Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1306.4191 · Physical Review Letters

Precision-Guaranteed Quantum Tomography

Takanori Sugiyama, Peter S. Turner, Mio Murao

Published Oct 17, 2013• 56 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Quantum state tomography is currently the standard tool for verifying that a state prepared in the lab is close to an ideal target state, but up to now there have been no rigorous methods for evaluating the precision of the state preparation in tomographic experiments. We propose a new estimator for quantum state tomography, and prove that the (always physical) estimates will be close to the true prepared state with a high probability. We derive an explicit formula for evaluating how high the probability is for an arbitrary finite-dimensional system and explicitly give the one- and two-qubit cases as examples. This formula applies for any informationally complete sets of measurements, arbitrary finite number of data sets, and general loss functions including the infidelity, the Hilbert-Schmidt, and the trace distances. Using the formula, we can evaluate not only the difference between the estimated and prepared states, but also the difference between the prepared and target states. This is the first result directly applicable to the problem of evaluating the precision of estimation and preparation in quantum tomographic experiments.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.111.160406

Related papers

Reliable Quantum State Tomography

Matthias Christandl, Renato Renner

Quantum state tomography is the task of inferring the state of a quantum system by appropriate measurements. Since the frequency distributions of the outcomes of any finite number of measurements will generally deviate from their asymptotic limits, the estimates computed by standard methods do not in general coincide with the true state and, therefore, have no operational significance unless their accuracy is defined in terms of error bounds. Here we show that quantum state tomography, together with an appropriate data analysis procedure, yields reliable and tight error bounds, specified in terms of confidence regions-a concept originating from classical statistics. Confidence regions are subsets of the state space in which the true state lies with high probability, independently of any prior assumption on the distribution of the possible states. Our method for computing confidence regions can be applied to arbitrary measurements including fully coherent ones; it is practical and particularly well suited for tomography on systems consisting of a small number of qubits, which are currently in the focus of interest in experimental quantum information science.

arXiv:1108.5329•Physical Review Letters•Sep 19, 2012•218 citations

Reliable confidence regions for quantum tomography using distribution moments

D. O. Norkin, Evgeniy O. Kiktenko, Aleksey K. Fedorov

Quantum tomography is a widely applicable method for reconstructing unknown quantum states and processes. However, its applications in quantum technologies usually also require estimating the difference between prepared and target quantum states with reliable confidence intervals. In this work we suggest a computationally efficient and reliable scheme for determining well-justified error bars for quantum tomography. We approximate the probability distribution of the Hilbert-Schmidt distance between the target state and the estimation, which is given by the linear inversion, by calculating its two moments. We also present a generalization of this approach for quantum process tomography and deriving confidence intervals for affine functions. We benchmark our approach for a number of quantum tomography protocols using both simulation and demonstration with the use of a cloud-accessible quantum processor. The obtained results pave the way for the use of the suggested scheme for the complete characterization of quantum systems of various natures.

arXiv:2307.12823•Physical Review A•Mar 14, 2024•1 citation

Reliable characterization of super-accurate quantum operations

Takanori Sugiyama, Shinpei Imori, Fuyuhiko Tanaka

Improving accuracy of quantum operations is an indispensable task for realizing a practical quantum computer. A reliable method for characterizing quantum operations is a useful tool towards further improvements of the accuracy. Quantum tomography and randomized benchmarking protocols are current standard methods for evaluating accuracies of quantum operations, but their estimates lack reliability because of high sensitivity to state preparation and measurement (SPAM) errors or they use multiple approximations. Here we propose a self-consistent quantum tomographic method. First, we derive a sufficient condition on experiments for characterizing quantum operations except for the gauge degrees of freedom. Second, we propose a new self-consistent estimator. We mathematically prove that, when the sufficient condition is satisfied, the estimator provides estimates that are always physical and converge to the gauge-equivalence class of the quantum operations of interest at the limit of data size going to infinity. We also derive the rate of the asymptotic convergence. These results theoretically guarantee that the method makes it possible to reliably characterize accurate quantum operations.

•Jun 7, 2018•2 citations

Error probability analysis in quantum tomography: A tool for evaluating experiments

Takanori Sugiyama, Peter S. Turner, Mio Murao

We expand the scope of the statistical notion of error probability, that is, how often large deviations are observed in an experiment, to make it directly applicable to quantum tomography. We verify that the error probability can decrease at most exponentially in the number of trials, we derive the explicit rate that bounds this decrease, and we show that a maximum likelihood estimator achieves this bound. We also show that the statistical notion of identifiability coincides with the tomographic notion of informational completeness. Our result implies that two quantum tomographic apparatuses that have the same risk function (e.g., variance) can have different error probability, and we give an example in one-qubit-state tomography. Thus by combining these two approaches we can evaluate, in a reconstruction-independent way, the performance of such experiments more discerningly.

arXiv:1009.2164•Physical Review A•Jan 18, 2011•14 citations

High-accuracy adaptive quantum tomography for high-dimensional quantum systems

Luciano Pereira, Daniel Martínez, Gustavo Cañas +4 more

The accuracy of estimating $d$-dimensional quantum states is limited by the Gill-Massar bound. It can be saturated in the qubit ($d=2$) scenario using adaptive standard quantum tomography. In higher dimensions, however, this is not the case and the accuracy achievable with adaptive quantum tomography quickly deteriorates with increasing $d$. Moreover, it is not known whether or not the Gill-Massar bound can be reached for an arbitrary $d$. To overcome this limitation, we introduce an adaptive tomographic method that is characterized by a precision that is better than half that of the Gill-Massar bound for any finite dimension. This provides a new achievable accuracy limit for quantum state estimation. We demonstrate the high-accuracy of our method by estimating the state of 10-dimensional quantum systems. With the advent of new technologies capable of high-dimensional quantum information processing, our results become critically relevant as state reconstruction is an essential tool for certifying the proper operation of quantum devices.

arXiv:2009.04791•Sep 10, 2020•3 citations

Precision-guaranteed quantum metrology

Takanori Sugiyama

Quantum metrology is a general term for methods to precisely estimate the value of an unknown parameter by actively using quantum resources. In particular, some classes of entangled states can be used to significantly suppress the estimation error. Here we derive a formula for rigorously evaluating an upper bound for the estimation error in a general setting of quantum metrology with arbitrary finite data sets. Unlike in the standard approach, where lower bounds for the error are evaluated in an ideal setting with almost infinite data, our method rigorously guarantees the estimation precision in realistic settings with finite data. We also prove that our upper bound shows the Heisenberg limit scaling whenever the linearized uncertainty, which is a popular benchmark in the standard approach, shows it. As an example, we apply our result to a Ramsey interferometer, and numerically show that the upper bound can exhibit the quantum enhancement of precision for finite data.

arXiv:1407.8065•Physical Review A•Apr 27, 2015•13 citations
Quantum state tomography is currently the standard tool for verifying that a state prepared in the lab is close to an ideal target state, but up to now there have been no rigorous methods for evaluating the precision of the state preparation in tomographic experiments. We propose a new estimator for quantum state tomography, and prove that the (always physical) estimates will be close to the true prepared state with a high probability. We derive an explicit formula for evaluating how high the probability is for an arbitrary finite-dimensional system and explicitly give the one- and two-qubit cases as examples. This formula applies for any informationally complete sets of measurements, arbitrary finite number of data sets, and general loss functions including the infidelity, the Hilbert-Schmidt, and the trace distances. Using the formula, we can evaluate not only the difference between the estimated and prepared states, but also the difference between the prepared and target states. This is the first result directly applicable to the problem of evaluating the precision of estimation and preparation in quantum tomographic experiments.
Quantum state tomography is the task of inferring the state of a quantum system by appropriate measurements. Since the frequency distributions of the outcomes of any finite number of measurements will generally deviate from their asymptotic limits, the estimates computed by standard methods do not in general coincide with the true state and, therefore, have no operational significance unless their accuracy is defined in terms of error bounds. Here we show that quantum state tomography, together with an appropriate data analysis procedure, yields reliable and tight error bounds, specified in terms of confidence regions-a concept originating from classical statistics. Confidence regions are subsets of the state space in which the true state lies with high probability, independently of any prior assumption on the distribution of the possible states. Our method for computing confidence regions can be applied to arbitrary measurements including fully coherent ones; it is practical and particularly well suited for tomography on systems consisting of a small number of qubits, which are currently in the focus of interest in experimental quantum information science.
Quantum tomography is a widely applicable method for reconstructing unknown quantum states and processes. However, its applications in quantum technologies usually also require estimating the difference between prepared and target quantum states with reliable confidence intervals. In this work we suggest a computationally efficient and reliable scheme for determining well-justified error bars for quantum tomography. We approximate the probability distribution of the Hilbert-Schmidt distance between the target state and the estimation, which is given by the linear inversion, by calculating its two moments. We also present a generalization of this approach for quantum process tomography and deriving confidence intervals for affine functions. We benchmark our approach for a number of quantum tomography protocols using both simulation and demonstration with the use of a cloud-accessible quantum processor. The obtained results pave the way for the use of the suggested scheme for the complete characterization of quantum systems of various natures.
Improving accuracy of quantum operations is an indispensable task for realizing a practical quantum computer. A reliable method for characterizing quantum operations is a useful tool towards further improvements of the accuracy. Quantum tomography and randomized benchmarking protocols are current standard methods for evaluating accuracies of quantum operations, but their estimates lack reliability because of high sensitivity to state preparation and measurement (SPAM) errors or they use multiple approximations. Here we propose a self-consistent quantum tomographic method. First, we derive a sufficient condition on experiments for characterizing quantum operations except for the gauge degrees of freedom. Second, we propose a new self-consistent estimator. We mathematically prove that, when the sufficient condition is satisfied, the estimator provides estimates that are always physical and converge to the gauge-equivalence class of the quantum operations of interest at the limit of data size going to infinity. We also derive the rate of the asymptotic convergence. These results theoretically guarantee that the method makes it possible to reliably characterize accurate quantum operations.
We expand the scope of the statistical notion of error probability, that is, how often large deviations are observed in an experiment, to make it directly applicable to quantum tomography. We verify that the error probability can decrease at most exponentially in the number of trials, we derive the explicit rate that bounds this decrease, and we show that a maximum likelihood estimator achieves this bound. We also show that the statistical notion of identifiability coincides with the tomographic notion of informational completeness. Our result implies that two quantum tomographic apparatuses that have the same risk function (e.g., variance) can have different error probability, and we give an example in one-qubit-state tomography. Thus by combining these two approaches we can evaluate, in a reconstruction-independent way, the performance of such experiments more discerningly.
The accuracy of estimating ddd-dimensional quantum states is limited by the Gill-Massar bound. It can be saturated in the qubit (d=2d=2d=2) scenario using adaptive standard quantum tomography. In higher dimensions, however, this is not the case and the accuracy achievable with adaptive quantum tomography quickly deteriorates with increasing ddd. Moreover, it is not known whether or not the Gill-Massar bound can be reached for an arbitrary ddd. To overcome this limitation, we introduce an adaptive tomographic method that is characterized by a precision that is better than half that of the Gill-Massar bound for any finite dimension. This provides a new achievable accuracy limit for quantum state estimation. We demonstrate the high-accuracy of our method by estimating the state of 10-dimensional quantum systems. With the advent of new technologies capable of high-dimensional quantum information processing, our results become critically relevant as state reconstruction is an essential tool for certifying the proper operation of quantum devices.
Quantum metrology is a general term for methods to precisely estimate the value of an unknown parameter by actively using quantum resources. In particular, some classes of entangled states can be used to significantly suppress the estimation error. Here we derive a formula for rigorously evaluating an upper bound for the estimation error in a general setting of quantum metrology with arbitrary finite data sets. Unlike in the standard approach, where lower bounds for the error are evaluated in an ideal setting with almost infinite data, our method rigorously guarantees the estimation precision in realistic settings with finite data. We also prove that our upper bound shows the Heisenberg limit scaling whenever the linearized uncertainty, which is a popular benchmark in the standard approach, shows it. As an example, we apply our result to a Ramsey interferometer, and numerically show that the upper bound can exhibit the quantum enhancement of precision for finite data.