Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1210.6371 · International Journal of Theoretical Physics

Quantum Correlations and the Measurement Problem

Jeffrey Bub

Published Jun 28, 2013• 17 citations
arXivHTMLPDF
DOI
10.1007/s10773-013-1695-z

Related papers

On the Quantum Measurement Problem

Časlav Brukner

arXiv:1507.05255•The frontiers collection•Nov 14, 2016•200 citations

The Measurement Problem from the Perspective of an Information-Theoretic Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

Jeffrey Bub

The aim of this paper is to consider the consequences of an information-theoretic interpretation of quantum mechanics for the measurement problem. The motivating idea of the interpretation is that the relation between quantum mechanics and the structure of information is analogous to the relation between special relativity and the structure of space-time. Insofar as quantum mechanics deals with a class of probabilistic correlations that includes correlations structurally different from classical correlations, the theory is about the structure of information: the possibilities for representing, manipulating, and communicating information in a genuinely indeterministic quantum world in which measurement outcomes are intrinsically random are different than we thought. Part of the measurement problem is deflated as a pseudo-problem on this view, and the theory has the resources to deal with the remaining part, given certain idealizations in the treatment of macrosystems.

Entropy•Oct 28, 2015•26 citations

Solution of the problem of definite outcomes of quantum measurements

Art Hobson

Theory and experiment both demonstrate that an entangled quantum state of two subsystems is neither a superposition of states of its subsystems nor a superposition of composite states but rather a coherent superposition of nonlocal correlations between incoherently mixed local states of the two subsystems. Thus, even if one subsystem happens to be macroscopic as in the entangled "Schrodinger's cat" state resulting from an ideal measurement, this state is not the paradoxical macroscopic superposition it is generally presumed to be. It is, instead, a "macroscopic correlation," a coherent quantum correlation in which one of the two correlated sub-systems happens to be macroscopic. This clarifies the physical meaning of entanglement: When a superposed quantum system A is unitarily entangled with a second quantum system B, the coherence of the original superposition of different states of A is transferred to different correlations between states of A and B, so the entangled state becomes a superposition of correlations rather than a superposition of states. This transfer preserves unitary evolution while permitting B to be macroscopic without entailing a macroscopic superposition. This resolves the "problem of outcomes" but is not a complete resolution of the measurement problem because the entangled state is still reversible.

arXiv:1705.01495•May 3, 2017•2 citations

Quantum and Classical Correlations in Quantum Measurement

Zhengjun Xi, Yongming Li

Foundations of Physics•Oct 11, 2012•6 citations

Models of the world, data-models and the practice of science : the semantics of quantum theory

Mauricio Suárez

The most important problems in the philosophy of quantum mechanics are the problem of measurement and the problem of the 'acausal' EPR correlations. It is commonly thought that these problems call for a new interpretation of the quantum theory. I argue that it is possible to construe both problems rather differently, as resulting from a mistaken understanding of scientific theory-application. It then becomes possible to tackle both problems independently of questions of interpretation, by attending carefully to what constitutes a successful application of a scientific theory, and of the quantum theory in particular. In the first part of the Thesis, I argue against a standard conception of scientific theory-application. This standard conception, which is often presupposed in the philosophical discussions of quantum mechanics, takes the applications of a scientific theory to constitute its domain of empirical adequacy. I argue that, on the contrary, a scientific theory can be applied to phenomena that it does not subsume. I present a case study in the history of superconductivity to illustrate and to motivate this claim. In the second part, I argue that the problem of measurement can be construed as the impossibility of applying the quantum theory to measurement interactions. I then argue that Arthur Fine's proposed solution to the measurement problem implicitly abandons the standard conception of application. Finally I look at quantum correlation phenomena. Bas Van Fraassen has claimed that the EPR correlations fit no causal model. The correctness of this claim depends on what probabilistic constraints a causal model is taken to have to satisfy. I argue, following Nancy Cartwright, that Van Fraassen's constraints on common-cause models are too strong; and I describe a direct-cause model that, I urge, constitutes a successful application of the quantum theory to the EPR correlations.

•Jan 1, 1997•5 citations

The Quantum Measurement Problem

R. W. Rendell, Michael Steiner

•Aug 17, 2018•0 citations
The aim of this paper is to consider the consequences of an information-theoretic interpretation of quantum mechanics for the measurement problem. The motivating idea of the interpretation is that the relation between quantum mechanics and the structure of information is analogous to the relation between special relativity and the structure of space-time. Insofar as quantum mechanics deals with a class of probabilistic correlations that includes correlations structurally different from classical correlations, the theory is about the structure of information: the possibilities for representing, manipulating, and communicating information in a genuinely indeterministic quantum world in which measurement outcomes are intrinsically random are different than we thought. Part of the measurement problem is deflated as a pseudo-problem on this view, and the theory has the resources to deal with the remaining part, given certain idealizations in the treatment of macrosystems.
Theory and experiment both demonstrate that an entangled quantum state of two subsystems is neither a superposition of states of its subsystems nor a superposition of composite states but rather a coherent superposition of nonlocal correlations between incoherently mixed local states of the two subsystems. Thus, even if one subsystem happens to be macroscopic as in the entangled "Schrodinger's cat" state resulting from an ideal measurement, this state is not the paradoxical macroscopic superposition it is generally presumed to be. It is, instead, a "macroscopic correlation," a coherent quantum correlation in which one of the two correlated sub-systems happens to be macroscopic. This clarifies the physical meaning of entanglement: When a superposed quantum system A is unitarily entangled with a second quantum system B, the coherence of the original superposition of different states of A is transferred to different correlations between states of A and B, so the entangled state becomes a superposition of correlations rather than a superposition of states. This transfer preserves unitary evolution while permitting B to be macroscopic without entailing a macroscopic superposition. This resolves the "problem of outcomes" but is not a complete resolution of the measurement problem because the entangled state is still reversible.
The most important problems in the philosophy of quantum mechanics are the problem of measurement and the problem of the 'acausal' EPR correlations. It is commonly thought that these problems call for a new interpretation of the quantum theory. I argue that it is possible to construe both problems rather differently, as resulting from a mistaken understanding of scientific theory-application. It then becomes possible to tackle both problems independently of questions of interpretation, by attending carefully to what constitutes a successful application of a scientific theory, and of the quantum theory in particular. In the first part of the Thesis, I argue against a standard conception of scientific theory-application. This standard conception, which is often presupposed in the philosophical discussions of quantum mechanics, takes the applications of a scientific theory to constitute its domain of empirical adequacy. I argue that, on the contrary, a scientific theory can be applied to phenomena that it does not subsume. I present a case study in the history of superconductivity to illustrate and to motivate this claim. In the second part, I argue that the problem of measurement can be construed as the impossibility of applying the quantum theory to measurement interactions. I then argue that Arthur Fine's proposed solution to the measurement problem implicitly abandons the standard conception of application. Finally I look at quantum correlation phenomena. Bas Van Fraassen has claimed that the EPR correlations fit no causal model. The correctness of this claim depends on what probabilistic constraints a causal model is taken to have to satisfy. I argue, following Nancy Cartwright, that Van Fraassen's constraints on common-cause models are too strong; and I describe a direct-cause model that, I urge, constitutes a successful application of the quantum theory to the EPR correlations.