Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1308.2450

Exponential Quantum-Classical Gaps in Multiparty Nondeterministic Communication Complexity

Xiaoming Sun, Marcos Villagra

Published Aug 12, 2013• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

There are three different types of nondeterminism in quantum communication: i) $\nqp$-communication, ii) $\qma$-communication, and iii) $\qcma$-communication. In this \redout{paper} we show that multiparty $\nqp$-communication can be exponentially stronger than $\qcma$-communication. This also implies an exponential separation with respect to classical multiparty nondeterministic communication complexity. We argue that there exists a total function that is hard for $\qcma$-communication and easy for $\nqp$-communication. The proof of it involves an application of the pattern tensor method and a new lower bound for polynomial threshold degree. Another important consequence of this result is that nondeterministic rank can be exponentially lower than the discrepancy bound.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1308.2450

Related papers

Tensor Rank and Strong Quantum Nondeterminism in Multiparty Communication

Marcos Villagra, Masaki Nakanishi, Shigeru Yamashita +1 more

In this paper we study quantum nondeterminism in multiparty communication. There are three (possibly) different types of nondeterminism in quantum computation: i) strong, ii) weak with classical proofs, and iii) weak with quantum proofs. Here we focus on the first one. A strong quantum nondeterministic protocol accepts a correct input with positive probability and rejects an incorrect input with probability 1. In this work we relate strong quantum nondeterministic multiparty communication complexity to the rank of the communication tensor in the Number-On-Forehead and Number-In-Hand models. In particular, by extending the definition proposed by de Wolf to nondeterministic tensor-rank (nrank), we show that for any boolean function f when there is no prior shared entanglement between the players, 1) in the Number-On-Forehead model the cost is upper-bounded by the logarithm of nrank(f); 2) in the Number-In-Hand model the cost is lower-bounded by the logarithm of nrank(f). Furthermore, we show that when the number of players is o(log log n), we have $NQP\nsubseteq BQP$ for Number-On-Forehead communication.

arXiv:1202.6444•IEICE Transactions on Information and Systems•Dec 31, 2012•4 citations

Nondeterministic Quantum Query and Communication Complexities

Ronald de Wolf

We study nondeterministic quantum algorithms for Boolean functions f. Such algorithms have positive acceptance probability on input x iff f(x)=1. In the setting of query complexity, we show that the nondeterministic quantum complexity of a Boolean function is equal to its "nondeterministic polynomial" degree. We also prove a quantum-vs.-classical gap of 1 vs. n for nondeterministic query complexity for a total function. In the setting of communication complexity, we show that the nondeterministic quantum complexity of a two-party function is equal to the logarithm of the rank of a nondeterministic version of the communication matrix. This implies that the quantum communication complexities of the equality and disjointness functions are n+1 if we do not allow any error probability. We also exhibit a total function in which the nondeterministic quantum communication complexity is exponentially smaller than its classical counterpart.

arXiv:cs/0001014•SIAM Journal on Computing•Jan 1, 2003•84 citations

Lower Bounds for Quantum Communication Complexity

Hartmut Klauck

We prove lower bounds on the bounded error quantum communication complexity. Our methods are based on the Fourier transform of the considered functions. First we generalize a method for proving classical communication complexity lower bounds developed by Raz [Comput. Complexity, 5 (1995), pp. 205–221] to the quantum case. Applying this method, we give an exponential separation between bounded error quantum communication complexity and nondeterministic quantum communication complexity. We develop several other lower bound methods based on the Fourier transform, notably showing that $\sqrt{\bar{s}(f)/\log n}$, for the average sensitivity $\bar{s}(f)$ of a function f, yields a lower bound on the bounded error quantum communication complexity of $f((x \wedge y)\oplus z)$, where x is a Boolean word held by Alice and $y,z$ are Boolean words held by Bob. We then prove the first large lower bounds on the bounded error quantum communication complexity of functions, for which a polynomial quantum speedup is possible. For all the functions we investigate, the only previously applied general lower bound method based on discrepancy yields bounds that are $O(\log n)$.

arXiv:quant-ph/0106160•SIAM Journal on Computing•Jan 1, 2007•127 citations

On Arthur Merlin Games in Communication Complexity

Hartmut Klauck

We show several results related to interactive proof modes of communication complexity. First we show lower bounds for the QMA-communication complexity of the functions Inner Product and Disjointness. We describe a general method to prove lower bounds for QMA-communication complexity, and show how one can 'transfer' hardness under an analogous measure in the query complexity model to the communication model using Sherstov's pattern matrix method. Combining a result by Vereshchagin and the pattern matrix method we find a communication problem with AM-communication complexity $O(\log n)$, PP-communication complexity $Ω(n^{1/3})$, and QMA-communication complexity $Ω(n^{1/6})$. Hence in the world of communication complexity noninteractive quantum proof systems are not able to efficiently simulate co-nondeterminism or interaction. These results imply that the related questions in Turing machine complexity theory cannot be resolved by 'algebrizing' techniques. Finally we show that in MA-protocols there is an exponential gap between one-way protocols and two-way protocols (this refers to the interaction between Alice and Bob). This is in contrast to nondeterministic, AM-, and QMA-protocols, where one-way communication is essentially optimal.

arXiv:1101.0523•Jan 3, 2011•8 citations

Lower Bounds on Quantum Multiparty Communication Complexity

Troy Lee, Gideon Schechtman, Adi Shraibman

A major open question in communication complexity is if randomized and quantum communication are polynomially related for all total functions. So far, no gap larger than a power of two is known, despite significant efforts. We examine this question in the number-on-the-forehead model of multiparty communication complexity. We show that essentially all lower bounds known on randomized complexity in this model also hold for quantum communication. This includes bounds of size Omega(n/2k) for the k-party complexity of explicit functions, bounds for the generalized inner product function, and recent work on the multiparty complexity of disjointness. To the best of our knowledge, these are the first lower bounds of any kind on quantum communication in the general number-on-the-forehead model. We show this result in the following way. In the two-party case, there is a lower bound on quantum communication complexity in terms of a norm gamma2, which is known to subsume nearly all other techniques in the literature. For randomized complexity there is another natural bound in terms of a different norm mu which is also one of the strongest techniques available. A deep theorem in functional analysis, Grothendieck's inequality, implies that gamma2and mu are equivalent up to a constant factor. This connection is one of the major obstacles to showing a larger gap between randomized and quantum communication complexity in the two-party case. The lower bound technique in terms of the norm mu was recently extended to the multiparty number-on-the-forehead model. Here we show how the gamma2norm can be also extended to lower bound quantum multiparty complexity. Surprisingly, even in this general setting the two lower bounds, on quantum and classical communication, are still very closely related. This implies that separating quantum and classical communication in this setting will require the development of new techniques. The relation between these extensions of mu and gamma2is proved by a multi-dimensional version of Grothendieck's inequality.

IEEE Conference on Computational Complexity (CCC)•Jul 1, 2009•22 citations

On Arthur Merlin Games in Communication Complexity

Hartmut Klauck

We show several results related to interactive proof modes of communication complexity. First we show lower bounds for the QMA-communication complexity of the functions Inner Product and Disjointness. We describe a general method to prove lower bounds for QMA-communication complexity, and show how one can 'transfer' hardness under an analogous measure in the query complexity model to the communication model using Sherstov's pattern matrix method.Combining a result by Vereshchagin and the pattern matrix method we find a partial function with AM-communication complexity O(log n), PP-communication complexity Ω(n1/3), and QMA-communication complexity Ω(n1/6). Hence in the world of communication complexity noninteractive quantum proof systems are not able to efficiently simulate co-nondeterminism or interaction. These results imply that the related questions in Turing machine complexity theory cannot be resolved by 'algebrizing' techniques. Finally we show that in MA-protocols there is an exponential gap between one-way protocols and two-way protocols for a partial function (this refers to the interaction between Alice and Bob). This is in contrast to nondeterministic, AM-, and QMA-protocols, where one-way communication is essentially optimal.

IEEE Conference on Computational Complexity (CCC)•Jun 1, 2011•40 citations
There are three different types of nondeterminism in quantum communication: i) \nqp\nqp\nqp-communication, ii) \qma\qma\qma-communication, and iii) \qcma\qcma\qcma-communication. In this \redout{paper} we show that multiparty \nqp\nqp\nqp-communication can be exponentially stronger than \qcma\qcma\qcma-communication. This also implies an exponential separation with respect to classical multiparty nondeterministic communication complexity. We argue that there exists a total function that is hard for \qcma\qcma\qcma-communication and easy for \nqp\nqp\nqp-communication. The proof of it involves an application of the pattern tensor method and a new lower bound for polynomial threshold degree. Another important consequence of this result is that nondeterministic rank can be exponentially lower than the discrepancy bound.
In this paper we study quantum nondeterminism in multiparty communication. There are three (possibly) different types of nondeterminism in quantum computation: i) strong, ii) weak with classical proofs, and iii) weak with quantum proofs. Here we focus on the first one. A strong quantum nondeterministic protocol accepts a correct input with positive probability and rejects an incorrect input with probability 1. In this work we relate strong quantum nondeterministic multiparty communication complexity to the rank of the communication tensor in the Number-On-Forehead and Number-In-Hand models. In particular, by extending the definition proposed by de Wolf to nondeterministic tensor-rank (nrank), we show that for any boolean function f when there is no prior shared entanglement between the players, 1) in the Number-On-Forehead model the cost is upper-bounded by the logarithm of nrank(f); 2) in the Number-In-Hand model the cost is lower-bounded by the logarithm of nrank(f). Furthermore, we show that when the number of players is o(log log n), we have NQP⊈BQPNQP\nsubseteq BQPNQP⊈BQP for Number-On-Forehead communication.
We study nondeterministic quantum algorithms for Boolean functions f. Such algorithms have positive acceptance probability on input x iff f(x)=1. In the setting of query complexity, we show that the nondeterministic quantum complexity of a Boolean function is equal to its "nondeterministic polynomial" degree. We also prove a quantum-vs.-classical gap of 1 vs. n for nondeterministic query complexity for a total function. In the setting of communication complexity, we show that the nondeterministic quantum complexity of a two-party function is equal to the logarithm of the rank of a nondeterministic version of the communication matrix. This implies that the quantum communication complexities of the equality and disjointness functions are n+1 if we do not allow any error probability. We also exhibit a total function in which the nondeterministic quantum communication complexity is exponentially smaller than its classical counterpart.
We prove lower bounds on the bounded error quantum communication complexity. Our methods are based on the Fourier transform of the considered functions. First we generalize a method for proving classical communication complexity lower bounds developed by Raz [Comput. Complexity, 5 (1995), pp. 205–221] to the quantum case. Applying this method, we give an exponential separation between bounded error quantum communication complexity and nondeterministic quantum communication complexity. We develop several other lower bound methods based on the Fourier transform, notably showing that sˉ(f)/log⁡n\sqrt{\bar{s}(f)/\log n}sˉ(f)/logn​, for the average sensitivity sˉ(f)\bar{s}(f)sˉ(f) of a function f, yields a lower bound on the bounded error quantum communication complexity of f((x∧y)⊕z)f((x \wedge y)\oplus z)f((x∧y)⊕z), where x is a Boolean word held by Alice and y,zy,zy,z are Boolean words held by Bob. We then prove the first large lower bounds on the bounded error quantum communication complexity of functions, for which a polynomial quantum speedup is possible. For all the functions we investigate, the only previously applied general lower bound method based on discrepancy yields bounds that are O(log⁡n)O(\log n)O(logn).
We show several results related to interactive proof modes of communication complexity. First we show lower bounds for the QMA-communication complexity of the functions Inner Product and Disjointness. We describe a general method to prove lower bounds for QMA-communication complexity, and show how one can 'transfer' hardness under an analogous measure in the query complexity model to the communication model using Sherstov's pattern matrix method. Combining a result by Vereshchagin and the pattern matrix method we find a communication problem with AM-communication complexity O(log⁡n)O(\log n)O(logn), PP-communication complexity Ω(n1/3)Ω(n^{1/3})Ω(n1/3), and QMA-communication complexity Ω(n1/6)Ω(n^{1/6})Ω(n1/6). Hence in the world of communication complexity noninteractive quantum proof systems are not able to efficiently simulate co-nondeterminism or interaction. These results imply that the related questions in Turing machine complexity theory cannot be resolved by 'algebrizing' techniques. Finally we show that in MA-protocols there is an exponential gap between one-way protocols and two-way protocols (this refers to the interaction between Alice and Bob). This is in contrast to nondeterministic, AM-, and QMA-protocols, where one-way communication is essentially optimal.
A major open question in communication complexity is if randomized and quantum communication are polynomially related for all total functions. So far, no gap larger than a power of two is known, despite significant efforts. We examine this question in the number-on-the-forehead model of multiparty communication complexity. We show that essentially all lower bounds known on randomized complexity in this model also hold for quantum communication. This includes bounds of size Omega(n/2k) for the k-party complexity of explicit functions, bounds for the generalized inner product function, and recent work on the multiparty complexity of disjointness. To the best of our knowledge, these are the first lower bounds of any kind on quantum communication in the general number-on-the-forehead model. We show this result in the following way. In the two-party case, there is a lower bound on quantum communication complexity in terms of a norm gamma2, which is known to subsume nearly all other techniques in the literature. For randomized complexity there is another natural bound in terms of a different norm mu which is also one of the strongest techniques available. A deep theorem in functional analysis, Grothendieck's inequality, implies that gamma2and mu are equivalent up to a constant factor. This connection is one of the major obstacles to showing a larger gap between randomized and quantum communication complexity in the two-party case. The lower bound technique in terms of the norm mu was recently extended to the multiparty number-on-the-forehead model. Here we show how the gamma2norm can be also extended to lower bound quantum multiparty complexity. Surprisingly, even in this general setting the two lower bounds, on quantum and classical communication, are still very closely related. This implies that separating quantum and classical communication in this setting will require the development of new techniques. The relation between these extensions of mu and gamma2is proved by a multi-dimensional version of Grothendieck's inequality.
We show several results related to interactive proof modes of communication complexity. First we show lower bounds for the QMA-communication complexity of the functions Inner Product and Disjointness. We describe a general method to prove lower bounds for QMA-communication complexity, and show how one can 'transfer' hardness under an analogous measure in the query complexity model to the communication model using Sherstov's pattern matrix method.Combining a result by Vereshchagin and the pattern matrix method we find a partial function with AM-communication complexity O(log n), PP-communication complexity Ω(n1/3), and QMA-communication complexity Ω(n1/6). Hence in the world of communication complexity noninteractive quantum proof systems are not able to efficiently simulate co-nondeterminism or interaction. These results imply that the related questions in Turing machine complexity theory cannot be resolved by 'algebrizing' techniques. Finally we show that in MA-protocols there is an exponential gap between one-way protocols and two-way protocols for a partial function (this refers to the interaction between Alice and Bob). This is in contrast to nondeterministic, AM-, and QMA-protocols, where one-way communication is essentially optimal.