Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1303.4716 · Physical Review B

Entanglement subspaces, trial wave functions, and special Hamiltonians in the fractional quantum Hall effect

Thomas Jackson, N. Read, Steven H. Simon

Published Aug 26, 2013• 22 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We consider spaces of trial wave functions for ground states and edge excitations in the fractional quantum Hall effect that can be obtained in various ways. In one way, functions are obtained by analyzing the entanglement of the ground-state wave function, partitioned into two parts. In another, functions are defined by the way in which they vanish as several coordinates approach the same value, or by a projection-operator Hamiltonian that enforces those conditions. In a third way, functions are given by conformal blocks from a conformal field theory (CFT). These different spaces of functions are closely related. The use of CFT methods permits an algebraic formulation to be given for all of them. In some cases, we can prove that there is a ground state, a Hamiltonian, and a CFT such that, for any number of particles, all of these spaces are the same. For such cases, this resolves several questions and conjectures: it gives a finite-size bulk-edge correspondence, and we can use the analysis of functions to construct a projection-operator Hamiltonian that produces those functions as zero-energy states. For a model related to the $\mathcal{N}=1$ superconformal algebra, the corresponding Hamiltonian imposes vanishing properties involving only three particles; for this we determine all the wave functions explicitly. We do the same for a sequence of models involving the $M(3,p)$ Virasoro minimal models that has been considered previously, using results from the literature. We exhibit the Hamiltonians for the first few cases of these. The techniques we introduce can be applied in numerous examples other than those considered here.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.88.075313

Related papers

Edge-state inner products and real-space entanglement spectrum of trial quantum Hall states

Jérôme Dubail, N. Read, Edward H. Rezayi

We consider the trial wave functions for the fractional quantum Hall effect that are given by conformal blocks, and construct their associated edge excited states in full generality. The inner products between these edge states are computed in the thermodynamic limit, assuming generalized screening (i.e., short-range correlations only) inside the quantum Hall droplet and using the language of boundary conformal field theory (boundary CFT). These inner products take universal values in this limit: they are equal to the corresponding inner products in the bulk two-dimensional chiral CFT which underlies the trial wave function. This is a bulk/edge correspondence; it shows the equality between equal-time correlators along the edge and the correlators of the bulk CFT up to a Wick rotation. This approach is then used to analyze the entanglement spectrum of the ground state obtained with a bipartition $A\ensuremath{\cup}B$ in real space. Starting from our universal result for inner products in the thermodynamic limit, we tackle corrections to scaling using standard field-theoretic and renormalization-group arguments. We prove that generalized screening implies that the entanglement Hamiltonian ${H}_{E}=\ensuremath{-}\mathrm{ln}{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{A}$ is isospectral to an operator that is local along the cut between $A$ and $B$. We also show that a similar analysis can be carried out for particle partition. We discuss the close analogy between the formalism of trial wave functions given by conformal blocks and tensor product states, for which results analogous to ours have appeared recently. Finally, the edge theory and entanglement spectrum of ${p}_{x}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}i{p}_{y}$ paired superfluids are treated in a similar fashion in the Appendixes.

arXiv:1207.7119•Physical Review B•Dec 13, 2012•151 citations

Conformal field theory approach to parton fractional quantum Hall trial wave functions

Greg J. Henderson, G. J. Sreejith, Steven H. Simon

We show that all lowest Landau-level projected and unprojected chiral parton type fractional quantum Hall ground and edge-state trial wave functions, which take the form of products of integer quantum Hall wave functions, can be expressed as conformal field theory (CFT) correlation functions, where we can associate a chiral algebra to each parton state such that the CFT defined by the algebra is the “smallest” such CFT that can generate the corresponding ground and edge-state trial wave functions (assuming that the corresponding chiral algebra does indeed define a physically “sensible” CFT). A field-theoretic generalization of Laughlin's plasma analogy, known as generalized screening, is formulated for these states. If this holds, along with an additional assumption, we argue that the inner products of edge-state trial wave functions, for parton states where the “densest” trial wave function is unique, can be expressed as matrix elements of an exponentiated local action operator of the CFT, generalizing the result of Dubail [], which implies the equality between edge-state and entanglement level counting to state counting in the corresponding CFT. We numerically test this result in the case of the unprojected ν=2/5 composite fermion state and the bosonic ν=1ϕ22 parton state. We discuss how Read's arguments [] still apply, implying that conformal blocks of the CFT defined by the corresponding chiral algebra are valid quasihole trial wave functions, with the adiabatic braiding statistics given by the monodromy of these functions, assuming the existence of a quasiparticle trapping Hamiltonian. Generalizations of these constructions are discussed, with particular attention given to simple current constructions. It is shown that all chiral composite fermion wave functions can be expressed as CFT correlation functions without explicit symmetrization or antisymmetrization and that the ground, edge, and certain quasihole trial wave functions of the ϕnm parton states can be expressed as the conformal blocks of the U(1)⊗SU(n)m WZW models. Finally, we discuss the relation of the ϕ2k series with the Read-Rezayi series, where several examples of quasihole braiding statistics calculations are given. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

arXiv:2309.11910•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•May 10, 2024•7 citations

Quantum Hall wave functions based on S3 conformal field theories

Steven H. Simon, Edward H. Rezayi, Nicolas Regnault

We construct a family of quantum Hall Hamiltonians whose ground states, at least for small system sizes, give correlators of the ${S}_{3}$ conformal field theories. The ground states are considered as trial wave functions for quantum Hall effect of bosons at filling fraction $\ensuremath{\nu}=3/4$ interacting either via delta function interaction or delta function plus dipole interaction. While the ${S}_{3}$ theories can be either unitary or nonunitary, we find high overlaps with exact diagonalizations only for the nonunitary case, suggesting that these wave functions may correspond to critical points, possibly analogous to the previously studied Gaffnian wave function. These wave functions give an explicit example which cannot be fully characterized by their thin-torus limit or by their pattern of zeros.

arXiv:0908.0947•Physical Review B•Mar 2, 2010•21 citations

Effective 1D Language for Fractional Quantum Hall States

John Flavin

In the theory of the fractional quantum Hall effect, much attention is paid to the correspondence between fractional quantum Hall wave functions and conformal blocks in certain rational conformal field theories (CFT). This correspondence is powerful, enabling the calculation of the fractional statistics of a state that would be difficult if not impossible to calculate directly from the wave functions. But it is, in general, conjectural, remaining without microscopic justification in many cases of interest, and involves heavy mathematical machinery. We detail an alternative method to calculate Abelian and non-Abelian fractional statistics, the coherent state method. The method relies on assumptions which are independent of those underlying the CFT correspondence, so it serves as an independent check of results for the statistics where they exist, and an alternative source of results when a CFT is not known. We show how the coherent state method can be used to derive the statistics of several increasingly complicated trial wave functions: ν=1/2 Laughlin, Moore-Read, and k=3 Read-Rezayi. We discuss implications of our method for a possible notion of braiding statistics of the Gaffnian state, a "nonunitary" quantum Hall state for which the ramifications of the CFT correspondence are less well understood. We go on to derive formulas for the counting of zero modes of all these states on the torus.

•Jan 1, 2012•0 citations

Real-space entanglement spectra of parton states in fractional quantum Hall systems

Abhishek Anand, Rushikesh A. Patil, Ajit Coimbatore Balram +1 more

Real-space entanglement spectra (RSES) capture characteristic features of the topological order encoded in the fractional quantum Hall (FQH) states. In this work, we numerically compute, using Monte Carlo methods, the RSES and the counting of edge excitations of non-Abelian FQH states constructed using the parton theory. Efficient numerical computation of RSES of parton states is possible, thanks to their product-of-Slater-determinant structure, allowing us to compute the spectra in systems of up to 80 particles. Specifically, we compute the RSES of the parton states ${\ensuremath{\phi}}_{2}^{2}, {\ensuremath{\phi}}_{2}^{3}$, and ${\ensuremath{\phi}}_{3}^{2}$, where ${\ensuremath{\phi}}_{n}$ is the wave function of $n$-filled Landau levels, in the ground state as well as in the presence of bulk quasihole states. We then explicitly demonstrate a one-to-one correspondence of RSES of the parton states with representations of the Kac-Moody algebras satisfied by their edge currents. We also show that for the lowest Landau level projected version of these parton states, the spectra match with that obtained from the edge current algebra. We also perform a computation of spectra of the overlap matrices corresponding to the edge excitations of the parton states with a constrained number of particles in the different parton Landau levels. Counting in these match the individual branches present in RSES, providing insight about how different branches are formed.

arXiv:2205.11214•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 26, 2022•18 citations

Matrix product states for trial quantum Hall states

Benoit Estienne, Zlatko Papić, Nicolas Regnault +1 more

We obtain an exact matrix-product-state (MPS) representation of a large series of fractional quantum Hall (FQH) states in various geometries of genus 0. The states in question include all paired $k=2$ Jack polynomials, such as the Moore-Read and Gaffnian states, as well as the Read-Rezayi $k=3$ state. We also outline the procedures through which the MPSs of other model FQH states can be obtained, provided their wave function can be written as a correlator in a $1+1$ conformal field theory (CFT). The auxiliary Hilbert space of the MPS, which gives the counting of the entanglement spectrum, is then simply the Hilbert space of the underlying CFT. This formalism enlightens the link between entanglement spectrum and edge modes. Properties of model wave functions such as the thin-torus root partitions and squeezing are recast in the MPS form, and numerical benchmarks for the accuracy of the new MPS prescription in various geometries are provided.

arXiv:1211.3353•Physical Review B•Apr 15, 2013•76 citations
We consider spaces of trial wave functions for ground states and edge excitations in the fractional quantum Hall effect that can be obtained in various ways. In one way, functions are obtained by analyzing the entanglement of the ground-state wave function, partitioned into two parts. In another, functions are defined by the way in which they vanish as several coordinates approach the same value, or by a projection-operator Hamiltonian that enforces those conditions. In a third way, functions are given by conformal blocks from a conformal field theory (CFT). These different spaces of functions are closely related. The use of CFT methods permits an algebraic formulation to be given for all of them. In some cases, we can prove that there is a ground state, a Hamiltonian, and a CFT such that, for any number of particles, all of these spaces are the same. For such cases, this resolves several questions and conjectures: it gives a finite-size bulk-edge correspondence, and we can use the analysis of functions to construct a projection-operator Hamiltonian that produces those functions as zero-energy states. For a model related to the N=1\mathcal{N}=1N=1 superconformal algebra, the corresponding Hamiltonian imposes vanishing properties involving only three particles; for this we determine all the wave functions explicitly. We do the same for a sequence of models involving the M(3,p)M(3,p)M(3,p) Virasoro minimal models that has been considered previously, using results from the literature. We exhibit the Hamiltonians for the first few cases of these. The techniques we introduce can be applied in numerous examples other than those considered here.
We consider the trial wave functions for the fractional quantum Hall effect that are given by conformal blocks, and construct their associated edge excited states in full generality. The inner products between these edge states are computed in the thermodynamic limit, assuming generalized screening (i.e., short-range correlations only) inside the quantum Hall droplet and using the language of boundary conformal field theory (boundary CFT). These inner products take universal values in this limit: they are equal to the corresponding inner products in the bulk two-dimensional chiral CFT which underlies the trial wave function. This is a bulk/edge correspondence; it shows the equality between equal-time correlators along the edge and the correlators of the bulk CFT up to a Wick rotation. This approach is then used to analyze the entanglement spectrum of the ground state obtained with a bipartition $A\ensuremath{\cup}B$ in real space. Starting from our universal result for inner products in the thermodynamic limit, we tackle corrections to scaling using standard field-theoretic and renormalization-group arguments. We prove that generalized screening implies that the entanglement Hamiltonian ${H}_{E}=\ensuremath{-}\mathrm{ln}{\ensuremath{\rho}}_{A}$ is isospectral to an operator that is local along the cut between AAA and BBB. We also show that a similar analysis can be carried out for particle partition. We discuss the close analogy between the formalism of trial wave functions given by conformal blocks and tensor product states, for which results analogous to ours have appeared recently. Finally, the edge theory and entanglement spectrum of ${p}_{x}\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}i{p}_{y}$ paired superfluids are treated in a similar fashion in the Appendixes.
We show that all lowest Landau-level projected and unprojected chiral parton type fractional quantum Hall ground and edge-state trial wave functions, which take the form of products of integer quantum Hall wave functions, can be expressed as conformal field theory (CFT) correlation functions, where we can associate a chiral algebra to each parton state such that the CFT defined by the algebra is the “smallest” such CFT that can generate the corresponding ground and edge-state trial wave functions (assuming that the corresponding chiral algebra does indeed define a physically “sensible” CFT). A field-theoretic generalization of Laughlin's plasma analogy, known as generalized screening, is formulated for these states. If this holds, along with an additional assumption, we argue that the inner products of edge-state trial wave functions, for parton states where the “densest” trial wave function is unique, can be expressed as matrix elements of an exponentiated local action operator of the CFT, generalizing the result of Dubail [], which implies the equality between edge-state and entanglement level counting to state counting in the corresponding CFT. We numerically test this result in the case of the unprojected ν=2/5 composite fermion state and the bosonic ν=1ϕ22 parton state. We discuss how Read's arguments [] still apply, implying that conformal blocks of the CFT defined by the corresponding chiral algebra are valid quasihole trial wave functions, with the adiabatic braiding statistics given by the monodromy of these functions, assuming the existence of a quasiparticle trapping Hamiltonian. Generalizations of these constructions are discussed, with particular attention given to simple current constructions. It is shown that all chiral composite fermion wave functions can be expressed as CFT correlation functions without explicit symmetrization or antisymmetrization and that the ground, edge, and certain quasihole trial wave functions of the ϕnm parton states can be expressed as the conformal blocks of the U(1)⊗SU(n)m WZW models. Finally, we discuss the relation of the ϕ2k series with the Read-Rezayi series, where several examples of quasihole braiding statistics calculations are given. Published by the American Physical Society 2024
We construct a family of quantum Hall Hamiltonians whose ground states, at least for small system sizes, give correlators of the S3{S}_{3}S3​ conformal field theories. The ground states are considered as trial wave functions for quantum Hall effect of bosons at filling fraction $\ensuremath{\nu}=3/4$ interacting either via delta function interaction or delta function plus dipole interaction. While the S3{S}_{3}S3​ theories can be either unitary or nonunitary, we find high overlaps with exact diagonalizations only for the nonunitary case, suggesting that these wave functions may correspond to critical points, possibly analogous to the previously studied Gaffnian wave function. These wave functions give an explicit example which cannot be fully characterized by their thin-torus limit or by their pattern of zeros.
In the theory of the fractional quantum Hall effect, much attention is paid to the correspondence between fractional quantum Hall wave functions and conformal blocks in certain rational conformal field theories (CFT). This correspondence is powerful, enabling the calculation of the fractional statistics of a state that would be difficult if not impossible to calculate directly from the wave functions. But it is, in general, conjectural, remaining without microscopic justification in many cases of interest, and involves heavy mathematical machinery. We detail an alternative method to calculate Abelian and non-Abelian fractional statistics, the coherent state method. The method relies on assumptions which are independent of those underlying the CFT correspondence, so it serves as an independent check of results for the statistics where they exist, and an alternative source of results when a CFT is not known. We show how the coherent state method can be used to derive the statistics of several increasingly complicated trial wave functions: ν=1/2 Laughlin, Moore-Read, and k=3 Read-Rezayi. We discuss implications of our method for a possible notion of braiding statistics of the Gaffnian state, a "nonunitary" quantum Hall state for which the ramifications of the CFT correspondence are less well understood. We go on to derive formulas for the counting of zero modes of all these states on the torus.
Real-space entanglement spectra (RSES) capture characteristic features of the topological order encoded in the fractional quantum Hall (FQH) states. In this work, we numerically compute, using Monte Carlo methods, the RSES and the counting of edge excitations of non-Abelian FQH states constructed using the parton theory. Efficient numerical computation of RSES of parton states is possible, thanks to their product-of-Slater-determinant structure, allowing us to compute the spectra in systems of up to 80 particles. Specifically, we compute the RSES of the parton states ${\ensuremath{\phi}}_{2}^{2}, {\ensuremath{\phi}}_{2}^{3}$, and ${\ensuremath{\phi}}_{3}^{2}$, where ${\ensuremath{\phi}}_{n}$ is the wave function of nnn-filled Landau levels, in the ground state as well as in the presence of bulk quasihole states. We then explicitly demonstrate a one-to-one correspondence of RSES of the parton states with representations of the Kac-Moody algebras satisfied by their edge currents. We also show that for the lowest Landau level projected version of these parton states, the spectra match with that obtained from the edge current algebra. We also perform a computation of spectra of the overlap matrices corresponding to the edge excitations of the parton states with a constrained number of particles in the different parton Landau levels. Counting in these match the individual branches present in RSES, providing insight about how different branches are formed.
We obtain an exact matrix-product-state (MPS) representation of a large series of fractional quantum Hall (FQH) states in various geometries of genus 0. The states in question include all paired k=2k=2k=2 Jack polynomials, such as the Moore-Read and Gaffnian states, as well as the Read-Rezayi k=3k=3k=3 state. We also outline the procedures through which the MPSs of other model FQH states can be obtained, provided their wave function can be written as a correlator in a 1+11+11+1 conformal field theory (CFT). The auxiliary Hilbert space of the MPS, which gives the counting of the entanglement spectrum, is then simply the Hilbert space of the underlying CFT. This formalism enlightens the link between entanglement spectrum and edge modes. Properties of model wave functions such as the thin-torus root partitions and squeezing are recast in the MPS form, and numerical benchmarks for the accuracy of the new MPS prescription in various geometries are provided.