Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1305.5242

Quantum Logical Structures For Identical Particles

Federico Holik, Décio Krause, Gómez Ignacio

Published May 22, 2013• 5 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this work we discuss logical structures related to indistinguishable particles. Most of the framework used to develop these structures was presented in [17, 28] and in [20, 14, 15, 16]. We use these structures and constructions to discuss possible ontologies for identical parti-cles. In other words, we use these structures in order to characterize the logical structure of quantum systems for the case of indistinguishable particles, and draw possible philosoph-ical implications. We also review some proposals available in the literature which may be considered within the framework of the quantum logical tradition regarding the problem of indistinguishability. Besides these discussions and constructions, we advance novel technical results, namely, a lattice theoretical structure for identical particles for the finite dimensional case. This kind of approach was not present in the scarcely literature of quantum logic and indistinguishable particles.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1305.5242

Related papers

QUANTUM LOGICAL STRUCTURES FOR SIMILAR PARTICLES

Federico Holik, Ignacio S. Gomez, Décio Krause

In this work we discuss logical structures related to indistinguishable (or similar) particles. Most of the framework used to develop these structures was presented in previous works. We use these structures and constructions to discuss possible ontologies for identical particles. In other words, we use these structures in order to characterize the logical structure of quantum systems for the case of similar particles, and draw possible philosophical implications. We also review some proposals available in the literature which may be considered within the framework of the quantum logical tradition regarding the problem of indistinguishability. Besides these discussions and constructions, we advance novel technical results, namely, a lattice-theoretical structure for identical particles for the finite dimensional case. This approach has not been present in the scarce literature on quantum logic and similar particles.

Cadernos de História e Filosofia da Ciência•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

Indistinguishable entangled fermions: basics and future challenges

A. P. Majtey, Andrea Valdés-Hernández, Eloisa Cuestas

The study of entanglement in systems composed of identical particles raises interesting challenges with far-reaching implications in both, our fundamental understanding of the physics of composite quantum systems, and our capability of exploiting quantum indistinguishability as a resource in quantum information theory. Impressive theoretical and experimental advances have been made in the last decades that bring us closer to a deeper comprehension and to a better control of entanglement. Yet, when it involves composites of indistinguishable quantum systems, the very meaning of entanglement, and hence its characterization, still finds controversy and lacks a widely accepted definition. The aim of the present paper is to introduce, within an accessible and self-contained exposition, the basic ideas behind one of the approaches advanced towards the construction of a coherent definition of entanglement in systems of indistinguishable particles, with focus on fermionic systems. We also inquire whether the corresponding tools developed for studying entanglement in identical-fermion systems can be exploited when analysing correlations in distinguishable-party systems, in which the complete information of the individual parts is not available. Further, we open the discussion on the broader problem of constructing a suitable framework that accommodates entanglement in the presence of generalized statistics. This article is part of the theme issue 'Identity, individuality and indistinguishability in physics and mathematics'.

arXiv:2303.17539•Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Jul 30, 2023•9 citations

Identical quantum particles as distinguishable objects

Dennis Dieks, Andrea Lubberdink

According to classical physics particles are basic building blocks of the world. Classical particles are distinguishable objects, individuated by physical characteristics. By contrast, in quantum mechanics the standard view is that particles of the same kind ("identical particles") are in all circumstances indistinguishable from each other. This indistinguishability doctrine is motivated by the (anti)symmetrization postulates together with the assumption (``factorism'') that each single particle is represented in exactly one factor space in the tensor product Hilbert space of a many-particles system. Although the factorist assumption is standard in the literature, it is conceptually problematic. Particle indistinguishability is incompatible with the everyday meaning of ``particle'', and also with how this term is used both in classical physics and in the experimental practice of physics. The standard view requires quantum particles of the same kind to remain indistinguishable even in the classical limit, so that a transition to the classical picture of the world seems impossible. Earlier we have proposed an alternative conception of quantum particles that does not rely on factorism and that avoids these and other problems. We further explain and develop this proposal here. In our view, particles in quantum theory are not fundamental but \emph{emergent}. However, in those situations where the particle concept is applicable, quantum particles---identical or not---are distinguishable in the same way as classical particles.

arXiv:1902.09280•Feb 25, 2019•4 citations

IDENTICAL PARTICLES ARE INHERENTLY INDISTINGUISHABLE

The preceding development has been specifically restricted to systems of identical indistinguishable particles, but no further conditions were imposed on the particles or their microstates. The relations derived in Chapter 8 are therefore equally applicable to systems of identical particles in both classical and quantum mechanics, provided the particles are regarded as indistinguishable . As discussed in the Preface and Introduction, it is our firm conviction that identical particles, by their very nature, are indeed inherently and unconditionally indistinguishable. If that proposition is accepted, the relations of Chapter 8 combine with the results of previous chapters to provide a unified general statistical formalism which applies to both classical and quantum particles. However, the appealing simplicity of this picture is undermined by the widespread misconception that identical classical particles are distinguishable, at least in principle, and must be treated as such. In this section we discuss the apparent origins and rationale for this unfortunate misconception in an attempt to reconstruct and rectify the fallacious notions on which it is based.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Nov 22, 2017•0 citations

Indistinguishability and the origins of contextuality in physics

J. Acácio de Barros, Federico Holik, Décio Krause

In this work, we discuss a formal way of dealing with the properties of contextual systems. Our approach is to assume that properties describing the same physical quantity, but belonging to different measurement contexts, are indistinguishable in a strong sense. To construct the formal theoretical structure, we develop a description using quasi-set theory, which is a set-theoretical framework built to describe collections of elements that violate Leibnitz's principle of identity of indiscernibles. This framework allows us to consider a new ontology in order to study the properties of quantum systems. This article is part of the theme issue 'Contextuality and probability in quantum mechanics and beyond'.

arXiv:1906.09041•Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Sep 16, 2019•10 citations

Identity, Indiscernibility, and Philosophical Claims

Décio Krause, Antonio M. N. Coelho

The standard ways classical logic and mathematics deal with the concept of indiscernibility (indistinguishability), with special emphasis to the concept of indiscernibility in a structure are considered. The aim is to emphasize that in asserting that ‘two’ objects of a certain domain (generally, a non empty set) are the same object, one becomes committed to the axioms of set theory, since the structures where these concepts are expressed are generally taken as set theoretical constructs. Some of the consequences of these points to the philosophical discussion on identity and indiscernibility in quantum theory are then investigated.

CLE e-Prints•Feb 15, 2002•0 citations
In this work we discuss logical structures related to indistinguishable particles. Most of the framework used to develop these structures was presented in [17, 28] and in [20, 14, 15, 16]. We use these structures and constructions to discuss possible ontologies for identical parti-cles. In other words, we use these structures in order to characterize the logical structure of quantum systems for the case of indistinguishable particles, and draw possible philosoph-ical implications. We also review some proposals available in the literature which may be considered within the framework of the quantum logical tradition regarding the problem of indistinguishability. Besides these discussions and constructions, we advance novel technical results, namely, a lattice theoretical structure for identical particles for the finite dimensional case. This kind of approach was not present in the scarcely literature of quantum logic and indistinguishable particles.
In this work we discuss logical structures related to indistinguishable (or similar) particles. Most of the framework used to develop these structures was presented in previous works. We use these structures and constructions to discuss possible ontologies for identical particles. In other words, we use these structures in order to characterize the logical structure of quantum systems for the case of similar particles, and draw possible philosophical implications. We also review some proposals available in the literature which may be considered within the framework of the quantum logical tradition regarding the problem of indistinguishability. Besides these discussions and constructions, we advance novel technical results, namely, a lattice-theoretical structure for identical particles for the finite dimensional case. This approach has not been present in the scarce literature on quantum logic and similar particles.
The study of entanglement in systems composed of identical particles raises interesting challenges with far-reaching implications in both, our fundamental understanding of the physics of composite quantum systems, and our capability of exploiting quantum indistinguishability as a resource in quantum information theory. Impressive theoretical and experimental advances have been made in the last decades that bring us closer to a deeper comprehension and to a better control of entanglement. Yet, when it involves composites of indistinguishable quantum systems, the very meaning of entanglement, and hence its characterization, still finds controversy and lacks a widely accepted definition. The aim of the present paper is to introduce, within an accessible and self-contained exposition, the basic ideas behind one of the approaches advanced towards the construction of a coherent definition of entanglement in systems of indistinguishable particles, with focus on fermionic systems. We also inquire whether the corresponding tools developed for studying entanglement in identical-fermion systems can be exploited when analysing correlations in distinguishable-party systems, in which the complete information of the individual parts is not available. Further, we open the discussion on the broader problem of constructing a suitable framework that accommodates entanglement in the presence of generalized statistics. This article is part of the theme issue 'Identity, individuality and indistinguishability in physics and mathematics'.
According to classical physics particles are basic building blocks of the world. Classical particles are distinguishable objects, individuated by physical characteristics. By contrast, in quantum mechanics the standard view is that particles of the same kind ("identical particles") are in all circumstances indistinguishable from each other. This indistinguishability doctrine is motivated by the (anti)symmetrization postulates together with the assumption (``factorism'') that each single particle is represented in exactly one factor space in the tensor product Hilbert space of a many-particles system. Although the factorist assumption is standard in the literature, it is conceptually problematic. Particle indistinguishability is incompatible with the everyday meaning of ``particle'', and also with how this term is used both in classical physics and in the experimental practice of physics. The standard view requires quantum particles of the same kind to remain indistinguishable even in the classical limit, so that a transition to the classical picture of the world seems impossible. Earlier we have proposed an alternative conception of quantum particles that does not rely on factorism and that avoids these and other problems. We further explain and develop this proposal here. In our view, particles in quantum theory are not fundamental but \emph{emergent}. However, in those situations where the particle concept is applicable, quantum particles---identical or not---are distinguishable in the same way as classical particles.
The preceding development has been specifically restricted to systems of identical indistinguishable particles, but no further conditions were imposed on the particles or their microstates. The relations derived in Chapter 8 are therefore equally applicable to systems of identical particles in both classical and quantum mechanics, provided the particles are regarded as indistinguishable . As discussed in the Preface and Introduction, it is our firm conviction that identical particles, by their very nature, are indeed inherently and unconditionally indistinguishable. If that proposition is accepted, the relations of Chapter 8 combine with the results of previous chapters to provide a unified general statistical formalism which applies to both classical and quantum particles. However, the appealing simplicity of this picture is undermined by the widespread misconception that identical classical particles are distinguishable, at least in principle, and must be treated as such. In this section we discuss the apparent origins and rationale for this unfortunate misconception in an attempt to reconstruct and rectify the fallacious notions on which it is based.
In this work, we discuss a formal way of dealing with the properties of contextual systems. Our approach is to assume that properties describing the same physical quantity, but belonging to different measurement contexts, are indistinguishable in a strong sense. To construct the formal theoretical structure, we develop a description using quasi-set theory, which is a set-theoretical framework built to describe collections of elements that violate Leibnitz's principle of identity of indiscernibles. This framework allows us to consider a new ontology in order to study the properties of quantum systems. This article is part of the theme issue 'Contextuality and probability in quantum mechanics and beyond'.
The standard ways classical logic and mathematics deal with the concept of indiscernibility (indistinguishability), with special emphasis to the concept of indiscernibility in a structure are considered. The aim is to emphasize that in asserting that ‘two’ objects of a certain domain (generally, a non empty set) are the same object, one becomes committed to the axioms of set theory, since the structures where these concepts are expressed are generally taken as set theoretical constructs. Some of the consequences of these points to the philosophical discussion on identity and indiscernibility in quantum theory are then investigated.