Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1212.6035 · Physical Review Letters

Ground States of the Spin-1 Bose-Hubbard Model

Hosho Katsura, Hal Tasaki

Published Mar 26, 2013• 29 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

We prove basic theorems about the ground states of the S=1 Bose-Hubbard model. The results are quite universal and depend only on the coefficient U2 of the spin-dependent interaction. We show that the ground state exhibits saturated ferromagnetism if U2<0, is spin-singlet if U2>0, and exhibits "SU(3)-ferromagnetism" if U2=0, and completely determine the degeneracy in each region.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.110.130405

Related papers

Rigorous Results for the Ground States of the Spin-2 Bose-Hubbard Model

Hong Wei Yang, Hosho Katsura

We present rigorous and universal results for the ground states of the f=2 spinor Bose-Hubbard model. The model includes three two-body on-site interaction terms, two of which are spin dependent while the other one is spin independent. We prove that, depending only on the coefficients of the two spin-dependent terms, the ground state exhibits maximum or minimum total spin or SU(5) ferromagnetism. Exact ground-state degeneracies and the forms of ground-state wave function are also determined in each case. All these results are valid regardless of dimension, lattice structure, or particle number. Our approach takes advantage of the symmetry of the Hamiltonian and employs mathematical tools including the Perron-Frobenius theorem and the Lie algebra so(5).

arXiv:1803.09441•Physical Review Letters•Feb 7, 2019•3 citations

Lieb's Theorem for Bose Hubbard Models

Zhongchao Wei, Chong Ke Zhao

Using a cone-theoretical method, we prove the uniqueness of the ground state for two Bose Hubbard models. The first model is the usual Bose Hubbard model with real hopping coefficients and attractive interactions. The second model is a two-component Bose Hubbard model. Under certain conditions, we show that the ground state in the subspace with particle number $N=2n$($n$ is a positive integer) is unique for both models. For the second model, we show that the ground state has spin along the z-axis $S^{z}=0$. When the hopping coefficients are real, it has zero spin quantum number, i.e., it is a singlet. Our proofs work equally well for any arbitrary finite-size lattice.

arXiv:2506.10319•Jun 12, 2025•1 citation

Ground State of the Kondo-Hubbard Model at Half Filling

Takashi Yanagisawa, Yukihiro Shimoi

We investigate the ground state of the Kondo-Hubbard model employing the recently introduced idea of spin-reflection positivity. It is shown exactly that the Kondo-Hubbard model for $J<0$ and $U>|J|/4$ at half filling has a unique ground state which can be ferromagnetic or singlet according to the lattice structure. In particular, for the Kondo lattice with $U>|J|/4$, the ground state is a singlet. We also show a theorem for the Kondo-Hubbard model with the anisotropic antiferromagnetic coupling ${J}_{\ensuremath{\perp}}>0$ and ${J}_{z}\ensuremath{\le}0$ for $U>|{J}_{z}|/4$.

Physical Review Letters•Jun 12, 1995•33 citations

New Saturated Ferromagnetism in the Flat-Band Hubbard Model in High Electron Filling

Yuuki Watanabe, Seiji Miyashita

We investigate the magnetization of the ground state of the one-dimensional flat-band Hubbard model as a function of the electron filling, using exact diagonalization techniques. Our calculation shows that the systems with odd n holes added to half-filling bands for a sufficiently large U (the on-site Coulomb repulsion energy) have a saturated ferromagnetic ground state, which is nondegenerate except for the trivial spin degeneracy. Dependences of the critical value of U on the size and on λ (a parameter of the system) are also investigated. For all values of λ, it is found that the ground state is a saturated ferromagnetic state if U is sufficiently large. Moreover, we find that the critical U for the saturated ferromagnetic ground state is almost independent on the system size, at least, for the system near quarter-filling. These facts indicate that even if the system size go to infinity, the ferromagnetic ground state can be exist for a finite U .

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Jul 15, 1997•20 citations

Properties of New Saturated Ferromagnetism in the 1D Flat-Band Hubbard Model as the Spiral State

Yuuki Watanabe, Seiji Miyashita

We investigate magnetic properties in the ground state of the one-dimensional flat-band Hubbard model in high electron filling. Until now, we found the new saturated ferromagnetism for odd numbers of holes, and its properties were investigated in detail. However, it was remained as a problem how we understand the complete alternation of magnetism between saturated ferromagnetism and singlet for odd and even numbers of holes, respectively. This alternation causes a difficulty when we consider the thermodynamic limit. In order to solve this difficulty, we investigate, at first, the change of the magnetization for systems with various boundary conditions, and we find that even for the even numbers of holes, the ground states are saturated ferromagnetic under the antiperiodic boundary condition. Furthermore, we explicitly investigate the spin-spin correlation functions < S z i S z j > to see the spin ordering. These calculations shows that all ground states in this filling region are the spiral state under a suitable boundary condition, and that the singlet states in these ground states, therefore, have a ferromagnetic order within, approximately, a half of the system size, although the total spin is still zero. From these results, we conclude that the properties in this region are by no means ill, and all ground states are essentially ferromagnetic in the sense that the spins in the singlet states are also ordered ferromagnetically if we take in the half of the system size.

Journal of the Physical Society of Japan•Dec 15, 1997•12 citations

Ferromagnetism in the Hubbard models with degenerate single-electron ground states

Hal Tasaki

We study a class of Hubbard models in which the corresponding single-electron ground states have bulk degeneracy. We prove that the ground states of the models exhibit ferromagnetism when the electron filling factor is not more than and sufficiently close to ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\rho}}}_{0}$=\ensuremath{\Vert}V\ensuremath{\Vert}/2\ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Lambda}\ensuremath{\Vert} (where \ensuremath{\Vert}V\ensuremath{\Vert} is the dimension of degeneracy and \ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Lambda}\ensuremath{\Vert} is the number of sites), and exhibit paramagnetism when the filling factor is sufficiently small. This is the first time that a three-dimensional itinerant-electron system is proved to exhibit ferromagnetism in a finite range of the electron filling factor.

Physical Review Letters•Sep 7, 1992•587 citations
We prove basic theorems about the ground states of the S=1 Bose-Hubbard model. The results are quite universal and depend only on the coefficient U2 of the spin-dependent interaction. We show that the ground state exhibits saturated ferromagnetism if U2<0, is spin-singlet if U2>0, and exhibits "SU(3)-ferromagnetism" if U2=0, and completely determine the degeneracy in each region.
We present rigorous and universal results for the ground states of the f=2 spinor Bose-Hubbard model. The model includes three two-body on-site interaction terms, two of which are spin dependent while the other one is spin independent. We prove that, depending only on the coefficients of the two spin-dependent terms, the ground state exhibits maximum or minimum total spin or SU(5) ferromagnetism. Exact ground-state degeneracies and the forms of ground-state wave function are also determined in each case. All these results are valid regardless of dimension, lattice structure, or particle number. Our approach takes advantage of the symmetry of the Hamiltonian and employs mathematical tools including the Perron-Frobenius theorem and the Lie algebra so(5).
Using a cone-theoretical method, we prove the uniqueness of the ground state for two Bose Hubbard models. The first model is the usual Bose Hubbard model with real hopping coefficients and attractive interactions. The second model is a two-component Bose Hubbard model. Under certain conditions, we show that the ground state in the subspace with particle number N=2nN=2nN=2n(nnn is a positive integer) is unique for both models. For the second model, we show that the ground state has spin along the z-axis Sz=0S^{z}=0Sz=0. When the hopping coefficients are real, it has zero spin quantum number, i.e., it is a singlet. Our proofs work equally well for any arbitrary finite-size lattice.
We investigate the ground state of the Kondo-Hubbard model employing the recently introduced idea of spin-reflection positivity. It is shown exactly that the Kondo-Hubbard model for J<0J<0J<0 and U>∣J∣/4U>|J|/4U>∣J∣/4 at half filling has a unique ground state which can be ferromagnetic or singlet according to the lattice structure. In particular, for the Kondo lattice with U>∣J∣/4U>|J|/4U>∣J∣/4, the ground state is a singlet. We also show a theorem for the Kondo-Hubbard model with the anisotropic antiferromagnetic coupling ${J}_{\ensuremath{\perp}}>0$ and ${J}_{z}\ensuremath{\le}0$ for U>∣Jz∣/4U>|{J}_{z}|/4U>∣Jz​∣/4.
We investigate the magnetization of the ground state of the one-dimensional flat-band Hubbard model as a function of the electron filling, using exact diagonalization techniques. Our calculation shows that the systems with odd n holes added to half-filling bands for a sufficiently large U (the on-site Coulomb repulsion energy) have a saturated ferromagnetic ground state, which is nondegenerate except for the trivial spin degeneracy. Dependences of the critical value of U on the size and on λ (a parameter of the system) are also investigated. For all values of λ, it is found that the ground state is a saturated ferromagnetic state if U is sufficiently large. Moreover, we find that the critical U for the saturated ferromagnetic ground state is almost independent on the system size, at least, for the system near quarter-filling. These facts indicate that even if the system size go to infinity, the ferromagnetic ground state can be exist for a finite U .
We investigate magnetic properties in the ground state of the one-dimensional flat-band Hubbard model in high electron filling. Until now, we found the new saturated ferromagnetism for odd numbers of holes, and its properties were investigated in detail. However, it was remained as a problem how we understand the complete alternation of magnetism between saturated ferromagnetism and singlet for odd and even numbers of holes, respectively. This alternation causes a difficulty when we consider the thermodynamic limit. In order to solve this difficulty, we investigate, at first, the change of the magnetization for systems with various boundary conditions, and we find that even for the even numbers of holes, the ground states are saturated ferromagnetic under the antiperiodic boundary condition. Furthermore, we explicitly investigate the spin-spin correlation functions < S z i S z j > to see the spin ordering. These calculations shows that all ground states in this filling region are the spiral state under a suitable boundary condition, and that the singlet states in these ground states, therefore, have a ferromagnetic order within, approximately, a half of the system size, although the total spin is still zero. From these results, we conclude that the properties in this region are by no means ill, and all ground states are essentially ferromagnetic in the sense that the spins in the singlet states are also ordered ferromagnetically if we take in the half of the system size.
We study a class of Hubbard models in which the corresponding single-electron ground states have bulk degeneracy. We prove that the ground states of the models exhibit ferromagnetism when the electron filling factor is not more than and sufficiently close to ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\rho}}}_{0}$=\ensuremath{\Vert}V\ensuremath{\Vert}/2\ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Lambda}\ensuremath{\Vert} (where \ensuremath{\Vert}V\ensuremath{\Vert} is the dimension of degeneracy and \ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Lambda}\ensuremath{\Vert} is the number of sites), and exhibit paramagnetism when the filling factor is sufficiently small. This is the first time that a three-dimensional itinerant-electron system is proved to exhibit ferromagnetism in a finite range of the electron filling factor.