Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1304.2197 · Physical Review A

Violation of an extended Wigner inequality with high-angular-momentum states

William N. Plick, Robert Fickler, Radek Łapkiewicz, Sven Ramelow

Published Feb 27, 2015• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In the study of systems that cannot be described classically, the Wigner inequality, has received only a small amount of attention. In this paper we extend the Wigner inequality---originally derived in 1969---and show how it may be used to contradict local realism with only coincidence detections in the absence of two-outcome measurements---that is, for any system where only one possible result of a pair of potential outcomes can be registered. It thus encapsulates a much broader class of measurement schemes than could previously violate a local-realistic inequality. This is possible due to an assumption of ``extended fairness'' on the measurement outcomes, which we posit is highly plausible. We then apply this inequality to a recently constructed setup with access to entangled pairs of photons with very high angular momenta, in which no previously derived local-realistic inequality could successfully be used without making very broad assumptions. We thus demonstrate the versatility of this inequality under very lossy conditions.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.91.022124

Related papers

A robust Bell inequality without two-outcome measurements

William N. Plick, Robert Fickler, Radek Łapkiewicz +1 more

We present a novel Bell inequality that does not require dichotomic (two-outcome) measurements. It is based on an inequality originally derived by Wigner in 1969, extending it such that no assumptions other than local-realism, fair-sampling, and freedom-of-choice are necessary. It is most useful in situations where there is no direct access to true two-outcome (dichotomic) measurements, like photonic quantum experiments where spatial degrees-of-freedoms are often analyzed with spatial light modulators (SLMs), as well as many other experimental scenarios. The only other class of inequalities (CH-type) that has this feature requires coincidence and single count-rates to be of the same order of magnitude for violation, ours does not. It thereby enables the stringent verification of entanglement and rejection of local-realism, without any assumptions about the underlying Hilbert-space, such as dimensionality – in the most dificult experimental conditions. We also experimentally violate this inequality in a novel setup: entangled states of very high orbital angular momentum. This constitutes a rejection of the hypothesis of local realism (under reasonable assumptions) with the highest quanta to date.

Research in Optical Sciences•Jan 1, 2014•0 citations

A robust Bell inequality without two-outcome measurements

William N. Plick, Robert Fickler, Radek Łapkiewicz +1 more

We present a Bell inequality that does not require two-outcome measurements. It is based on an inequality originally derived by Wigner, extending it such that no assumptions other than local-realism, fair-sampling, and freedom-of-choice are necessary.

Bulletin of the American Physical Society•Mar 6, 2014•0 citations

Wigner inequalities for testing the hypothesis of realism and concepts of macroscopic and local realism

N. Nikitin, K. S. Toms

We propose a Wigner-like inequality suitable for testing the hypothesis of realism. We show that this inequality is identical neither to the well-known Wigner inequality nor to the Leggett-Garg inequality in Wigner form. The obtained inequality is suitable for testing realism not only in quantum mechanical systems, but also in quantum field systems. Also we propose a mathematically consistent derivation of the Leggett-Garg inequality in Wigner form, which was recently presented in the literature, for three and $n$ distinct moments of time. Contrary to these works, our rigor derivation uses Kolmogorov axiomatics of probability theory. We pay special attention to the construction and studies of the spaces of elementary outcomes. Based on the Leggett-Garg inequality in Wigner form for $n$ distinct moments of time we prove that any unitary evolution of a quantum system contradicts the concept of macroscopic realism. We show that application of the concept of macroscopic realism to any quantum system leads to ``freezing'' of the system in the initial state. It is shown that for a particle with an infinite number of observables the probability to find a pair of the observables in some defined state is zero, even if the operators of these observables commute. This fact might serve as an additional logical argument for the contradiction between quantum theory and classical realism.

arXiv:1808.03119•Physical Review A•Dec 10, 2019•8 citations

Maximum violation of Wigner inequality for two-spin entangled states with parallel and antiparallel polarizations

Yan Gu, Haifeng Zhang, Zhigang Song +2 more

The experimental test of Bell’s inequality is mainly focused on Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt (CHSH) form, which provides a quantitative bound, while little attention has been paid to the violation of Wigner inequality (WI). Based on the spin coherent state quantum probability statistics, we in the present paper extend the WI and its violation to arbitrary two-spin entangled states with antiparallel and parallel spin-polarizations. The local part of density operator gives rise to the WI while the violation is a direct result of nonlocal interference between two components of the entangled states. The Wigner measuring outcome correlation denoted by [Formula: see text] is always less than or at most equal to zero for the local realist model ([Formula: see text]) regardless of the specific initial state. On the other hand, the violation of WI is characterized by any positive value of [Formula: see text], which possesses a maximum violation bound [Formula: see text] [Formula: see text]. We conclude that the WI is equally convenient for the experimental test of violation by the quantum entanglement.

arXiv:1801.08802•International Journal of Quantum Information•Jul 8, 2018•3 citations

Bell-inequality violation with entangled photons, free of the coincidence-time loophole

Jan-Åke Larsson, Marissa Giustina, Johannes Kofler +3 more

In a local realist model, physical properties are defined prior to and independent of measurement and no physical influence can propagate faster than the speed of light. Proper experimental violation of a Bell inequality would show that the world cannot be described with such a model. Experiments intended to demonstrate a violation usually require additional assumptions that make them vulnerable to a number of ``loopholes.'' In both pulsed and continuously pumped photonic experiments, an experimenter needs to identify which detected photons belong to the same pair, giving rise to the coincidence-time loophole. Here, via two different methods, we derive Clauser-Horne- and Eberhard-type inequalities that are not only free of the fair-sampling assumption (thus not being vulnerable to the detection loophole), but also free of the fair-coincidence assumption (thus not being vulnerable to the coincidence-time loophole). Both approaches can be used for pulsed as well as for continuously pumped experiments. Moreover, as they can also be applied to already existing experimental data, we finally show that a recent experiment [Giustina et al., Nature (London) 497, 227 (2013)] violated local realism without requiring the fair-coincidence assumption.

arXiv:1309.0712•Physical Review A•Sep 16, 2014•53 citations

A Probability Model for the Bell Experiment

Kees van Hee, Kees van Berkel, J. de Graaf

The Bell inequality constrains the outcomes of measurements on pairs of distant entangled particles. The Bell contradiction states that the Bell inequality is inconsistent with the calculated outcomes of these quantum experiments. This contradiction led many to question the underlying assumptions, viz. so-called realism and locality. The probability model underlying the Bell inequality is generally left implicit. We propose an explicit probability model for the CHSH version of the Bell experiment. This model has only two simultaneously observable detector settings per measurement, and therefore does not assume realism. The quantum expectation now becomes a conditional expectation, given the two detector settings. This probability model is in full agreement with both quantum mechanics and experiments. As a result, the model satisfies the Bell inequality; there are no so-called violations. We extend this model to include a hidden variable. This extended model is not Bell-separable. This non-separability implies that the model is non-deterministic or non-local (or both).

arXiv:2302.05174•Quantum Reports•Feb 14, 2026•1 citation
In the study of systems that cannot be described classically, the Wigner inequality, has received only a small amount of attention. In this paper we extend the Wigner inequality---originally derived in 1969---and show how it may be used to contradict local realism with only coincidence detections in the absence of two-outcome measurements---that is, for any system where only one possible result of a pair of potential outcomes can be registered. It thus encapsulates a much broader class of measurement schemes than could previously violate a local-realistic inequality. This is possible due to an assumption of ``extended fairness'' on the measurement outcomes, which we posit is highly plausible. We then apply this inequality to a recently constructed setup with access to entangled pairs of photons with very high angular momenta, in which no previously derived local-realistic inequality could successfully be used without making very broad assumptions. We thus demonstrate the versatility of this inequality under very lossy conditions.
We present a novel Bell inequality that does not require dichotomic (two-outcome) measurements. It is based on an inequality originally derived by Wigner in 1969, extending it such that no assumptions other than local-realism, fair-sampling, and freedom-of-choice are necessary. It is most useful in situations where there is no direct access to true two-outcome (dichotomic) measurements, like photonic quantum experiments where spatial degrees-of-freedoms are often analyzed with spatial light modulators (SLMs), as well as many other experimental scenarios. The only other class of inequalities (CH-type) that has this feature requires coincidence and single count-rates to be of the same order of magnitude for violation, ours does not. It thereby enables the stringent verification of entanglement and rejection of local-realism, without any assumptions about the underlying Hilbert-space, such as dimensionality – in the most dificult experimental conditions. We also experimentally violate this inequality in a novel setup: entangled states of very high orbital angular momentum. This constitutes a rejection of the hypothesis of local realism (under reasonable assumptions) with the highest quanta to date.
We propose a Wigner-like inequality suitable for testing the hypothesis of realism. We show that this inequality is identical neither to the well-known Wigner inequality nor to the Leggett-Garg inequality in Wigner form. The obtained inequality is suitable for testing realism not only in quantum mechanical systems, but also in quantum field systems. Also we propose a mathematically consistent derivation of the Leggett-Garg inequality in Wigner form, which was recently presented in the literature, for three and nnn distinct moments of time. Contrary to these works, our rigor derivation uses Kolmogorov axiomatics of probability theory. We pay special attention to the construction and studies of the spaces of elementary outcomes. Based on the Leggett-Garg inequality in Wigner form for nnn distinct moments of time we prove that any unitary evolution of a quantum system contradicts the concept of macroscopic realism. We show that application of the concept of macroscopic realism to any quantum system leads to ``freezing'' of the system in the initial state. It is shown that for a particle with an infinite number of observables the probability to find a pair of the observables in some defined state is zero, even if the operators of these observables commute. This fact might serve as an additional logical argument for the contradiction between quantum theory and classical realism.
The experimental test of Bell’s inequality is mainly focused on Clauser–Horne–Shimony–Holt (CHSH) form, which provides a quantitative bound, while little attention has been paid to the violation of Wigner inequality (WI). Based on the spin coherent state quantum probability statistics, we in the present paper extend the WI and its violation to arbitrary two-spin entangled states with antiparallel and parallel spin-polarizations. The local part of density operator gives rise to the WI while the violation is a direct result of nonlocal interference between two components of the entangled states. The Wigner measuring outcome correlation denoted by [Formula: see text] is always less than or at most equal to zero for the local realist model ([Formula: see text]) regardless of the specific initial state. On the other hand, the violation of WI is characterized by any positive value of [Formula: see text], which possesses a maximum violation bound [Formula: see text] [Formula: see text]. We conclude that the WI is equally convenient for the experimental test of violation by the quantum entanglement.
In a local realist model, physical properties are defined prior to and independent of measurement and no physical influence can propagate faster than the speed of light. Proper experimental violation of a Bell inequality would show that the world cannot be described with such a model. Experiments intended to demonstrate a violation usually require additional assumptions that make them vulnerable to a number of ``loopholes.'' In both pulsed and continuously pumped photonic experiments, an experimenter needs to identify which detected photons belong to the same pair, giving rise to the coincidence-time loophole. Here, via two different methods, we derive Clauser-Horne- and Eberhard-type inequalities that are not only free of the fair-sampling assumption (thus not being vulnerable to the detection loophole), but also free of the fair-coincidence assumption (thus not being vulnerable to the coincidence-time loophole). Both approaches can be used for pulsed as well as for continuously pumped experiments. Moreover, as they can also be applied to already existing experimental data, we finally show that a recent experiment [Giustina et al., Nature (London) 497, 227 (2013)] violated local realism without requiring the fair-coincidence assumption.
The Bell inequality constrains the outcomes of measurements on pairs of distant entangled particles. The Bell contradiction states that the Bell inequality is inconsistent with the calculated outcomes of these quantum experiments. This contradiction led many to question the underlying assumptions, viz. so-called realism and locality. The probability model underlying the Bell inequality is generally left implicit. We propose an explicit probability model for the CHSH version of the Bell experiment. This model has only two simultaneously observable detector settings per measurement, and therefore does not assume realism. The quantum expectation now becomes a conditional expectation, given the two detector settings. This probability model is in full agreement with both quantum mechanics and experiments. As a result, the model satisfies the Bell inequality; there are no so-called violations. We extend this model to include a hidden variable. This extended model is not Bell-separable. This non-separability implies that the model is non-deterministic or non-local (or both).