Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1210.4249

Checking the error correction strength of arbitrary surface code logical gates

Thomas J. Milburn, Austin G. Fowler

Published Oct 16, 2012• 2 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Topologically quantum error corrected logical gates are complex. Chains of errors can form in space and time and diagonally in spacetime. It is highly nontrivial to determine whether a given logical gate is free of low weight combinations of errors leading to failure. We report a new tool Nestcheck capable of analyzing an arbitrary topological computation and determining the minimum number of errors required to cause failure.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1210.4249

Related papers

Surface code quantum error correction incorporating accurate error propagation

Austin G. Fowler, David S. Wang, Lloyd C. L. Hollenberg

The surface code is a powerful quantum error correcting code that can be defined on a 2-D square lattice of qubits with only nearest neighbor interactions. Syndrome and data qubits form a checkerboard pattern. Information about errors is obtained by repeatedly measuring each syndrome qubit after appropriate interaction with its four nearest neighbor data qubits. Changes in the measurement value indicate the presence of chains of errors in space and time. The standard method of determining operations likely to return the code to its error-free state is to use the minimum weight matching algorithm to connect pairs of measurement changes with chains of corrections such that the minimum total number of corrections is used. Prior work has not taken into account the propagation of errors in space and time by the two-qubit interactions. We show that taking this into account leads to a quadratic improvement of the logical error rate.

arXiv:1004.0255•Quantum Information and Computation•Jan 1, 2011•36 citations

Fault-tolerance thresholds for the surface code with fabrication errors

James M. Auger, Hussain Anwar, Mercedes Gimeno-Segovia +2 more

The construction of topological error correction codes requires the ability to fabricate a lattice of physical qubits embedded on a manifold with a nontrivial topology such that the quantum information is encoded in the global degrees of freedom (i.e., the topology) of the manifold. However, the manufacturing of large-scale topological devices will undoubtedly suffer from fabrication errors---permanent faulty components such as missing physical qubits or failed entangling gates---introducing permanent defects into the topology of the lattice and hence significantly reducing the distance of the code and the quality of the encoded logical qubits. In this work we investigate how fabrication errors affect the performance of topological codes, using the surface code as the test bed. A known approach to mitigate defective lattices involves the use of primitive swap gates in a long sequence of syndrome extraction circuits. Instead, we show that in the presence of fabrication errors the syndrome can be determined using the supercheck operator approach and the outcome of the defective gauge stabilizer generators without any additional computational overhead or use of swap gates. We report numerical fault-tolerance thresholds in the presence of both qubit fabrication and gate fabrication errors using a circuit-based noise model and the minimum-weight perfect-matching decoder. Our numerical analysis is most applicable to two-dimensional chip-based technologies, but the techniques presented here can be readily extended to other topological architectures. We find that in the presence of $8%$ qubit fabrication errors, the surface code can still tolerate a computational error rate of up to $0.1%$.

arXiv:1706.04912•Physical Review A•Oct 12, 2017•52 citations

Engineering logical gates with irrep surface codes

Yabo Li, Zijian Song, Vieri Mattei +3 more

Fault-tolerant quantum computation can incur a substantial resource cost when a desired logical operation must be constructed from a restricted set of logical primitives. To make such operations directly available, we introduce irrep surface codes (ISCs), two-dimensional topological quantum error-correcting codes engineered to transversally implement a prescribed set of logical gates. The target logical gates only need to satisfy two conditions: (i) they generate a finite group, which, up to global phases, is forced by the Eastin-Knill theorem, and (ii) they are irreducible, meaning that any operator commuting with the set of gates must be proportional to the identity. This accommodates arbitrary finite groups of diagonal gates and arbitrary reversible classical gates, since each can be embedded into a larger irreducible finite group of gates. It also enables logical gates outside every finite level of the Clifford hierarchy. To incorporate these operations into surface-code computations, we further develop lattice-surgery protocols to transfer the encoded information between surface codes and ISCs obeying one of two sufficient conditions. Together, these results establish a systematic method for tailoring topological codes to desired logical operations and integrating them into conventional computations.

quant-pharXiv:2610.06775•Oct 6, 2026•2 citations

Analysis of surface code under the restricted number of CNOT gates

Jonghyun Lee, Jinyoung Ha, Yujin Kang +1 more

To date, the surface code has become a promising candidate for quantum error correcting codes because of its high threshold, nearest gate operations and low weight stabilizers. Here, we assume that the number of CNOT gates is restricted because of the quantum crosstalk due to residual inter-qubit coupling or max channels per pulse gate. We thus calculated the effective physical error rate in this case and determine the surface code distance accordingly. The optimal code distance was obtained based on the logical error rate performance estimation of the surface code for some T1and T2time.

IEEE VTS Asia Pacific Wireless Communications Symposium (APWCS)•Aug 24, 2022•0 citations

Hardness of Braided Quantum Circuit Optimization in the Surface Code

Kunihiro Wasa, S. Nishio, Koki Suetsugu +4 more

Large-scale quantum information processing requires the use of quantum error correcting codes to mitigate the effects of noise in quantum devices. Topological error-correcting codes, such as surface codes, are promising candidates as they can be implemented using only local interactions in a twodimensional array of physical qubits. Procedures such as defect braiding and lattice surgery can then be used to realize a fault-tolerant universal set of gates on the logical space of such topological codes. However, error correction also introduces a significant overhead in computation time, the number of physical qubits, and the number of physical gates. While optimizing fault-tolerant circuits to minimize this overhead is critical, the computational complexity of such optimization problems remains unknown. This ambiguity leaves room for doubt surrounding the most effective methods for compiling fault-tolerant circuits for a large-scale quantum computer. In this paper, we show that the optimization of a special subset of braided quantum circuits is NP-hard by a polynomial-time reduction of the optimization problem into a specific problem called PlanarRectilinear3SAT.

arXiv:2302.00273•IEEE Transactions on Quantum Engineering•Jan 1, 2023•7 citations

Quantum Error Correction: Surface And Topological Codes

N Raji

Quantum error correction (QEC) represents a critical enabler for fault-tolerant quantum computing, protecting fragile quantum states from decoherence and operational errors. This paper provides a comprehensive analysis of leading quantum error correction schemes, focusing on surface codes and topological codes within the context of Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era processors. We examine the theoretical foundations of stabilizer codes, compare surface code implementations with code distances ranging from d=3 to d=17, and analyze topological codes including toric codes and color codes. Our investigation encompasses syndrome extraction circuits, logical qubit encoding strategies, and threshold analysis for contemporary quantum hardware platforms. Performance metrics reveal that surface codes achieve error thresholds of approximately 1% with realistic noise models, while topological codes offer architectural advantages for specific qubit connectivity constraints. We discuss implementation challenges on current NISQ processors including IBM Quantum, Google Sycamore, and IonQ systems, addressing qubit overhead, gate fidelity requirements, and decoding algorithms. This analysis provides insights for selecting appropriate error correction schemes based on application requirements and hardware capabilities.

•Mar 12, 2026•0 citations
Topologically quantum error corrected logical gates are complex. Chains of errors can form in space and time and diagonally in spacetime. It is highly nontrivial to determine whether a given logical gate is free of low weight combinations of errors leading to failure. We report a new tool Nestcheck capable of analyzing an arbitrary topological computation and determining the minimum number of errors required to cause failure.
The surface code is a powerful quantum error correcting code that can be defined on a 2-D square lattice of qubits with only nearest neighbor interactions. Syndrome and data qubits form a checkerboard pattern. Information about errors is obtained by repeatedly measuring each syndrome qubit after appropriate interaction with its four nearest neighbor data qubits. Changes in the measurement value indicate the presence of chains of errors in space and time. The standard method of determining operations likely to return the code to its error-free state is to use the minimum weight matching algorithm to connect pairs of measurement changes with chains of corrections such that the minimum total number of corrections is used. Prior work has not taken into account the propagation of errors in space and time by the two-qubit interactions. We show that taking this into account leads to a quadratic improvement of the logical error rate.
The construction of topological error correction codes requires the ability to fabricate a lattice of physical qubits embedded on a manifold with a nontrivial topology such that the quantum information is encoded in the global degrees of freedom (i.e., the topology) of the manifold. However, the manufacturing of large-scale topological devices will undoubtedly suffer from fabrication errors---permanent faulty components such as missing physical qubits or failed entangling gates---introducing permanent defects into the topology of the lattice and hence significantly reducing the distance of the code and the quality of the encoded logical qubits. In this work we investigate how fabrication errors affect the performance of topological codes, using the surface code as the test bed. A known approach to mitigate defective lattices involves the use of primitive swap gates in a long sequence of syndrome extraction circuits. Instead, we show that in the presence of fabrication errors the syndrome can be determined using the supercheck operator approach and the outcome of the defective gauge stabilizer generators without any additional computational overhead or use of swap gates. We report numerical fault-tolerance thresholds in the presence of both qubit fabrication and gate fabrication errors using a circuit-based noise model and the minimum-weight perfect-matching decoder. Our numerical analysis is most applicable to two-dimensional chip-based technologies, but the techniques presented here can be readily extended to other topological architectures. We find that in the presence of 88%8 qubit fabrication errors, the surface code can still tolerate a computational error rate of up to 0.10.1%0.1.
Fault-tolerant quantum computation can incur a substantial resource cost when a desired logical operation must be constructed from a restricted set of logical primitives. To make such operations directly available, we introduce irrep surface codes (ISCs), two-dimensional topological quantum error-correcting codes engineered to transversally implement a prescribed set of logical gates. The target logical gates only need to satisfy two conditions: (i) they generate a finite group, which, up to global phases, is forced by the Eastin-Knill theorem, and (ii) they are irreducible, meaning that any operator commuting with the set of gates must be proportional to the identity. This accommodates arbitrary finite groups of diagonal gates and arbitrary reversible classical gates, since each can be embedded into a larger irreducible finite group of gates. It also enables logical gates outside every finite level of the Clifford hierarchy. To incorporate these operations into surface-code computations, we further develop lattice-surgery protocols to transfer the encoded information between surface codes and ISCs obeying one of two sufficient conditions. Together, these results establish a systematic method for tailoring topological codes to desired logical operations and integrating them into conventional computations.
To date, the surface code has become a promising candidate for quantum error correcting codes because of its high threshold, nearest gate operations and low weight stabilizers. Here, we assume that the number of CNOT gates is restricted because of the quantum crosstalk due to residual inter-qubit coupling or max channels per pulse gate. We thus calculated the effective physical error rate in this case and determine the surface code distance accordingly. The optimal code distance was obtained based on the logical error rate performance estimation of the surface code for some T1and T2time.
Large-scale quantum information processing requires the use of quantum error correcting codes to mitigate the effects of noise in quantum devices. Topological error-correcting codes, such as surface codes, are promising candidates as they can be implemented using only local interactions in a twodimensional array of physical qubits. Procedures such as defect braiding and lattice surgery can then be used to realize a fault-tolerant universal set of gates on the logical space of such topological codes. However, error correction also introduces a significant overhead in computation time, the number of physical qubits, and the number of physical gates. While optimizing fault-tolerant circuits to minimize this overhead is critical, the computational complexity of such optimization problems remains unknown. This ambiguity leaves room for doubt surrounding the most effective methods for compiling fault-tolerant circuits for a large-scale quantum computer. In this paper, we show that the optimization of a special subset of braided quantum circuits is NP-hard by a polynomial-time reduction of the optimization problem into a specific problem called PlanarRectilinear3SAT.
Quantum error correction (QEC) represents a critical enabler for fault-tolerant quantum computing, protecting fragile quantum states from decoherence and operational errors. This paper provides a comprehensive analysis of leading quantum error correction schemes, focusing on surface codes and topological codes within the context of Noisy Intermediate-Scale Quantum (NISQ) era processors. We examine the theoretical foundations of stabilizer codes, compare surface code implementations with code distances ranging from d=3 to d=17, and analyze topological codes including toric codes and color codes. Our investigation encompasses syndrome extraction circuits, logical qubit encoding strategies, and threshold analysis for contemporary quantum hardware platforms. Performance metrics reveal that surface codes achieve error thresholds of approximately 1% with realistic noise models, while topological codes offer architectural advantages for specific qubit connectivity constraints. We discuss implementation challenges on current NISQ processors including IBM Quantum, Google Sycamore, and IonQ systems, addressing qubit overhead, gate fidelity requirements, and decoding algorithms. This analysis provides insights for selecting appropriate error correction schemes based on application requirements and hardware capabilities.