Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1304.2402 · Physical Review B

Equilibration and coarsening in the quantum O(N) model at infinite N

Anushya Chandran, Arun Nanduri, Steven S. Gubser, Shivaji L. Sondhi

Published Jul 31, 2013• 89 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The quantum $O(N)$ model in the infinite-$N$ limit is a paradigm for symmetry breaking. Qualitatively, its phase diagram is an excellent guide to the equilibrium physics for more realistic values of $N$ in varying spatial dimensions ($d>1$). Here, we investigate the physics of this model out of equilibrium, specifically its response to global quenches starting in the disordered phase. If the model were to exhibit equilibration, the late-time state could be inferred from the finite-temperature phase diagram. In the infinite-$N$ limit, we show that not only does the model not lead to equilibration on account of an infinite number of conserved quantities, it also does not relax to a generalized Gibbs ensemble (GGE) consistent with these conserved quantities. Instead, an infinite number of new conservation laws emerge at late times and the system relaxes to an emergent GGE consistent with these. Nevertheless, we still find that the late-time states following quenches bear strong signatures of the equilibrium phase diagram. Notably, we find that the model exhibits coarsening to a nonequilibrium critical state only in dimensions $d>2$, that is, if the equilibrium phase diagram contains an ordered phase at nonzero temperatures.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.88.024306

Related papers

Entanglement and dynamics in many-body systems

Anushya Chandran

In the first part of this dissertation, we study the dynamics of isolated and clean quantum systems out of equilibrium. We initially address the Kibble-Zurek (KZ) problem of determining the dynamical evolution of a system close to its critical point under slow changes of a control parameter. We formulate a scaling limit in which the nonequilibrium behavior is universal and discuss the universal content. We then report computations of some scaling functions in model Gaussian and large-N problems. Next, we apply KZ scaling to topologically ordered systems with no local order parameter. In the examples of the Ising gauge theory and the SU(2)k phases of the Levin-Wen models, we observe a slow, coarsening dynamics for the string-net that underlies the physics of the topological phase at late times for ramps across transitions that reduce topological order. We conclude by studying quenches in the quantum O(N) model in the infinite N limit in varying spatial dimensions. Despite the failure to equilibrate owing to an infinite number of emergent conservation laws, the qualitative features of late time states following quenches is predicted by the equilibrium phase diagram. In the second part of this dissertation, we explore the relationship between entanglement and topological order in fractional quantum Hall (FQH) phases. In 2008, Li and Haldane conjectured that the entanglement spectrum (ES), a presentation of the Schmidt values of a real space cut, reflects the energy spectrum of the FQH chiral edge. Specifically, both spectra should have the same quasi-degeneracy of eigenvalues everywhere in the phase. We offer an analytic, microscopic proof of this conjecture in the Read-Rezayi sequence of model states. We further identify a different ES that reflects the bulk quasihole spectrum and prove a bulk-edge correspondence in the ES. Finally, we show that the finite-size corrections of the ES of the Laughlin states reveal the fractionalization of the underlying quasiparticles.

•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Athermality of generalized Gibbs ensembles

Riccardo Senese, Bruno Bertini, Katja Klobas +1 more

Integrable quantum systems evolving from non-equilibrium initial states do not thermalize to conventional Gibbs ensembles (GE). Instead, at long times they relax to generalized Gibbs ensembles (GGEs), which incorporate the full set of local and quasi-local conserved quantities. While GGEs have been extensively studied in the literature, a quantitative analytic characterization of how different they are from ordinary GEs is still lacking. In this work, we address this question by employing the concept of athermality, which we define within quantum resource theory as the relative entropy between a given state and the closest thermal state. By means of integrability techniques we compute the athermality for several quantum quenches in paradigmatic integrable models, including the free XY spin chain, the interacting Lieb-Liniger model, the XXZ spin chain, and the harmonic chain. We find that often the athermality becomes anomalously small when the post-quench Hamiltonian is critical in its ground state, despite probing physics at a finite energy density. We also prove that it systematically develops a singularity at criticality, which is inherited from the entropy of the GGE.

cond-mat.stat-mechCross-listedarXiv:2606.30762•Journal of Quantum Science•Jul 1, 2026•2 citations

Non-equilibrium critical dynamics

Uwe Claus Täuber

We now begin our exposition of universal dynamic scaling behavior that emerges under non-equilibrium conditions. We are mainly concerned with the relaxational models A and B here, but also touch on other dynamic universality classes. First, we consider non-equilibrium critical relaxation from a disordered initial state, and compute the associated universal scaling exponents within the dynamic renormalization group framework. Related phenomena in the early-time regime, prior to reaching temporally translationally invariant asymptotics, are ‘aging’ and a non-equilibrium fluctuation-dissipation ratio, both of which have enjoyed prominence in the literature on ‘glassy’ kinetics. In this context, we derive the critical initial slip exponent for the order parameter, and briefly discuss interesting persistence properties. Second, we explore the long-time scaling laws in phase ordering kinetics and coarsening for the relaxational models, following a fast temperature ‘quench’ into the ordered phase, in systems with either non-conserved or conserved order parameters. Aside from a few explicit computations in the spherical model limit (wherein the number of order parameter components n → ∞), we largely employ phenomenological considerations and scaling theory, stressing the importance of topological defects for energy dissipation during coarsening. Next we address the question how violations of Einstein's relation that links relaxation coefficients and noise correlations might affect the asymptotic dynamic critical scaling behavior. Whereas in systems with non-conserved order parameter typically the equilibrium scaling laws are recovered in the vicinity of the critical point, in contrast genuinely novel universality classes may emerge in the case of a conserved parameter, provided it is driven out of equilibrium in a spatially anisotropic fashion.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Mar 6, 2014•2 citations

Universality in the equilibration of quantum systems after a small quench

Lorenzo Campos Venuti, Paolo Zanardi

A sudden change in the Hamiltonian parameter drives a quantum system out of equilibrium. For a finite-size system, expectations of observables start fluctuating in time without converging to a precise limit. A new equilibrium state emerges only in the probabilistic sense, when the probability distribution for the observable expectations over long times concentrates around their mean value. In this paper we study the full statistic of generic observables after a small quench. When the quench is performed around a regular (i.e., noncritical) point of the phase diagram, generic observables are expected to be characterized by Gaussian distribution functions (``good equilibration''). Instead, when quenching around a critical point a new, universal, double-peaked distribution function emerges for relevant perturbations. Our analytic predictions are numerically checked for a nonintegrable extension of the quantum Ising model.

arXiv:0912.3357•Physical Review A•Mar 11, 2010•37 citations

Quantum Quench from interacting massive to free massless bosons in one dimension

Spyros Sotiriadis

One of the fundamental principles of statistical physics is that only partial information about a system's state is required for its macroscopic description. This is not only true for thermal ensembles, but also for the unconventional ensemble, known as Generalized Gibbs Ensemble (GGE), that is expected to describe the relaxation of integrable systems after a quantum quench. By analytically studying the quench dynamics in a prototypical one-dimensional critical model, the massless free bosonic field theory, we find evidence of a novel type of equilibration characterized by the preservation of an enormous amount of memory of the initial state that is accessible by local measurements. In particular, we show that the equilibration retains memory of non-Gaussian initial correlations, in contrast to the case of massive free evolution which erases all such memory. The GGE in its standard form, being a Gaussian ensemble, fails to predict correctly the equilibrium values of local observables, unless the initial state is Gaussian itself. Our findings show that the equilibration of a broad class of quenches whose evolution is described by Luttinger liquid theory with an initial state that is non-Gaussian in terms of the bosonic field, is not correctly captured by the corresponding bosonic GGE, raising doubts about the validity of the latter in general one-dimensional gapless integrable systems such as the Lieb-Liniger model. We also propose that the same experiment by which the GGE was recently observed [Langen et al., Science 348 (2015) 207-211] can also be used to observe its failure, simply by starting from a non-Gaussian initial state.

•Jul 28, 2015•1 citation

Universality and weak-ergodicity breaking in quantum quenches

Guido Giachetti, Andrea Solfanelli, Nicolò Defenu

Understanding equilibration and universality after sudden quantum quenches remains a central challenge in isolated many-body systems. Persistent oscillations and anomalous scaling reported in lattice models appear to challenge the standard picture based on integrability and quantum-to-classical correspondence. Focusing on the quantum $O(n)$ model in the large-$n$ limit, we show that these apparent anomalies originate from lattice effects and an underlying integrable structure. In particular, we map the post-quench dynamics onto an integrable Neumann system and we derive a new action-angle description valid in the thermodynamic limit. This framework explains both the convergence of long-time averages to the generalized Gibbs ensemble and the emergence of persistent oscillations associated with an isolated mode at the upper edge of the phonon spectrum. We further show that the expected thermal universality class is recovered in the appropriate scaling regime, while the oscillations disappear in the quantum field theory limit.

cond-mat.stat-mechCross-listedarXiv:2511.08687•Physical Review Research•Nov 13, 2025•3 citations
The quantum O(N)O(N)O(N) model in the infinite-NNN limit is a paradigm for symmetry breaking. Qualitatively, its phase diagram is an excellent guide to the equilibrium physics for more realistic values of NNN in varying spatial dimensions (d>1d>1d>1). Here, we investigate the physics of this model out of equilibrium, specifically its response to global quenches starting in the disordered phase. If the model were to exhibit equilibration, the late-time state could be inferred from the finite-temperature phase diagram. In the infinite-NNN limit, we show that not only does the model not lead to equilibration on account of an infinite number of conserved quantities, it also does not relax to a generalized Gibbs ensemble (GGE) consistent with these conserved quantities. Instead, an infinite number of new conservation laws emerge at late times and the system relaxes to an emergent GGE consistent with these. Nevertheless, we still find that the late-time states following quenches bear strong signatures of the equilibrium phase diagram. Notably, we find that the model exhibits coarsening to a nonequilibrium critical state only in dimensions d>2d>2d>2, that is, if the equilibrium phase diagram contains an ordered phase at nonzero temperatures.
In the first part of this dissertation, we study the dynamics of isolated and clean quantum systems out of equilibrium. We initially address the Kibble-Zurek (KZ) problem of determining the dynamical evolution of a system close to its critical point under slow changes of a control parameter. We formulate a scaling limit in which the nonequilibrium behavior is universal and discuss the universal content. We then report computations of some scaling functions in model Gaussian and large-N problems. Next, we apply KZ scaling to topologically ordered systems with no local order parameter. In the examples of the Ising gauge theory and the SU(2)k phases of the Levin-Wen models, we observe a slow, coarsening dynamics for the string-net that underlies the physics of the topological phase at late times for ramps across transitions that reduce topological order. We conclude by studying quenches in the quantum O(N) model in the infinite N limit in varying spatial dimensions. Despite the failure to equilibrate owing to an infinite number of emergent conservation laws, the qualitative features of late time states following quenches is predicted by the equilibrium phase diagram. In the second part of this dissertation, we explore the relationship between entanglement and topological order in fractional quantum Hall (FQH) phases. In 2008, Li and Haldane conjectured that the entanglement spectrum (ES), a presentation of the Schmidt values of a real space cut, reflects the energy spectrum of the FQH chiral edge. Specifically, both spectra should have the same quasi-degeneracy of eigenvalues everywhere in the phase. We offer an analytic, microscopic proof of this conjecture in the Read-Rezayi sequence of model states. We further identify a different ES that reflects the bulk quasihole spectrum and prove a bulk-edge correspondence in the ES. Finally, we show that the finite-size corrections of the ES of the Laughlin states reveal the fractionalization of the underlying quasiparticles.
Integrable quantum systems evolving from non-equilibrium initial states do not thermalize to conventional Gibbs ensembles (GE). Instead, at long times they relax to generalized Gibbs ensembles (GGEs), which incorporate the full set of local and quasi-local conserved quantities. While GGEs have been extensively studied in the literature, a quantitative analytic characterization of how different they are from ordinary GEs is still lacking. In this work, we address this question by employing the concept of athermality, which we define within quantum resource theory as the relative entropy between a given state and the closest thermal state. By means of integrability techniques we compute the athermality for several quantum quenches in paradigmatic integrable models, including the free XY spin chain, the interacting Lieb-Liniger model, the XXZ spin chain, and the harmonic chain. We find that often the athermality becomes anomalously small when the post-quench Hamiltonian is critical in its ground state, despite probing physics at a finite energy density. We also prove that it systematically develops a singularity at criticality, which is inherited from the entropy of the GGE.
We now begin our exposition of universal dynamic scaling behavior that emerges under non-equilibrium conditions. We are mainly concerned with the relaxational models A and B here, but also touch on other dynamic universality classes. First, we consider non-equilibrium critical relaxation from a disordered initial state, and compute the associated universal scaling exponents within the dynamic renormalization group framework. Related phenomena in the early-time regime, prior to reaching temporally translationally invariant asymptotics, are ‘aging’ and a non-equilibrium fluctuation-dissipation ratio, both of which have enjoyed prominence in the literature on ‘glassy’ kinetics. In this context, we derive the critical initial slip exponent for the order parameter, and briefly discuss interesting persistence properties. Second, we explore the long-time scaling laws in phase ordering kinetics and coarsening for the relaxational models, following a fast temperature ‘quench’ into the ordered phase, in systems with either non-conserved or conserved order parameters. Aside from a few explicit computations in the spherical model limit (wherein the number of order parameter components n → ∞), we largely employ phenomenological considerations and scaling theory, stressing the importance of topological defects for energy dissipation during coarsening. Next we address the question how violations of Einstein's relation that links relaxation coefficients and noise correlations might affect the asymptotic dynamic critical scaling behavior. Whereas in systems with non-conserved order parameter typically the equilibrium scaling laws are recovered in the vicinity of the critical point, in contrast genuinely novel universality classes may emerge in the case of a conserved parameter, provided it is driven out of equilibrium in a spatially anisotropic fashion.
A sudden change in the Hamiltonian parameter drives a quantum system out of equilibrium. For a finite-size system, expectations of observables start fluctuating in time without converging to a precise limit. A new equilibrium state emerges only in the probabilistic sense, when the probability distribution for the observable expectations over long times concentrates around their mean value. In this paper we study the full statistic of generic observables after a small quench. When the quench is performed around a regular (i.e., noncritical) point of the phase diagram, generic observables are expected to be characterized by Gaussian distribution functions (``good equilibration''). Instead, when quenching around a critical point a new, universal, double-peaked distribution function emerges for relevant perturbations. Our analytic predictions are numerically checked for a nonintegrable extension of the quantum Ising model.
One of the fundamental principles of statistical physics is that only partial information about a system's state is required for its macroscopic description. This is not only true for thermal ensembles, but also for the unconventional ensemble, known as Generalized Gibbs Ensemble (GGE), that is expected to describe the relaxation of integrable systems after a quantum quench. By analytically studying the quench dynamics in a prototypical one-dimensional critical model, the massless free bosonic field theory, we find evidence of a novel type of equilibration characterized by the preservation of an enormous amount of memory of the initial state that is accessible by local measurements. In particular, we show that the equilibration retains memory of non-Gaussian initial correlations, in contrast to the case of massive free evolution which erases all such memory. The GGE in its standard form, being a Gaussian ensemble, fails to predict correctly the equilibrium values of local observables, unless the initial state is Gaussian itself. Our findings show that the equilibration of a broad class of quenches whose evolution is described by Luttinger liquid theory with an initial state that is non-Gaussian in terms of the bosonic field, is not correctly captured by the corresponding bosonic GGE, raising doubts about the validity of the latter in general one-dimensional gapless integrable systems such as the Lieb-Liniger model. We also propose that the same experiment by which the GGE was recently observed [Langen et al., Science 348 (2015) 207-211] can also be used to observe its failure, simply by starting from a non-Gaussian initial state.
Understanding equilibration and universality after sudden quantum quenches remains a central challenge in isolated many-body systems. Persistent oscillations and anomalous scaling reported in lattice models appear to challenge the standard picture based on integrability and quantum-to-classical correspondence. Focusing on the quantum O(n)O(n)O(n) model in the large-nnn limit, we show that these apparent anomalies originate from lattice effects and an underlying integrable structure. In particular, we map the post-quench dynamics onto an integrable Neumann system and we derive a new action-angle description valid in the thermodynamic limit. This framework explains both the convergence of long-time averages to the generalized Gibbs ensemble and the emergence of persistent oscillations associated with an isolated mode at the upper edge of the phonon spectrum. We further show that the expected thermal universality class is recovered in the appropriate scaling regime, while the oscillations disappear in the quantum field theory limit.