Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1302.6003

Quantum logic and weak values

Riuji Mochizuki

Published Feb 25, 2013• 0 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

In this study, we study weak values from a quantum-logical viewpoint. In addition, we examine the validity of the counterfactual statements of Hardy's paradox, which are based on weak values, and we show that these statements have not been validated. It is also shown that strange weak values may only appear if they are not (conditional) probabilities. PACS numbers: 03.65.Ta, 03.65.Ud, 03.65.Ca

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1302.6003

Related papers

Weak Value Theory

Yutaka Shikano, Andrei Yu. Khrennikov, Gregg S. Jaeger +2 more

I show that the weak value theory is useful from the viewpoints of the experimentally verifiability, consistency, capacity for explanation as to many quantum paradoxes, and practical advantages. As an example, the initial state in the Hardy paradox can be experimentally verified using the weak value via the weak measurement.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2011•0 citations

Weak Value Theory

Yutaka Shikano

I show that the weak value theory is useful from the viewpoints of the experimentally verifiability, consistency, capacity for explanation as to many quantum paradoxes, and practical advantages. As an example, the initial state in the Hardy paradox can be experimentally verified using the weak value via the weak measurement.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2011•1 citation

Strange weak values

Akio Hosoya, Yutaka Shikano

We develop a formal theory of the weak values with emphasis on the consistency conditions and a probabilistic interpretation in the counter-factual processes. We present the condition for the choice of the post-selected state to give a negative weak value of a given projection operator and strange values of an observable in general. The general framework is applied to Hardy's paradox and the spin-1/2 system to explicitly address the issues of counter-factuality and strange weak values. The counter-factual arguments which characterize the paradox specify the pre-selected state, and a complete set of the post-selected states clarifies how the strange weak values emerge.

arXiv:1006.1615•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Aug 18, 2010•68 citations

What Is a Quantum-Mechanical “Weak Value” the Value of?

B. E. Y. Svensson

A so called “weak value” of an observable in quantum mechanics (QM) may be obtained in a weak measurement + post-selection procedure on the QM system under study. Applied to number operators, it has been invoked in revisiting some QM paradoxes ( e.g. , the so called Three-Box Paradox and Hardy’s Paradox). This requires the weak value to be interpreted as a bona fide property of the system considered, a par with entities like operator mean values and eigenvalues. I question such an interpretation; it has no support in the basic axioms of quantum mechanics and it leads to unreasonable results in concrete situations.

arXiv:1301.4328•Foundations of Physics•Sep 4, 2013•29 citations

Quantum Weak Values and Logic: An Uneasy Couple

B. E. Y. Svensson

Quantum mechanical weak values of projection operators have been used to answer which-way questions, e . g . to trace which arms in a multiple Mach–Zehnder setup a particle may have traversed from a given initial to a prescribed final state. I show that this procedure might lead to logical inconsistencies in the sense that different methods used to answer composite questions, like “Has the particle traversed the way X or the way Y ?”, may result in different answers depending on which methods are used to find the answer. I illustrate the problem by considering some examples: the “quantum pigeonhole” framework of Aharonov et al. , the three-box problem, and Hardy’s paradox. To prepare the ground for my main conclusion on the incompatibility in certain cases of weak values and logic, I study the corresponding situation for strong/projective measurements. In this case, no logical inconsistencies occur provided one is always careful in specifying exactly to which ensemble or sample space one refers. My results cast doubts on the utility of quantum weak values in treating cases like the examples mentioned.

arXiv:1605.03023•Foundations of Physics•Feb 6, 2017•10 citations

Weak value as an indicator of back-action

Riuji Mochizuki

In this study we critically examine some important papers on weak measurement and weak values. We find some insufficiency and mistakes in these papers, and we demonstrate that the real parts of weak values provide the back-action to the post-selection, which is caused by weak measurement. Two examples, a counterfactual statement of Hardy's paradox and experiments that determine the average trajectory of photons passing through double slits, are investigated from our point of view.

arXiv:1312.3036•Progress of Theoretical and Experimental Physics•Apr 1, 2014•2 citations
In this study, we study weak values from a quantum-logical viewpoint. In addition, we examine the validity of the counterfactual statements of Hardy's paradox, which are based on weak values, and we show that these statements have not been validated. It is also shown that strange weak values may only appear if they are not (conditional) probabilities. PACS numbers: 03.65.Ta, 03.65.Ud, 03.65.Ca
We develop a formal theory of the weak values with emphasis on the consistency conditions and a probabilistic interpretation in the counter-factual processes. We present the condition for the choice of the post-selected state to give a negative weak value of a given projection operator and strange values of an observable in general. The general framework is applied to Hardy's paradox and the spin-1/2 system to explicitly address the issues of counter-factuality and strange weak values. The counter-factual arguments which characterize the paradox specify the pre-selected state, and a complete set of the post-selected states clarifies how the strange weak values emerge.
A so called “weak value” of an observable in quantum mechanics (QM) may be obtained in a weak measurement + post-selection procedure on the QM system under study. Applied to number operators, it has been invoked in revisiting some QM paradoxes ( e.g. , the so called Three-Box Paradox and Hardy’s Paradox). This requires the weak value to be interpreted as a bona fide property of the system considered, a par with entities like operator mean values and eigenvalues. I question such an interpretation; it has no support in the basic axioms of quantum mechanics and it leads to unreasonable results in concrete situations.
Quantum mechanical weak values of projection operators have been used to answer which-way questions, e . g . to trace which arms in a multiple Mach–Zehnder setup a particle may have traversed from a given initial to a prescribed final state. I show that this procedure might lead to logical inconsistencies in the sense that different methods used to answer composite questions, like “Has the particle traversed the way X or the way Y ?”, may result in different answers depending on which methods are used to find the answer. I illustrate the problem by considering some examples: the “quantum pigeonhole” framework of Aharonov et al. , the three-box problem, and Hardy’s paradox. To prepare the ground for my main conclusion on the incompatibility in certain cases of weak values and logic, I study the corresponding situation for strong/projective measurements. In this case, no logical inconsistencies occur provided one is always careful in specifying exactly to which ensemble or sample space one refers. My results cast doubts on the utility of quantum weak values in treating cases like the examples mentioned.