Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1304.7623 · Journal of Russian Laser Research

Contextuality and the probability representation of quantum states

Vladimir I. Man’ko, Alexey A. Strakhov

Published May 1, 2013• 3 citations
arXivHTMLPDF
DOI
10.1007/s10946-013-9351-x

Related papers

An Epistemic Interpretation of Quantum Probability via Contextuality

Claudio Garola

arXiv:1806.09125•Foundations of Science•Jul 23, 2018•7 citations

Contextuality and Ontological Models: A Tale of Desire and Disappointment

Piers Lillystone

Since being defined by Kochen and Specker, and separately by Bell, contextuality has been proposed as one of the key phenomena that distinguishing quantum theory from classical theories. However, with the rise of quantum information contextuality's position as the leading definition of the quantum/classical boundary has been called into question. This is due to the fact that a contextual explanation is required by subtheories that offer no exponential quantum computational advantage over classical computation. In this thesis, submitted in requirement for a PhD in physics with quantum information, we shall explore this unwanted contextuality, and show that generalized contextuality is more prevalent than was previously thought. \n \nFirst we will show that the single-qubit stabilizer subtheory, which was previously thought of as a non-contextual subtheory, requires a generalized contextual ontological model, when transformations are included in the operational description. In addition to this we show that the even smaller single-rebit stabilizer subtheory, a strict subtheory of the single-qubit stabilizer subtheory, must also admit a generalized contextual ontological model, again when transformations are included in the operational description. We then show that both these subtheories require negatively represented quasi-probability representations, re-establishing the link between contextuality and negativity for transformations. We also investigate the representation of transformations in generic quasi-probability representations, showing that under a reasonable assumption almost-all unitaries must be negatively represented by a finite quasi-probability representation. \n \nSecond we will investigate the efficiently simulable n-qubit stabilizer subtheory, which exhibits all forms of contextuality and thus represents the main obstacle to identifying contextuality as a resource for quantum computation. To this end we present an attempt at constructing a model based on a frame-switching Wigner function. This leads us to constructing a contextual ψ-epistemic ontological model of the n-qubit stabilizer formalism. We shall see that this model is outcome deterministic, which is one of the core assumptions in the definition of traditional non-contextuality. This model then will lead us to a result that proves that any ontological model of the n-qubit stabilizer formalism requires at least n-1 generators to be encoded in the ontology of the model. As n-1 generators represents almost full knowledge about the stabilizer state, we therefore posit that ψ-onicity, a more controversial notion of non-classicality, is actually the resource for quantum computation.

•Sep 23, 2019•0 citations

Exploring Quantum contextuality with the quantum Möbius-Escher-Penrose hypergraph

Mirko Navara, Karl Svozil

This paper presents the quantum Möbius-Escher-Penrose hypergraph, drawing inspiration from paradoxical constructs such as the Möbius strip and Penrose's “impossible objects.” The hypergraph is constructed using faithful orthogonal representations in Hilbert space, thereby embedding the graph within a quantum framework. Additionally, a quasiclassical realization is achieved through two-valued states and partition logic, leading to an embedding within a Boolean algebra. This dual representation delineates the distinctions between classical and quantum embeddings, with a particular focus on contextuality, highlighted by violations of exclusivity and completeness, quantified through classical and quantum probabilities. The paper also examines violations of Boole's conditions of possible experience using correlation polytopes, underscoring the inherent contextuality of the hypergraph. These results offer deeper insights into quantum contextuality and its intricate relationship with classical logic structures.

arXiv:2409.10179•Physical Review A•Apr 16, 2025•0 citations

Contextuality and probability in quantum mechanics and beyond: a preface

Ehtibar N. Dzhafarov

Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Sep 16, 2019•8 citations

Contextuality of the probability current in quantum mechanics

Franck Laloë

arXiv:2412.04104•The European Physical Journal D•May 1, 2026•0 citations

Contrasting classical and quantum theory in the context of quasi-probability

Christopher Ferrie

Several finite dimensional quasi-probability representations of \nquantum states have been proposed to study various problems in \nquantum information theory and quantum foundations. These \nrepresentations are often defined only on restricted dimensions and \ntheir physical significance in contexts such as drawing \nquantum-classical comparisons is limited by the non-uniqueness of \nthe particular representation. In this thesis it is shown how the mathematical \ntheory of frames provides a unified formalism which accommodates all \nknown quasi-probability representations of finite dimensional \nquantum systems. \n \nIt is also shown that any quasi-probability \nrepresentation is equivalent to a frame representation and it is \nproven that any such representation of quantum mechanics must exhibit \neither negativity or a deformed probability calculus. \n \nAlong the way, the connection between negativity and two other famous notions of non-classicality, namely contextuality and nonlocality, is clarified.

•Aug 22, 2008•0 citations
Since being defined by Kochen and Specker, and separately by Bell, contextuality has been proposed as one of the key phenomena that distinguishing quantum theory from classical theories. However, with the rise of quantum information contextuality's position as the leading definition of the quantum/classical boundary has been called into question. This is due to the fact that a contextual explanation is required by subtheories that offer no exponential quantum computational advantage over classical computation. In this thesis, submitted in requirement for a PhD in physics with quantum information, we shall explore this unwanted contextuality, and show that generalized contextuality is more prevalent than was previously thought. \n \nFirst we will show that the single-qubit stabilizer subtheory, which was previously thought of as a non-contextual subtheory, requires a generalized contextual ontological model, when transformations are included in the operational description. In addition to this we show that the even smaller single-rebit stabilizer subtheory, a strict subtheory of the single-qubit stabilizer subtheory, must also admit a generalized contextual ontological model, again when transformations are included in the operational description. We then show that both these subtheories require negatively represented quasi-probability representations, re-establishing the link between contextuality and negativity for transformations. We also investigate the representation of transformations in generic quasi-probability representations, showing that under a reasonable assumption almost-all unitaries must be negatively represented by a finite quasi-probability representation. \n \nSecond we will investigate the efficiently simulable n-qubit stabilizer subtheory, which exhibits all forms of contextuality and thus represents the main obstacle to identifying contextuality as a resource for quantum computation. To this end we present an attempt at constructing a model based on a frame-switching Wigner function. This leads us to constructing a contextual ψ-epistemic ontological model of the n-qubit stabilizer formalism. We shall see that this model is outcome deterministic, which is one of the core assumptions in the definition of traditional non-contextuality. This model then will lead us to a result that proves that any ontological model of the n-qubit stabilizer formalism requires at least n-1 generators to be encoded in the ontology of the model. As n-1 generators represents almost full knowledge about the stabilizer state, we therefore posit that ψ-onicity, a more controversial notion of non-classicality, is actually the resource for quantum computation.
This paper presents the quantum Möbius-Escher-Penrose hypergraph, drawing inspiration from paradoxical constructs such as the Möbius strip and Penrose's “impossible objects.” The hypergraph is constructed using faithful orthogonal representations in Hilbert space, thereby embedding the graph within a quantum framework. Additionally, a quasiclassical realization is achieved through two-valued states and partition logic, leading to an embedding within a Boolean algebra. This dual representation delineates the distinctions between classical and quantum embeddings, with a particular focus on contextuality, highlighted by violations of exclusivity and completeness, quantified through classical and quantum probabilities. The paper also examines violations of Boole's conditions of possible experience using correlation polytopes, underscoring the inherent contextuality of the hypergraph. These results offer deeper insights into quantum contextuality and its intricate relationship with classical logic structures.
Several finite dimensional quasi-probability representations of \nquantum states have been proposed to study various problems in \nquantum information theory and quantum foundations. These \nrepresentations are often defined only on restricted dimensions and \ntheir physical significance in contexts such as drawing \nquantum-classical comparisons is limited by the non-uniqueness of \nthe particular representation. In this thesis it is shown how the mathematical \ntheory of frames provides a unified formalism which accommodates all \nknown quasi-probability representations of finite dimensional \nquantum systems. \n \nIt is also shown that any quasi-probability \nrepresentation is equivalent to a frame representation and it is \nproven that any such representation of quantum mechanics must exhibit \neither negativity or a deformed probability calculus. \n \nAlong the way, the connection between negativity and two other famous notions of non-classicality, namely contextuality and nonlocality, is clarified.