Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1309.0060 · Physical Review A

Comparative studies of many-body corrections to an interacting Bose-Einstein condensate

Shohei Watabe, Yoji Ohashi

Published Nov 26, 2013• 14 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We compare many-body theories describing fluctuation corrections to the mean-field theory in a weakly interacting Bose-condensed gas. Using a generalized random-phase approximation, we include both density fluctuations and fluctuations in the particle-particle scattering channel in a consistent manner. We also separately examine effects of the fluctuations within the framework of the random-phase approximation. Effects of fluctuations in the particle-particle scattering channel are also separately examined by using the many-body $T$-matrix approximation. We assess these approximations with respect to the transition temperature ${T}_{\mathrm{c}}$, the order of phase transition, as well as the so-called Nepomnyashchii-Nepomnyashchii identity, which states the vanishing off-diagonal self-energy in the low-energy and low-momentum limit. Since the construction of a consistent theory for interacting bosons which satisfies various required conditions is a long-standing problem in cold atom physics, our results would be useful for this important challenge.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.88.053633

Related papers

Order-Parameter Fluctuations in a Weakly Interacting Bose Gas near the Superfluid Transition

Harvey Gould, Victor K. Wong

The contribution of order-parameter fluctuations to the static and dynamic properties of a weakly interacting Bose gas near the Bose-Einstein condensation temperature ${T}_{c}$ is investigated via a novel approach. Self-consistent approximations for the propagator of order-parameter fluctuations $G$ are generated in successive temperature ranges closer and closer to ${T}_{c}$. Mean-field theory corresponds to assuming that the correlation of fluctuations ${G}_{2}$ is given by ${{G}_{2}}^{(1)}=GG$. This first approximation is valid in the range ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{1}<\ensuremath{\tau}=\frac{(T\ensuremath{-}{T}_{c})}{{T}_{c}}<1$, where at $\ensuremath{\tau}={\ensuremath{\tau}}_{1}$ the neglected terms are comparable to those included. In this paper we consider the second approximation ${{G}_{2}}^{(2)}=GGVGG$, which involves the first-order interaction between the fluctuations. Two independent criteria for the range of validity ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{2}<\ensuremath{\tau}<{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{1}$ of the second approximation are established. It is conjectured that the qualitative results of the present model calculation are applicable to liquid helium in the presently accessible temperature range. The predicted temperature dependences of the specific heat, superfluid density, and fourth sound are in agreement with the scaling hypothesis and available experiments in helium. The condensate density is predicted to vanish linearly with $\ensuremath{\tau}$. It is shown that the contribution of order-parameter fluctuations to the thermal conductivity diverges as ${\ensuremath{\tau}}^{\frac{\ensuremath{-}1}{3}}$ above ${T}_{c}$, and it is suggested that the absence of logarithmic factors is due to the inconsistent treatment of entropy fluctuations.

Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1971•5 citations

Theory of the weakly interacting Bose gas

Jens O. Andersen

This article reviews recent advances in the theory of the three-dimensional dilute homogeneous Bose gas at zero and finite temperature. Effective-field-theory methods are used to formulate a systematic perturbative framework that can be used to calculate the properties of a system at $T=0.$ The perturbative expansion of these properties is essentially an expansion in the gas parameter $\sqrt{{\mathrm{na}}^{3}},$ where $a$ is the $s$-wave scattering length and $n$ is the number density. In particular, the leading quantum corrections to the ground-state energy density, the condensate depletion, and long-wavelength collective excitations are rederived in an efficient and economical manner. Nonuniversal effects are also discussed. These effects are higher-order corrections that depend on properties of the interatomic potential other than the scattering length, such as the effective range. The article critically examines various approaches to the dilute Bose gas in equilibrium at finite temperature. These include the Bogoliubov approximation, the Popov approximation, the Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov approximation, the \ensuremath{\Phi}-derivable approach, optimized perturbation theory, and renormalization-group techniques. The article ends with a look at recent calculations of the critical temperature of the dilute Bose gas, which include $1/N$ techniques, lattice simulations, self-consistent calculations, and variational perturbation theory.

arXiv:cond-mat/0305138•Reviews of Modern Physics•Jul 1, 2004•518 citations

Third Order Corrections to the Ground State Energy of Bose Gases

Diane Louise Jeanne Saint Aubin

This thesis is concerned with the analysis of the ground state energy of dilute interacting Bose gases. From a physical point of view, bosonic many-body quantum systems are particularly interesting because they can exhibit quantum effects at macroscopic scales, such as Bose-Einstein condensation. This phenomenon, predicted by Bose and Einstein more than a hundred years ago and realized experimentally seventy years later by the groups of Cornell and Wieman and Ketterle, occurs when a gas of bosons is cooled down to very low temperatures. Below a critical temperature, a macroscopic fraction of the particles, known as the Bose-Einstein condensate, occupies the same one-particle state, and quantum effects become visible at the macroscopic scale. From a mathematical point of view, Bose gases are particularly interesting because their study requires effective theories. Indeed, since they consist of a very large number of interacting particles, their microscopic description is too complex to be analyzed directly. The goal is then to derive macroscopic effective theories from the microscopic many-body description. This requires, in particular, to understand the correlations between the particles generated by the interaction. An important effective theory to describe weakly interacting Bose gases was proposed by Bogoliubov. It predicts the low- energy properties of the system under certain assumptions, such as the occurrence of Bose-Einstein condensation. In this thesis, we rigorously justify third order corrections in the expansion of the ground state energy of dilute interacting Bose gases in three different settings. These corrections are consistent with the predictions from the physics literature first made by Wu. In the first result, we study an ultra-dilute Bose gas in the Gross-Pitaevskii regime. In this setting, the particles interact through a repulsive potential of the form N 2V (N·), where V is sufficiently regular and N denotes the number of particles. The leading contribution to the energy is of order N , the second order terms are of order one, and the third order corrections obtained here are of order log N/N. In our second result, we again consider a Bose gas in the Gross-Pitaevskii regime, but now with hard-sphere interactions, and establish an upper bound for the ground state energy which resolves the third order term. Finally, in the third result, we consider a dilute Bose gas in the thermodynamic limit. In this regime, the number of particles and the volume both tend to infinity while the density stays fixed. Here, we prove an upper bound for the ground state energy density which captures the third order corrections.

•Nov 12, 2026•0 citations

Bose-Einstein-condensate fluctuations versus an interparticle interaction

Sergey V. Tarasov, Vl. V. Kocharovsky, Vitaly V. Kocharovsky

We calculate the Bose-Einstein-condensate (BEC) occupation statistics vs the interparticle interaction in a dilute gas with a nonuniform condensate in a box trap within the Bogoliubov approach. The results are compared against the previously found BEC-occupation statistics in (i) an ideal gas and (ii) a weakly interacting gas with a uniform condensate. In particular, we reveal and explicitly describe an appearance of a nontrivial transition from the ideal gas to the Thomas-Fermi regime. The results include finding the main regimes of the BEC statistics---the anomalous non-Gaussian thermally dominated fluctuations and the Gaussian quantum-dominated fluctuations---as well as a crossover between them and their manifestations in a mesoscopic system. Remarkably, we show that the effect of the boundary conditions, imposed at the box trap, on the BEC fluctuations does not vanish in the thermodynamic limit of a macroscopic system even in the presence of the interparticle interactions. Finally, we discuss a challenging problem of an experimental verification of the theory of the BEC fluctuations addressing a much deeper level of the many-body statistical physics than usually studied quantities related to the mean condensate occupation.

arXiv:2007.15753•Physical Review A•Oct 13, 2020•14 citations

Interactions in low-dimensional Bose-Einstein condensates

Lee, Mark David

Recent experiments have been moving ever closer to the goal of creating cold quantum-degenerate Bose gases in one and two dimensional systems. In this thesis we investigate such systems by adapting the mean-field theories used so successfully to describe Bose-Einstein condensates in the three dimensional case. We find that the key to describing the low dimensional systems lies in an accurate description of the interactions within those systems. In three dimensions the interactions may be well approximated by a simple form in which atoms are assumed to interact in a vacuum. Many-body effects on the scattering then lead to only a small perturbation. However, in one and two dimensions we find that the inclusion of many-body effects on the scattering is crucial, even for a first order calculation. We use a many-body T-matrix to describe the interactions, and develop a simple approximation in the zero-temperature limit that involves the off-shell two-body T-matrix evaluated at a shifted interaction energy. We therefore derive expressions for the off-shell two-body T-matrix in one, two, and three dimensions, and so find expressions for the coupling parameters which describe interactions in one and two dimensional Bose gases. These lead to interaction terms in the one and two dimensional Gross-Pitaevskii equations which differ significantly from the three dimensional case. We present numerical solutions of the Gross-Pitaevskii equation in both one and two dimensions, and in one dimension we find that the results are in agreement with exact results in the extreme limits of the interaction strength. We also investigate higher order theories in the one-dimensional case, with a view to describing the cross-over from a weakly-interacting Bose-Einstein condensate to a quasicondensate as the interactions become stronger. Finally, we study the Bogoliubov-de Gennes excitation spectrum for a one dimensional condensate containing solitons. We show that it has an anomalous mode with a negative energy, and that this represents the collective motion of the soliton relative to the background condensate. (author)

•Jan 1, 2002•0 citations

Bose–Einstein condensation in self-consistent mean-field theory

Vyacheslav I. Yukalov, Elizaveta P. Yukalova

There is a wide-spread belief in the literature on Bose-Einstein condensation of interacting atoms that all variants of mean-field theory incorrectly describe the condensation phase transition, exhibiting, instead of the necessary second-order transition, a first-order transition, even for weakly interacting Bose gas. In the present paper, it is shown that a self-consistent mean-field approach is the sole mean-field theory that provides the correct second-order condensation transition for Bose systems with atomic interactions of arbitrary strength, whether weak or strong.

arXiv:1404.4848•Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Apr 15, 2014•18 citations
We compare many-body theories describing fluctuation corrections to the mean-field theory in a weakly interacting Bose-condensed gas. Using a generalized random-phase approximation, we include both density fluctuations and fluctuations in the particle-particle scattering channel in a consistent manner. We also separately examine effects of the fluctuations within the framework of the random-phase approximation. Effects of fluctuations in the particle-particle scattering channel are also separately examined by using the many-body TTT-matrix approximation. We assess these approximations with respect to the transition temperature Tc{T}_{\mathrm{c}}Tc​, the order of phase transition, as well as the so-called Nepomnyashchii-Nepomnyashchii identity, which states the vanishing off-diagonal self-energy in the low-energy and low-momentum limit. Since the construction of a consistent theory for interacting bosons which satisfies various required conditions is a long-standing problem in cold atom physics, our results would be useful for this important challenge.
The contribution of order-parameter fluctuations to the static and dynamic properties of a weakly interacting Bose gas near the Bose-Einstein condensation temperature Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ is investigated via a novel approach. Self-consistent approximations for the propagator of order-parameter fluctuations GGG are generated in successive temperature ranges closer and closer to Tc{T}_{c}Tc​. Mean-field theory corresponds to assuming that the correlation of fluctuations G2{G}_{2}G2​ is given by G2(1)=GG{{G}_{2}}^{(1)}=GGG2​(1)=GG. This first approximation is valid in the range ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{1}<\ensuremath{\tau}=\frac{(T\ensuremath{-}{T}_{c})}{{T}_{c}}<1$, where at $\ensuremath{\tau}={\ensuremath{\tau}}_{1}$ the neglected terms are comparable to those included. In this paper we consider the second approximation G2(2)=GGVGG{{G}_{2}}^{(2)}=GGVGGG2​(2)=GGVGG, which involves the first-order interaction between the fluctuations. Two independent criteria for the range of validity ${\ensuremath{\tau}}_{2}<\ensuremath{\tau}<{\ensuremath{\tau}}_{1}$ of the second approximation are established. It is conjectured that the qualitative results of the present model calculation are applicable to liquid helium in the presently accessible temperature range. The predicted temperature dependences of the specific heat, superfluid density, and fourth sound are in agreement with the scaling hypothesis and available experiments in helium. The condensate density is predicted to vanish linearly with $\ensuremath{\tau}$. It is shown that the contribution of order-parameter fluctuations to the thermal conductivity diverges as ${\ensuremath{\tau}}^{\frac{\ensuremath{-}1}{3}}$ above Tc{T}_{c}Tc​, and it is suggested that the absence of logarithmic factors is due to the inconsistent treatment of entropy fluctuations.
This article reviews recent advances in the theory of the three-dimensional dilute homogeneous Bose gas at zero and finite temperature. Effective-field-theory methods are used to formulate a systematic perturbative framework that can be used to calculate the properties of a system at T=0.T=0.T=0. The perturbative expansion of these properties is essentially an expansion in the gas parameter na3,\sqrt{{\mathrm{na}}^{3}},na3​, where aaa is the sss-wave scattering length and nnn is the number density. In particular, the leading quantum corrections to the ground-state energy density, the condensate depletion, and long-wavelength collective excitations are rederived in an efficient and economical manner. Nonuniversal effects are also discussed. These effects are higher-order corrections that depend on properties of the interatomic potential other than the scattering length, such as the effective range. The article critically examines various approaches to the dilute Bose gas in equilibrium at finite temperature. These include the Bogoliubov approximation, the Popov approximation, the Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov approximation, the \ensuremath{\Phi}-derivable approach, optimized perturbation theory, and renormalization-group techniques. The article ends with a look at recent calculations of the critical temperature of the dilute Bose gas, which include 1/N1/N1/N techniques, lattice simulations, self-consistent calculations, and variational perturbation theory.
This thesis is concerned with the analysis of the ground state energy of dilute interacting Bose gases. From a physical point of view, bosonic many-body quantum systems are particularly interesting because they can exhibit quantum effects at macroscopic scales, such as Bose-Einstein condensation. This phenomenon, predicted by Bose and Einstein more than a hundred years ago and realized experimentally seventy years later by the groups of Cornell and Wieman and Ketterle, occurs when a gas of bosons is cooled down to very low temperatures. Below a critical temperature, a macroscopic fraction of the particles, known as the Bose-Einstein condensate, occupies the same one-particle state, and quantum effects become visible at the macroscopic scale. From a mathematical point of view, Bose gases are particularly interesting because their study requires effective theories. Indeed, since they consist of a very large number of interacting particles, their microscopic description is too complex to be analyzed directly. The goal is then to derive macroscopic effective theories from the microscopic many-body description. This requires, in particular, to understand the correlations between the particles generated by the interaction. An important effective theory to describe weakly interacting Bose gases was proposed by Bogoliubov. It predicts the low- energy properties of the system under certain assumptions, such as the occurrence of Bose-Einstein condensation. In this thesis, we rigorously justify third order corrections in the expansion of the ground state energy of dilute interacting Bose gases in three different settings. These corrections are consistent with the predictions from the physics literature first made by Wu. In the first result, we study an ultra-dilute Bose gas in the Gross-Pitaevskii regime. In this setting, the particles interact through a repulsive potential of the form N 2V (N·), where V is sufficiently regular and N denotes the number of particles. The leading contribution to the energy is of order N , the second order terms are of order one, and the third order corrections obtained here are of order log N/N. In our second result, we again consider a Bose gas in the Gross-Pitaevskii regime, but now with hard-sphere interactions, and establish an upper bound for the ground state energy which resolves the third order term. Finally, in the third result, we consider a dilute Bose gas in the thermodynamic limit. In this regime, the number of particles and the volume both tend to infinity while the density stays fixed. Here, we prove an upper bound for the ground state energy density which captures the third order corrections.
We calculate the Bose-Einstein-condensate (BEC) occupation statistics vs the interparticle interaction in a dilute gas with a nonuniform condensate in a box trap within the Bogoliubov approach. The results are compared against the previously found BEC-occupation statistics in (i) an ideal gas and (ii) a weakly interacting gas with a uniform condensate. In particular, we reveal and explicitly describe an appearance of a nontrivial transition from the ideal gas to the Thomas-Fermi regime. The results include finding the main regimes of the BEC statistics---the anomalous non-Gaussian thermally dominated fluctuations and the Gaussian quantum-dominated fluctuations---as well as a crossover between them and their manifestations in a mesoscopic system. Remarkably, we show that the effect of the boundary conditions, imposed at the box trap, on the BEC fluctuations does not vanish in the thermodynamic limit of a macroscopic system even in the presence of the interparticle interactions. Finally, we discuss a challenging problem of an experimental verification of the theory of the BEC fluctuations addressing a much deeper level of the many-body statistical physics than usually studied quantities related to the mean condensate occupation.
Recent experiments have been moving ever closer to the goal of creating cold quantum-degenerate Bose gases in one and two dimensional systems. In this thesis we investigate such systems by adapting the mean-field theories used so successfully to describe Bose-Einstein condensates in the three dimensional case. We find that the key to describing the low dimensional systems lies in an accurate description of the interactions within those systems. In three dimensions the interactions may be well approximated by a simple form in which atoms are assumed to interact in a vacuum. Many-body effects on the scattering then lead to only a small perturbation. However, in one and two dimensions we find that the inclusion of many-body effects on the scattering is crucial, even for a first order calculation. We use a many-body T-matrix to describe the interactions, and develop a simple approximation in the zero-temperature limit that involves the off-shell two-body T-matrix evaluated at a shifted interaction energy. We therefore derive expressions for the off-shell two-body T-matrix in one, two, and three dimensions, and so find expressions for the coupling parameters which describe interactions in one and two dimensional Bose gases. These lead to interaction terms in the one and two dimensional Gross-Pitaevskii equations which differ significantly from the three dimensional case. We present numerical solutions of the Gross-Pitaevskii equation in both one and two dimensions, and in one dimension we find that the results are in agreement with exact results in the extreme limits of the interaction strength. We also investigate higher order theories in the one-dimensional case, with a view to describing the cross-over from a weakly-interacting Bose-Einstein condensate to a quasicondensate as the interactions become stronger. Finally, we study the Bogoliubov-de Gennes excitation spectrum for a one dimensional condensate containing solitons. We show that it has an anomalous mode with a negative energy, and that this represents the collective motion of the soliton relative to the background condensate. (author)
There is a wide-spread belief in the literature on Bose-Einstein condensation of interacting atoms that all variants of mean-field theory incorrectly describe the condensation phase transition, exhibiting, instead of the necessary second-order transition, a first-order transition, even for weakly interacting Bose gas. In the present paper, it is shown that a self-consistent mean-field approach is the sole mean-field theory that provides the correct second-order condensation transition for Bose systems with atomic interactions of arbitrary strength, whether weak or strong.