Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1305.4685 · Classical and Quantum Gravity

Machian classical and semiclassical emergent time

Edward Anderson

Published Nov 27, 2013• 19 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Classical and semiclassical schemes are presented that are timeless at the primary level and recover time from Mach's `time is to be abstracted from change' principle at the emergent secondary level. The semiclassical scheme is a Machian variant of the Semiclassical Approach to the Problem of Time in Quantum Gravity. The classical scheme is Barbour's, cast here explicitly as the classical precursor of the Semiclassical Approach. Thus the two schemes have been married up, as equally-Machian and necessarily distinct, since quantum change is part of whence the latter's timestandard is abstracted.

DOI
10.1088/0264-9381/31/2/025006

Related papers

Quantum Machian Time in Newtonian Mechanics and Beyond

Sean Gryb

Abstract: We study a formulation of Newtonian mechanics where the time translational invariance of the theory is best-matched, a procedure that is mathematically similar to gauging a symmetry. Using insights gained from this procedure, we can move back and forth between absolute and relational time by changing the way in which the auxiliary fields (analogous to gauge fields) are varied. We then proceed to quantize this theory using Dirac and path integral quantizations. We discover that one of the constraints of the theory, which we call the Machian constraint, is responsible for removing the dependence of the theory on a background structure. It is this Machian constraint that is responsible for making the theory temporally relational. Because general relativity, through its geometrodynamics formulation, holds many formal similarities to the models of classical mechanics we study, we expect that analogous things should hold for gravity. This may shed new light on the problem of time in quantum gravity and the emergence of time on quantum subsystems of the

•Oct 22, 2008•1 citation

The End of Time?

J. N. Butterfield

I discuss J. Barbour's Machian theories of dynamics, and his proposal that a Machian perspective enables one to solve the problem of time in quantum geometrodynamics (by saying that there is no time). I concentrate on his recent book 'The End of Time' (1999).

arXiv:gr-qc/0103055•Mar 15, 2001•26 citations

Emergent Time in the Path Integral of Barbour and Bertotti's Timeless Mechanics

Sean Gryb

Abstract: The problem of time is studied in a toy model for quantum gravity: Barbour and Bertotti’s timeless formulation of non-relativistic mechanics. We quantize this timeless theory using path integrals and compare it to the path integral quantization of parameterized Newtonian mechanics, which contains absolute time. In general, we find that the solutions to the timeless theory are energy eigenstates, as predicted by the usual canonical quantization. Nevertheless, the path integral formalism brings new insight as it allows us to precisely determine the difference between the theory with and without time. This difference is found to lie in the form of the constraints imposed on the gauge fixing functions by the boundary conditions. In the stationary phase approximation, the constraints of both theories are equivalent. This suggests that a notion of

•Apr 18, 2008•15 citations

The problem of time: a path integral view

Juan Manuel Diaz, Alejandro Perez

We show that the emergence of time evolution in an otherwise timeless nonrelativistic closed quantum system -- viewed as a poor man's model of generally covariant quantum theory -- can be understood from the perspective of the path integral representation. As often happens in the functional integral approach, this viewpoint offers a more intuitive account of features that become cumbersome in the operator/Hilbert-space formulation. We show how Schrödinger evolution emerges once a clock degree of freedom is identified and placed in a suitable semiclassical `good-clock state'. Our analysis has a consequence that extends to path integral formulations of generally covariant systems with action $S$ (including gravity). In such theories certain transition amplitudes take the form $\exp(iS/\hbar)+\exp(-iS/\hbar)$ rather than the expected `forward propagating' $\exp(iS/\hbar)$. This feature, known as the {\em cosine problem}, appears in concrete regularizations of the path integral, for example in the spin foam representation defining the physical inner product between spin network states in loop quantum gravity. Both formally and in explicit regularizations, this apparent difficulty has led some authors to seek modifications of the basic amplitudes to eliminate backward propagation. Our model shows that the cosine problem is instead a natural consequence of time-reversal invariance of the fundamental dynamics together with the time-neutral boundary states commonly used in transition amplitudes. When a suitable clock system is identified and placed in a semiclassical `good-clock state', it introduces a time arrow selecting the `forward propagating' $\exp(iS/\hbar)$, without modifying the fundamental dynamics. The analysis clarifies how time emerges under suitable conditions and emphasizes that, in the canonical formulation, quantum gravity is fundamentally timeless.

gr-qcCross-listedarXiv:2605.17935•May 19, 2026•1 citation

Equivalent emergence of time dependence in classical and quantum mechanics

J S Briggs

Beginning with the principle that a closed mechanical composite system is timeless, time can be defined by the regular changes in a suitable position coordinate (clock) in the observing part, when one part of the closed composite observes another part. Translating this scenario into both classical and quantum mechanics allows a transition to be made from a time-independent mechanics for the closed composite to a time-dependent description of the observed part alone. The use of Hamilton-Jacobi theory yields a very close parallel between the derivations in classical and quantum mechanics. The time-dependent equations, Hamilton-Jacobi or Schr\"odinger, appear as approximations since no observed system is truly closed. The quantum case has an additional feature in the condition that the observing environment must become classical in order to define a real classical time variable. This condition leads to a removal of entanglement engendered by the interaction between the observed system and the observing environment. Comparison is made to the similar emergence of time in quantum gravity theory.

arXiv:1503.02146•Physical Review A•May 26, 2015•28 citations

Effective approach to the problem of time: General features and examples

Martin Bojowald A, Philipp A. Höhn, Artur Tsobanjan

The effective approach to quantum dynamics allows a reformulation of the Dirac quantization procedure for constrained systems in terms of an infinite-dimensional constrained system of classical type. For semiclassical approximations, the quantum constrained system can be truncated to finite size and solved by the reduced phase space or gauge-fixing methods. In particular, the classical feasibility of local internal times is directly generalized to quantum systems, overcoming the main difficulties associated with the general problem of time in the semiclassical realm. The key features of local internal times and the procedure of patching global solutions using overlapping intervals of local internal times are described and illustrated by two quantum mechanical examples. Relational evolution in a given choice of internal time is most conveniently described and interpreted in a corresponding choice of gauge at the effective level and changing the internal clock is, therefore, essentially achieved by a gauge transformation. This article complements the conceptual discussion in [M. Bojowald, P. A. H\"ohn, and A. Tsobanjan, Classical Quantum Gravity 28, 035006 (2011).].

arXiv:1011.3040•Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Jun 21, 2011•125 citations
Classical and semiclassical schemes are presented that are timeless at the primary level and recover time from Mach's `time is to be abstracted from change' principle at the emergent secondary level. The semiclassical scheme is a Machian variant of the Semiclassical Approach to the Problem of Time in Quantum Gravity. The classical scheme is Barbour's, cast here explicitly as the classical precursor of the Semiclassical Approach. Thus the two schemes have been married up, as equally-Machian and necessarily distinct, since quantum change is part of whence the latter's timestandard is abstracted.
Abstract: We study a formulation of Newtonian mechanics where the time translational invariance of the theory is best-matched, a procedure that is mathematically similar to gauging a symmetry. Using insights gained from this procedure, we can move back and forth between absolute and relational time by changing the way in which the auxiliary fields (analogous to gauge fields) are varied. We then proceed to quantize this theory using Dirac and path integral quantizations. We discover that one of the constraints of the theory, which we call the Machian constraint, is responsible for removing the dependence of the theory on a background structure. It is this Machian constraint that is responsible for making the theory temporally relational. Because general relativity, through its geometrodynamics formulation, holds many formal similarities to the models of classical mechanics we study, we expect that analogous things should hold for gravity. This may shed new light on the problem of time in quantum gravity and the emergence of time on quantum subsystems of the
Abstract: The problem of time is studied in a toy model for quantum gravity: Barbour and Bertotti’s timeless formulation of non-relativistic mechanics. We quantize this timeless theory using path integrals and compare it to the path integral quantization of parameterized Newtonian mechanics, which contains absolute time. In general, we find that the solutions to the timeless theory are energy eigenstates, as predicted by the usual canonical quantization. Nevertheless, the path integral formalism brings new insight as it allows us to precisely determine the difference between the theory with and without time. This difference is found to lie in the form of the constraints imposed on the gauge fixing functions by the boundary conditions. In the stationary phase approximation, the constraints of both theories are equivalent. This suggests that a notion of
We show that the emergence of time evolution in an otherwise timeless nonrelativistic closed quantum system -- viewed as a poor man's model of generally covariant quantum theory -- can be understood from the perspective of the path integral representation. As often happens in the functional integral approach, this viewpoint offers a more intuitive account of features that become cumbersome in the operator/Hilbert-space formulation. We show how Schrödinger evolution emerges once a clock degree of freedom is identified and placed in a suitable semiclassical `good-clock state'. Our analysis has a consequence that extends to path integral formulations of generally covariant systems with action SSS (including gravity). In such theories certain transition amplitudes take the form exp⁡(iS/ℏ)+exp⁡(−iS/ℏ)\exp(iS/\hbar)+\exp(-iS/\hbar)exp(iS/ℏ)+exp(−iS/ℏ) rather than the expected `forward propagating' exp⁡(iS/ℏ)\exp(iS/\hbar)exp(iS/ℏ). This feature, known as the {\em cosine problem}, appears in concrete regularizations of the path integral, for example in the spin foam representation defining the physical inner product between spin network states in loop quantum gravity. Both formally and in explicit regularizations, this apparent difficulty has led some authors to seek modifications of the basic amplitudes to eliminate backward propagation. Our model shows that the cosine problem is instead a natural consequence of time-reversal invariance of the fundamental dynamics together with the time-neutral boundary states commonly used in transition amplitudes. When a suitable clock system is identified and placed in a semiclassical `good-clock state', it introduces a time arrow selecting the `forward propagating' exp⁡(iS/ℏ)\exp(iS/\hbar)exp(iS/ℏ), without modifying the fundamental dynamics. The analysis clarifies how time emerges under suitable conditions and emphasizes that, in the canonical formulation, quantum gravity is fundamentally timeless.
Beginning with the principle that a closed mechanical composite system is timeless, time can be defined by the regular changes in a suitable position coordinate (clock) in the observing part, when one part of the closed composite observes another part. Translating this scenario into both classical and quantum mechanics allows a transition to be made from a time-independent mechanics for the closed composite to a time-dependent description of the observed part alone. The use of Hamilton-Jacobi theory yields a very close parallel between the derivations in classical and quantum mechanics. The time-dependent equations, Hamilton-Jacobi or Schr\"odinger, appear as approximations since no observed system is truly closed. The quantum case has an additional feature in the condition that the observing environment must become classical in order to define a real classical time variable. This condition leads to a removal of entanglement engendered by the interaction between the observed system and the observing environment. Comparison is made to the similar emergence of time in quantum gravity theory.
The effective approach to quantum dynamics allows a reformulation of the Dirac quantization procedure for constrained systems in terms of an infinite-dimensional constrained system of classical type. For semiclassical approximations, the quantum constrained system can be truncated to finite size and solved by the reduced phase space or gauge-fixing methods. In particular, the classical feasibility of local internal times is directly generalized to quantum systems, overcoming the main difficulties associated with the general problem of time in the semiclassical realm. The key features of local internal times and the procedure of patching global solutions using overlapping intervals of local internal times are described and illustrated by two quantum mechanical examples. Relational evolution in a given choice of internal time is most conveniently described and interpreted in a corresponding choice of gauge at the effective level and changing the internal clock is, therefore, essentially achieved by a gauge transformation. This article complements the conceptual discussion in [M. Bojowald, P. A. H\"ohn, and A. Tsobanjan, Classical Quantum Gravity 28, 035006 (2011).].