Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1304.6758 · Physical Review E

Frozen into stripes: Fate of the critical Ising model after a quench

Thibault Blanchard, Marco Picco

Published Sep 20, 2013• 31 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this article we study numerically the final state of the two-dimensional ferromagnetic critical Ising model after a quench to zero temperature. Beginning from equilibrium at T_{c}, the system can be blocked in a variety of infinitely long lived stripe states in addition to the ground state. Similar results have already been obtained for an infinite temperature initial condition and an interesting connection to exact percolation crossing probabilities has emerged. Here we complete this picture by providing an example of stripe states precisely related to initial crossing probabilities for various boundary conditions. We thus show that this is not specific to percolation but rather that it depends on the properties of spanning clusters in the initial state.

DOI
10.1103/physreve.88.032131

Related papers

Zero-temperature dynamics in the two-dimensional axial next-nearest-neighbor Ising model

Soham Biswas, Anjan Kumar Chandra, Parongama Sen

We investigate the dynamics of a two-dimensional axial next-nearest-neighbor Ising model following a quench to zero temperature. The Hamiltonian is given by H= -J_(0) summation operator(L)_(i,j=1)S_(i,j)S_(i+1,j)-J_(1)summation operator_(i,j=1)(S_{i,j}S_{i,j+1}-kappaS_{i,j}S_{i,j+2}) . For kappa<1 , the system does not reach the equilibrium ground state but slowly evolves to a metastable state. For kappa>1 , the system shows a behavior similar to that of the two-dimensional ferromagnetic Ising model in the sense that it freezes to a striped state with a finite probability. The persistence probability shows algebraic decay here with an exponent theta=0.235+/-0.001 while the dynamical exponent of growth z=2.08+/-0.01 . For kappa=1 , the system belongs to a completely different dynamical class; it always evolves to the true ground state with the persistence and dynamical exponent having unique values. Much of the dynamical phenomena can be understood by studying the dynamics and distribution of the number of domain walls. We also compare the dynamical behavior to that of a Ising model in which both the nearest and next-nearest-neighbor interactions are ferromagnetic.

arXiv:0810.2672•Physical Review E•Oct 21, 2008•10 citations

Zero-temperature ordering dynamics in a two-dimensional biaxial next-nearest-neighbor Ising model

Soham Biswas, Mauricio Martin Saavedra Contreras

We investigate the dynamics of a two-dimensional biaxial next-nearest-neighbor Ising model following a quench to zero temperature. The Hamiltonian is given by H=-J_{0}∑_{i,j=1}^{L}[(S_{i,j}S_{i+1,j}+S_{i,j}S_{i,j+1})-κ(S_{i,j}S_{i+2,j}+S_{i,j}S_{i,j+2})]. For κ<1, the system does not reach the equilibrium ground state and keeps evolving in active states forever. For κ≥1, though, the system reaches a final state, but it does not reach the ground state always and freezes to a striped state with a finite probability like a two-dimensional ferromagnetic Ising model and an axial next-nearest-neighbor Ising (ANNNI) model. The overall dynamical behavior for κ>1 and κ=1 is quite different. The residual energy decays in a power law for both κ>1 and κ=1 from which the dynamical exponent z has been estimated. The persistence probability shows algebraic decay for κ>1 with an exponent θ=0.22±0.002 while the dynamical exponent for ordering z=2.33±0.01. For κ=1, the system belongs to a completely different dynamical class with θ=0.332±0.002 and z=2.47±0.04. We have computed the freezing probability for different values of κ. We have also studied the decay of autocorrelation function with time for a different regime of κ values. The results have been compared with those of the two-dimensional ANNNI model.

arXiv:1905.12064•Physical review. E•Oct 22, 2019•2 citations

Out-of-equilibrium percolation transitions at finite critical times after quenches across magnetic first-order transitions

Andrea Pelissetto C, Davide Rossini, Ettore Vicari

We show that an out-of-equilibrium percolation transition occurs after quenching ferromagnetic Ising-like systems across their magnetic first-order transitions. As a paradigmatic example, we consider a two-dimensional Ising system driven across its low-temperature first-order transition line by a quench of the magnetic field $h$ from $h_i<0$ to $h>0$. In the thermodynamic limit and for finite values of $h$, the post-quench evolution under a purely relaxational dynamics is characterized by a dynamic transition at a finite critical time $t_c(h)$ from the metastable negatively magnetized phase to the positive one, marked by the percolation of the largest clusters of positive and negative spins. This out-of-equilibrium percolation transition displays a finite-size scaling behavior as in the standard random-percolation case. However, while the fractal dimension of the percolating clusters is consistent with the random-percolation value, the exponent controlling the approach to criticality differs and depends on $h$. We also show that the percolation critical behavior is related to the spinodal-like behavior of the magnetization in the small-$h$ limit, which implies that the percolation time $t_c(h)$ exhibits a spinodal-like exponential dependence on $h$.

arXiv:2603.13127•Mar 13, 2026•3 citations

How soon after a zero-temperature quench is the fate of the Ising model sealed?

Thibault Blanchard, Federico Corberi, Leticia F. Cugliandolo +1 more

We study the transient between a fully disordered initial condition and a percolating structure in the low-temperature non-conserved order parameter dynamics of the two-dimensional Ising model. We show that a stable structure of spanning clusters establishes at a time . Our numerical results yield for the square and kagome lattices, for the triangular and for the bowtie-a lattices. We generalise the dynamic scaling hypothesis to take into account this new time-scale. We discuss the implications of these results for other non-equilibrium processes.

arXiv:1312.1712•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Jun 1, 2014•46 citations

Anomalous Ising freezing times

James Denholm, Ben Hourahine

Abstract We measure the relaxation time of a square lattice Ising ferromagnet that is quenched to zero-temperature from supercritical initial conditions. We reveal an anomalous and seemingly overlooked timescale associated with the relaxation to ‘frozen’ two-stripe states. While close to a power law of the form ∼ L ν , we argue this timescale actually grows as ∼ L 2 ln L , with L the linear dimension of the system. We uncover the mechanism behind this scaling form by using a synthetic initial condition that replicates the late time ordering of two-stripe states, and subsequently explain it heuristically.

arXiv:2001.11774•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Sep 1, 2020•4 citations

Asymptotic states of Ising ferromagnets with long-range interactions

Ramgopal Agrawal, Federico Corberi, Ferdinando Insalata +1 more

It is known that, after a quench to zero temperature (T=0), two-dimensional (d=2) Ising ferromagnets with short-range interactions do not always relax to the ordered state. They can also fall in infinitely long-lived striped metastable states with a finite probability. In this paper, we study how the abundance of striped states is affected by long-range interactions. We investigate the relaxation of d=2 Ising ferromagnets with power-law interactions by means of Monte Carlo simulations at both T=0 and T≠0. For T=0 and the finite system size, the striped metastable states are suppressed by long-range interactions. In the thermodynamic limit, their occurrence probabilities are consistent with the short-range case. For T≠0, the final state is always ordered. Further, the equilibration occurs at earlier times with an increase in the strength of the interactions.

arXiv:2111.10118•Physical review. E•Mar 22, 2022•16 citations
In this article we study numerically the final state of the two-dimensional ferromagnetic critical Ising model after a quench to zero temperature. Beginning from equilibrium at T_{c}, the system can be blocked in a variety of infinitely long lived stripe states in addition to the ground state. Similar results have already been obtained for an infinite temperature initial condition and an interesting connection to exact percolation crossing probabilities has emerged. Here we complete this picture by providing an example of stripe states precisely related to initial crossing probabilities for various boundary conditions. We thus show that this is not specific to percolation but rather that it depends on the properties of spanning clusters in the initial state.
We investigate the dynamics of a two-dimensional axial next-nearest-neighbor Ising model following a quench to zero temperature. The Hamiltonian is given by H= -J_(0) summation operator(L)_(i,j=1)S_(i,j)S_(i+1,j)-J_(1)summation operator_(i,j=1)(S_{i,j}S_{i,j+1}-kappaS_{i,j}S_{i,j+2}) . For kappa<1 , the system does not reach the equilibrium ground state but slowly evolves to a metastable state. For kappa>1 , the system shows a behavior similar to that of the two-dimensional ferromagnetic Ising model in the sense that it freezes to a striped state with a finite probability. The persistence probability shows algebraic decay here with an exponent theta=0.235+/-0.001 while the dynamical exponent of growth z=2.08+/-0.01 . For kappa=1 , the system belongs to a completely different dynamical class; it always evolves to the true ground state with the persistence and dynamical exponent having unique values. Much of the dynamical phenomena can be understood by studying the dynamics and distribution of the number of domain walls. We also compare the dynamical behavior to that of a Ising model in which both the nearest and next-nearest-neighbor interactions are ferromagnetic.
We investigate the dynamics of a two-dimensional biaxial next-nearest-neighbor Ising model following a quench to zero temperature. The Hamiltonian is given by H=-J_{0}∑_{i,j=1}^{L}[(S_{i,j}S_{i+1,j}+S_{i,j}S_{i,j+1})-κ(S_{i,j}S_{i+2,j}+S_{i,j}S_{i,j+2})]. For κ<1, the system does not reach the equilibrium ground state and keeps evolving in active states forever. For κ≥1, though, the system reaches a final state, but it does not reach the ground state always and freezes to a striped state with a finite probability like a two-dimensional ferromagnetic Ising model and an axial next-nearest-neighbor Ising (ANNNI) model. The overall dynamical behavior for κ>1 and κ=1 is quite different. The residual energy decays in a power law for both κ>1 and κ=1 from which the dynamical exponent z has been estimated. The persistence probability shows algebraic decay for κ>1 with an exponent θ=0.22±0.002 while the dynamical exponent for ordering z=2.33±0.01. For κ=1, the system belongs to a completely different dynamical class with θ=0.332±0.002 and z=2.47±0.04. We have computed the freezing probability for different values of κ. We have also studied the decay of autocorrelation function with time for a different regime of κ values. The results have been compared with those of the two-dimensional ANNNI model.
We show that an out-of-equilibrium percolation transition occurs after quenching ferromagnetic Ising-like systems across their magnetic first-order transitions. As a paradigmatic example, we consider a two-dimensional Ising system driven across its low-temperature first-order transition line by a quench of the magnetic field hhh from hi<0h_i<0hi​<0 to h>0h>0h>0. In the thermodynamic limit and for finite values of hhh, the post-quench evolution under a purely relaxational dynamics is characterized by a dynamic transition at a finite critical time tc(h)t_c(h)tc​(h) from the metastable negatively magnetized phase to the positive one, marked by the percolation of the largest clusters of positive and negative spins. This out-of-equilibrium percolation transition displays a finite-size scaling behavior as in the standard random-percolation case. However, while the fractal dimension of the percolating clusters is consistent with the random-percolation value, the exponent controlling the approach to criticality differs and depends on hhh. We also show that the percolation critical behavior is related to the spinodal-like behavior of the magnetization in the small-hhh limit, which implies that the percolation time tc(h)t_c(h)tc​(h) exhibits a spinodal-like exponential dependence on hhh.
We study the transient between a fully disordered initial condition and a percolating structure in the low-temperature non-conserved order parameter dynamics of the two-dimensional Ising model. We show that a stable structure of spanning clusters establishes at a time . Our numerical results yield for the square and kagome lattices, for the triangular and for the bowtie-a lattices. We generalise the dynamic scaling hypothesis to take into account this new time-scale. We discuss the implications of these results for other non-equilibrium processes.
Abstract We measure the relaxation time of a square lattice Ising ferromagnet that is quenched to zero-temperature from supercritical initial conditions. We reveal an anomalous and seemingly overlooked timescale associated with the relaxation to ‘frozen’ two-stripe states. While close to a power law of the form ∼ L ν , we argue this timescale actually grows as ∼ L 2 ln L , with L the linear dimension of the system. We uncover the mechanism behind this scaling form by using a synthetic initial condition that replicates the late time ordering of two-stripe states, and subsequently explain it heuristically.
It is known that, after a quench to zero temperature (T=0), two-dimensional (d=2) Ising ferromagnets with short-range interactions do not always relax to the ordered state. They can also fall in infinitely long-lived striped metastable states with a finite probability. In this paper, we study how the abundance of striped states is affected by long-range interactions. We investigate the relaxation of d=2 Ising ferromagnets with power-law interactions by means of Monte Carlo simulations at both T=0 and T≠0. For T=0 and the finite system size, the striped metastable states are suppressed by long-range interactions. In the thermodynamic limit, their occurrence probabilities are consistent with the short-range case. For T≠0, the final state is always ordered. Further, the equilibration occurs at earlier times with an increase in the strength of the interactions.