Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1301.4508 · Physical Review B

Comment on “ Z2 -slave-spin theory for strongly correlated fermions”

Álvaro Antônio Bandeira Ferraz, E. A. Kochetov

Published Jan 2, 2013• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

The authors of Ref. 1 introduced a new slave-spin (SS) \nmean-field (MF) approach to the Hubbard model of strongly \ncorrelated electrons in terms of Ising spins and standard \nfermion operators by constructing an enlarged Hilbert space \nwith both physical and unphysical states. The purpose of \nthis construction is clear: this formulation involves a much \nsmaller number of slave fields, compared with more standard \nslave particle frameworks. In this way, the complexity of the \noriginal model is reduced to a more readily tractable system \nof Ising spins in a transverse field coupled to free fermions. \nIn this Comment, we show that the unphysical states are not \nproperly excluded, and despite the claimed good agreement \nwith previous results, the consistency of their MF theory is \nunjustified

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.87.037101

Related papers

Reply to “Comment on ‘ Z2 -slave-spin theory for strongly correlated fermions’”

Andreas Rüegg, Sebastian D. Huber, Manfred Sigrist

We show that the physical subspace in the ${\mathbb{Z}}_{2}$-slave-spin theory is conserved under the time evolution of the system. Thus, when restricted to the physical subspace, this representation gives a complete and consistent description of the original problem. In addition, we review two known examples from the existing literature in which the projection onto the physical subspace can be relaxed: (i) the noninteracting limit in any dimension at half-filling and (ii) the interacting model in the infinite-dimensional limit at half-filling. In both cases, physical observables are correctly obtained without explicit treatment of the constraints which define the physical subspace. In these examples, correct results are obtained, despite the fact that unphysical states enter the solution.

arXiv:1301.0347•Physical Review B•Jan 2, 2013•1 citation

Slave-spin approach to the strongly correlated systems

Mardani, Masoud, Mohammad-Sadegh Vaezi, Abolhassan Vaezi

In this paper, we develop a new type of slave particle method which is similar to the slave rotor model except that the quantum rotor is substituted by a spin one slave particle. The spin-one slave particle itself can be represented in terms of Schwinger bosons/fermions. This approach is more conveniently applicable to the strongly correlated Hamiltonians with on-site Hubbard interaction and resolves the limitations of using the slave rotor model as well as the Anderson-Zou slave particle technique. For instance, the mean-field parameters of the slave spin method do not vanish above the Mott transition and this approach is smoothly connected to the non-interacting limit. As an example, we study the phase diagram of the Kane-Mele-Hubbard model using our current approach. In the absence of the spin-orbit interaction, the Mott transition occurs at $U_c ~ 3 t_1$. Several aspects of the slave spin method, its gauge theory and various possible mean-field states associated with this approach have been discussed.

arXiv:1111.5980•Nov 25, 2011•18 citations

Generalized slave-particle method for extended Hubbard models

Alexandru Bogdan Georgescu, Sohrab Ismail‐Beigi

We introduce a set of generalized slave-particle models for extended Hubbard models that treat localized electronic correlations using slave-boson decompositions. Our models automatically include two slave-particle methods of recent interest, the slave-rotor and slave-spin methods, as well as a ladder of new intermediate models where one can choose which of the electronic degrees of freedom (e.g., spin or orbital labels) are treated as correlated degrees of freedom by the slave bosons. In addition, our method removes the aberrant behavior of the slave-rotor model, where it systematically overestimates the importance of electronic correlation effects for weak interaction strength, by removing the contribution of unphysical states from the bosonic Hilbert space. The flexibility of our formalism permits one to separate and isolate the effect of correlations on the key degrees of freedom.

arXiv:1506.03515•Physical Review B•Dec 8, 2015•22 citations

Z2 -slave-spin theory for strongly correlated fermions

Andreas Rüegg, Sebastian D. Huber, Manfred Sigrist

We review a representation of Hubbard-like models that is based on auxiliary pseudospin variables. These pseudospins refer to the local charge modulo two in the original model and display a local ${\mathsf{Z}}_{2}$ gauge freedom. We discuss the associated mean-field theory in a variety of different contexts which are related to the problem of the interaction-driven metal-insulator transition at half-filling including Fermi surface deformation and spectral features beyond the local approximation. Notably, on the mean-field level, the Hubbard bands are derived from the excitations of an Ising model in a transverse field and the quantum critical point of this model is identified with the Brinkman-Rice criticality of the almost localized Fermi liquid state. Nonlocal correlations are included using a cluster mean-field approximation and the Schwinger boson theory for the auxiliary quantum Ising model.

arXiv:0912.3801•Physical Review B•Apr 22, 2010•86 citations

Antiferromagnetism in the Hubbard model using a cluster slave-spin method

Wei‐Cheng Lee, Ting-Kuo Lee

The cluster slave-spin method is introduced to systematically investigate the solutions of the Hubbard model including the symmetry-broken phases. In this method, the electron operator is factorized into a fermionic spinon describing the physical spin and a slave-spin describing the charge fluctuations. Following the $U(1)$ formalism derived by Yu and Si [Phys. Rev. B 86, 085104 (2012)], it is shown that the self-consistent equations to explore various symmetry-broken density wave states can be constructed in general with a cluster of multiple slave-spin sites. We employ this method to study the antiferromagnetic (AFM) state in the single band Hubbard model with the two- and four-site clusters of slave spins. While the Hubbard gap, the charge gap due to the doubly occupied states, scales with the Hubbard interaction $U$ as expected, the AFM gap $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}$, the gap in the spinon dispersion in the AFM state, exhibits a crossover from the weak- to strong-coupling behaviors as $U$ increases. Our cluster slave-spin method reproduces not only the traditional mean-field behavior of $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}\ensuremath{\sim}U$ in the weak-coupling limit, but also the behavior of $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}\ensuremath{\sim}{t}^{2}/U$ predicted by the superexchange mechanism in the strong-coupling limit. In addition, the holon-doublon correlator as functions of $U$ and doping $x$ is also computed, which exhibits a strong tendency toward the holon-doublon binding in the strong coupling regime. We further show that the quasiparticle weight obtained by the cluster slave-spin method is in a good agreement with the generalized Gutzwiller approximation in both AFM and paramagnetic states, and the results can be improved beyond the generalized Gutzwiller approximation as the cluster is enlarged from a single site to four sites. Our results demonstrate that the cluster slave-spin method can be a powerful tool to systematically investigate the strongly correlated system.

arXiv:1707.03042•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Sep 8, 2017•12 citations

A STRONG-COUPLING EXPANSION FOR THE HUBBARD MODEL

N. Dupuis, Stéphane Pairault

We reconsider the strong-coupling expansion for the Hubbard model recently introduced by Sarker and Pairault et al. By introducing slave particles that act as projection operators onto the empty, singly occupied and doubly occupied atomic states, the perturbation theory around the atomic limit distinguishes between processes that do conserve or do not conserve the total number of doubly occupied sites. This allows for a systematic t/U expansion that does not break down at low temperature (t being the intersite hopping amplitude and U the local Coulomb repulsion). The fermionic field becomes a two-component field, which reflects the presence of the two Hubbard bands. The single-particle propagator is naturally expressed as a function of a 2×2 matrix self-energy. Furthermore, by introducing a time- and space-fluctuating spin-quantization axis in the functional integral, we can expand around a "non-degenerate" ground-state where each singly occupied site has a well defined spin direction (which may fluctuate in time). This formalism is used to derive the effective action of charge carriers in the lower Hubbard band to first order in t/U. We recover the action of the t–J model in the spin-hole coherent-state path integral. We also compare our results with those previously obtained by studying fluctuations around the large-U Hartree–Fock saddle point.

arXiv:cond-mat/0008447•International Journal of Modern Physics B•Sep 30, 2000•7 citations
The authors of Ref. 1 introduced a new slave-spin (SS) \nmean-field (MF) approach to the Hubbard model of strongly \ncorrelated electrons in terms of Ising spins and standard \nfermion operators by constructing an enlarged Hilbert space \nwith both physical and unphysical states. The purpose of \nthis construction is clear: this formulation involves a much \nsmaller number of slave fields, compared with more standard \nslave particle frameworks. In this way, the complexity of the \noriginal model is reduced to a more readily tractable system \nof Ising spins in a transverse field coupled to free fermions. \nIn this Comment, we show that the unphysical states are not \nproperly excluded, and despite the claimed good agreement \nwith previous results, the consistency of their MF theory is \nunjustified
We show that the physical subspace in the Z2{\mathbb{Z}}_{2}Z2​-slave-spin theory is conserved under the time evolution of the system. Thus, when restricted to the physical subspace, this representation gives a complete and consistent description of the original problem. In addition, we review two known examples from the existing literature in which the projection onto the physical subspace can be relaxed: (i) the noninteracting limit in any dimension at half-filling and (ii) the interacting model in the infinite-dimensional limit at half-filling. In both cases, physical observables are correctly obtained without explicit treatment of the constraints which define the physical subspace. In these examples, correct results are obtained, despite the fact that unphysical states enter the solution.
In this paper, we develop a new type of slave particle method which is similar to the slave rotor model except that the quantum rotor is substituted by a spin one slave particle. The spin-one slave particle itself can be represented in terms of Schwinger bosons/fermions. This approach is more conveniently applicable to the strongly correlated Hamiltonians with on-site Hubbard interaction and resolves the limitations of using the slave rotor model as well as the Anderson-Zou slave particle technique. For instance, the mean-field parameters of the slave spin method do not vanish above the Mott transition and this approach is smoothly connected to the non-interacting limit. As an example, we study the phase diagram of the Kane-Mele-Hubbard model using our current approach. In the absence of the spin-orbit interaction, the Mott transition occurs at Uc 3t1U_c ~ 3 t_1Uc​ 3t1​. Several aspects of the slave spin method, its gauge theory and various possible mean-field states associated with this approach have been discussed.
We introduce a set of generalized slave-particle models for extended Hubbard models that treat localized electronic correlations using slave-boson decompositions. Our models automatically include two slave-particle methods of recent interest, the slave-rotor and slave-spin methods, as well as a ladder of new intermediate models where one can choose which of the electronic degrees of freedom (e.g., spin or orbital labels) are treated as correlated degrees of freedom by the slave bosons. In addition, our method removes the aberrant behavior of the slave-rotor model, where it systematically overestimates the importance of electronic correlation effects for weak interaction strength, by removing the contribution of unphysical states from the bosonic Hilbert space. The flexibility of our formalism permits one to separate and isolate the effect of correlations on the key degrees of freedom.
We review a representation of Hubbard-like models that is based on auxiliary pseudospin variables. These pseudospins refer to the local charge modulo two in the original model and display a local Z2{\mathsf{Z}}_{2}Z2​ gauge freedom. We discuss the associated mean-field theory in a variety of different contexts which are related to the problem of the interaction-driven metal-insulator transition at half-filling including Fermi surface deformation and spectral features beyond the local approximation. Notably, on the mean-field level, the Hubbard bands are derived from the excitations of an Ising model in a transverse field and the quantum critical point of this model is identified with the Brinkman-Rice criticality of the almost localized Fermi liquid state. Nonlocal correlations are included using a cluster mean-field approximation and the Schwinger boson theory for the auxiliary quantum Ising model.
The cluster slave-spin method is introduced to systematically investigate the solutions of the Hubbard model including the symmetry-broken phases. In this method, the electron operator is factorized into a fermionic spinon describing the physical spin and a slave-spin describing the charge fluctuations. Following the U(1)U(1)U(1) formalism derived by Yu and Si [Phys. Rev. B 86, 085104 (2012)], it is shown that the self-consistent equations to explore various symmetry-broken density wave states can be constructed in general with a cluster of multiple slave-spin sites. We employ this method to study the antiferromagnetic (AFM) state in the single band Hubbard model with the two- and four-site clusters of slave spins. While the Hubbard gap, the charge gap due to the doubly occupied states, scales with the Hubbard interaction UUU as expected, the AFM gap $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}$, the gap in the spinon dispersion in the AFM state, exhibits a crossover from the weak- to strong-coupling behaviors as UUU increases. Our cluster slave-spin method reproduces not only the traditional mean-field behavior of $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}\ensuremath{\sim}U$ in the weak-coupling limit, but also the behavior of $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Delta}}\ensuremath{\sim}{t}^{2}/U$ predicted by the superexchange mechanism in the strong-coupling limit. In addition, the holon-doublon correlator as functions of UUU and doping xxx is also computed, which exhibits a strong tendency toward the holon-doublon binding in the strong coupling regime. We further show that the quasiparticle weight obtained by the cluster slave-spin method is in a good agreement with the generalized Gutzwiller approximation in both AFM and paramagnetic states, and the results can be improved beyond the generalized Gutzwiller approximation as the cluster is enlarged from a single site to four sites. Our results demonstrate that the cluster slave-spin method can be a powerful tool to systematically investigate the strongly correlated system.
We reconsider the strong-coupling expansion for the Hubbard model recently introduced by Sarker and Pairault et al. By introducing slave particles that act as projection operators onto the empty, singly occupied and doubly occupied atomic states, the perturbation theory around the atomic limit distinguishes between processes that do conserve or do not conserve the total number of doubly occupied sites. This allows for a systematic t/U expansion that does not break down at low temperature (t being the intersite hopping amplitude and U the local Coulomb repulsion). The fermionic field becomes a two-component field, which reflects the presence of the two Hubbard bands. The single-particle propagator is naturally expressed as a function of a 2×2 matrix self-energy. Furthermore, by introducing a time- and space-fluctuating spin-quantization axis in the functional integral, we can expand around a "non-degenerate" ground-state where each singly occupied site has a well defined spin direction (which may fluctuate in time). This formalism is used to derive the effective action of charge carriers in the lower Hubbard band to first order in t/U. We recover the action of the t–J model in the spin-hole coherent-state path integral. We also compare our results with those previously obtained by studying fluctuations around the large-U Hartree–Fock saddle point.