Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1210.2034 · Physical Review B

Dynamical quantum phase transitions and broken-symmetry edges in the many-body eigenvalue spectrum

Giacomo Mazza, Michele Fabrizio

Published Nov 30, 2012• 34 citations
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Many-body models undergoing a quantum phase transition to a broken-symmetry phase that survives up to a critical temperature must possess, in the ordered phase, symmetric as well as nonsymmetric eigenstates. We predict, and explicitly show in the fully connected Ising model in a transverse field, that these two classes of eigenstates do not overlap in energy, and therefore that an energy edge exists separating low-energy symmetry-breaking eigenstates from high-energy symmetry-invariant ones. This energy is actually responsible, as we show, for the dynamical phase transition displayed by this model under a sudden large increase of the transverse field. A second situation we consider is the opposite, where the symmetry-breaking eigenstates are those in the high-energy sector of the spectrum, whereas the low-energy eigenstates are symmetric. In that case too a special energy must exist marking the boundary and leading to unexpected out-of-equilibrium dynamical behavior. An example is the fermonic repulsive Hubbard model Hamiltonian $\mathcal{H}$. Exploiting the trivial fact that the high-energy spectrum of $\mathcal{H}$ is also the low-energy one of $\ensuremath{-}\mathcal{H}$, we conclude that the high-energy eigenstates of the Hubbard model are superfluid. Simulating in a time-dependent Gutzwiller approximation the time evolution of a high-energy BCS-like trial wave function, we show that a small superconducting order parameter will actually grow in spite of the repulsive nature of the interaction.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.86.184303

Related papers

Theory of Dynamical Phase Transitions in Quantum Systems with Symmetry-Breaking Eigenstates

Ángel L. Corps, Armando Relaño

We present a theory for the two kinds of dynamical quantum phase transitions, termed DPT-I and DPT-II, based on a minimal set of symmetry assumptions. In the special case of collective systems with infinite-range interactions, both are triggered by excited-state quantum phase transitions. For quenches below the critical energy, the existence of an additional conserved charge, identifying the corresponding phase, allows for a nonzero value of the dynamical order parameter characterizing DPTs-I, and precludes the main mechanism giving rise to nonanalyticities in the return probability, trademark of DPTs-II. We propose a statistical ensemble describing the long-time averages of order parameters in DPTs-I, and provide a theoretical proof for the incompatibility of the main mechanism for DPTs-II with the presence of this additional conserved charge. Our results are numerically illustrated in the fully connected transverse-field Ising model, which exhibits both kinds of dynamical phase transitions. Finally, we discuss the applicability of our theory to systems with finite-range interactions, where the phenomenology of excited-state quantum phase transitions is absent. We illustrate our findings by means of numerical calculations with experimentally relevant initial states.

arXiv:2205.03443•Physical Review Letters•Mar 9, 2023•43 citations

Dynamical Quantum Phase Transitions in the Transverse-Field Ising Model

Markus Heyl, Anatoli Polkovnikov, Stefan K. Kehrein

A phase transition indicates a sudden change in the properties of a large system. For temperature-driven phase transitions this is related to nonanalytic behavior of the free energy density at the critical temperature: The knowledge of the free energy density in one phase is insufficient to predict the properties of the other phase. In this Letter we show that a close analogue of this behavior can occur in the real time evolution of quantum systems, namely nonanalytic behavior at a critical time. We denote such behavior a dynamical phase transition and explore its properties in the transverse-field Ising model. Specifically, we show that the equilibrium quantum phase transition and the dynamical phase transition in this model are intimately related.

arXiv:1206.2505•Physical Review Letters•Mar 28, 2013•897 citations

Dynamical quantum phase transitions in extended transverse Ising models

Sourav Bhattacharjee, Amit Dutta

We study the dynamical quantum phase transitions (DQPTs) manifested in the subsequent unitary dynamics of an extended Ising model with an additional three spin interactions following a sudden quench. Revisiting the equilibrium phase diagram of the model, where different quantum phases are characterized by different winding numbers, we show that in some situations the winding number may not change across a gap closing point in the energy spectrum. Although, usually there exists a one-to-one correspondence between the change in winding number and the number of critical time scales associated with DQPTs, we show that the extended nature of interactions may lead to unusual situations. Importantly, we show that in the limit of the cluster Ising model, three critical modes associated with DQPTs become degenerate, thereby leading to a single critical time scale for a given sector of Fisher zeros.

arXiv:1801.09463•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Apr 20, 2018•54 citations

Quantum phase transitions in the two-dimensional hardcore boson model

F. Hébert, G. G. Batrouni, R. T. Scalettar +3 more

We use two quantum Monte Carlo algorithms to map out the phase diagram of the two-dimensional hardcore boson Hubbard model with near ${(V}_{1})$ and next near ${(V}_{2})$ neighbor repulsion. At half filling we find three phases: superfluid (SF), checkerboard solid, and striped solid depending on the relative values of ${V}_{1}{,V}_{2},$ and the kinetic energy. Doping away from half filling, the checkerboard solid undergoes phase separation: The superfluid and solid phases coexist but not as a single thermodynamic phase. As a function of doping, the transition from the checkerboard solid is therefore first order. In contrast, doping the striped solid away from half filling instead produces a striped supersolid phase: coexistence of density order with superfluidity as a single phase. One surprising result is that the entire line of transitions between the SF and checkerboard solid phases at half filling appears to exhibit dynamical $O(3)$ symmetry restoration. The transitions appear to be in the same universality class as the special Heisenberg point even though this symmetry is explicitly broken by the ${V}_{2}$ interaction.

arXiv:cond-mat/0105450•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Dec 5, 2001•186 citations

Eigenstate Thermalization and Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking in the One-Dimensional Transverse-Field Ising Model with Power-Law Interactions

Keith R. Fratus, Mark Srednicki

We study eigenstate thermalization and related signatures of quantum chaos in the one-dimensional ferromagnetic transverse-field Ising model with power-law interactions. The presence of long-range interactions allows for a finite-temperature phase transition despite the one-dimensional geometry of the model. Unlike previous studies of eigenstate thermalization in non-disordered systems with finite temperature phase transitions, our model possesses sufficiently many energy eigenstates below the critical energy density to allow us to make a definitive statement about the presence of eigenstate thermalization and chaotic level statistics in the broken-symmetry phase.

arXiv:1611.03992•Nov 12, 2016•28 citations

Numerical simulations of continuum field theories and exotic quantum phase transitions

Zhenjiu Wang

In this thesis, we investigate several topics pertaining to emergent collective quantum phenomena in the domain of correlated fermions, using the quantum Monte Carlo method. They display exotic low temperature phases as well as phase transitions which are beyond the Landau–Ginzburg theory. The interplay between three key points is crucial for us: fermion statistics, many body effects and topology. We highlight the following several achievements: 1. Successful modeling of continuum field theories with lattice Hamiltonians, 2. their sign-problem-free Monte Carlo simulations of these models, 3. and numerical results beyond mean field descriptions. First, we consider a model of Dirac fermions with a spin rotational invariant inter- action term that dynamically generates a quantum spin Hall insulator. Surprisingly, an s-wave superconducting phase emerges due to the condensation of topological de- fects of the spin Hall order parameter. When particle-hole symmetry is present, the phase transition between the topological insulator and the superconducting phase is an example of a deconfined quantum critical point(DQCP). Although its low energy effec- tive field theory is purely bosonic, the exact conservation law of the skyrmion number operator rules out the possibility of realizing this critical point in lattice boson models. This work is published in Ref. [1]. Second, we dope the dynamically generated quantum spin Hall insulator mentioned above. Hence it is described by a field theory without Lorentz invariance due to the lack of particle-hole symmetry. This sheds light on the extremely hot topic of twisted bilayergraphene: Why is superconductivity generated when the repulsive Coulomb interaction is much stronger than the electron-phonon coupling energy scale? In our case, Cooper pairs come from the topological skyrmion defects of the spin current order parameter, which are charged. Remarkably, the nature of the phase transition is highly non-mean-field-like: one is not allowed to simply view pairs of electrons as single bosons in a superfluid-Mott insulator transition, since the spin-current order parameter can not be ignored. Again, due to the aforementioned skyrmions, the two order parameters are intertwined: One phase transition occurs between the two symmetry breaking states. This work is summarized in Ref. [2]. Third, we investigate the 2 + 1 dimensional O(5) nonlinear sigma model with a topological Wess-Zumino-Witten term. Remarkably, we are able to perform Monte Carlo calculations with a UV cutoff given by the Dirac Landau level quantization. It is a successful example of simulating a continuous field theory without lattice regularization which leads to an additional symmetry breaking. The Dirac background and the five anti-commuting Dirac mass terms naturally introduce the picture of a non-trivial Berry phase contribution in the parameter space of the five component order parameter. Using the finite size scaling method given by the flux quantization, we find a stable critical phase in the low stiffness region of the sigma model. This is a candidate ground state of DQCP when the O(5) symmetry breaking terms are irrelevant at the critical point. Again, it has a bosonic low energy field theory which is seemingly unable to be realized in pure boson Hamiltonians. This work is summarized in Ref. [3].

•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations
Many-body models undergoing a quantum phase transition to a broken-symmetry phase that survives up to a critical temperature must possess, in the ordered phase, symmetric as well as nonsymmetric eigenstates. We predict, and explicitly show in the fully connected Ising model in a transverse field, that these two classes of eigenstates do not overlap in energy, and therefore that an energy edge exists separating low-energy symmetry-breaking eigenstates from high-energy symmetry-invariant ones. This energy is actually responsible, as we show, for the dynamical phase transition displayed by this model under a sudden large increase of the transverse field. A second situation we consider is the opposite, where the symmetry-breaking eigenstates are those in the high-energy sector of the spectrum, whereas the low-energy eigenstates are symmetric. In that case too a special energy must exist marking the boundary and leading to unexpected out-of-equilibrium dynamical behavior. An example is the fermonic repulsive Hubbard model Hamiltonian H\mathcal{H}H. Exploiting the trivial fact that the high-energy spectrum of H\mathcal{H}H is also the low-energy one of \ensuremath−H\ensuremath{-}\mathcal{H}\ensuremath−H, we conclude that the high-energy eigenstates of the Hubbard model are superfluid. Simulating in a time-dependent Gutzwiller approximation the time evolution of a high-energy BCS-like trial wave function, we show that a small superconducting order parameter will actually grow in spite of the repulsive nature of the interaction.
We present a theory for the two kinds of dynamical quantum phase transitions, termed DPT-I and DPT-II, based on a minimal set of symmetry assumptions. In the special case of collective systems with infinite-range interactions, both are triggered by excited-state quantum phase transitions. For quenches below the critical energy, the existence of an additional conserved charge, identifying the corresponding phase, allows for a nonzero value of the dynamical order parameter characterizing DPTs-I, and precludes the main mechanism giving rise to nonanalyticities in the return probability, trademark of DPTs-II. We propose a statistical ensemble describing the long-time averages of order parameters in DPTs-I, and provide a theoretical proof for the incompatibility of the main mechanism for DPTs-II with the presence of this additional conserved charge. Our results are numerically illustrated in the fully connected transverse-field Ising model, which exhibits both kinds of dynamical phase transitions. Finally, we discuss the applicability of our theory to systems with finite-range interactions, where the phenomenology of excited-state quantum phase transitions is absent. We illustrate our findings by means of numerical calculations with experimentally relevant initial states.
A phase transition indicates a sudden change in the properties of a large system. For temperature-driven phase transitions this is related to nonanalytic behavior of the free energy density at the critical temperature: The knowledge of the free energy density in one phase is insufficient to predict the properties of the other phase. In this Letter we show that a close analogue of this behavior can occur in the real time evolution of quantum systems, namely nonanalytic behavior at a critical time. We denote such behavior a dynamical phase transition and explore its properties in the transverse-field Ising model. Specifically, we show that the equilibrium quantum phase transition and the dynamical phase transition in this model are intimately related.
We study the dynamical quantum phase transitions (DQPTs) manifested in the subsequent unitary dynamics of an extended Ising model with an additional three spin interactions following a sudden quench. Revisiting the equilibrium phase diagram of the model, where different quantum phases are characterized by different winding numbers, we show that in some situations the winding number may not change across a gap closing point in the energy spectrum. Although, usually there exists a one-to-one correspondence between the change in winding number and the number of critical time scales associated with DQPTs, we show that the extended nature of interactions may lead to unusual situations. Importantly, we show that in the limit of the cluster Ising model, three critical modes associated with DQPTs become degenerate, thereby leading to a single critical time scale for a given sector of Fisher zeros.
We use two quantum Monte Carlo algorithms to map out the phase diagram of the two-dimensional hardcore boson Hubbard model with near (V1){(V}_{1})(V1​) and next near (V2){(V}_{2})(V2​) neighbor repulsion. At half filling we find three phases: superfluid (SF), checkerboard solid, and striped solid depending on the relative values of V1,V2,{V}_{1}{,V}_{2},V1​,V2​, and the kinetic energy. Doping away from half filling, the checkerboard solid undergoes phase separation: The superfluid and solid phases coexist but not as a single thermodynamic phase. As a function of doping, the transition from the checkerboard solid is therefore first order. In contrast, doping the striped solid away from half filling instead produces a striped supersolid phase: coexistence of density order with superfluidity as a single phase. One surprising result is that the entire line of transitions between the SF and checkerboard solid phases at half filling appears to exhibit dynamical O(3)O(3)O(3) symmetry restoration. The transitions appear to be in the same universality class as the special Heisenberg point even though this symmetry is explicitly broken by the V2{V}_{2}V2​ interaction.
We study eigenstate thermalization and related signatures of quantum chaos in the one-dimensional ferromagnetic transverse-field Ising model with power-law interactions. The presence of long-range interactions allows for a finite-temperature phase transition despite the one-dimensional geometry of the model. Unlike previous studies of eigenstate thermalization in non-disordered systems with finite temperature phase transitions, our model possesses sufficiently many energy eigenstates below the critical energy density to allow us to make a definitive statement about the presence of eigenstate thermalization and chaotic level statistics in the broken-symmetry phase.
In this thesis, we investigate several topics pertaining to emergent collective quantum phenomena in the domain of correlated fermions, using the quantum Monte Carlo method. They display exotic low temperature phases as well as phase transitions which are beyond the Landau–Ginzburg theory. The interplay between three key points is crucial for us: fermion statistics, many body effects and topology. We highlight the following several achievements: 1. Successful modeling of continuum field theories with lattice Hamiltonians, 2. their sign-problem-free Monte Carlo simulations of these models, 3. and numerical results beyond mean field descriptions. First, we consider a model of Dirac fermions with a spin rotational invariant inter- action term that dynamically generates a quantum spin Hall insulator. Surprisingly, an s-wave superconducting phase emerges due to the condensation of topological de- fects of the spin Hall order parameter. When particle-hole symmetry is present, the phase transition between the topological insulator and the superconducting phase is an example of a deconfined quantum critical point(DQCP). Although its low energy effec- tive field theory is purely bosonic, the exact conservation law of the skyrmion number operator rules out the possibility of realizing this critical point in lattice boson models. This work is published in Ref. [1]. Second, we dope the dynamically generated quantum spin Hall insulator mentioned above. Hence it is described by a field theory without Lorentz invariance due to the lack of particle-hole symmetry. This sheds light on the extremely hot topic of twisted bilayergraphene: Why is superconductivity generated when the repulsive Coulomb interaction is much stronger than the electron-phonon coupling energy scale? In our case, Cooper pairs come from the topological skyrmion defects of the spin current order parameter, which are charged. Remarkably, the nature of the phase transition is highly non-mean-field-like: one is not allowed to simply view pairs of electrons as single bosons in a superfluid-Mott insulator transition, since the spin-current order parameter can not be ignored. Again, due to the aforementioned skyrmions, the two order parameters are intertwined: One phase transition occurs between the two symmetry breaking states. This work is summarized in Ref. [2]. Third, we investigate the 2 + 1 dimensional O(5) nonlinear sigma model with a topological Wess-Zumino-Witten term. Remarkably, we are able to perform Monte Carlo calculations with a UV cutoff given by the Dirac Landau level quantization. It is a successful example of simulating a continuous field theory without lattice regularization which leads to an additional symmetry breaking. The Dirac background and the five anti-commuting Dirac mass terms naturally introduce the picture of a non-trivial Berry phase contribution in the parameter space of the five component order parameter. Using the finite size scaling method given by the flux quantization, we find a stable critical phase in the low stiffness region of the sigma model. This is a candidate ground state of DQCP when the O(5) symmetry breaking terms are irrelevant at the critical point. Again, it has a bosonic low energy field theory which is seemingly unable to be realized in pure boson Hamiltonians. This work is summarized in Ref. [3].