Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1301.7036 · WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks

Uncertainty, Incompleteness, Chance, and Design

Fernando Sols

Published Oct 28, 2013• 6 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The 20th century has revealed two important limitations of scientific knowledge. On the one hand, the combination of Poincaré's nonlinear dynamics and Heisenberg's uncertainty principle leads to a world picture where physical reality is, in many respects, intrinsically undetermined. On the other hand, Gödel's incompleteness theorems reveal us the existence of mathematical truths that cannot be demonstrated. More recently, Chaitin has proved that, from the incompleteness theorems, it follows that the random character of a given mathematical sequence cannot be proved in general (it is 'undecidable'). I reflect here on the consequences derived from the indeterminacy of the future and the undecidability of randomness, concluding that the question of the presence or absence of finality in nature is fundamentally outside the scope of the scientific method.

DOI
10.1142/9789814447614_0006

Related papers

Between quantum indeterminacy and biological mutation: stability and uncertainty in a probabilistic living world

Dhia Bouktila

The classical deterministic worldview that dominated science from the seventeenth to the nineteenth century has been profoundly challenged by developments in modern physics and biology. Quantum mechanics has revealed that indeterminacy and probability are not merely epistemic limitations, but intrinsic features of physical reality. At the same time, evolutionary biology has shown that random genetic variation, filtered by natural selection, is the fundamental driver of biological diversity and adaptation. This article explores the conceptual parallel between quantum indeterminacy and evolutionary randomness, not as a reduction of biology to physics, but as an epistemological reflection on how stability and order emerge from probabilistic processes across different levels of organization. By examining emergence, contingency, historical irreversibility, and the limits of prediction, the paper argues that determinism is best understood as a scale-dependent approximation rather than a foundational ontological principle. The absence of finality in nature does not imply chaos or nihilism, but invites a renewed philosophical understanding of explanation, responsibility, and scientific humility in a probabilistic universe.

Science & philosophy•Jun 1, 2026•0 citations

Randomness from initial conditions: The challenge of incompleteness

Klaas Landsman

Certain prima facie deterministic theories, notably Bohmian mechanics and kinetic theory, require ``random'' initial conditions in order to achieve their goals. I analyze recent proposals that this idea should be implemented using algorithmic randomness, seen as a mathematical sharpening of the typicality arguments originally used to understand these theories. On the one hand my analysis includes a critique of these arguments and hence a defense of this sharpening. On the other hand, I argue that Chaitin's incompleteness theorems for random sequences make it impossible for a dynamical theory to either process given random initial conditions beyond some finite (but not arbitrary) number of their digits, or else to state such conditions with arbitrary precision without compromising their randomness (these are two sides of the same coin). This challenges the ability of such theories to make any other predictions than those that hold typically in the usual sense of the word (like macroscopic statements), and moves their alleged determinism high up the metaphysical ladder.

arXiv:2610.23355•Oct 16, 2026•0 citations

Chapter Life: Making uncertainty certain

Anatoly Ruvinsky

How to unite scientific zest for universal causation with ubiquitous randomness is a profound question. Nearly a century ago quantum physics and then genetics were forced to accept both concepts as two independent realities which seemingly contradict one another. Here we are not going deep into philosophical considerations about the essence of the material world and science. However, it is difficult to deny that randomness, or in other words uncertainty, looks like a serious challenge to universal causation and science has to moderate the importance of this traditional core principle. Surprisingly such an uneasy shift did not significantly reduce the capability of science to describe and predict. Even more surprisingly this fundamental change went relatively smoothly and did not dramatically affect the “daily business” of science. This does not mean of course that science can still operate in a purely Laplacian deterministic framework. A steady transition to a new scientific perception of the world is inevitable and ongoing.

CRC Press eBooks•Jul 28, 2009•0 citations

Randomness from Relationships and Interfaces

Michel Bitbol

Neither essential chance nor contingent ignorance chance (neither indeterminacy nor uncertainty), the form of chance underlying the probabilistic character of quantum physics, needs to be better characterized.In this article we develop the intermediate concept of a chance of necessary ignorance. A randomness imposed by a limit of knowledge, on a par with the standard randomness of ignorance, except that here the limit is in principle insurmountable, unlike those encountered, for example, in classical statistical physics.

•Jul 1, 2024•0 citations

Is chance or choice the essence of Nature

Thomas J. Chalko

At the beginning of the twenty first century the prevailing and vigorously defended view is that the Universe happened by chance. All fundamental sub-atomic processes are thought to be “random” and the only way to quantify them seems to be the “uncertainty” principle. Clearly, our conclusions about the Reality of the Universe are determined and limited by our imagination. Can we imagine alternatives? What if nothing in the Universe is by chance? Could it be by CHOICE?

•Jan 1, 2001•5 citations

Science of Uncertainty

Rajan Gurukkal

This chapter virtually illuminates the invisible universe of subatomic dynamics through mathematical formalism and probability theory rather than empiricism based on instrumentation. A series of strange discoveries go into the making of the New Science and a discussion of the process constitutes the core of this chapter. Max Planck’s proposition of the Quanta, Niels Bohr’s discovery of objects’ non-observable and immeasurable complementary properties, Erwin Schrodinger’s interpretation of the object-subject split as a figment of imagination, Werner Karl Heisenberg’s enunciation of the Uncertainty Principle precluding the possibility of precision about certain pairs of physical properties of a particle, Kurt Friedrich Godel’s thesis of Undecidability based on his incompleteness theorems demonstrating certain inherent limits of provability about formal axiomatic theories, Murray Gell-Mann’s theory of Complexity in particle physics, Richard Feynman’s thesis on quantum mechanics, and Einstein’s theories of relativity, literally shook Newtonian physics of certainty with problems of uncertainty and subjectivity. At the end, the chapter makes a review of speculative thoughts and imagination about the dynamics of subatomic micro-universe as well as the mechanics of the galactic macro-universe.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Mar 21, 2019•0 citations
The 20th century has revealed two important limitations of scientific knowledge. On the one hand, the combination of Poincaré's nonlinear dynamics and Heisenberg's uncertainty principle leads to a world picture where physical reality is, in many respects, intrinsically undetermined. On the other hand, Gödel's incompleteness theorems reveal us the existence of mathematical truths that cannot be demonstrated. More recently, Chaitin has proved that, from the incompleteness theorems, it follows that the random character of a given mathematical sequence cannot be proved in general (it is 'undecidable'). I reflect here on the consequences derived from the indeterminacy of the future and the undecidability of randomness, concluding that the question of the presence or absence of finality in nature is fundamentally outside the scope of the scientific method.
The classical deterministic worldview that dominated science from the seventeenth to the nineteenth century has been profoundly challenged by developments in modern physics and biology. Quantum mechanics has revealed that indeterminacy and probability are not merely epistemic limitations, but intrinsic features of physical reality. At the same time, evolutionary biology has shown that random genetic variation, filtered by natural selection, is the fundamental driver of biological diversity and adaptation. This article explores the conceptual parallel between quantum indeterminacy and evolutionary randomness, not as a reduction of biology to physics, but as an epistemological reflection on how stability and order emerge from probabilistic processes across different levels of organization. By examining emergence, contingency, historical irreversibility, and the limits of prediction, the paper argues that determinism is best understood as a scale-dependent approximation rather than a foundational ontological principle. The absence of finality in nature does not imply chaos or nihilism, but invites a renewed philosophical understanding of explanation, responsibility, and scientific humility in a probabilistic universe.
Certain prima facie deterministic theories, notably Bohmian mechanics and kinetic theory, require ``random'' initial conditions in order to achieve their goals. I analyze recent proposals that this idea should be implemented using algorithmic randomness, seen as a mathematical sharpening of the typicality arguments originally used to understand these theories. On the one hand my analysis includes a critique of these arguments and hence a defense of this sharpening. On the other hand, I argue that Chaitin's incompleteness theorems for random sequences make it impossible for a dynamical theory to either process given random initial conditions beyond some finite (but not arbitrary) number of their digits, or else to state such conditions with arbitrary precision without compromising their randomness (these are two sides of the same coin). This challenges the ability of such theories to make any other predictions than those that hold typically in the usual sense of the word (like macroscopic statements), and moves their alleged determinism high up the metaphysical ladder.
How to unite scientific zest for universal causation with ubiquitous randomness is a profound question. Nearly a century ago quantum physics and then genetics were forced to accept both concepts as two independent realities which seemingly contradict one another. Here we are not going deep into philosophical considerations about the essence of the material world and science. However, it is difficult to deny that randomness, or in other words uncertainty, looks like a serious challenge to universal causation and science has to moderate the importance of this traditional core principle. Surprisingly such an uneasy shift did not significantly reduce the capability of science to describe and predict. Even more surprisingly this fundamental change went relatively smoothly and did not dramatically affect the “daily business” of science. This does not mean of course that science can still operate in a purely Laplacian deterministic framework. A steady transition to a new scientific perception of the world is inevitable and ongoing.
Neither essential chance nor contingent ignorance chance (neither indeterminacy nor uncertainty), the form of chance underlying the probabilistic character of quantum physics, needs to be better characterized.In this article we develop the intermediate concept of a chance of necessary ignorance. A randomness imposed by a limit of knowledge, on a par with the standard randomness of ignorance, except that here the limit is in principle insurmountable, unlike those encountered, for example, in classical statistical physics.
This chapter virtually illuminates the invisible universe of subatomic dynamics through mathematical formalism and probability theory rather than empiricism based on instrumentation. A series of strange discoveries go into the making of the New Science and a discussion of the process constitutes the core of this chapter. Max Planck’s proposition of the Quanta, Niels Bohr’s discovery of objects’ non-observable and immeasurable complementary properties, Erwin Schrodinger’s interpretation of the object-subject split as a figment of imagination, Werner Karl Heisenberg’s enunciation of the Uncertainty Principle precluding the possibility of precision about certain pairs of physical properties of a particle, Kurt Friedrich Godel’s thesis of Undecidability based on his incompleteness theorems demonstrating certain inherent limits of provability about formal axiomatic theories, Murray Gell-Mann’s theory of Complexity in particle physics, Richard Feynman’s thesis on quantum mechanics, and Einstein’s theories of relativity, literally shook Newtonian physics of certainty with problems of uncertainty and subjectivity. At the end, the chapter makes a review of speculative thoughts and imagination about the dynamics of subatomic micro-universe as well as the mechanics of the galactic macro-universe.