Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1210.2403 · Physical Review B

Detecting classical phase transitions with Renyi mutual information

Jason Iaconis, Stephen Inglis, Ann B. Kallin, Roger G. Melko

Published May 28, 2013• 59 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

By developing a method to represent the Renyi entropies via a replica trick on classical statistical mechanical systems, we introduce a procedure to calculate the Renyi mutual information (RMI) in any Monte Carlo simulation. Through simulations on several classical models, we demonstrate that the RMI can detect finite-temperature critical points, and even identify their universality class, without knowledge of an order parameter or other thermodynamic estimators. Remarkably, in addition to critical points mediated by symmetry breaking, the RMI is able to detect topological vortex-unbinding transitions, as we explicitly demonstrate on simulations of the $XY$ model.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.87.195134

Related papers

Implementations and applications of Renyi entanglement in Monte Carlo simulations of spin models

Stephen Inglis

Although entanglement is a well studied property in the context of quantum systems, the ability to measure it in Monte Carlo methods is relatively new. \nThrough measures of the Renyi entanglement entropy and mutual information one is able to examine and characterize criticality, pinpoint phase transitions, and probe universality. \nWe describe the most basic algorithms for calculating these quantities in straightforward Monte Carlo methods and state of the art techniques used in high performance computing. \nThis description emphasizes the core principal of these measurements and allows one to both build an intuition for these quantities and how they are useful in numerical studies. \n \nUsing the Renyi entanglement entropy we demonstrate the ability to detect thermal phase transitions in the Ising model and XY model without use of an order parameter. \nThe scaling near the critical point also shows signatures identifying the universality class of the model. \nImproved methods are explored using extended ensemble techniques that can increase calculation efficiency, and show good agreement with the standard approach. \nWe explore the "ratio trick" at finite temperature and use it to explore the quantum critical fan of the one dimensional transverse field Ising model, showing agreement with finite temperature and finite size scaling from field theory. \nThis same technique is used at zero temperature to explore the geometric dependence of the entanglement entropy and examine the universal scaling functions in the two dimensional transverse field Ising model. \nAll of this shows the multitude of ways in which the study of the Renyi entanglement entropy can be efficiently and practically used in conventional and exotic condensed matter systems, and should serve as a reference for those wishing to use it as a tool.

•Sep 27, 2013•8 citations

Wang-Landau method for calculating Rényi entropies in finite-temperature quantum Monte Carlo simulations

Stephen Inglis, Roger G. Melko

We implement a Wang-Landau sampling technique in quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulations for the purpose of calculating the Rényi entanglement entropies and associated mutual information. The algorithm converges an estimate for an analog to the density of states for stochastic series expansion QMC, allowing a direct calculation of Rényi entropies without explicit thermodynamic integration. We benchmark results for the mutual information on two-dimensional (2D) isotropic and anisotropic Heisenberg models, a 2D transverse field Ising model, and a three-dimensional Heisenberg model, confirming a critical scaling of the mutual information in cases with a finite-temperature transition. We discuss the benefits and limitations of broad sampling techniques compared to standard importance sampling methods.

arXiv:1207.5052•Physical Review E•Jan 22, 2013•52 citations

Rényi mutual information in quantum field theory, tensor networks, and gravity

Jonah Kudler-Flam, Laimei Nie, Akash Vijay

A bstract We explore a large class of correlation measures called the α − z Rényi mutual informations (RMIs). Unlike the commonly used notion of RMI involving linear combinations of Rényi entropies, the α − z RMIs are positive semi-definite and monotonically decreasing under local quantum operations, making them sensible measures of total (quantum and classical) correlations. This follows from their descendance from Rényi relative entropies. In addition to upper bounding connected correlation functions between subsystems, we prove the much stronger statement that for certain values of α and z , the α − z RMIs also lower bound certain connected correlation functions. We develop an easily implementable replica trick which enables us to compute the α − z RMIs in a variety of many-body systems including conformal field theories, free fermions, random tensor networks, and holography.

arXiv:2308.08600•Journal of High Energy Physics•Jun 27, 2024•11 citations

Rényi entropy perspective on topological order in classical toric code models

Johannes Helmes, Jean-Marie Stéphan, Simon Trebst

Concepts of information theory are increasingly used to characterize collective phenomena in condensed matter systems, such as the use of entanglement entropies to identify emergent topological order in interacting quantum many-body systems. Here, we employ classical variants of these concepts, in particular R\'enyi entropies and their associated mutual information, to identify topological order in classical systems. Like for their quantum counterparts, the presence of topological order can be identified in such classical systems via a universal, subleading contribution to the prevalent volume and boundary laws of the classical R\'enyi entropies. We demonstrate that an additional subleading $O(1)$ contribution generically arises for all R\'enyi entropies ${S}^{(n)}$ with $n\ensuremath{\ge}2$ when driving the system towards a phase transition, e.g., into a conventionally ordered phase. This additional subleading term, which we dub connectivity contribution, tracks back to partial subsystem ordering and is proportional to the number of connected parts in a given bipartition. Notably, the Levin-Wen summation scheme, typically used to extract the topological contribution to the R\'enyi entropies, does not fully eliminate this additional connectivity contribution in this classical context. This indicates that the distillation of topological order from R\'enyi entropies requires an additional level of scrutiny to distinguish topological from nontopological $O(1)$ contributions. This is also the case for quantum systems, for which we discuss which entropies are sensitive to these connectivity contributions. We showcase these findings by extensive numerical simulations of a classical variant of the toric code model, for which we study the stability of topological order in the presence of a magnetic field and at finite temperatures from a R\'enyi entropy perspective.

arXiv:1507.04682•Physical Review B•Sep 24, 2015•8 citations

Finite-size scaling of mutual information in Monte Carlo simulations: Application to the spin- 12 XXZ model

Roger G. Melko, Ann B. Kallin, Matthew B. Hastings

We develop a quantum Monte Carlo procedure to compute the Renyi mutual information of an interacting quantum many-body system at nonzero temperature. Performing simulations on a spin-$\frac{1}{2}$ $XXZ$ model, we observe that for a subregion of fixed size embedded in a system of size $L$, the mutual information converges at large $L$ to a limiting function which displays nonmonotonic temperature behavior corresponding to the onset of correlations. For a region of size $L/2$ embedded in a system of size $L$, the mutual information divided by $L$ converges to a limiting function of temperature, with apparently nontrivial corrections near critical points.

arXiv:1007.2182•Physical Review B•Sep 17, 2010•93 citations

Finite-Temperature Critical Behavior of Mutual Information

Rajiv R. P. Singh, Matthew B. Hastings, Ann B. Kallin +1 more

We study mutual information for Renyi entropy of arbitrary index n, in interacting quantum systems at finite-temperature critical points, using high-temperature expansion, quantum Monte Carlo simulations and scaling theory. We find that, for n>1, the critical behavior is manifest at two temperatures T(c) and nT(c). For the XXZ model with Ising anisotropy, the coefficient of the area law has a t lnt singularity, whereas the subleading correction from corners has a logarithmic divergence, with a coefficient related to the exact results of Cardy and Peschel. For T<nT(c) there is a constant term associated with broken symmetries that jumps at both T(c) and nT(c), which can be understood in terms of a scaling function analogous to the boundary entropy of Affleck and Ludwig.

arXiv:1101.0430•Physical Review Letters•Mar 29, 2011•73 citations
By developing a method to represent the Renyi entropies via a replica trick on classical statistical mechanical systems, we introduce a procedure to calculate the Renyi mutual information (RMI) in any Monte Carlo simulation. Through simulations on several classical models, we demonstrate that the RMI can detect finite-temperature critical points, and even identify their universality class, without knowledge of an order parameter or other thermodynamic estimators. Remarkably, in addition to critical points mediated by symmetry breaking, the RMI is able to detect topological vortex-unbinding transitions, as we explicitly demonstrate on simulations of the XYXYXY model.
Although entanglement is a well studied property in the context of quantum systems, the ability to measure it in Monte Carlo methods is relatively new. \nThrough measures of the Renyi entanglement entropy and mutual information one is able to examine and characterize criticality, pinpoint phase transitions, and probe universality. \nWe describe the most basic algorithms for calculating these quantities in straightforward Monte Carlo methods and state of the art techniques used in high performance computing. \nThis description emphasizes the core principal of these measurements and allows one to both build an intuition for these quantities and how they are useful in numerical studies. \n \nUsing the Renyi entanglement entropy we demonstrate the ability to detect thermal phase transitions in the Ising model and XY model without use of an order parameter. \nThe scaling near the critical point also shows signatures identifying the universality class of the model. \nImproved methods are explored using extended ensemble techniques that can increase calculation efficiency, and show good agreement with the standard approach. \nWe explore the "ratio trick" at finite temperature and use it to explore the quantum critical fan of the one dimensional transverse field Ising model, showing agreement with finite temperature and finite size scaling from field theory. \nThis same technique is used at zero temperature to explore the geometric dependence of the entanglement entropy and examine the universal scaling functions in the two dimensional transverse field Ising model. \nAll of this shows the multitude of ways in which the study of the Renyi entanglement entropy can be efficiently and practically used in conventional and exotic condensed matter systems, and should serve as a reference for those wishing to use it as a tool.
We implement a Wang-Landau sampling technique in quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) simulations for the purpose of calculating the Rényi entanglement entropies and associated mutual information. The algorithm converges an estimate for an analog to the density of states for stochastic series expansion QMC, allowing a direct calculation of Rényi entropies without explicit thermodynamic integration. We benchmark results for the mutual information on two-dimensional (2D) isotropic and anisotropic Heisenberg models, a 2D transverse field Ising model, and a three-dimensional Heisenberg model, confirming a critical scaling of the mutual information in cases with a finite-temperature transition. We discuss the benefits and limitations of broad sampling techniques compared to standard importance sampling methods.
A bstract We explore a large class of correlation measures called the α − z Rényi mutual informations (RMIs). Unlike the commonly used notion of RMI involving linear combinations of Rényi entropies, the α − z RMIs are positive semi-definite and monotonically decreasing under local quantum operations, making them sensible measures of total (quantum and classical) correlations. This follows from their descendance from Rényi relative entropies. In addition to upper bounding connected correlation functions between subsystems, we prove the much stronger statement that for certain values of α and z , the α − z RMIs also lower bound certain connected correlation functions. We develop an easily implementable replica trick which enables us to compute the α − z RMIs in a variety of many-body systems including conformal field theories, free fermions, random tensor networks, and holography.
Concepts of information theory are increasingly used to characterize collective phenomena in condensed matter systems, such as the use of entanglement entropies to identify emergent topological order in interacting quantum many-body systems. Here, we employ classical variants of these concepts, in particular R\'enyi entropies and their associated mutual information, to identify topological order in classical systems. Like for their quantum counterparts, the presence of topological order can be identified in such classical systems via a universal, subleading contribution to the prevalent volume and boundary laws of the classical R\'enyi entropies. We demonstrate that an additional subleading O(1)O(1)O(1) contribution generically arises for all R\'enyi entropies S(n){S}^{(n)}S(n) with $n\ensuremath{\ge}2$ when driving the system towards a phase transition, e.g., into a conventionally ordered phase. This additional subleading term, which we dub connectivity contribution, tracks back to partial subsystem ordering and is proportional to the number of connected parts in a given bipartition. Notably, the Levin-Wen summation scheme, typically used to extract the topological contribution to the R\'enyi entropies, does not fully eliminate this additional connectivity contribution in this classical context. This indicates that the distillation of topological order from R\'enyi entropies requires an additional level of scrutiny to distinguish topological from nontopological O(1)O(1)O(1) contributions. This is also the case for quantum systems, for which we discuss which entropies are sensitive to these connectivity contributions. We showcase these findings by extensive numerical simulations of a classical variant of the toric code model, for which we study the stability of topological order in the presence of a magnetic field and at finite temperatures from a R\'enyi entropy perspective.
We develop a quantum Monte Carlo procedure to compute the Renyi mutual information of an interacting quantum many-body system at nonzero temperature. Performing simulations on a spin-12\frac{1}{2}21​ XXZXXZXXZ model, we observe that for a subregion of fixed size embedded in a system of size LLL, the mutual information converges at large LLL to a limiting function which displays nonmonotonic temperature behavior corresponding to the onset of correlations. For a region of size L/2L/2L/2 embedded in a system of size LLL, the mutual information divided by LLL converges to a limiting function of temperature, with apparently nontrivial corrections near critical points.
We study mutual information for Renyi entropy of arbitrary index n, in interacting quantum systems at finite-temperature critical points, using high-temperature expansion, quantum Monte Carlo simulations and scaling theory. We find that, for n>1, the critical behavior is manifest at two temperatures T(c) and nT(c). For the XXZ model with Ising anisotropy, the coefficient of the area law has a t lnt singularity, whereas the subleading correction from corners has a logarithmic divergence, with a coefficient related to the exact results of Cardy and Peschel. For T<nT(c) there is a constant term associated with broken symmetries that jumps at both T(c) and nT(c), which can be understood in terms of a scaling function analogous to the boundary entropy of Affleck and Ludwig.