Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1305.4281 · Journal of Applied Physics

Operation of a titanium nitride superconducting microresonator detector in the nonlinear regime

Loren J. Swenson, Peter K. Day, Byeong Ho Eom, Henry George LeDuc, Nuria Llombart, Christopher M. McKenney, Omid Noroozian, Jonas Stasys Zmuidzinas

Published Mar 8, 2013• 123 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

If driven sufficiently strongly, superconducting microresonators exhibit nonlinear behavior including response bifurcation. This behavior can arise from a variety of physical mechanisms including heating effects, grain boundaries or weak links, vortex penetration, or through the intrinsic nonlinearity of the kinetic inductance. Although microresonators used for photon detection are usually driven fairly hard in order to optimize their sensitivity, most experiments to date have not explored detector performance beyond the onset of bifurcation. Here, we present measurements of a lumped-element superconducting microresonator designed for use as a far-infrared detector and operated deep into the nonlinear regime. The 1 GHz resonator was fabricated from a 22 nm thick titanium nitride film with a critical temperature of 2 K and a normal-state resistivity of 100 μΩ cm. We measured the response of the device when illuminated with 6.4 pW optical loading using microwave readout powers that ranged from the low-power, linear regime to 18 dB beyond the onset of bifurcation. Over this entire range, the nonlinear behavior is well described by a nonlinear kinetic inductance. The best noise-equivalent power of 2×10−16 W/Hz1/2 at 10 Hz was measured at the highest readout power, and represents a ∼10 fold improvement compared with operating below the onset of bifurcation.

DOI
10.1063/1.4794808

Related papers

Titanium nitride films for ultrasensitive microresonator detectors

Henry George LeDuc, B. Bumble, Peter K. Day +10 more

Titanium nitride (TiNx) films are ideal for use in superconducting microresonator detectors for the following reasons: (a) the critical temperature varies with composition (0<Tc<5 K); (b) the normal-state resistivity is large, ρn∼100 μΩ cm, facilitating efficient photon absorption and providing a large kinetic inductance and detector responsivity; and (c) TiN films are very hard and mechanically robust. Resonators using reactively sputtered TiN films show remarkably low loss (Qi>107) and have noise properties similar to resonators made using other materials, while the quasiparticle lifetimes are reasonably long, 10–200 μs. TiN microresonators should therefore reach sensitivities well below 10−19 W Hz−1/2.

arXiv:1003.5584•Applied Physics Letters•Sep 6, 2010•253 citations

Kinetic inductance compact resonator with NbTiN micronwires

Ming Yang, Xiaoliang He, Wanpeng Gao +6 more

Nonlinear resonators of superconducting thin-film kinetic inductance have attracted considerable research interest in the fields of detectors, qubits, parametric amplifiers, and more. By tuning the deposition parameters, niobium titanium nitride (NbTiN) films (∼12 nm in thickness) present high resistivity(∼2000 μΩ cm) and large sheet kinetic inductance (∼0.7 nH/□). We designed resonators with NbTiN micronwire as the inductor and aluminum as the capacitor, which result in a high internal quality factor and a Kerr nonlinearity of a few hertz. The radio frequency response of the resonators demonstrates nonlinear behavior similar to that of the cubic Duffing oscillator, including frequency shift and hysteresis region. The kinetic inductance resonator is a promising candidate for high saturation power parametric amplifiers.

AIP Advances•Aug 1, 2024•8 citations

Demonstration of an NEP of 3.8×10−19 W/Hz1/2 at 1.54 THz in multiplexible superconducting microresonator detectors

Pieter de Visser, J. J. A. Baselmans, Juan Bueno +1 more

Microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKIDs) promise high sensitivity, combined with device simplicity and intrinsic multiplexibility. We have measured the response and noise equivalent power (NEP) of an all-aluminium, antenna coupled MKID at 1.54 THz, both as a function of radiation power and as a function of readout power. Eight optical filters and a box-in-box configuration at the bath temperature, allow a large range of optical powers by varying the temperature of a black body source. In the range of 80 aW-700 fW the detector is photon-noise limited, with an optical efficiency of 48±8% for one polarisation, which is limited by the antenna design. At lower optical powers we reveal a saturation level in the NEP of 3.8×10-19W/Hz1/2, competitive with other detectors for this purpose and the lowest optical NEP so far for MKIDs. The noise over the entire power range is limited by photon- and generation-recombination noise, the fundamental noise sources for these detectors.

International Conference on Infrared, Millimeter, and Terahertz Waves (IRMMW-THz)•Sep 1, 2014•0 citations

Photon-noise limited sensitivity in titanium nitride kinetic inductance detectors

J. Hubmayr, J. Beall, D. Becker +14 more

We demonstrate photon-noise limited performance at sub-millimeter wavelengths in feedhorn-coupled, microwave kinetic inductance detectors made of a TiN/Ti/TiN trilayer superconducting film, tuned to have a transition temperature of 1.4 K. Micro-machining of the silicon-on-insulator wafer backside creates a quarter-wavelength backshort optimized for efficient coupling at 250 μm. Using frequency read out and when viewing a variable temperature blackbody source, we measure device noise consistent with photon noise when the incident optical power is >0.5 pW, corresponding to noise equivalent powers >3×10−17 W/Hz. This sensitivity makes these devices suitable for broadband photometric applications at these wavelengths.

arXiv:1406.4010•Applied Physics Letters•Feb 16, 2015•83 citations

Design and performance of hafnium optical and near-IR kinetic inductance detectors

Nicholas Zobrist, Grégoire Coiffard, Bruce Bumble +9 more

We report on the design and performance of microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKIDs) sensitive to single photons in the optical to near-infrared range using hafnium as the sensor material. Our test device had a superconducting transition temperature of 395 mK and a room temperature normal state resistivity of 97 μΩ cm with RRR=1.6. Resonators on the device displayed internal quality factors of around 200 000. Similar to the analysis of MKIDs made from other highly resistive superconductors, we find that modeling the temperature response of the detector requires an extra broadening parameter in the superconducting density of states. Finally, we show that this material and design is compatible with a full-array fabrication process, which resulted in pixels with decay times of about 40 μs and resolving powers of ∼9 at 800 nm.

arXiv:1911.06434•Applied Physics Letters•Nov 18, 2019•30 citations

Superconducting Microwave Resonator Arrays for Submillimeter/Far-infrared Imaging

Omid Noroozian

Superconducting microwave resonators have the potential to revolutionize submillimeter and far-infrared astronomy, and with it our understanding of the universe. The field of low-temperature detector technology has reached a point where extremely sensitive devices like transition-edge sensors are now capable of detecting radiation limited by the background noise of the universe. However, the size of these detector arrays are limited to only a few thousand pixels. This is because of the cost and complexity of fabricating large-scale arrays of these detectors that can reach up to 10 lithographic levels on chip, and the complicated SQUID-based multiplexing circuitry and wiring for readout of each detector. In order to make substantial progress, next- generation ground-based telescopes such as CCAT or future space telescopes require focal planes with large-scale detector arrays of 104–106 pixels. Arrays using microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKID) are a potential solution. These arrays can be easily made with a single layer of superconducting metal film deposited on a silicon substrate and pattered using conventional optical lithography. Furthermore, MKIDs are inherently multiplexable in the frequency domain, allowing ∼ 103 detectors to be read out using a single coaxial transmission line and cryogenic amplifier, drastically reducing cost and complexity. An MKID uses the change in the microwave surface impedance of a superconducting thin-film microresonator to detect photons. Absorption of photons in the superconductor breaks Cooper pairs into quasiparticles, changing the complex surface impedance, which results in a perturbation of resonator frequency and quality factor. For excitation and readout, the resonator is weakly coupled to a transmission line. The complex amplitude of a microwave probe signal tuned on-resonance and transmitted on the feedline past the resonator is perturbed as photons are absorbed in the superconductor. The perturbation can be detected using a cryogenic amplifier and subsequent homodyne mixing at room temperature. In an array of MKIDs, all the resonators are coupled to a shared feedline and are tuned to slightly different frequencies. They can be read out simultaneously using a comb of frequencies generated and measured using digital techniques. This thesis documents an effort to demonstrate the basic operation of ∼ 256 pixel arrays of lumped-element MKIDs made from superconducting TiNx on silicon. The resonators are designed and simulated for optimum operation. Various properties of the resonators and arrays are measured and compared to theoretical expectations. A particularly exciting observation is the extremely high quality factors (∼ 3 × 107) of our TiNx resonators which is essential for ultra-high sensitivity. The arrays are tightly packed both in space and in frequency which is desirable for larger full-size arrays. However, this can cause a serious problem in terms of microwave crosstalk between neighboring pixels. We show that by properly designing the resonator geometry, crosstalk can be eliminated; this is supported by our measurement results. We also tackle the problem of excess frequency noise in MKIDs. Intrinsic noise in the form of an excess resonance frequency jitter exists in planar superconducting resonators that are made on dielectric substrates. We conclusively show that this noise is due to fluctuations of the resonator capacitance. In turn, the capacitance fluctuations are thought to be driven by two-level system (TLS) fluctuators in a thin layer on the surface of the device. With a modified resonator design we demonstrate with measurements that this noise can be substantially reduced. An optimized version of this resonator was designed for the multiwavelength submillimeter kinetic inductance camera (MUSIC) instrument for the Caltech Submillimeter Observatory.

•Jun 12, 2012•14 citations
If driven sufficiently strongly, superconducting microresonators exhibit nonlinear behavior including response bifurcation. This behavior can arise from a variety of physical mechanisms including heating effects, grain boundaries or weak links, vortex penetration, or through the intrinsic nonlinearity of the kinetic inductance. Although microresonators used for photon detection are usually driven fairly hard in order to optimize their sensitivity, most experiments to date have not explored detector performance beyond the onset of bifurcation. Here, we present measurements of a lumped-element superconducting microresonator designed for use as a far-infrared detector and operated deep into the nonlinear regime. The 1 GHz resonator was fabricated from a 22 nm thick titanium nitride film with a critical temperature of 2 K and a normal-state resistivity of 100 μΩ cm. We measured the response of the device when illuminated with 6.4 pW optical loading using microwave readout powers that ranged from the low-power, linear regime to 18 dB beyond the onset of bifurcation. Over this entire range, the nonlinear behavior is well described by a nonlinear kinetic inductance. The best noise-equivalent power of 2×10−16 W/Hz1/2 at 10 Hz was measured at the highest readout power, and represents a ∼10 fold improvement compared with operating below the onset of bifurcation.
Titanium nitride (TiNx) films are ideal for use in superconducting microresonator detectors for the following reasons: (a) the critical temperature varies with composition (0<Tc<5 K); (b) the normal-state resistivity is large, ρn∼100 μΩ cm, facilitating efficient photon absorption and providing a large kinetic inductance and detector responsivity; and (c) TiN films are very hard and mechanically robust. Resonators using reactively sputtered TiN films show remarkably low loss (Qi>107) and have noise properties similar to resonators made using other materials, while the quasiparticle lifetimes are reasonably long, 10–200 μs. TiN microresonators should therefore reach sensitivities well below 10−19 W Hz−1/2.
Nonlinear resonators of superconducting thin-film kinetic inductance have attracted considerable research interest in the fields of detectors, qubits, parametric amplifiers, and more. By tuning the deposition parameters, niobium titanium nitride (NbTiN) films (∼12 nm in thickness) present high resistivity(∼2000 μΩ cm) and large sheet kinetic inductance (∼0.7 nH/□). We designed resonators with NbTiN micronwire as the inductor and aluminum as the capacitor, which result in a high internal quality factor and a Kerr nonlinearity of a few hertz. The radio frequency response of the resonators demonstrates nonlinear behavior similar to that of the cubic Duffing oscillator, including frequency shift and hysteresis region. The kinetic inductance resonator is a promising candidate for high saturation power parametric amplifiers.
Microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKIDs) promise high sensitivity, combined with device simplicity and intrinsic multiplexibility. We have measured the response and noise equivalent power (NEP) of an all-aluminium, antenna coupled MKID at 1.54 THz, both as a function of radiation power and as a function of readout power. Eight optical filters and a box-in-box configuration at the bath temperature, allow a large range of optical powers by varying the temperature of a black body source. In the range of 80 aW-700 fW the detector is photon-noise limited, with an optical efficiency of 48±8% for one polarisation, which is limited by the antenna design. At lower optical powers we reveal a saturation level in the NEP of 3.8×10-19W/Hz1/2, competitive with other detectors for this purpose and the lowest optical NEP so far for MKIDs. The noise over the entire power range is limited by photon- and generation-recombination noise, the fundamental noise sources for these detectors.
We demonstrate photon-noise limited performance at sub-millimeter wavelengths in feedhorn-coupled, microwave kinetic inductance detectors made of a TiN/Ti/TiN trilayer superconducting film, tuned to have a transition temperature of 1.4 K. Micro-machining of the silicon-on-insulator wafer backside creates a quarter-wavelength backshort optimized for efficient coupling at 250 μm. Using frequency read out and when viewing a variable temperature blackbody source, we measure device noise consistent with photon noise when the incident optical power is >0.5 pW, corresponding to noise equivalent powers >3×10−17 W/Hz. This sensitivity makes these devices suitable for broadband photometric applications at these wavelengths.
We report on the design and performance of microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKIDs) sensitive to single photons in the optical to near-infrared range using hafnium as the sensor material. Our test device had a superconducting transition temperature of 395 mK and a room temperature normal state resistivity of 97 μΩ cm with RRR=1.6. Resonators on the device displayed internal quality factors of around 200 000. Similar to the analysis of MKIDs made from other highly resistive superconductors, we find that modeling the temperature response of the detector requires an extra broadening parameter in the superconducting density of states. Finally, we show that this material and design is compatible with a full-array fabrication process, which resulted in pixels with decay times of about 40 μs and resolving powers of ∼9 at 800 nm.
Superconducting microwave resonators have the potential to revolutionize submillimeter and far-infrared astronomy, and with it our understanding of the universe. The field of low-temperature detector technology has reached a point where extremely sensitive devices like transition-edge sensors are now capable of detecting radiation limited by the background noise of the universe. However, the size of these detector arrays are limited to only a few thousand pixels. This is because of the cost and complexity of fabricating large-scale arrays of these detectors that can reach up to 10 lithographic levels on chip, and the complicated SQUID-based multiplexing circuitry and wiring for readout of each detector. In order to make substantial progress, next- generation ground-based telescopes such as CCAT or future space telescopes require focal planes with large-scale detector arrays of 104–106 pixels. Arrays using microwave kinetic inductance detectors (MKID) are a potential solution. These arrays can be easily made with a single layer of superconducting metal film deposited on a silicon substrate and pattered using conventional optical lithography. Furthermore, MKIDs are inherently multiplexable in the frequency domain, allowing ∼ 103 detectors to be read out using a single coaxial transmission line and cryogenic amplifier, drastically reducing cost and complexity. An MKID uses the change in the microwave surface impedance of a superconducting thin-film microresonator to detect photons. Absorption of photons in the superconductor breaks Cooper pairs into quasiparticles, changing the complex surface impedance, which results in a perturbation of resonator frequency and quality factor. For excitation and readout, the resonator is weakly coupled to a transmission line. The complex amplitude of a microwave probe signal tuned on-resonance and transmitted on the feedline past the resonator is perturbed as photons are absorbed in the superconductor. The perturbation can be detected using a cryogenic amplifier and subsequent homodyne mixing at room temperature. In an array of MKIDs, all the resonators are coupled to a shared feedline and are tuned to slightly different frequencies. They can be read out simultaneously using a comb of frequencies generated and measured using digital techniques. This thesis documents an effort to demonstrate the basic operation of ∼ 256 pixel arrays of lumped-element MKIDs made from superconducting TiNx on silicon. The resonators are designed and simulated for optimum operation. Various properties of the resonators and arrays are measured and compared to theoretical expectations. A particularly exciting observation is the extremely high quality factors (∼ 3 × 107) of our TiNx resonators which is essential for ultra-high sensitivity. The arrays are tightly packed both in space and in frequency which is desirable for larger full-size arrays. However, this can cause a serious problem in terms of microwave crosstalk between neighboring pixels. We show that by properly designing the resonator geometry, crosstalk can be eliminated; this is supported by our measurement results. We also tackle the problem of excess frequency noise in MKIDs. Intrinsic noise in the form of an excess resonance frequency jitter exists in planar superconducting resonators that are made on dielectric substrates. We conclusively show that this noise is due to fluctuations of the resonator capacitance. In turn, the capacitance fluctuations are thought to be driven by two-level system (TLS) fluctuators in a thin layer on the surface of the device. With a modified resonator design we demonstrate with measurements that this noise can be substantially reduced. An optimized version of this resonator was designed for the multiwavelength submillimeter kinetic inductance camera (MUSIC) instrument for the Caltech Submillimeter Observatory.