Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1305.6250 · Physical Review Letters

Entanglement Concentration is Irreversible

Wataru Kumagai, Masahito Hayashi

Published Sep 26, 2013• 29 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In quantum information theory, it is widely believed that entanglement concentration for bipartite pure states is asymptotically reversible. In order to examine this, we give a precise formulation of the problem, and show a trade-off relation between performance and reversibility, which implies the irreversibility of entanglement concentration. Then, we regard entanglement concentration as entangled state compression in an entanglement storage with lower dimension. Because of the irreversibility of entanglement concentration, an initial state cannot be completely recovered after the compression process and a loss inevitably arises in the process. We numerically calculate this loss and also derive for it a highly accurate analytical approximation.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.111.130407

Related papers

Asymptotic reversibility of LOCC conversions

Kosuke Ito, Wataru Kumagai, Masahito Hayashi

Recently, two of the authors showed that entanglement concentration is irreversible. However, it is still not clear what kind of LOCC conversion is reversible. We derive the necessary and sufficient condition for reversibility of LOCC conversion between two bipartite pure entangled states in an asymptotic setting. Simultaneously, we evaluate how many copies of the initial state is to be lost to overcome irreversibility of LOCC conversion. Our result is useful for designing how to store entangled states via LOCC operations without error.

IEEE International Symposium on Information Theory (ISIT)•Jun 1, 2014•0 citations

Irreversibility of Entanglement Concentration for Pure State

Wataru Kumagai, Masahito Hayashi

For a pure state $ψ$ on a composite system $\mathcal{H}_A\otimes\mathcal{H}_B$, both the entanglement cost $E_C(ψ)$ and the distillable entanglement $E_D(ψ)$ coincide with the von Neumann entropy $H(\mathrm{Tr}_{B}ψ)$. Therefore, the entanglement concentration from the multiple state $ψ^{\otimes n}$ of a pure state $ψ$ to the multiple state $Φ^{\otimes L_n}$ of the EPR state $Φ$ seems to be able to be reversibly performed with an asymptotically infinitesimal error when the rate ${L_n}/{n}$ goes to $H(\mathrm{Tr}_{B}ψ)$. In this paper, we show that it is impossible to reversibly perform the entanglement concentration for a multiple pure state even in asymptotic situation. In addition, in the case when we recover the multiple state $ψ^{\otimes M_n}$ after the concentration for $ψ^{\otimes n}$, we evaluate the asymptotic behavior of the loss number $n-M_n$ of $ψ$. This evaluation is thought to be closely related to the entanglement compression in distant parties.

arXiv:1205.4370•May 20, 2012•3 citations

Very Strong Irreversibility of Quantum Entanglement

Tulja Varun Kondra, Raphael Brinster, Hermann Kampermann +2 more

The manipulation of quantum entanglement is fundamentally irreversible: some mixed entangled states require pure entanglement for their preparation, although no pure entanglement can be recovered from them by local operations and classical communication. This irreversibility is known to persist even under the maximal class of operations that do not generate entanglement, revealing a fundamental distinction between entanglement theory and thermodynamics. We construct cases for which any attempt to restore reversibility necessarily incurs an error that increases exponentially with the number of copies. Technically, we demonstrate a strict separation between the exponential strong-converse distillable entanglement and the exponential strong-converse entanglement cost. Our result resolves a conjecture posed by Lami and Regula (Nat. Phys. 19, 184-189 (2023)) and strengthens it by showing that the irreversibility of entanglement persists even at the level of polynomially (in the number of copies) growing error. We further derive a semidefinite-programming lower bound on the exponential strong-converse cost under non-entangling operations. Finally, for the class of completely PPT-preserving operations, we construct analytically solvable families of antisymmetric states exhibiting the exponential strong-converse irreversibility. Remarkably, to our knowledge, no analogous separation between exponential strong converse cost and the analogous distillable entanglement is currently known even under the more restrictive class of LOCC operations.

quant-pharXiv:2607.27195•Jul 30, 2026•0 citations

Irreversibility of entanglement distillation for a class of symmetric states

K. G. H. Vollbrecht, Reinhard F. Werner, Michael M. Wolf

We investigate the irreversibility of entanglement distillation for a symmetric $(d+1)$-parameter family of mixed bipartite quantum states acting on Hilbert spaces of arbitrary dimension $d\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}d$. We prove that in this family the entanglement cost is generically strictly larger than the distillable entanglement, so that the set of states for which the distillation process is asymptotically reversible is of measure zero. This remains true even if the distillation process is catalytically assisted by pure-state entanglement and every operation is allowed, which preserves the positivity of the partial transpose. It is shown that reversibility occurs only in cases where the state is a tagged mixture. The reversible cases are shown to be completely characterized by minimal uncertainty vectors for entropic uncertainty relations.

arXiv:quant-ph/0301072•Physical Review A•Jun 3, 2004•22 citations

Asymptotic compatibility between local-operations-and-classical-communication conversion and recovery

Kosuke Ito, Wataru Kumagai, Masahito Hayashi

Recently, entanglement concentration was explicitly shown to be irreversible. However, it is still not clear what kind of states can be reversibly converted in the asymptotic setting by local operations and classical communication (LOCC) when neither the initial nor the target state is maximally entangled. We derive the necessary and sufficient condition for the reversibility of LOCC conversions between two bipartite pure entangled states in the asymptotic setting. In addition, we show that conversion can be achieved perfectly with only local unitary operation under such condition except for special cases. Interestingly, our result implies that an error-free reversible conversion is asymptotically possible even between states whose copies can never be locally unitarily equivalent with any finite numbers of copies, although such a conversion is impossible in the finite setting. In fact, we show such an example. Moreover, we establish how to overcome the irreversibility of LOCC conversion in two ways. As for the first method, we evaluate how many copies of the initial state are to be lost to overcome the irreversibility of LOCC conversion. The second method is to add a supplementary state appropriately, which also works for local unitary conversion unlike the first method. Especially, for the qubit system, any nonmaximally pure entangled state can be a universal resource for the asymptotic reversibility when copies of the state are sufficiently many. More interestingly, our analysis implies that far-from-maximally entangled states can be better than nearly maximally entangled states as this type of resource. This fact brings new insight to the resource theory of state conversion.

arXiv:1504.02967•Physical Review A•Nov 6, 2015•9 citations

Asymptotic convertibility of entanglement: An information-spectrum approach to entanglement concentration and dilution

Yong Jiao, Eyuri Wakakuwa, Tomohiro Ogawa

We consider asymptotic convertibility of an arbitrary sequence of bipartite pure states into another by local operations and classical communication (LOCC). We adopt an information-spectrum approach to address cases where each element of the sequences is not necessarily a tensor power of a bipartite pure state. We derive necessary and sufficient conditions for the LOCC convertibility of one sequence to another in terms of spectral entropy rates of entanglement of the sequences. Based on these results, we also provide simple proofs for previously known results on the optimal rates of entanglement concentration and dilution of general sequences of bipartite pure states.

arXiv:1701.09050•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Feb 1, 2018•4 citations
In quantum information theory, it is widely believed that entanglement concentration for bipartite pure states is asymptotically reversible. In order to examine this, we give a precise formulation of the problem, and show a trade-off relation between performance and reversibility, which implies the irreversibility of entanglement concentration. Then, we regard entanglement concentration as entangled state compression in an entanglement storage with lower dimension. Because of the irreversibility of entanglement concentration, an initial state cannot be completely recovered after the compression process and a loss inevitably arises in the process. We numerically calculate this loss and also derive for it a highly accurate analytical approximation.
Recently, two of the authors showed that entanglement concentration is irreversible. However, it is still not clear what kind of LOCC conversion is reversible. We derive the necessary and sufficient condition for reversibility of LOCC conversion between two bipartite pure entangled states in an asymptotic setting. Simultaneously, we evaluate how many copies of the initial state is to be lost to overcome irreversibility of LOCC conversion. Our result is useful for designing how to store entangled states via LOCC operations without error.
For a pure state ψψψ on a composite system HA⊗HB\mathcal{H}_A\otimes\mathcal{H}_BHA​⊗HB​, both the entanglement cost EC(ψ)E_C(ψ)EC​(ψ) and the distillable entanglement ED(ψ)E_D(ψ)ED​(ψ) coincide with the von Neumann entropy H(TrBψ)H(\mathrm{Tr}_{B}ψ)H(TrB​ψ). Therefore, the entanglement concentration from the multiple state ψ⊗nψ^{\otimes n}ψ⊗n of a pure state ψψψ to the multiple state Φ⊗LnΦ^{\otimes L_n}Φ⊗Ln​ of the EPR state ΦΦΦ seems to be able to be reversibly performed with an asymptotically infinitesimal error when the rate Ln/n{L_n}/{n}Ln​/n goes to H(TrBψ)H(\mathrm{Tr}_{B}ψ)H(TrB​ψ). In this paper, we show that it is impossible to reversibly perform the entanglement concentration for a multiple pure state even in asymptotic situation. In addition, in the case when we recover the multiple state ψ⊗Mnψ^{\otimes M_n}ψ⊗Mn​ after the concentration for ψ⊗nψ^{\otimes n}ψ⊗n, we evaluate the asymptotic behavior of the loss number n−Mnn-M_nn−Mn​ of ψψψ. This evaluation is thought to be closely related to the entanglement compression in distant parties.
The manipulation of quantum entanglement is fundamentally irreversible: some mixed entangled states require pure entanglement for their preparation, although no pure entanglement can be recovered from them by local operations and classical communication. This irreversibility is known to persist even under the maximal class of operations that do not generate entanglement, revealing a fundamental distinction between entanglement theory and thermodynamics. We construct cases for which any attempt to restore reversibility necessarily incurs an error that increases exponentially with the number of copies. Technically, we demonstrate a strict separation between the exponential strong-converse distillable entanglement and the exponential strong-converse entanglement cost. Our result resolves a conjecture posed by Lami and Regula (Nat. Phys. 19, 184-189 (2023)) and strengthens it by showing that the irreversibility of entanglement persists even at the level of polynomially (in the number of copies) growing error. We further derive a semidefinite-programming lower bound on the exponential strong-converse cost under non-entangling operations. Finally, for the class of completely PPT-preserving operations, we construct analytically solvable families of antisymmetric states exhibiting the exponential strong-converse irreversibility. Remarkably, to our knowledge, no analogous separation between exponential strong converse cost and the analogous distillable entanglement is currently known even under the more restrictive class of LOCC operations.
We investigate the irreversibility of entanglement distillation for a symmetric (d+1)(d+1)(d+1)-parameter family of mixed bipartite quantum states acting on Hilbert spaces of arbitrary dimension $d\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}d$. We prove that in this family the entanglement cost is generically strictly larger than the distillable entanglement, so that the set of states for which the distillation process is asymptotically reversible is of measure zero. This remains true even if the distillation process is catalytically assisted by pure-state entanglement and every operation is allowed, which preserves the positivity of the partial transpose. It is shown that reversibility occurs only in cases where the state is a tagged mixture. The reversible cases are shown to be completely characterized by minimal uncertainty vectors for entropic uncertainty relations.
Recently, entanglement concentration was explicitly shown to be irreversible. However, it is still not clear what kind of states can be reversibly converted in the asymptotic setting by local operations and classical communication (LOCC) when neither the initial nor the target state is maximally entangled. We derive the necessary and sufficient condition for the reversibility of LOCC conversions between two bipartite pure entangled states in the asymptotic setting. In addition, we show that conversion can be achieved perfectly with only local unitary operation under such condition except for special cases. Interestingly, our result implies that an error-free reversible conversion is asymptotically possible even between states whose copies can never be locally unitarily equivalent with any finite numbers of copies, although such a conversion is impossible in the finite setting. In fact, we show such an example. Moreover, we establish how to overcome the irreversibility of LOCC conversion in two ways. As for the first method, we evaluate how many copies of the initial state are to be lost to overcome the irreversibility of LOCC conversion. The second method is to add a supplementary state appropriately, which also works for local unitary conversion unlike the first method. Especially, for the qubit system, any nonmaximally pure entangled state can be a universal resource for the asymptotic reversibility when copies of the state are sufficiently many. More interestingly, our analysis implies that far-from-maximally entangled states can be better than nearly maximally entangled states as this type of resource. This fact brings new insight to the resource theory of state conversion.
We consider asymptotic convertibility of an arbitrary sequence of bipartite pure states into another by local operations and classical communication (LOCC). We adopt an information-spectrum approach to address cases where each element of the sequences is not necessarily a tensor power of a bipartite pure state. We derive necessary and sufficient conditions for the LOCC convertibility of one sequence to another in terms of spectral entropy rates of entanglement of the sequences. Based on these results, we also provide simple proofs for previously known results on the optimal rates of entanglement concentration and dilution of general sequences of bipartite pure states.