Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

arXiv:1207.5718

Real Units Imaginary in Kaehler's Quantum Mechanics

José G. Vargas

Published Jul 18, 2012• 1 citation
arXivHTMLPDF

Abstract

Inspired by a similar, more general treatment by Kahler, we obtain the spin operator by pulling to the Cartesian coordinate system the azimuthal partial derivative of differential forms. At this point, no unit imaginary enters the picture, regardless of whether those forms are over the real or the complex field. Hence, the operator is to be viewed as a real operator. Also a view of Lie differentiation as a pullback emerges, thus avoiding conceps such as flows of vector fields for its definition. Enter Quantum Mechanics based on the Kahler calculus. Independently of the unit imaginary in the phase factor, the proper values of the spin part of angular momentum emerge as imaginary because of the idempotent defining the ideal associated with cylindrical symmetry. Thus the unit imaginary has to be introduced by hand as a factor in the angular momentum operator |and as a result also in its orbital part| for it to have real proper values. This is a concept of real operator opposite to that of the previous paragraph. Kahler stops short of stating the antithesis in this pair of concepts, both of them implicit in his work. A solution to this antithesis lies in viewing units imaginary in those idempotents as being the real quantities of square minus 1 in rotation operators of real tangent Clifford algebra. In so doing, one expands the calculus, and launches in principle a geometrization of quantum mechanics, whether by design or not.

DOI
10.48550/arxiv.1207.5718

Related papers

Quantum Mechanics as Real Geometry: Curvature, Torsion, and Holonomy

Kwon, Se Kyun

While the complex formalism of quantum mechanics has been extraordinarily successful, the fundamental geometric origin of its core elements—the imaginary unit, operator non-commutativity, quantum phase, and the intrinsic geometry with quantum spin—has remained unresolved for more than a century. Here we resolve these foundational questions by deriving an exact and physically equivalent formulation of the Schrödinger equation as a Real Geometric Flow—a moving-frame evolution on a 2𝑁-dimensional real state space. In this restored framework, the global imaginary unit 𝑖 fully decomposes into a set of local skew-symmetric generators that drive planar rotations in real space, revealing that the traditional complex formalism is a compressed representation of an intrinsic rotational geometry.Within the real geometric flow, energy eigenvalues appear as the Curvatures of the state trajectory, energy gaps correspond to Torsions that couple internal planes—naturally generating the geometry of quantum spin—and quantum phase emerges naturally as the Holonomy of the real moving frame. This formulation preserves the full empirical content of quantum mechanics while exposing the geometric mechanisms hidden beneath its notation, providing the first coherent explanation of curvature, torsion, non-commutativity, spin behavior, and quantum phase within a single framework.By demonstrating that the algebraic postulates of quantum mechanics arise from a deeper geometric order—one that stands alongside curvature-based theories such as General Relativity—this work establishes a unified differential-geometric foundation for quantum dynamics.It opens new directions for quantum control, quantum information, and fundamental physics.

•Nov 24, 2025•0 citations

Geometric Law of Quantum Mechanics and the Imaginary Unit

Kwon, Se Kyun

Mathematically, the imaginary unit 𝑖 has long been regarded as an algebraic generator extending the real numbers to the complex field. Yet a century after the birth of quantum mechanics (1925–2025), the answer to its oldest question is now clear: quantum mechanics is not merely a mathematical structure—it is a physical reality, and all quantities appearing in its non-commutative relations are physical. Therefore, 𝑖 is not a mere algebraic extension but the universal operator demanded by the geometric completeness of non-commutative reality between position and momentum. The imaginary unit is a physical reality. The canonical relation [𝑥, 𝑝] = 𝑖ℏ is not merely algebraic—it is a geometric law, showing that the complex structure of quantum mechanics arises inevitably from physical reality itself. It stands without contradiction, without complexity. This is nature. In the (𝑥, 𝑝) plane, 𝑖 represents a 90° rotation and ℏ quantizes the curvature of that rotation. Complex numbers thus arise as the natural geometric language of non-commutative physics, providing a geometric resolution to the century-old question of physical completeness first raised by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (1935).

•Nov 14, 2025•0 citations

The Real Origin of the Imaginary Unit- Informational Rotation and the Emergence of Quantum Mechanics in the TGIU Framework

Sebastian Virtosu

In standard quantum mechanics, the imaginary unit (i) is introduced axiomatically within the Hilbert space formalism, leaving its physical ontology largely unexplained. This paper demonstrates that within the Theory of Global Irreducible Unfolding (TGIU), the complex structure of the Schrödinger equation emerges naturally from a purely real, two-dimensional informational geometry. By representing the physical state as a real vector composed of structural coherence (\Phi) and entropy (S), we show that the conservation of total informational magnitude necessitates a continuous phase rotation in the (\Phi, S) plane. This rotation is generated by the Curvature-State Transform (CST) operator (\mathcal{J}_{\mathrm{CST}}), an antisymmetric matrix mathematically isomorphic to the imaginary unit (\mathcal{J}_{\mathrm{CST}}^2 = -I). Consequently, the complex quantum wavefunction \psi = \Phi + iS is redefined as the compact mathematical representation of a real informational state. In this framework, the Born rule for probability conservation (|\psi|^2 = \Phi^2 + S^2) translates directly to the conservation of informational magnitude, while the angular velocity of the phase evolution is shown to be driven by the TGIU Equilibrium Force (TEF). Ultimately, we prove that quantum mechanics is not fundamentally complex, but rather the complex representation of a deeper, real-valued symplectic informational dynamics.

•Mar 14, 2026•0 citations

Real Dirac Dynamics and Conservation Laws in Unified Quantum Mechanics

Pushpendra Singh

We extend the framework of Unified Quantum Mechanics (UQM) to the relativistic domain by formulating the Dirac equation entirely in terms of real-valued fields. In this approach, the complex imaginary unit \(i\) is systematically replaced by the temporal Hilbert transform operator \(\mathcal{H}_{t}\), which satisfies the anti-involution property \(\mathcal{H}_{t}^{2}=-\mathcal{I}\) and acts as a dimensionless isometric operator. The resulting theory is expressed as a coupled system of real-valued equations for a primary field \(\psi\) and its Hilbert-transformed partner \(\phi=\mathcal{H}_{t}[\psi]\), whose evolution is governed exclusively by local differential operators. We demonstrate that all essential algebraic and symmetry structures of relativistic quantum mechanics are preserved within this real-valued formulation. In particular, the full Clifford algebra of the Dirac matrices, Lorentz covariance, and the relativistic energy-momentum relation are recovered exactly. A rigorous isomorphism with the conventional complex Dirac equation is established via the analytic signal representation \(\psi_{a}=\psi-i\phi\), under which the standard \(U(1)\) gauge symmetry emerges naturally as a global \(SO(2)\) rotation in the real field space. The resulting formulation is therefore operationally and predictively equivalent to the standard complex theory. The conserved scalar density \(\rho=\psi^{\dagger}\psi+\phi^{\dagger}\phi=|\psi_{a}|^{2}\) is shown to arise as the squared envelope (intensity) of a real physical field and admits a direct interpretation as a local field intensity with well-defined physical dimensions. Probability conservation is recovered through the continuity equation, while normalization in standard quantum mechanics is reinterpreted as a rescaling by the conserved total field. Stability of matter, expressed as energy positivity, is shown to restrict the physical solution space to analytic signals, enforcing a Hilbert-pair structure and eliminating independent complex degrees of freedom. This work demonstrates that the complex structure of relativistic quantum mechanics is not fundamental but emerges from the analytically constrained dynamics of real-valued fields, providing a unified and physically transparent foundation for the Dirac theory.

•Jan 27, 2026•0 citations

Real-commutant phase selection from real Hilbert representations

Mohamed Haj Yousef

Complex Hilbert space is usually assumed at the start of quantum mechanics. This paper formulates a reverse construction for the one-particle and operator-algebraic setting. Starting from a real Hilbert space carrying an orthogonal representation, the admissible imaginary units are identified with the skew-adjoint square roots of − Id in the Real commutant of the complexified representation. The novelty is not the isolated use of complexification, spectral orientation, or polar decomposition, but their order of dependence: first the symmetry representation defines an intrinsic operator-valued phase space; then an oriented internal time flow selects a distinguished point of that phase space; only afterward are the usual complex one-particle, observable, probability, and Weyl–CCR structures invoked under their standard hypotheses. In the terminology used here, this oriented internal flow is the reversible or inner-generative side of a dual-time distinction. It is not a second observer clock and not an additional Lorentzian coordinate: mathematically it is the strongly continuous orthogonal group U ( t ) = exp ( t A ) on the real Hilbert space. Its Stone-dual variable is energy/frequency λ ; canonical conjugation pairs λ with − λ ; positive energy orients this pair and selects the canonical phase on the dynamic sector through A = J | A | = | A | J . Thus inner-generative time is the source of phase orientation, while irreversible record time, projection, memory, and decoherence enter only as later reduced-dynamics layers. No spectral gap at zero is required, and zero modes remain visible as residual phase data rather than being hidden by the construction. The selected phase is invariant under time-orientation-preserving symmetries and changes sign under time reversal, giving the usual antiunitary action after complex reconstruction. The paper also makes explicit the monoidal limitation: two selected local phases do not make the raw real tensor product the standard composite system; the standard composite is recovered only after imposing the J -balanced, equivalently complex, tensor product rule. Thus the result is a reconstruction of compatible complex kinematics on the selected one-particle/operator-algebraic sector, not a derivation of all quantum foundations from purely real data.

Physics Letters A•Aug 13, 2026•0 citations

Quantum dynamics in real Hilbert space: Algebraic isomorphism and symplectic geometry of the Schrödinger equation

Pushpendra Singh

This work reformulates quantum mechanics in real Hilbert space and demonstrates that the complex structure inherent to the Schrödinger equation can be fully captured by a coupled system of real-valued dynamics. By employing the standard field isomorphism of ( R 2 , + , ⋅ ) to ℂ , the real counterpart of the Schrödinger equation is derived, yielding a system of coupled real partial differential equations. This system reveals a symplectic structure where the symplectic matrix J geometrically represents the imaginary unit i , acting as a phase-space rotation operator. Time-independent solutions decouple into identical real Helmholtz equations, preserving spectral equivalence. The reformulation provides geometric insights into foundational aspects: the geometric representation of i , the emergence of probability conservation from real-component interactions, and the encoding of quantum phase relationships through the multiplicative structure of the R 2 field. This perspective reinforces connections to classical Hamiltonian mechanics and geometric quantization, suggesting that complex numbers are structural, emerging from field operations on the real plane, rather than fundamental. Building on these foundations, we present original results where quantum computation elements like qubits and gates are shown to have equivalent representations as real symplectic and special orthogonal matrices, maintaining unitary equivalence. We introduce a framework for quantum computation within a real vector space and provide a generalized protocol for generating entangled Bell states. These results offer a new perspective on the necessity of complex numbers in quantum theory, providing a framework with potential computational advantages for hybrid quantum–classical systems and enhanced geometric interpretability.

Annals of Physics•Jan 29, 2026•4 citations
Inspired by a similar, more general treatment by Kahler, we obtain the spin operator by pulling to the Cartesian coordinate system the azimuthal partial derivative of differential forms. At this point, no unit imaginary enters the picture, regardless of whether those forms are over the real or the complex field. Hence, the operator is to be viewed as a real operator. Also a view of Lie differentiation as a pullback emerges, thus avoiding conceps such as flows of vector fields for its definition. Enter Quantum Mechanics based on the Kahler calculus. Independently of the unit imaginary in the phase factor, the proper values of the spin part of angular momentum emerge as imaginary because of the idempotent defining the ideal associated with cylindrical symmetry. Thus the unit imaginary has to be introduced by hand as a factor in the angular momentum operator |and as a result also in its orbital part| for it to have real proper values. This is a concept of real operator opposite to that of the previous paragraph. Kahler stops short of stating the antithesis in this pair of concepts, both of them implicit in his work. A solution to this antithesis lies in viewing units imaginary in those idempotents as being the real quantities of square minus 1 in rotation operators of real tangent Clifford algebra. In so doing, one expands the calculus, and launches in principle a geometrization of quantum mechanics, whether by design or not.
While the complex formalism of quantum mechanics has been extraordinarily successful, the fundamental geometric origin of its core elements—the imaginary unit, operator non-commutativity, quantum phase, and the intrinsic geometry with quantum spin—has remained unresolved for more than a century. Here we resolve these foundational questions by deriving an exact and physically equivalent formulation of the Schrödinger equation as a Real Geometric Flow—a moving-frame evolution on a 2𝑁-dimensional real state space. In this restored framework, the global imaginary unit 𝑖 fully decomposes into a set of local skew-symmetric generators that drive planar rotations in real space, revealing that the traditional complex formalism is a compressed representation of an intrinsic rotational geometry.Within the real geometric flow, energy eigenvalues appear as the Curvatures of the state trajectory, energy gaps correspond to Torsions that couple internal planes—naturally generating the geometry of quantum spin—and quantum phase emerges naturally as the Holonomy of the real moving frame. This formulation preserves the full empirical content of quantum mechanics while exposing the geometric mechanisms hidden beneath its notation, providing the first coherent explanation of curvature, torsion, non-commutativity, spin behavior, and quantum phase within a single framework.By demonstrating that the algebraic postulates of quantum mechanics arise from a deeper geometric order—one that stands alongside curvature-based theories such as General Relativity—this work establishes a unified differential-geometric foundation for quantum dynamics.It opens new directions for quantum control, quantum information, and fundamental physics.
Mathematically, the imaginary unit 𝑖 has long been regarded as an algebraic generator extending the real numbers to the complex field. Yet a century after the birth of quantum mechanics (1925–2025), the answer to its oldest question is now clear: quantum mechanics is not merely a mathematical structure—it is a physical reality, and all quantities appearing in its non-commutative relations are physical. Therefore, 𝑖 is not a mere algebraic extension but the universal operator demanded by the geometric completeness of non-commutative reality between position and momentum. The imaginary unit is a physical reality. The canonical relation [𝑥, 𝑝] = 𝑖ℏ is not merely algebraic—it is a geometric law, showing that the complex structure of quantum mechanics arises inevitably from physical reality itself. It stands without contradiction, without complexity. This is nature. In the (𝑥, 𝑝) plane, 𝑖 represents a 90° rotation and ℏ quantizes the curvature of that rotation. Complex numbers thus arise as the natural geometric language of non-commutative physics, providing a geometric resolution to the century-old question of physical completeness first raised by Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen (1935).
In standard quantum mechanics, the imaginary unit (i) is introduced axiomatically within the Hilbert space formalism, leaving its physical ontology largely unexplained. This paper demonstrates that within the Theory of Global Irreducible Unfolding (TGIU), the complex structure of the Schrödinger equation emerges naturally from a purely real, two-dimensional informational geometry. By representing the physical state as a real vector composed of structural coherence (\Phi) and entropy (S), we show that the conservation of total informational magnitude necessitates a continuous phase rotation in the (\Phi, S) plane. This rotation is generated by the Curvature-State Transform (CST) operator (\mathcal{J}_{\mathrm{CST}}), an antisymmetric matrix mathematically isomorphic to the imaginary unit (\mathcal{J}_{\mathrm{CST}}^2 = -I). Consequently, the complex quantum wavefunction \psi = \Phi + iS is redefined as the compact mathematical representation of a real informational state. In this framework, the Born rule for probability conservation (|\psi|^2 = \Phi^2 + S^2) translates directly to the conservation of informational magnitude, while the angular velocity of the phase evolution is shown to be driven by the TGIU Equilibrium Force (TEF). Ultimately, we prove that quantum mechanics is not fundamentally complex, but rather the complex representation of a deeper, real-valued symplectic informational dynamics.
We extend the framework of Unified Quantum Mechanics (UQM) to the relativistic domain by formulating the Dirac equation entirely in terms of real-valued fields. In this approach, the complex imaginary unit iii is systematically replaced by the temporal Hilbert transform operator Ht\mathcal{H}_{t}Ht​, which satisfies the anti-involution property Ht2=−I\mathcal{H}_{t}^{2}=-\mathcal{I}Ht2​=−I and acts as a dimensionless isometric operator. The resulting theory is expressed as a coupled system of real-valued equations for a primary field ψ\psiψ and its Hilbert-transformed partner ϕ=Ht[ψ]\phi=\mathcal{H}_{t}[\psi]ϕ=Ht​[ψ], whose evolution is governed exclusively by local differential operators. We demonstrate that all essential algebraic and symmetry structures of relativistic quantum mechanics are preserved within this real-valued formulation. In particular, the full Clifford algebra of the Dirac matrices, Lorentz covariance, and the relativistic energy-momentum relation are recovered exactly. A rigorous isomorphism with the conventional complex Dirac equation is established via the analytic signal representation ψa=ψ−iϕ\psi_{a}=\psi-i\phiψa​=ψ−iϕ, under which the standard U(1)U(1)U(1) gauge symmetry emerges naturally as a global SO(2)SO(2)SO(2) rotation in the real field space. The resulting formulation is therefore operationally and predictively equivalent to the standard complex theory. The conserved scalar density ρ=ψ†ψ+ϕ†ϕ=∣ψa∣2\rho=\psi^{\dagger}\psi+\phi^{\dagger}\phi=|\psi_{a}|^{2}ρ=ψ†ψ+ϕ†ϕ=∣ψa​∣2 is shown to arise as the squared envelope (intensity) of a real physical field and admits a direct interpretation as a local field intensity with well-defined physical dimensions. Probability conservation is recovered through the continuity equation, while normalization in standard quantum mechanics is reinterpreted as a rescaling by the conserved total field. Stability of matter, expressed as energy positivity, is shown to restrict the physical solution space to analytic signals, enforcing a Hilbert-pair structure and eliminating independent complex degrees of freedom. This work demonstrates that the complex structure of relativistic quantum mechanics is not fundamental but emerges from the analytically constrained dynamics of real-valued fields, providing a unified and physically transparent foundation for the Dirac theory.
Complex Hilbert space is usually assumed at the start of quantum mechanics. This paper formulates a reverse construction for the one-particle and operator-algebraic setting. Starting from a real Hilbert space carrying an orthogonal representation, the admissible imaginary units are identified with the skew-adjoint square roots of − Id in the Real commutant of the complexified representation. The novelty is not the isolated use of complexification, spectral orientation, or polar decomposition, but their order of dependence: first the symmetry representation defines an intrinsic operator-valued phase space; then an oriented internal time flow selects a distinguished point of that phase space; only afterward are the usual complex one-particle, observable, probability, and Weyl–CCR structures invoked under their standard hypotheses. In the terminology used here, this oriented internal flow is the reversible or inner-generative side of a dual-time distinction. It is not a second observer clock and not an additional Lorentzian coordinate: mathematically it is the strongly continuous orthogonal group U ( t ) = exp ( t A ) on the real Hilbert space. Its Stone-dual variable is energy/frequency λ ; canonical conjugation pairs λ with − λ ; positive energy orients this pair and selects the canonical phase on the dynamic sector through A = J | A | = | A | J . Thus inner-generative time is the source of phase orientation, while irreversible record time, projection, memory, and decoherence enter only as later reduced-dynamics layers. No spectral gap at zero is required, and zero modes remain visible as residual phase data rather than being hidden by the construction. The selected phase is invariant under time-orientation-preserving symmetries and changes sign under time reversal, giving the usual antiunitary action after complex reconstruction. The paper also makes explicit the monoidal limitation: two selected local phases do not make the raw real tensor product the standard composite system; the standard composite is recovered only after imposing the J -balanced, equivalently complex, tensor product rule. Thus the result is a reconstruction of compatible complex kinematics on the selected one-particle/operator-algebraic sector, not a derivation of all quantum foundations from purely real data.
This work reformulates quantum mechanics in real Hilbert space and demonstrates that the complex structure inherent to the Schrödinger equation can be fully captured by a coupled system of real-valued dynamics. By employing the standard field isomorphism of ( R 2 , + , ⋅ ) to ℂ , the real counterpart of the Schrödinger equation is derived, yielding a system of coupled real partial differential equations. This system reveals a symplectic structure where the symplectic matrix J geometrically represents the imaginary unit i , acting as a phase-space rotation operator. Time-independent solutions decouple into identical real Helmholtz equations, preserving spectral equivalence. The reformulation provides geometric insights into foundational aspects: the geometric representation of i , the emergence of probability conservation from real-component interactions, and the encoding of quantum phase relationships through the multiplicative structure of the R 2 field. This perspective reinforces connections to classical Hamiltonian mechanics and geometric quantization, suggesting that complex numbers are structural, emerging from field operations on the real plane, rather than fundamental. Building on these foundations, we present original results where quantum computation elements like qubits and gates are shown to have equivalent representations as real symplectic and special orthogonal matrices, maintaining unitary equivalence. We introduce a framework for quantum computation within a real vector space and provide a generalized protocol for generating entangled Bell states. These results offer a new perspective on the necessity of complex numbers in quantum theory, providing a framework with potential computational advantages for hybrid quantum–classical systems and enhanced geometric interpretability.