Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1304.0216 · High Temperature

Analytical contradictions of the fixed-node density matrix

Vladimir S. Filinov

Published Sep 1, 2014• 17 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Over the last decades the fixed-node method has been used for a numerical treatment of thermo-dynamic properties of strongly correlated Fermi systems. In this work correctness of the fixed-node method for ideal Fermi systems is analytically analyzed. It is shown that the fixed-node prescription of calculation of the density matrix leads to contradictions even for two ideal fermions. The main conclusion of this work is that the fixed-node method can not reproduce the fermion density matrices and should be considered as uncontrolled empirical approach in treatment of thermodynamics of Fermi systems.

DOI
10.1134/s0018151x14040105

Related papers

Cluster expansion for ideal Fermi systems in the `fixed-node approximation'

Vladimir S. Filinov

Over the last ten years the `fixed-node approximation', well known in the literature, has been widely used for a numerical treatment of thermodynamic properties of strongly correlated Fermi systems. Results of the direct path integral Monte Carlo simulation performed here show that the `fixed-node approximation' describes the thermodynamic properties of the strongly coupling fermions rather well at `weak and moderate' degeneracy. To analyse the reasons for the increasing difference between the `fixed-node approximation' and the results of direct path integral Monte Carlo simulations for highly degenerate fermions, the correctness of the `fixed-node approximation' for ideal Fermi systems has been analysed by analytical methods. A rigorous proof has been given of the fact that the exact Fermi function with index 3 / 2 describing the logarithm of the grand partition function of ideal fermions cannot be reproduced in the `fixed-node approximation', which means that the `fixed-node approximation' does not give the correct ideal Fermi gas limit.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Feb 19, 2001•20 citations

Jellium at finite temperature

Riccardo Fantoni

We adopt the fixed node restricted path integral Monte Carlo method within the ‘Worm algorithm’ to simulate Wigner's Jellium model at finite, non zero, temperatures using free-particle nodes of the density matrix. The new element is that we incorporate the Worm algorithm paradigm of Prokof'ev and Svistunov in the grand canonical ensemble in order to more efficiently handle the fermionic exchanges. We present results for the structure and thermodynamic properties of the ideal Fermi gas and three points for the interacting electron gas. We treat explicitly the case of the partially polarized electron gas.

arXiv:2110.07527•Molecular Physics•Oct 28, 2021•8 citations

Superfluidity of a Fermi liquid from the viewpoint of a hierarchy of equations for reduced density matrices

В. А. Головко

The hierarchy of equations for reduced density matrices relevant to thermodynamic equilibrium with account taken of the spin obtained earlier is modified in order to describe the state of a Fermi system with a condensate. Although the procedure is to some extent analogous with the one carried out by the author earlier for a Bose liquid peculiarities relevant to Fermi statistics complicate considerably the treatment. As in the case of the Bose liquid the condensate phase can be superfluid as well as nonsuperfluid, the physical causes of superfluidity being identical. A new mechanism of fermion pairing that acts even in the case of a purely repulsive Hamiltonian is pointed out. Special attention is given to the thermodynamics of a superfluid Fermi system. The example of a hard-sphere system is used to find out the form of phase diagrams, the character of the phase transition to a condensate phase and the properties of the last. Noticeable dissimilarities from a Bose system with the same Hamiltonian are revealed. Application of the present approach to superconductivity is discussed as well.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Mar 17, 2004•2 citations

The density matrix, density, and Fermi hole in Hartree–Fock theory

Kenneth A. Dawson, Norman Henry March

In density matrix and density functional theory, one is concerned with methods that bypass explicit calculation of antisymmetric wave functions but nevertheless take full account of the Fermionic nature of the problem. The purpose of this paper is to examine two quite different approaches which achieve this aim. The first of these involves general many-electron theory and subsequent closure yielding an integrodifferential equation for the density matrix. Despite the interesting nature of this equation, analytical progress is hampered by its nonlinearity. Hence we have considered an alternative more practical variational procedure which, for some simpler systems, has the additional merit of yielding closed differential equations for the density.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Dec 20, 1984•96 citations

Properties of fermionic systems with the path-integral ground state method

Sebastian Ujevic, Vinicius Zampronio, Bruno Ricardi de Abreu +1 more

We investigate strongly correlated many-body systems composed of bosons and fermions with a fully quantum treatment using the path-integral ground state method, PIGS. To account for the Fermi-Dirac statistics, we implement the fixed-node approximation into PIGS, which we then call FN-PIGS. In great detail, we discuss the pair density matrices we use to construct the full density operator in coordinate representation, a vital ingredient of the method. We consider the harmonic oscillator as a proof-of-concept and, as a platform representing quantum many-body systems, we explore helium atoms. Pure ^4 4 He systems demonstrate most of the features of the method. Complementarily, for pure ^3 3 He, the fixed-node approximation resolves the ubiquitous sign problem stemming from anti-symmetric wave functions. Finally, we investigate ^3 3 He- ^4 4 He mixtures, demonstrating the method’s robustness. One of the main features of FN-PIGS is its ability to estimate any property at temperature T = 0 T = 0 without any additional bias apart from the FN approximation; biases from long simulations are also excluded. In particular, we calculate the correlation function of pairs of equal and opposite spins and precise values of the ^3 3 He kinetic energy in the mixture.

arXiv:2207.12294•SciPost Physics Core•Apr 20, 2023•2 citations

Density Matrices of n-Fermion Systems

Alan Coleman

The energy of a system of indistinguishable particles in two-body interaction may be expressed in terms of the one and two-particle density matrices. In order to work directly with the density matrices we must know what restrictions are imposed on them by the statistics of the system. This report summarizes some results giving a partial answer to the question "What functions can arise as density matrices of a system of n fermions?".

Canadian Mathematical Bulletin•May 1, 1961•47 citations
Over the last decades the fixed-node method has been used for a numerical treatment of thermo-dynamic properties of strongly correlated Fermi systems. In this work correctness of the fixed-node method for ideal Fermi systems is analytically analyzed. It is shown that the fixed-node prescription of calculation of the density matrix leads to contradictions even for two ideal fermions. The main conclusion of this work is that the fixed-node method can not reproduce the fermion density matrices and should be considered as uncontrolled empirical approach in treatment of thermodynamics of Fermi systems.
Over the last ten years the `fixed-node approximation', well known in the literature, has been widely used for a numerical treatment of thermodynamic properties of strongly correlated Fermi systems. Results of the direct path integral Monte Carlo simulation performed here show that the `fixed-node approximation' describes the thermodynamic properties of the strongly coupling fermions rather well at `weak and moderate' degeneracy. To analyse the reasons for the increasing difference between the `fixed-node approximation' and the results of direct path integral Monte Carlo simulations for highly degenerate fermions, the correctness of the `fixed-node approximation' for ideal Fermi systems has been analysed by analytical methods. A rigorous proof has been given of the fact that the exact Fermi function with index 3 / 2 describing the logarithm of the grand partition function of ideal fermions cannot be reproduced in the `fixed-node approximation', which means that the `fixed-node approximation' does not give the correct ideal Fermi gas limit.
We adopt the fixed node restricted path integral Monte Carlo method within the ‘Worm algorithm’ to simulate Wigner's Jellium model at finite, non zero, temperatures using free-particle nodes of the density matrix. The new element is that we incorporate the Worm algorithm paradigm of Prokof'ev and Svistunov in the grand canonical ensemble in order to more efficiently handle the fermionic exchanges. We present results for the structure and thermodynamic properties of the ideal Fermi gas and three points for the interacting electron gas. We treat explicitly the case of the partially polarized electron gas.
The hierarchy of equations for reduced density matrices relevant to thermodynamic equilibrium with account taken of the spin obtained earlier is modified in order to describe the state of a Fermi system with a condensate. Although the procedure is to some extent analogous with the one carried out by the author earlier for a Bose liquid peculiarities relevant to Fermi statistics complicate considerably the treatment. As in the case of the Bose liquid the condensate phase can be superfluid as well as nonsuperfluid, the physical causes of superfluidity being identical. A new mechanism of fermion pairing that acts even in the case of a purely repulsive Hamiltonian is pointed out. Special attention is given to the thermodynamics of a superfluid Fermi system. The example of a hard-sphere system is used to find out the form of phase diagrams, the character of the phase transition to a condensate phase and the properties of the last. Noticeable dissimilarities from a Bose system with the same Hamiltonian are revealed. Application of the present approach to superconductivity is discussed as well.
In density matrix and density functional theory, one is concerned with methods that bypass explicit calculation of antisymmetric wave functions but nevertheless take full account of the Fermionic nature of the problem. The purpose of this paper is to examine two quite different approaches which achieve this aim. The first of these involves general many-electron theory and subsequent closure yielding an integrodifferential equation for the density matrix. Despite the interesting nature of this equation, analytical progress is hampered by its nonlinearity. Hence we have considered an alternative more practical variational procedure which, for some simpler systems, has the additional merit of yielding closed differential equations for the density.
We investigate strongly correlated many-body systems composed of bosons and fermions with a fully quantum treatment using the path-integral ground state method, PIGS. To account for the Fermi-Dirac statistics, we implement the fixed-node approximation into PIGS, which we then call FN-PIGS. In great detail, we discuss the pair density matrices we use to construct the full density operator in coordinate representation, a vital ingredient of the method. We consider the harmonic oscillator as a proof-of-concept and, as a platform representing quantum many-body systems, we explore helium atoms. Pure ^4 4 He systems demonstrate most of the features of the method. Complementarily, for pure ^3 3 He, the fixed-node approximation resolves the ubiquitous sign problem stemming from anti-symmetric wave functions. Finally, we investigate ^3 3 He- ^4 4 He mixtures, demonstrating the method’s robustness. One of the main features of FN-PIGS is its ability to estimate any property at temperature T = 0 T = 0 without any additional bias apart from the FN approximation; biases from long simulations are also excluded. In particular, we calculate the correlation function of pairs of equal and opposite spins and precise values of the ^3 3 He kinetic energy in the mixture.