Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1304.2982 · Physical Review E

Non-mean-field critical exponent in a mean-field model: Dynamics versus statistical mechanics

Shun Ogawa, Aurelio Patelli, Yoshiyuki Y. Yamaguchi

Published Mar 25, 2014• 16 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Mean-field theory tells us that the classical critical exponent of susceptibility is twice that of magnetization. However, linear response theory based on the Vlasov equation, which is naturally introduced by the mean-field nature, makes the former exponent half of the latter for families of quasistationary states having second order phase transitions in the Hamiltonian mean-field model and its variances, in the low-energy phase. We clarify that this strange exponent is due to the existence of Casimir invariants which trap the system in a quasistationary state for a time scale diverging with the system size. The theoretical prediction is numerically confirmed by N-body simulations for the equilibrium states and a family of quasistationary states.

DOI
10.1103/physreve.89.032131

Related papers

Landau-like theory for universality of critical exponents in quasistationary states of isolated mean-field systems

Shun Ogawa, Yoshiyuki Y. Yamaguchi

An external force dynamically drives an isolated mean-field Hamiltonian system to a long-lasting quasistationary state, whose lifetime increases with population of the system. For second order phase transitions in quasistationary states, two nonclassical critical exponents have been reported individually by using a linear and a nonlinear response theories in a toy model. We provide a simple way to compute the critical exponents all at once, which is an analog of the Landau theory. The present theory extends the universality class of the nonclassical exponents to spatially periodic one-dimensional systems and shows that the exponents satisfy a classical scaling relation inevitably by using a key scaling of momentum.

arXiv:1412.1593•Physical Review E•Jun 8, 2015•16 citations

Nonlinear response for external field and perturbation in the Vlasov system

Shun Ogawa, Yoshiyuki Y. Yamaguchi

A nonlinear response theory is provided by use of the transient linearization method in the spatially one-dimensional Vlasov systems. The theory inclusively gives responses to external fields and to perturbations for initial stationary states, and is applicable even to the critical point of a second-order phase transition. We apply the theory to the Hamiltonian mean-field model, a toy model of a ferromagnetic body, and investigate the critical exponent associated with the response to the external field at the critical point in particular. The obtained critical exponent is the nonclassical value 3/2, while the classical value is 3. However, interestingly, one scaling relation holds with another nonclassical critical exponent of susceptibility in the isolated Vlasov systems. Validity of the theory is numerically confirmed by directly simulating temporal evolutions of the Vlasov equation.

arXiv:1402.4250•Physical Review E•May 12, 2014•17 citations

Linear and Nonlinear Responses and Universality of Critical Exponents in Hamiltonian Systems with Long-Range Interaction

Shun Ogawa, Yoshiyuki Y. Yamaguchi

We investigate the linear and the nonlinear responses to the external field in the mean-field interaction systems whose dynamics is described by the Vlasov equation in the limit of large population. A nonlinear response formula is derived by the asymptotic-transient decomposition, which is developed for analyzing the nonlinear Landau damping and plasma waves. The formula gives a self-consistent equation for the asymptotic state, which is in general not in thermal equilibrium but in a long-lasting nonequilibrium quasistationary state due to the long-range nature of the interaction. This formula is useful to compute the critical exponent analytically for the nonlinear response at the critical point, denoted by δ. Further advantage of this formula is that it includes the linear response formula obtained from the naively linearized equation, and unifies the nonlinear and the linear responses, where the latter induces another critical exponent γ for the zero-field susceptibility. Interestingly, these critical exponents for the quasistationary states differ from ones in thermal equilibria, but the Widom’s scaling relation holds true even for the non-classical critical exponents. We discuss universality of the critical exponents and the scaling relation for spatially periodic one-dimensional systems.

Chaos, Complexity and Transport (CCT)•Jan 4, 2017•0 citations

Long-time behavior of quasistationary states of the Hamiltonian mean-field model

Alessandro Campa, Andrea Giansanti, Gianluca Morelli

The Hamiltonian mean-field model has been investigated, since its introduction about a decade ago, to study the equilibrium and dynamical properties of long-range interacting systems. Here we study the long-time behavior of long-lived, out-of-equilibrium, quasistationary dynamical states, whose lifetime diverges in the thermodynamic limit. The nature of these states has been the object of a lively debate in the recent past. We introduce a numerical tool, based on the fluctuations of the phase of the instantaneous magnetization of the system. Using this tool, we study the quasistationary states that arise when the system is started from different classes of initial conditions, showing that the new observable can be exploited to compute the lifetime of these states. We also show that quasistationary states are present not only below, but also above the critical temperature of the second-order magnetic phase transition of the model. We find that at supercritical temperatures the lifetime is much larger than at subcritical temperatures.

arXiv:0706.3664•Physical Review E•Oct 11, 2007•71 citations

Analytical derivation of critical exponents of the dynamic phase transition in the mean-field approximation

R. A. Gallardo, O. Idigoras, P. Landeros +1 more

We have analyzed the dynamic phase transition of the kinetic Ising model in mean-field approximation by means of an analytical approach. Specifically, we study the evolution of the system under the simultaneous influence of time-dependent and time-independent magnetic fields. We demonstrate that within the approximate analytical treatment of our approach, the dynamic phase transition exhibits power-law dependencies for the order parameter that have the same critical exponents as the mean-field equilibrium case. Moreover we have obtained an equation of state, with which we can prove that the time-independent field component is effectively the conjugate field of the order parameter. Our analysis is limited to the parameter range, in which only second-order phase transitions occur, i.e., for small applied field amplitudes and temperatures close to the Curie point. In order to ensure the reliability of our analytical results we have corroborated them by comparison to numerical evaluations of the same model.

Physical Review E•Nov 2, 2012•31 citations

Strange scaling and relaxation of finite-size fluctuation in thermal equilibrium

Yoshiyuki Y. Yamaguchi

We numerically exhibit two strange phenomena of finite-size fluctuation in thermal equilibrium of a paradigmatic long-range interacting system having a second-order phase transition. One is a nonclassical finite-size scaling at the critical point, which differs from the prediction by statistical mechanics. With the aid of this strange scaling, the scaling theory for infinite-range models conjectures the nonclassical values of critical exponents for the correlation length. The other is relaxation of the fluctuation strength from one level to another in spite of being in thermal equilibrium. A scenario is proposed to explain these phenomena from the viewpoint of the Casimir invariants and their nonexactness in finite-size systems, where the Casimir invariants are conserved in the Vlasov dynamics describing the long-range interacting systems in the limit of large population. This scenario suggests appearance of the reported phenomena in a wide class of isolated long-range interacting systems.

arXiv:1603.03173•Physical review. E•Jul 22, 2016•9 citations
Mean-field theory tells us that the classical critical exponent of susceptibility is twice that of magnetization. However, linear response theory based on the Vlasov equation, which is naturally introduced by the mean-field nature, makes the former exponent half of the latter for families of quasistationary states having second order phase transitions in the Hamiltonian mean-field model and its variances, in the low-energy phase. We clarify that this strange exponent is due to the existence of Casimir invariants which trap the system in a quasistationary state for a time scale diverging with the system size. The theoretical prediction is numerically confirmed by N-body simulations for the equilibrium states and a family of quasistationary states.
An external force dynamically drives an isolated mean-field Hamiltonian system to a long-lasting quasistationary state, whose lifetime increases with population of the system. For second order phase transitions in quasistationary states, two nonclassical critical exponents have been reported individually by using a linear and a nonlinear response theories in a toy model. We provide a simple way to compute the critical exponents all at once, which is an analog of the Landau theory. The present theory extends the universality class of the nonclassical exponents to spatially periodic one-dimensional systems and shows that the exponents satisfy a classical scaling relation inevitably by using a key scaling of momentum.
A nonlinear response theory is provided by use of the transient linearization method in the spatially one-dimensional Vlasov systems. The theory inclusively gives responses to external fields and to perturbations for initial stationary states, and is applicable even to the critical point of a second-order phase transition. We apply the theory to the Hamiltonian mean-field model, a toy model of a ferromagnetic body, and investigate the critical exponent associated with the response to the external field at the critical point in particular. The obtained critical exponent is the nonclassical value 3/2, while the classical value is 3. However, interestingly, one scaling relation holds with another nonclassical critical exponent of susceptibility in the isolated Vlasov systems. Validity of the theory is numerically confirmed by directly simulating temporal evolutions of the Vlasov equation.
We investigate the linear and the nonlinear responses to the external field in the mean-field interaction systems whose dynamics is described by the Vlasov equation in the limit of large population. A nonlinear response formula is derived by the asymptotic-transient decomposition, which is developed for analyzing the nonlinear Landau damping and plasma waves. The formula gives a self-consistent equation for the asymptotic state, which is in general not in thermal equilibrium but in a long-lasting nonequilibrium quasistationary state due to the long-range nature of the interaction. This formula is useful to compute the critical exponent analytically for the nonlinear response at the critical point, denoted by δ. Further advantage of this formula is that it includes the linear response formula obtained from the naively linearized equation, and unifies the nonlinear and the linear responses, where the latter induces another critical exponent γ for the zero-field susceptibility. Interestingly, these critical exponents for the quasistationary states differ from ones in thermal equilibria, but the Widom’s scaling relation holds true even for the non-classical critical exponents. We discuss universality of the critical exponents and the scaling relation for spatially periodic one-dimensional systems.
The Hamiltonian mean-field model has been investigated, since its introduction about a decade ago, to study the equilibrium and dynamical properties of long-range interacting systems. Here we study the long-time behavior of long-lived, out-of-equilibrium, quasistationary dynamical states, whose lifetime diverges in the thermodynamic limit. The nature of these states has been the object of a lively debate in the recent past. We introduce a numerical tool, based on the fluctuations of the phase of the instantaneous magnetization of the system. Using this tool, we study the quasistationary states that arise when the system is started from different classes of initial conditions, showing that the new observable can be exploited to compute the lifetime of these states. We also show that quasistationary states are present not only below, but also above the critical temperature of the second-order magnetic phase transition of the model. We find that at supercritical temperatures the lifetime is much larger than at subcritical temperatures.
We have analyzed the dynamic phase transition of the kinetic Ising model in mean-field approximation by means of an analytical approach. Specifically, we study the evolution of the system under the simultaneous influence of time-dependent and time-independent magnetic fields. We demonstrate that within the approximate analytical treatment of our approach, the dynamic phase transition exhibits power-law dependencies for the order parameter that have the same critical exponents as the mean-field equilibrium case. Moreover we have obtained an equation of state, with which we can prove that the time-independent field component is effectively the conjugate field of the order parameter. Our analysis is limited to the parameter range, in which only second-order phase transitions occur, i.e., for small applied field amplitudes and temperatures close to the Curie point. In order to ensure the reliability of our analytical results we have corroborated them by comparison to numerical evaluations of the same model.
We numerically exhibit two strange phenomena of finite-size fluctuation in thermal equilibrium of a paradigmatic long-range interacting system having a second-order phase transition. One is a nonclassical finite-size scaling at the critical point, which differs from the prediction by statistical mechanics. With the aid of this strange scaling, the scaling theory for infinite-range models conjectures the nonclassical values of critical exponents for the correlation length. The other is relaxation of the fluctuation strength from one level to another in spite of being in thermal equilibrium. A scenario is proposed to explain these phenomena from the viewpoint of the Casimir invariants and their nonexactness in finite-size systems, where the Casimir invariants are conserved in the Vlasov dynamics describing the long-range interacting systems in the limit of large population. This scenario suggests appearance of the reported phenomena in a wide class of isolated long-range interacting systems.