Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1306.1279 · Physical Review Letters

Stochastic Heisenberg Limit: Optimal Estimation of a Fluctuating Phase

Dominic William Berry, Michael J. W. Hall, Howard M. Wiseman

Published Sep 10, 2013• 34 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The ultimate limits to estimating a fluctuating phase imposed on an optical beam can be found using the recently derived continuous quantum Cram\'er-Rao bound. For Gaussian stationary statistics, and a phase spectrum scaling asymptotically as ${\ensuremath{\omega}}^{\ensuremath{-}p}$ with $p>1$, the minimum mean-square error in any (single-time) phase estimate scales as ${\mathcal{N}}^{\ensuremath{-}2(p\ensuremath{-}1)/(p+1)}$, where $\mathcal{N}$ is the photon flux. This gives the usual Heisenberg limit for a constant phase (as the limit $p\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$) and provides a stochastic Heisenberg limit for fluctuating phases. For $p=2$ (Brownian motion), this limit can be attained by phase tracking.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.111.113601

Related papers

Adaptive estimation of a time-varying phase with coherent states: Smoothing can give an unbounded improvement over filtering

Kiarn T. Laverick, Howard M. Wiseman, Hossein T. Dinani +1 more

The problem of measuring a time-varying phase, even when the statistics of the variation is known, is considerably harder than that of measuring a constant phase. In particular, the usual bounds on accuracy, such as the $1/(4\overline{n})$ standard quantum limit with coherent states, do not apply. Here, by restricting to coherent states, we are able to analytically obtain the achievable accuracy, the equivalent of the standard quantum limit, for a wide class of phase variation. In particular, we consider the case where the phase has Gaussian statistics and a power-law spectrum equal to ${\ensuremath{\kappa}}^{p\ensuremath{-}1}/{|\ensuremath{\omega}|}^{p}$ for large $\ensuremath{\omega}$, for some $p>1$. For coherent states with mean photon flux $\mathcal{N}$, we give the quantum Cram\'er-Rao bound on the mean-square phase error as ${[psin(\ensuremath{\pi}/p)]}^{\ensuremath{-}1}{(4\mathcal{N}/\ensuremath{\kappa})}^{\ensuremath{-}(p\ensuremath{-}1)/p}$. Next, we consider whether the bound can be achieved by an adaptive homodyne measurement in the limit $\mathcal{N}/\ensuremath{\kappa}\ensuremath{\gg}1$, which allows the photocurrent to be linearized. Applying the optimal filtering for the resultant linear Gaussian system, we find the same scaling with $\mathcal{N}$, but with a prefactor larger by a factor of $p$. By contrast, if we employ optimal smoothing we can exactly obtain the quantum Cram\'er-Rao bound. That is, contrary to previously considered ($p=2$) cases of phase estimation, here the improvement offered by smoothing over filtering is not limited to a factor of 2 but rather can be unbounded by a factor of $p$. We also study numerically the performance of these estimators for an adaptive measurement in the limit where $\mathcal{N}/\ensuremath{\kappa}$ is not large and find a more complicated picture.

arXiv:1710.08548•Physical Review A•Apr 23, 2018•9 citations

Optimal Heisenberg-style bounds for the average performance of arbitrary phase estimates

Dominic William Berry, Michael J. W. Hall, Marcin Zwierz +1 more

The ultimate bound to the accuracy of phase estimates is often assumed to be given by the Heisenberg limit. Recent work seemed to indicate that this bound can be violated, yielding measurements with much higher accuracy than was previously expected. The Heisenberg limit can be restored as a rigorous bound to the accuracy provided one considers the accuracy averaged over the possible values of the unknown phase, as we have recently shown [Phys. Rev. A 85, 041802(R) (2012)]. Here we present an expanded proof of this result together with a number of additional results, including the proof of a previously conjectured stronger bound in the asymptotic limit. Other measures of the accuracy are examined, as well as other restrictions on the generator of the phase shifts. We provide expanded numerical results for the minimum error and asymptotic expansions. The significance of the results claiming violation of the Heisenberg limit is assessed, followed by a detailed discussion of the limitations of the Cram\'er-Rao bound.

arXiv:1209.3547•Physical Review A•Nov 13, 2012•48 citations

Quantum Bell-Ziv-Zakai Bounds and Heisenberg Limits for Waveform Estimation

Dominic William Berry, Mankei Tsang, Michael J. W. Hall +1 more

We propose quantum versions of the Bell-Ziv-Zakai lower bounds for the error in multiparameter estimation.As an application, we consider measurement of a time-varying optical phase signal with stationary Gaussian prior statistics and a power-law spectrum ∼1=jωj p , with p > 1.With no other assumptions, we show that the mean-square error has a lower bound scaling as 1=N 2ðp-1Þ=ðpþ1Þ , where N is the time-averaged mean photon flux.Moreover, we show that this scaling is achievable by sampling and interpolation, for any p > 1.This bound is thus a rigorous generalization of the Heisenberg limit, for measurement of a single unknown optical phase, to a stochastically varying optical phase.

arXiv:1409.7877•Physical Review X•Aug 18, 2015•78 citations

Heisenberg limit in phase measurements: the threshold detection approach

Dariya Salykina, V. S. Liamin, Valentin L. Gorshenin +2 more

The ultimate precision of phase estimation is limited by the Heisenberg scaling $Δϕ_0 = K/N$, where $K\sim1$ is a numerical prefactor and $N$ is the mean number of photons interacting with the phase shifting object(s). However, achieving this fundamental limit often comes at the cost of an extremely narrow high-sensitive range, rendering schemes impractical. We analyze the precision limits of phase measurements in single- and two-arm optical interferometers with input Gaussian states. We consider two detection methods: conventional homodyne measurement and non-Gaussian threshold detection that saturates the quantum Cramér-Rao bound. We characterize the performance by two complementary metrics: the peak sensitivity $Δϕ_0$ and the width $δϕ$ of the high-sensitivity range. We demonstrate that Heisenberg scaling is attainable in all configurations considered. However, we reveal that $δϕ$ strongly depends on $K$. We derive an approximate analytic expression that describes this trade-off. We show also that the two-arm interferometer with antisymmetrically squeezed inputs exhibits exceptional performance, simultaneously achieving Heisenberg-limited sensitivity and a broad high-sensitivity range $δϕ=π/2$.

arXiv:2505.06714•May 10, 2025•0 citations

Quantum-enhanced stochastic phase estimation with the SU(1,1) interferometer

Kaimin Zheng, Minghao Mi, Ben Wang +6 more

Quantum stochastic phase estimation has many applications in the precise measurement of various physical parameters. Similar to the estimation of a constant phase, there is a standard quantum limit for stochastic phase estimation, which can be obtained with the Mach–Zehnder interferometer and coherent input state. Recently, it has been shown that the stochastic standard quantum limit can be surpassed with nonclassical resources such as squeezed light. However, practical methods to achieve quantum enhancement in the stochastic phase estimation remain largely unexplored. Here we propose a method utilizing the SU(1,1) interferometer and coherent input states to estimate a stochastic optical phase. As an example, we investigate the Ornstein–Uhlenback stochastic phase. We analyze the performance of this method for three key estimation problems: prediction, tracking, and smoothing. The results show significant reduction of the mean square error compared with the Mach–Zehnder interferometer under the same photon number flux inside the interferometers. In particular, we show that the method with the SU(1,1) interferometer can achieve fundamental quantum scaling, achieve stochastic Heisenberg scaling, and surpass the precision of the canonical measurement.

arXiv:2008.02969•Photonics Research•Aug 4, 2020•19 citations

Ziv-Zakai Error Bounds for Quantum Parameter Estimation

Mankei Tsang

I propose quantum versions of the Ziv-Zakai bounds as alternatives to the widely used quantum Cramér-Rao bounds for quantum parameter estimation. From a simple form of the proposed bounds, I derive both a Heisenberg error limit that scales with the average energy and a limit similar to the quantum Cramér-Rao bound that scales with the energy variance. These results are further illustrated by applying the bound to a few examples of optical phase estimation, which show that a quantum Ziv-Zakai bound can be much higher and thus tighter than a quantum Cramér-Rao bound for states with highly non-gaussian photon-number statistics in certain regimes and also stay close to the latter where the latter is expected to be tight.

arXiv:1111.3568•Physical Review Letters•Jun 6, 2012•139 citations
The ultimate limits to estimating a fluctuating phase imposed on an optical beam can be found using the recently derived continuous quantum Cram'er-Rao bound. For Gaussian stationary statistics, and a phase spectrum scaling asymptotically as \ensuremathω\ensuremath−p{\ensuremath{\omega}}^{\ensuremath{-}p}\ensuremathω\ensuremath−p with p>1p>1p>1, the minimum mean-square error in any (single-time) phase estimate scales as N\ensuremath−2(p\ensuremath−1)/(p+1){\mathcal{N}}^{\ensuremath{-}2(p\ensuremath{-}1)/(p+1)}N\ensuremath−2(p\ensuremath−1)/(p+1), where N\mathcal{N}N is the photon flux. This gives the usual Heisenberg limit for a constant phase (as the limit p\ensuremath→\ensuremath∞p\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}p\ensuremath→\ensuremath∞) and provides a stochastic Heisenberg limit for fluctuating phases. For p=2p=2p=2 (Brownian motion), this limit can be attained by phase tracking.
The problem of measuring a time-varying phase, even when the statistics of the variation is known, is considerably harder than that of measuring a constant phase. In particular, the usual bounds on accuracy, such as the 1/(4n‾)1/(4\overline{n})1/(4n) standard quantum limit with coherent states, do not apply. Here, by restricting to coherent states, we are able to analytically obtain the achievable accuracy, the equivalent of the standard quantum limit, for a wide class of phase variation. In particular, we consider the case where the phase has Gaussian statistics and a power-law spectrum equal to ${\ensuremath{\kappa}}^{p\ensuremath{-}1}/{|\ensuremath{\omega}|}^{p}$ for large $\ensuremath{\omega}$, for some p>1p>1p>1. For coherent states with mean photon flux N\mathcal{N}N, we give the quantum Cram\'er-Rao bound on the mean-square phase error as ${[psin(\ensuremath{\pi}/p)]}^{\ensuremath{-}1}{(4\mathcal{N}/\ensuremath{\kappa})}^{\ensuremath{-}(p\ensuremath{-}1)/p}$. Next, we consider whether the bound can be achieved by an adaptive homodyne measurement in the limit $\mathcal{N}/\ensuremath{\kappa}\ensuremath{\gg}1$, which allows the photocurrent to be linearized. Applying the optimal filtering for the resultant linear Gaussian system, we find the same scaling with N\mathcal{N}N, but with a prefactor larger by a factor of ppp. By contrast, if we employ optimal smoothing we can exactly obtain the quantum Cram\'er-Rao bound. That is, contrary to previously considered (p=2p=2p=2) cases of phase estimation, here the improvement offered by smoothing over filtering is not limited to a factor of 2 but rather can be unbounded by a factor of ppp. We also study numerically the performance of these estimators for an adaptive measurement in the limit where $\mathcal{N}/\ensuremath{\kappa}$ is not large and find a more complicated picture.
The ultimate bound to the accuracy of phase estimates is often assumed to be given by the Heisenberg limit. Recent work seemed to indicate that this bound can be violated, yielding measurements with much higher accuracy than was previously expected. The Heisenberg limit can be restored as a rigorous bound to the accuracy provided one considers the accuracy averaged over the possible values of the unknown phase, as we have recently shown [Phys. Rev. A 85, 041802(R) (2012)]. Here we present an expanded proof of this result together with a number of additional results, including the proof of a previously conjectured stronger bound in the asymptotic limit. Other measures of the accuracy are examined, as well as other restrictions on the generator of the phase shifts. We provide expanded numerical results for the minimum error and asymptotic expansions. The significance of the results claiming violation of the Heisenberg limit is assessed, followed by a detailed discussion of the limitations of the Cram\'er-Rao bound.
We propose quantum versions of the Bell-Ziv-Zakai lower bounds for the error in multiparameter estimation.As an application, we consider measurement of a time-varying optical phase signal with stationary Gaussian prior statistics and a power-law spectrum ∼1=jωj p , with p > 1.With no other assumptions, we show that the mean-square error has a lower bound scaling as 1=N 2ðp-1Þ=ðpþ1Þ , where N is the time-averaged mean photon flux.Moreover, we show that this scaling is achievable by sampling and interpolation, for any p > 1.This bound is thus a rigorous generalization of the Heisenberg limit, for measurement of a single unknown optical phase, to a stochastically varying optical phase.
The ultimate precision of phase estimation is limited by the Heisenberg scaling Δϕ0=K/NΔϕ_0 = K/NΔϕ0​=K/N, where K∼1K\sim1K∼1 is a numerical prefactor and NNN is the mean number of photons interacting with the phase shifting object(s). However, achieving this fundamental limit often comes at the cost of an extremely narrow high-sensitive range, rendering schemes impractical. We analyze the precision limits of phase measurements in single- and two-arm optical interferometers with input Gaussian states. We consider two detection methods: conventional homodyne measurement and non-Gaussian threshold detection that saturates the quantum Cramér-Rao bound. We characterize the performance by two complementary metrics: the peak sensitivity Δϕ0Δϕ_0Δϕ0​ and the width δϕδϕδϕ of the high-sensitivity range. We demonstrate that Heisenberg scaling is attainable in all configurations considered. However, we reveal that δϕδϕδϕ strongly depends on KKK. We derive an approximate analytic expression that describes this trade-off. We show also that the two-arm interferometer with antisymmetrically squeezed inputs exhibits exceptional performance, simultaneously achieving Heisenberg-limited sensitivity and a broad high-sensitivity range δϕ=π/2δϕ=π/2δϕ=π/2.
Quantum stochastic phase estimation has many applications in the precise measurement of various physical parameters. Similar to the estimation of a constant phase, there is a standard quantum limit for stochastic phase estimation, which can be obtained with the Mach–Zehnder interferometer and coherent input state. Recently, it has been shown that the stochastic standard quantum limit can be surpassed with nonclassical resources such as squeezed light. However, practical methods to achieve quantum enhancement in the stochastic phase estimation remain largely unexplored. Here we propose a method utilizing the SU(1,1) interferometer and coherent input states to estimate a stochastic optical phase. As an example, we investigate the Ornstein–Uhlenback stochastic phase. We analyze the performance of this method for three key estimation problems: prediction, tracking, and smoothing. The results show significant reduction of the mean square error compared with the Mach–Zehnder interferometer under the same photon number flux inside the interferometers. In particular, we show that the method with the SU(1,1) interferometer can achieve fundamental quantum scaling, achieve stochastic Heisenberg scaling, and surpass the precision of the canonical measurement.
I propose quantum versions of the Ziv-Zakai bounds as alternatives to the widely used quantum Cramér-Rao bounds for quantum parameter estimation. From a simple form of the proposed bounds, I derive both a Heisenberg error limit that scales with the average energy and a limit similar to the quantum Cramér-Rao bound that scales with the energy variance. These results are further illustrated by applying the bound to a few examples of optical phase estimation, which show that a quantum Ziv-Zakai bound can be much higher and thus tighter than a quantum Cramér-Rao bound for states with highly non-gaussian photon-number statistics in certain regimes and also stay close to the latter where the latter is expected to be tight.