Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1305.6076 · Quantum Topology

Complexity classes as mathematical axioms II

Shawn Xingshan Cui, Michael H. Freedman, Zhenghan Wang

Published Feb 8, 2016• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The second author previously discussed how classical complexity separation conjectures, we call them “axioms,” have implications in three manifold topology: polynomial length strings of operations which preserve certain Jones polynomial evaluations cannot produce exponential simplications of link diagrams. In this paper, we continue this theme, exploring now more subtle separation axioms for quantum complexity classes. Surprisingly, we now find that similar strings of operations are unable to effect even linear simplications of the diagrams.

DOI
10.4171/qt/75

Related papers

Topological aspects of quantum entanglement

Louis Hirsch Kauffman, Eshan Mehrotra

Kauffman and Lomonaco (New J Phys 4:73.1–73.18, 2002. arXiv:quant-ph/0401090 , New J Phys 6:134.1–134.40, 2004) explored the idea of understanding quantum entanglement (the non-local correlation of certain properties of particles) topologically by viewing unitary entangling operators as braiding operators. In Alagic et al. (Yang–Baxter operators need quantum entanglement to distinguish knots, 2015. arXiv:1507.05979v1 ), it is shown that entanglement is a necessary condition for forming non-trivial invariants of knots from braid closures via solutions to the Yang–Baxter equation. We show that the arguments used by Alagic et al. (2015) generalize to essentially the same results for quantum invariant state summation models of knots. In one case (the unoriented swap case) we give an example of a Yang–Baxter operator, and associated quantum invariant, that can detect the Hopf link. Again this is analogous to the results of Alagic et al. (2015). We also give a class of R matrices that are entangling and are weak invariants of classical knots and links yet strong invariants of virtual knots and links. We also give an example of an SU(2) representation of the three-strand braid group that models the Jones polynomial for closures of three-strand braids. This invariant is a quantum model for the Jones polynomial restricted to three-strand braids, and it does not involve quantum entanglement. These relationships between topological braiding and quantum entanglement can be used as a framework for future work in understanding the properties of entangling gates in topological quantum computing. The paper ends with a discussion of the Aravind hypothesis about the direct relationship of knots and quantum entanglement and the $$ER = EPR$$ E R = E P R hypothesis about the relationship of quantum entanglement with the connectivity of space. We describe how, given a background space and a quantum tensor network, to construct a new topological space that welds the network and the background space together. This construction embodies the principle that quantum entanglement and topological connectivity are intimately related.

arXiv:1611.08047•Quantum Information Processing•Feb 2, 2019•27 citations

Topological quantum information theory

Louis H. Kauffman, Samuel J. Lomonaco

This paper is dedicated to new progress in the relationship of topology and quantum physics. Abstract. This paper is an introduction to relationships between quantum topology and quantum computing. In this paper we discuss unitary solutions to the Yang-Baxter equation that are universal quantum gates, quantum entanglement and topological entanglement, and we give an exposition of knottheoretic recoupling theory, its relationship with topological quantum field theory and apply these methods to produce unitary representations of the braid groups that are dense in the unitary groups. Our methods are rooted in the bracket state sum model for the Jones polynomial. We give our results for a large class of representations based on values for the bracket polynomial that are roots of unity. We make a separate and self-contained study of the quantum universal Fibonacci model in this framework. We apply our results to give quantum algorithms for the computation of the colored Jones polynomials for knots and links, and the Witten-Reshetikhin-Turaev invariant of three manifolds. 1.

Proceedings of symposia in applied mathematics•Jan 1, 2010•16 citations

Quantum generalizations of the polynomial hierarchy with applications to QMA(2)

Sevag Gharibian, Miklós Sántha, Jamie Sikora +2 more

The polynomial-time hierarchy (PH) has proven to be a powerful tool for providing separations in computational complexity theory (modulo standard conjectures such as PH do not collapse). Here, we study whether two quantum generalizations of PH can similarly prove separations in the quantum setting. The first generalization, $$\rm{QCPH}$$ , uses classical proofs, and the second, $$\rm{QPH}$$ , uses quantum proofs. For the former, we show quantum variants of the Karp-Lipton theorem and Toda's theorem. For the latter, we place its third level, $$\rm{Q\Sigma_3}$$ , into NEXP using the ellipsoid method for efficiently solving semidefinite programs. These results yield two implications for $$\rm{QMA(2)}$$ , the variant of Quantum Merlin-Arthur ( $$\rm{QMA}$$ ) with two unentangled proofs, a complexity class whose characterization has proven difficult. First, if $$\rm{QCPH = QPH}$$ (i.e., alternating quantifiers are sufficiently powerful so as to make classical and quantum proofs ``equivalent''), then QMA(2) is in the counting hierarchy (specifically, in $${\rm P}^{{\rm pp}^{{\rm pp}}}$$ ). Second, because $$\rm{QMA(2)}\subseteq \rm{Q\Sigma_3}$$ , $$\rm{QMA(2)}$$ is strictly contained in NEXP unless $$\rm{QMA(2)}=\rm{Q\Sigma_3}$$ (i.e., alternating quantifiers do not help in the presence of ``unentanglement'').

arXiv:1805.11139•Computational Complexity•Sep 20, 2022•25 citations

A Separation Between Types of Quantum Oracle Separations

Scott Aaronson, Adam Bouland, Jordan Docter +1 more

Recent works have demonstrated that quantum oracles have subtle behavior, as access to inverse, conjugate or controlled queries can exponentially change the query complexity of certain tasks. Inspired by these works, we introduce the notion of meta-complexity of quantum relativization. We ask: for any two quantum complexity classes, under which "types" of quantum oracles are they equal or separated? Different pantheons of oracles (or quantum oracle types, e.g. unitary vs state, poly- vs superpoly-dimensional, closed under inverse or not) form a partially ordered set based on their power in separating complexity classes. Moreover, two oracle pantheons A and B are separated if there exists a pair of complexity classes that are separated under an oracle from pantheon A but yet the complexity classes are equivalent under all oracles from pantheon B. We show that this meta-complexity can be nontrivial by giving a complete classification, within the family of oracle pantheons defined in this paper, of which models can separate the complexity classes $\mathsf{PostBQP}$ and $\mathsf{PreciseBQP}$, the exponentially precise variant of $\mathsf{BQP}$. Both classes equal $\mathsf{PP}$ in the unrelativized setting. Within our taxonomy, they remain equal relative to real or polynomial-dimensional unitary oracles and whenever inverse or conjugate access is supplied. In contrast, we give a separation relative to forward-only complex diagonal unitaries of superpolynomial dimension, as well as a separation relative to single-qubit state-preparation oracles. We view this as a test case for the meta-complexity of oracles which underscores the subtlety inherent to the relativization of quantum complexity classes.

quant-pharXiv:2609.38704•Oct 1, 2026•0 citations

Polynomial Equivalence of Complexity Geometries

Adam R. Brown

This paper proves the polynomial equivalence of a broad class of definitions of quantum computational complexity. We study right-invariant metrics on the unitary group—often called `complexity geometries' following the definition of quantum complexity proposed by Nielsen—and delineate the equivalence class of metrics that have the same computational power as quantum circuits. Within this universality class, any unitary that can be reached in one metric can be approximated in any other metric in the class with a slowdown that is at-worst polynomial in the length and number of qubits and inverse-polynomial in the permitted error. We describe the equivalence classes for two different kinds of error we might tolerate: Killing-distance error, and operator-norm error. All metrics in both equivalence classes are shown to have exponential diameter; all metrics in the operator-norm equivalence class are also shown to give an alternative definition of the quantum complexity class BQP. My results extend those of Nielsen et al., who in 2006 proved that one particular metric is polynomially equivalent to quantum circuits. The Nielsen et al. metric is incredibly highly curved. I show that the greatly enlarged equivalence class established in this paper also includes metrics that have modest curvature. I argue that the modest curvature makes these metrics more amenable to the tools of differential geometry, and therefore makes them more promising starting points for Nielsen's program of using differential geometry to prove complexity lowerbounds. In a previous paper my collaborators and I—inspired by the UV/IR decoupling that happens in the phenomenon of renormalization—conjectured that high- dimensional metrics that look very different at short scales will often nevertheless give rise at long scales to the same emergent effective geometry. The results of this paper provide evidence for those conjectures, since many complexity metrics that have radically different penalty factors and therefore radically different short- distance properties are shown to belong to the same long-distance equivalence class.

arXiv:2205.04485•Quantum•Jul 2, 2024•18 citations

Quantum knitting

Silvano Garnerone, Annalisa Marzuoli, Mario Rasetti

We analyze the connections between the mathematical theory of knots and quantum physics by addressing a number of algorithmic questions related to both knots and braid groups. Knots can be distinguished by means of “knot invariants,” among which the Jones polynomial plays a prominent role, since it can be associated with observables in topological quantum field theory. Although the problem of computing the Jones polynomial is intractable in the framework of classical complexity theory, it has been recently recognized that a quantum computer is capable of approximating it in an efficient way. The quantum algorithms discussed here represent a breakthrough for quantum computation, since approximating the Jones polynomial is actually a “universal problem,” namely, the hardest problem that a quantum computer can efficiently handle.

arXiv:quant-ph/0606137•Laser Physics•Oct 30, 2006•14 citations
The second author previously discussed how classical complexity separation conjectures, we call them “axioms,” have implications in three manifold topology: polynomial length strings of operations which preserve certain Jones polynomial evaluations cannot produce exponential simplications of link diagrams. In this paper, we continue this theme, exploring now more subtle separation axioms for quantum complexity classes. Surprisingly, we now find that similar strings of operations are unable to effect even linear simplications of the diagrams.
Kauffman and Lomonaco (New J Phys 4:73.1–73.18, 2002. arXiv:quant-ph/0401090 , New J Phys 6:134.1–134.40, 2004) explored the idea of understanding quantum entanglement (the non-local correlation of certain properties of particles) topologically by viewing unitary entangling operators as braiding operators. In Alagic et al. (Yang–Baxter operators need quantum entanglement to distinguish knots, 2015. arXiv:1507.05979v1 ), it is shown that entanglement is a necessary condition for forming non-trivial invariants of knots from braid closures via solutions to the Yang–Baxter equation. We show that the arguments used by Alagic et al. (2015) generalize to essentially the same results for quantum invariant state summation models of knots. In one case (the unoriented swap case) we give an example of a Yang–Baxter operator, and associated quantum invariant, that can detect the Hopf link. Again this is analogous to the results of Alagic et al. (2015). We also give a class of R matrices that are entangling and are weak invariants of classical knots and links yet strong invariants of virtual knots and links. We also give an example of an SU(2) representation of the three-strand braid group that models the Jones polynomial for closures of three-strand braids. This invariant is a quantum model for the Jones polynomial restricted to three-strand braids, and it does not involve quantum entanglement. These relationships between topological braiding and quantum entanglement can be used as a framework for future work in understanding the properties of entangling gates in topological quantum computing. The paper ends with a discussion of the Aravind hypothesis about the direct relationship of knots and quantum entanglement and the ER=EPRER = EPRER=EPR E R = E P R hypothesis about the relationship of quantum entanglement with the connectivity of space. We describe how, given a background space and a quantum tensor network, to construct a new topological space that welds the network and the background space together. This construction embodies the principle that quantum entanglement and topological connectivity are intimately related.
This paper is dedicated to new progress in the relationship of topology and quantum physics. Abstract. This paper is an introduction to relationships between quantum topology and quantum computing. In this paper we discuss unitary solutions to the Yang-Baxter equation that are universal quantum gates, quantum entanglement and topological entanglement, and we give an exposition of knottheoretic recoupling theory, its relationship with topological quantum field theory and apply these methods to produce unitary representations of the braid groups that are dense in the unitary groups. Our methods are rooted in the bracket state sum model for the Jones polynomial. We give our results for a large class of representations based on values for the bracket polynomial that are roots of unity. We make a separate and self-contained study of the quantum universal Fibonacci model in this framework. We apply our results to give quantum algorithms for the computation of the colored Jones polynomials for knots and links, and the Witten-Reshetikhin-Turaev invariant of three manifolds. 1.
The polynomial-time hierarchy (PH) has proven to be a powerful tool for providing separations in computational complexity theory (modulo standard conjectures such as PH do not collapse). Here, we study whether two quantum generalizations of PH can similarly prove separations in the quantum setting. The first generalization, QCPH\rm{QCPH}QCPH , uses classical proofs, and the second, QPH\rm{QPH}QPH , uses quantum proofs. For the former, we show quantum variants of the Karp-Lipton theorem and Toda's theorem. For the latter, we place its third level, QΣ3\rm{Q\Sigma_3}QΣ3​ , into NEXP using the ellipsoid method for efficiently solving semidefinite programs. These results yield two implications for QMA(2)\rm{QMA(2)}QMA(2) , the variant of Quantum Merlin-Arthur ( QMA\rm{QMA}QMA ) with two unentangled proofs, a complexity class whose characterization has proven difficult. First, if QCPH=QPH\rm{QCPH = QPH}QCPH=QPH (i.e., alternating quantifiers are sufficiently powerful so as to make classical and quantum proofs ``equivalent''), then QMA(2) is in the counting hierarchy (specifically, in Ppppp{\rm P}^{{\rm pp}^{{\rm pp}}}Ppppp ). Second, because QMA(2)⊆QΣ3\rm{QMA(2)}\subseteq \rm{Q\Sigma_3}QMA(2)⊆QΣ3​ , QMA(2)\rm{QMA(2)}QMA(2) is strictly contained in NEXP unless QMA(2)=QΣ3\rm{QMA(2)}=\rm{Q\Sigma_3}QMA(2)=QΣ3​ (i.e., alternating quantifiers do not help in the presence of ``unentanglement'').
Recent works have demonstrated that quantum oracles have subtle behavior, as access to inverse, conjugate or controlled queries can exponentially change the query complexity of certain tasks. Inspired by these works, we introduce the notion of meta-complexity of quantum relativization. We ask: for any two quantum complexity classes, under which "types" of quantum oracles are they equal or separated? Different pantheons of oracles (or quantum oracle types, e.g. unitary vs state, poly- vs superpoly-dimensional, closed under inverse or not) form a partially ordered set based on their power in separating complexity classes. Moreover, two oracle pantheons A and B are separated if there exists a pair of complexity classes that are separated under an oracle from pantheon A but yet the complexity classes are equivalent under all oracles from pantheon B. We show that this meta-complexity can be nontrivial by giving a complete classification, within the family of oracle pantheons defined in this paper, of which models can separate the complexity classes PostBQP\mathsf{PostBQP}PostBQP and PreciseBQP\mathsf{PreciseBQP}PreciseBQP, the exponentially precise variant of BQP\mathsf{BQP}BQP. Both classes equal PP\mathsf{PP}PP in the unrelativized setting. Within our taxonomy, they remain equal relative to real or polynomial-dimensional unitary oracles and whenever inverse or conjugate access is supplied. In contrast, we give a separation relative to forward-only complex diagonal unitaries of superpolynomial dimension, as well as a separation relative to single-qubit state-preparation oracles. We view this as a test case for the meta-complexity of oracles which underscores the subtlety inherent to the relativization of quantum complexity classes.
This paper proves the polynomial equivalence of a broad class of definitions of quantum computational complexity. We study right-invariant metrics on the unitary group—often called `complexity geometries' following the definition of quantum complexity proposed by Nielsen—and delineate the equivalence class of metrics that have the same computational power as quantum circuits. Within this universality class, any unitary that can be reached in one metric can be approximated in any other metric in the class with a slowdown that is at-worst polynomial in the length and number of qubits and inverse-polynomial in the permitted error. We describe the equivalence classes for two different kinds of error we might tolerate: Killing-distance error, and operator-norm error. All metrics in both equivalence classes are shown to have exponential diameter; all metrics in the operator-norm equivalence class are also shown to give an alternative definition of the quantum complexity class BQP. My results extend those of Nielsen et al., who in 2006 proved that one particular metric is polynomially equivalent to quantum circuits. The Nielsen et al. metric is incredibly highly curved. I show that the greatly enlarged equivalence class established in this paper also includes metrics that have modest curvature. I argue that the modest curvature makes these metrics more amenable to the tools of differential geometry, and therefore makes them more promising starting points for Nielsen's program of using differential geometry to prove complexity lowerbounds. In a previous paper my collaborators and I—inspired by the UV/IR decoupling that happens in the phenomenon of renormalization—conjectured that high- dimensional metrics that look very different at short scales will often nevertheless give rise at long scales to the same emergent effective geometry. The results of this paper provide evidence for those conjectures, since many complexity metrics that have radically different penalty factors and therefore radically different short- distance properties are shown to belong to the same long-distance equivalence class.
We analyze the connections between the mathematical theory of knots and quantum physics by addressing a number of algorithmic questions related to both knots and braid groups. Knots can be distinguished by means of “knot invariants,” among which the Jones polynomial plays a prominent role, since it can be associated with observables in topological quantum field theory. Although the problem of computing the Jones polynomial is intractable in the framework of classical complexity theory, it has been recently recognized that a quantum computer is capable of approximating it in an efficient way. The quantum algorithms discussed here represent a breakthrough for quantum computation, since approximating the Jones polynomial is actually a “universal problem,” namely, the hardest problem that a quantum computer can efficiently handle.