Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1307.1454 · Physical Review A

Relative volume of separable bipartite states

Rajeev Singh, Ravi Kunjwal, R. Simon

Published Feb 10, 2014• 10 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Every choice of an orthonormal frame in the $d$-dimensional Hilbert space of a system corresponds to one set of all mutually commuting density matrices or, equivalently, to the classical statistical state space of the system; the quantum state space itself can thus be profitably viewed as an $\text{SU}(d)$ orbit of classical state spaces, one for each orthonormal frame. We exploit this connection to study the relative volume of separable states of a bipartite quantum system. While the two-qubit case is studied in considerable analytic detail, for higher-dimensional systems we fall back on Monte Carlo. Several insights seem to emerge from our study.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.89.022308

Related papers

Volume of the set of separable states

Karol Życzkowski, Paweł Horodecki, Anna Sanpera +1 more

The question of how many entangled or, respectively, separable states there are in the set of all quantum states is considered. We propose a natural measure in the space of density matrices $\ensuremath{\varrho}$ describing $N$-dimensional quantum systems. We prove that, under this measure, the set of separable states possesses a nonzero volume. Analytical lower and upper bounds of this volume are also derived for $N=2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}2$ and $N=2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}3$ cases. Finally, numerical Monte Carlo calculations allow us to estimate the volume of separable states, providing numerical evidence that it decreases exponentially with the dimension of the composite system. We have also analyzed a conditional measure of separability under the condition of fixed purity. Our results display a clear dualism between purity and separability: entanglement is typical of pure states, while separability is connected with quantum mixtures. In particular, states of sufficiently low purity are necessarily separable.

arXiv:quant-ph/9804024•Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1998•1,422 citations

Volumes of conditioned bipartite state spaces

Simon Milz, Walter T. Strunz

We analyze the metric properties of conditioned quantum state spaces These spaces are the convex sets of density matrices that, when partially traced over m degrees of freedom, respectively yield the given n × n density matrix η . For the case n = 2, the volume of equipped with the Hilbert–Schmidt measure can be conjectured to be a simple polynomial of the radius of η in the Bloch-ball. Remarkably, for we find numerically that the probability to find a separable state in is independent of η (except for η pure). For , the same holds for , the probability to find a state with a positive partial transpose in . These results are proven analytically for the case of the family of 4 × 4 X -states, and thoroughly numerically investigated for the general case. The important implications of these findings for the clarification of open problems in quantum theory are pointed out and discussed.

arXiv:1408.3666•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Dec 22, 2014•21 citations

Volume of the set of separable states. II

Karol Życzkowski

The problem of how many entangled or, respectively, separable states there are in the set of all quantum states is investigated. We study to what extent the choice of a measure in the space of density matrices $\ensuremath{\varrho}$ describing N-dimensional quantum systems affects the results obtained. We demonstrate that the link between the purity of the mixed states and the probability of entanglement is not sensitive to the measure chosen. Since the criterion of partial transposition is not sufficient to distinguish all separable states for $N>~8$, we develop an efficient algorithm to calculate numerically the entanglement of formation of a given mixed quantum state, which allows us to compute the volume of separable states for $N=8$ and to estimate the volume of the bound entangled states in this case.

arXiv:quant-ph/9902050•Physical Review A•Nov 1, 1999•260 citations

Volumes and hyperareas of the spaces of separable and nonseparable qubit-qutrit systems: Initial numerical analyses

Paul B. Slater

Paralleling our recent computationally-intensive work for the case N=4 (quant-ph/0308037), we undertake the task for N=6 of computing to high numerical accuracy, the formulas of Sommers and Zyczkowski (quant-ph/0304041) for the (N^2-1)-dimensional volume and (N^2-2)-dimensional hyperarea of the (separable and nonseparable) N x N density matrices, based on the Bures (minimal monotone) metric. At the same time, we estimate the unknown volumes and hyperareas based on a number of other monotone metrics of interest. Additionally, we estimate -- but with perhaps unavoidably diminished accuracy -- all these volume and hyperarea quantities, when restricted to the ``small'' subset of 6 x 6 density matrices that are separable (classically correlated) in nature. The ratios of separable to separable plus nonseparable volumes, then, yield corresponding estimates of the ``probabilities of separability''. We are particularly interested in exploring the possibility that a number of the various 35-dimensional volumes and 34-dimensional hyperareas, possess exact values -- which we had, in fact, conjectured to be the case for the qubit-qubit systems (N=4), with the ``silver mean'', sqrt{2}-1, appearing to play a fundamental role as regards the separable states.

arXiv:quant-ph/0405114•May 20, 2004•5 citations

Conditionalq-entropies and quantum separability: a numerical exploration

Josep Amengual i Batle, Angel Ricardo Plastino, Montserrat Casas +1 more

We revisit the relationship between quantum separability and the sign of the relative q -entropies of composite quantum systems. The q -entropies depend on the density matrix eigenvalues p i through the quantity ω q = ∑ i p q i . Rényi's and Tsallis' measures constitute particular instances of these entropies. We perform a systematic numerical survey of the space of mixed states of two-qubit systems in order to determine, as a function of the degree of mixture, and for different values of the entropic parameter q , the volume in state space occupied by those states characterized by positive values of the relative entropy. Similar calculations are performed for qubit–qutrit systems and for composite systems described by Hilbert spaces of larger dimensionality. We pay particular attention to the limit case q → ∞. Our numerical results indicate that, as the dimensionalities of both subsystems increase, typical mixed states of composite quantum systems tend, as far as their relative q -entropies are concerned, to behave in a classical way.

arXiv:quant-ph/0207129•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Nov 19, 2002•51 citations

A prioriprobability that a qubit–qutrit pair is separable

Paul B. Slater

We extend to arbitrarily coupled pairs of qubits (two-state quantum systems) and qutrits (three-state quantum systems) our earlier study (Slater 2002 Quantum Inf. Process. 1 387), which was concerned with the simplest instance of entangled quantum systems, pairs of qubits. As in that analysis—again on the basis of numerical (quasi-Monte Carlo) integration results, but now in a still higher-dimensional space (35D versus 15D)—we examine a conjecture that the Bures/SD (statistical distinguishability) probability that arbitrarily paired qubits and qutrits are separable (unentangled) has a simple exact value, , where u = 2 20 × 3 3 × 5 × 7 and v = 19 × 23 × 29 × 31 × 37 × 41 × 43 (the product of consecutive primes). This is considerably less than the conjectured value of the Bures/SD probability, , in the qubit–qubit case. Both of these conjectures, in turn, rely upon ones to the effect that the SD volumes of separable states assume certain remarkable forms, involving 'primorial' numbers. We also estimate the SD area of the boundary of separable qubit–qutrit states, and provide preliminary calculations of the Bures/SD probability of separability in the general qubit–qubit–qubit and qutrit–qutrit cases.

arXiv:quant-ph/0211150•Journal of Optics B Quantum and Semiclassical Optics•Oct 16, 2003•14 citations
Every choice of an orthonormal frame in the ddd-dimensional Hilbert space of a system corresponds to one set of all mutually commuting density matrices or, equivalently, to the classical statistical state space of the system; the quantum state space itself can thus be profitably viewed as an SU(d)\text{SU}(d)SU(d) orbit of classical state spaces, one for each orthonormal frame. We exploit this connection to study the relative volume of separable states of a bipartite quantum system. While the two-qubit case is studied in considerable analytic detail, for higher-dimensional systems we fall back on Monte Carlo. Several insights seem to emerge from our study.
The question of how many entangled or, respectively, separable states there are in the set of all quantum states is considered. We propose a natural measure in the space of density matrices $\ensuremath{\varrho}$ describing NNN-dimensional quantum systems. We prove that, under this measure, the set of separable states possesses a nonzero volume. Analytical lower and upper bounds of this volume are also derived for $N=2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}2$ and $N=2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}3$ cases. Finally, numerical Monte Carlo calculations allow us to estimate the volume of separable states, providing numerical evidence that it decreases exponentially with the dimension of the composite system. We have also analyzed a conditional measure of separability under the condition of fixed purity. Our results display a clear dualism between purity and separability: entanglement is typical of pure states, while separability is connected with quantum mixtures. In particular, states of sufficiently low purity are necessarily separable.
We analyze the metric properties of conditioned quantum state spaces These spaces are the convex sets of density matrices that, when partially traced over m degrees of freedom, respectively yield the given n × n density matrix η . For the case n = 2, the volume of equipped with the Hilbert–Schmidt measure can be conjectured to be a simple polynomial of the radius of η in the Bloch-ball. Remarkably, for we find numerically that the probability to find a separable state in is independent of η (except for η pure). For , the same holds for , the probability to find a state with a positive partial transpose in . These results are proven analytically for the case of the family of 4 × 4 X -states, and thoroughly numerically investigated for the general case. The important implications of these findings for the clarification of open problems in quantum theory are pointed out and discussed.
The problem of how many entangled or, respectively, separable states there are in the set of all quantum states is investigated. We study to what extent the choice of a measure in the space of density matrices $\ensuremath{\varrho}$ describing N-dimensional quantum systems affects the results obtained. We demonstrate that the link between the purity of the mixed states and the probability of entanglement is not sensitive to the measure chosen. Since the criterion of partial transposition is not sufficient to distinguish all separable states for N> 8N>~8N> 8, we develop an efficient algorithm to calculate numerically the entanglement of formation of a given mixed quantum state, which allows us to compute the volume of separable states for N=8N=8N=8 and to estimate the volume of the bound entangled states in this case.
Paralleling our recent computationally-intensive work for the case N=4 (quant-ph/0308037), we undertake the task for N=6 of computing to high numerical accuracy, the formulas of Sommers and Zyczkowski (quant-ph/0304041) for the (N^2-1)-dimensional volume and (N^2-2)-dimensional hyperarea of the (separable and nonseparable) N x N density matrices, based on the Bures (minimal monotone) metric. At the same time, we estimate the unknown volumes and hyperareas based on a number of other monotone metrics of interest. Additionally, we estimate -- but with perhaps unavoidably diminished accuracy -- all these volume and hyperarea quantities, when restricted to the ``small'' subset of 6 x 6 density matrices that are separable (classically correlated) in nature. The ratios of separable to separable plus nonseparable volumes, then, yield corresponding estimates of the ``probabilities of separability''. We are particularly interested in exploring the possibility that a number of the various 35-dimensional volumes and 34-dimensional hyperareas, possess exact values -- which we had, in fact, conjectured to be the case for the qubit-qubit systems (N=4), with the ``silver mean'', sqrt{2}-1, appearing to play a fundamental role as regards the separable states.
We revisit the relationship between quantum separability and the sign of the relative q -entropies of composite quantum systems. The q -entropies depend on the density matrix eigenvalues p i through the quantity ω q = ∑ i p q i . Rényi's and Tsallis' measures constitute particular instances of these entropies. We perform a systematic numerical survey of the space of mixed states of two-qubit systems in order to determine, as a function of the degree of mixture, and for different values of the entropic parameter q , the volume in state space occupied by those states characterized by positive values of the relative entropy. Similar calculations are performed for qubit–qutrit systems and for composite systems described by Hilbert spaces of larger dimensionality. We pay particular attention to the limit case q → ∞. Our numerical results indicate that, as the dimensionalities of both subsystems increase, typical mixed states of composite quantum systems tend, as far as their relative q -entropies are concerned, to behave in a classical way.
We extend to arbitrarily coupled pairs of qubits (two-state quantum systems) and qutrits (three-state quantum systems) our earlier study (Slater 2002 Quantum Inf. Process. 1 387), which was concerned with the simplest instance of entangled quantum systems, pairs of qubits. As in that analysis—again on the basis of numerical (quasi-Monte Carlo) integration results, but now in a still higher-dimensional space (35D versus 15D)—we examine a conjecture that the Bures/SD (statistical distinguishability) probability that arbitrarily paired qubits and qutrits are separable (unentangled) has a simple exact value, , where u = 2 20 × 3 3 × 5 × 7 and v = 19 × 23 × 29 × 31 × 37 × 41 × 43 (the product of consecutive primes). This is considerably less than the conjectured value of the Bures/SD probability, , in the qubit–qubit case. Both of these conjectures, in turn, rely upon ones to the effect that the SD volumes of separable states assume certain remarkable forms, involving 'primorial' numbers. We also estimate the SD area of the boundary of separable qubit–qutrit states, and provide preliminary calculations of the Bures/SD probability of separability in the general qubit–qubit–qubit and qutrit–qutrit cases.