very weakly interacting particles adsorbed on a surface or the particles in an ideal gas. The chapter presents more strict derivations of the probability expressions in the canonical, isobaric-isothermal and grand canonical ensembles. Volume and number of particles can also be considered as being mechanical variables. Entropy and temperature are examples of nonmechanical variables.

CRC Press eBooks•Jul 30, 2019•0 citations
In phenomenological thermodynamics, the canonical coordinates of a physical system split in pairs, with each pair consisting of an extensive quantity and an intensive one. In the present paper, the quasithermodynamic fluctuation theory of a model system of a large number of oscillators is extended to statistical thermodynamics based on the idea of perceiving the fluctuations of intensive variables as the fluctuations of specific extensive ones in a “thermodynamically dual” system. The extension is motivated by the symmetry of the problem in the context of an analogy with quantum mechanics, which is stated in terms of a generalized Pauli problem for the thermodynamic fluctuations. The doubled Boltzmann constant divided by the number of particles plays a similar role as the Planck constant.
A thermodynamic analogue of the Pauli problem (reconstruction of a wavefunction from the position and momentum distributions) is formulated. The coordinates of a quantum system are replaced by the inverse absolute temperature and other intensive quantities, and the Planck constant is replaced by the Boltzmann constant multiplied by two. A new natural mathematical generalization of the quasithermodynamic fluctuation theory is suggested and sufficient conditions for the existence of asymptotic solutions of the thermodynamic Pauli problem are obtained.
The paper deals with "quantization" and "second quantization" of phenomenological thermodynamics with respect to the Boltzmann's constant. It is suggested to perceive the quasithermodynamic parameter (corresponding to the Boltzmann's constant) as a mathematical analogue of the semiclassical parameter (corresponding to the Planck's constant), and to introduce a new concept of a "thermocorpuscle" (a thermodynamic analogue of a particle where the coordinates are replaced by the nonequilibrium thermodynamic forces and the momenta are replaced by the corresponding flows). The semiclassical quantization of phenomenological thermodynamic Lagrangian manifolds yields a new system of equations for the quasithermodynamic fluctuations along a curve of evolution of a nonequilibrium physical system. This leads to a quasithermodynamic analogue of Bell's inequalities and their violation is a new effect that can be tested experimentally. The generating function of the quasithermodynamic fluctuations (the nonequilibrium analogue of a partition function) is interpreted as an expectation value of a second quantized operator expressed via the density of thermocorpuscles. An analogue of the BBGKY chain of equations defines a deformation of the fluctuations by an interaction between the thermocorpuscles. In place of an interaction parameter in mechanics (the "external" Planck's constant), one introduces the "external" Boltzmann's constant for an asymptotic expansion of the thermodynamic collision integral.
Based on a commonly used model for the time evolution of extensive variables and on the basis of the analogies between the nonlinear stochastic theory and imaginary time quantum mechanics in curved space, we set up a canonical operator formulation of non-equilibrium thermodynamics which emphasizes the fundamental role played by the Boltzmann constant k in fluctuations. The k to 0 of this theory yields the classical description of non-equilibrium thermodynamics. The new formulation is technically useful and provides new insights which have important consequences, namely the thermodynamic uncertainty principle and the quantization of the entropy production rate for stationary states.
"Boltzmann's problem" of statistical thermodynamics, is that of eliminating the paradoxical incompatibility of structure, existing between the irreversibility of the classical phenomenological thermodynamics, and the reversibility of any purely kinetic model, one could ever think of for these phenomena. One finds that, in order to construct kinetic "analogs" to the laws of phenomenological thermodynamics, the dynamics of large assemblies of molecules (Liouville theorem, etc,\cdots) must be completed by some hypotheses of randomness. Once established, this randomness can be followed up in its development, with no new conceptual paradox (although with great technical difficulty: there is a great amount of current work on this topic). But the introduction of randomness still raises entirely uncleared problems. Since, therefore, the kinetic foundations of thermodynamics are not sufficient in the absence of further hypotheses of randomness, are they still quite necessary in the presence of such hypotheses? Or else, could not one "short-circuit" the atoms, by centering upon any elements of randomness, for example those introduced by the process of observation? Our aim is to show (partly after Szilard) that a substantial part of the results, usually obtained through kinetic arguments, could be obtained by postulating from the outset a statistical distribution for the properties of a system, and following up with a purely phenomenological argument. The spirit of the theory is extremely close to that of the conventional (Copenhagen) approach to quantum theory, and the results are quite parallel, although the mathematics is quite different. Randomness is introduced by following the modern statistical theory of the estimation of non directly observable intensive variables of state, such as the temperature. The discussion of the methodological foundations of modern statistics can thus be translated into a full-fledged, and possibly significant , counterpart of the discussion of the kinetic foundations of thermodynamics. Statistics is thus provided with a particularly concrete example for some of its more involved methods; thermodynamics appears clarified in its classical aspects, and is further completed with an apparently new uncertainty relationship. It may also be of interest to the communication engineer to have a unified treatment of the foundations of fluctuation phenomena, and of methods of fighting noise : a discussion of entropy and information performed in this spirit, will be given in Part II of the paper.
For a small system at a low temperature, thermal fluctuation and quantum effect play important roles in quantum thermodynamics. Starting from micro-canonical ensemble, we generalize the Boltzmann–Gibbs statistical factor from infinite to finite systems, no matter the interactions between particles are considered or not. This generalized factor, similar to Tsallis’s q-form as a power-law distribution, has the restriction of finite energy spectrum and includes the nonextensivities of the small systems. We derive the exact expression for distribution of average particle numbers in the interacting classical and quantum nonextensive systems within a generalized canonical ensemble. This expression in the almost independent or elementary excitation quantum finite systems is similar to the corresponding ones obtained from the conventional grand-canonical ensemble. In the reconstruction for the statistical theory of the small systems, we present the entropy of the equilibrium systems and equation of total thermal energy. When we investigate the thermodynamics for the interacting nonextensive systems, we obtain the system–bath heat exchange and “uncompensated heat” which are in the thermodynamical level and independent on the detail of the system–bath coupling. For ideal finite systems, with different traps and boundary conditions, we calculate some thermodynamic quantities, such as the specific heat, entropy, and equation of state, etc. Particularly at low temperatures for the small systems, we predict some novel behaviors in the quantum thermodynamics, including internal entropy production, heat exchanges between the system and its surroundings and finite-size effects on the free energy.
An energy level consists of all microscopic states of a system with the same energy. The energy levels of a system depend on the number of particles and the volume. At each instance in time, many different quantum states are represented in the various systems in the ensemble. A microcanonical ensemble describes an isolated system which has a fixed energy, volume and number of particles. The chapter describes certain relationships between fluctuations in thermodynamical variables and some other thermodynamical entities. One case of particular interest is when each subsystem is composed of one single particle, for instance very weakly interacting particles adsorbed on a surface or the particles in an ideal gas. The chapter presents more strict derivations of the probability expressions in the canonical, isobaric-isothermal and grand canonical ensembles. Volume and number of particles can also be considered as being mechanical variables. Entropy and temperature are examples of nonmechanical variables.